Abstract
This article examines contemporary thinking about viable ways forward for gender equality at work. It questions both the lingering attachment to feminization in popular commentary and the renewed interest in positive discrimination within academic circles. Focusing on pay disparities in the public sector, it argues that greater attention should be given to the frontline agency of disadvantaged women and the material conditions that affect equality activism. Tensions in equality bargaining are highlighted, along with contradictory pressures on trade union intervention. ‘No-win-no-fee’ lawyers are considered to be neglected third party agents with greater relevance for representation and mobilization than the literature typically acknowledges, some proving to be highly effective in politicizing pay inequality.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Al-Ahmadi
H
(2011 ) Challenges facing women leaders in Saudi Arabia . Human Resource Development International 14 (2 ): 149 –66 .
2.
Alvesson
M
Billing
Y
(2009 ) Understanding Gender and Organizations . London : SAGE .
3.BBC (2012 ) Birmingham city council loses equal pay appeal bid . BBC News , 24 October . Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-birmingham-24383352 (accessed 21 June 2013 ).
4.
Belt
V
(2002 ) A female ghetto? Women’s careers in call centres . Human Resource Management Journal 12 (4 ): 51 –66 .
5.
Berry
M
(2008 ) No win no fee lawyers face tighter controls in equal pay dispute . Personnel Today , 30 June . Available at: http://www.personneltoday.com/articles/30/06/2008/46491/no-win-no-fee-lawyers (accessed 24 June 2013 ).
6.
Broadbridge
A
Simpson
R
(2011 ) Reflecting on the past and looking to the future in gender and management research . British Journal of Management 22 : 470 –83 .
7.
Butler
P
(2012 ) Birmingham equal pay victory for women may impact city of London . The Guardian , 24 October . Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/society/2012/oct/24/birmingham-equal-pay-victory-women-city (accessed 13 April 2013 ).
8.
Conley
H
(2012 ) Using equality to challenge austerity . Work, Employment and Society 26 (2 ): 349 –59 .
9.
Cooper
N
(2006 ) No-win no-fee lawyers are a threat to the success of local government equal pay negotiations . Personnel Today , 5 December . Available at: http://www.personneltoday.com/articles/05/12/2006/38409/no-win-no-fee-lawyers (accessed 24 June 2013 ).
10.
Craven
J
(2009 ) The future is female: why the business world wants a woman’s touch . The Mail Online , 8 August . Available at: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/you/article-1204533/The-future-female.html (accessed 13 April 2013 ).
11.
Davidson
C
(2007 ) The future is female, BT predicts . BBC News , 23 April . Available at: http://www.news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/6518241.stm (accessed 12 April 2013 ).
12.
Dickens
L
(2000 ) Collective bargaining and the promotion of gender equality at work . Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 6 : 193 –208 .
13.
England
P
(2010 ) The gender revolution: uneven and stalled . Gender and Society 24 : 149 –64 .
14.Equality Challenge Unit (2011 ) Equality in Higher Education: Statistical Report . London : Equality Challenge Unit .
15.Fawcett Society (2013 ) Pay gap widens as women’s standing in the economy undermined . Available at: http://www.fawcettsociety.org.uk/gap-in-pay-between-women-and-men-widens-after-years-of-slow-steady-progress/#sthash.1KZ118bB.dpbs (accessed 21 June 2013 ).
16.
Fondas
N
(1997 ) Feminization unveiled . Academy of Management Review 22 (1 ): 257 –82 .
17.
Foster
D
Williams
L
(2011 ) The past, present and future of workplace equality agendas . In:
Blyton
P
Heery
E
Turnbull
P
(eds) Reassessing the Employment Relationship . Basingstoke : Palgrave Macmillan , 318 –41 .
18.
Fricker
J
(2007 ) Greedy lawyers are making a fortune out of inequality . Personnel Today , 16 January . Available at: http://www.personneltoday.com/articles/16/01/2007/38887/greedy-lawyers-are-making (accessed 24 June 2013 ).
19.
Fuller
G
(2009 ) Equal pay: robbing Peter to pay Paula? Personnel Today , 3 December . Available at: http://www.personneltoday.com/articles/03/12/2009/53553/equal-pay-robbing-peter (accessed 24 June 2013 ).
20.
Greene
A
Kirton
G
(2004 ) Views from another stakeholder: trade union perspectives on the rhetoric of managing diversity . Warwick Papers in Industrial Relations no. 74, June . Coventry : University of Warwick Business School . Available at: http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/wbs/research/irru/wpir/wpir74.pdf.
21.
Hattenstone
S
(2010 ) The most hated lawyer in Britain . The Guardian , 1 May . Available at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2010/may/01/stefan-cross-female-pay-birmingham (accessed 12 April 2013 ).
22.
Hoque
K
Noon
M
(2004 ) Equal opportunities policy and practice in Britain . Work, Employment and Society 18 (3 ): 481 –506 .
23.
Jenkins
S
Martinez Lucio
M
Noon
M
(2002 ) Return to gender: an analysis of women’s disadvantage in postal work . Gender, Work and Organization 9 (1 ): 81 –104 .
24.
Johns
N
(2005 ) Positive action and the problem of merit . Critical Social Policy 25 (2 ): 139 –63 .
25.
Kantor
J
(2012 ) Elite women put new spin on old debate . The New York Times , 22 June , p. A14 .
26.
Kelan
E
Gratton
L
Mah
A
Walker
L
(2009 ) The Reflexive Generation . London : London Business School .
27.
Kirton
G
(2005 ) Influences on women joining and participating in unions . Industrial Relations Journal 36 (5 ): 386 –401 .
28.
Kirton
G
Healy
G
(2013 ) Commitment and collective identity of long term union participation . Work, Employment and Society 27 (2 ): 195 –212 .
29.
Major
B
Vanderslice
V
McFarlin
D
(1984 ) Effects of pay expected on pay received . Journal of Applied Social Psychology 14 : 399 –412 .
30.
Medland
D
(2012 ) The benefits of gender diversity put to the test . The Financial Times , 18 October , p. 4 .
31.
Milkman
R
(2007 ) Two worlds of unionism . In:
Cobble
D
(ed.) The Sex of Class . Ithaca, NY : Cornell University Press , 63 –80 .
32.
Miller
M
(2006 ) Is there a case for positive discrimination? Personnel Today , 17 January . Available at: http://www.personneltoday.com/hr/is-there-a-case-for-positive-discrimination/ (accessed 25 June 2013 ).
33.
Mills
A
(2002 ) Studying the gendering of organizational culture over time . Gender, Work and Organization 9 (3 ): 286 –307 .
34.
Noon
M
(2010 ) The shackled runner: time to rethink positive discrimination? Work, Employment and Society 24 (4 ): 728 –39 .
35.
Noon
M
(2012 ) Simply the best? The case for using threshold selection in hiring decisions . Human Resource Management Journal 22 (1 ): 76 –88 .
36.
Perales
F
(2013 ) Occupational sex-segregation, specialized human capital and wages . Work, Employment and Society 27 (4 ): 600 –20 .
37.
Personnel Today
(2007 ) Equal pay claim lawyers are best hope for change . Personnel Today , 16 January . Available at: http://www.personneltoday.com/articles/16/01/2007/38886/equal-pay-claim-lawyers-are-best-hope-for-change.htm (accessed 25 June 2013 ).
38.
Poling
S
(2005 ) Only women’s work . Frontline Scotland , BBC One.
39.
Ramsay
H
Scholarios
D
(2005 ) Organizational participation and women: an attitude problem? In:
Harley
B
Hyman
J
Thompson
P
(eds) Participation and Democracy at Work . Basingstoke : Palgrave Macmillan , 113 –44 .
40.
Rubery
J
Rafferty
A
(2013 ) Women and recession revisited . Work, Employment and Society 27 (3 ): 414 –32 .
41.
Scholarios
D
Taylor
P
(2011 ) Beneath the glass ceiling: explaining gendered role segmentation in call centres . Human Relations 64 (10 ): 1291 –319 .
42.
Scott
J
Crompton
R
Lyonette
C
(eds) (2010 ) Gender Inequalities in the 21st Century . Cheltenham : Edward Elgar .
43.
Street
S
(2010 ) In my opinion . Management Today , November , p. 66 .
44.
The Observer
(2012 ) Equality: coalition is missing the point about women . The Observer , 12 February . Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/feb/12/observer-editorial-women-equality-benefits (accessed 12 April 2013 ).
45.
Tomlinson
J
(2005 ) Women’s attitudes towards trade unions in the UK . Industrial Relations Journal 36 (5 ): 402 –18 .
46.
Treanor
J
(2011 ) EU calls for women to make up one third of bank directors . The Guardian , 21 June . Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/business/2011/jun/21/eu-women-bank-directors (accessed 12 April 2013 ).
47.
Vinnicombe
S
Sealy
R
Graham
J
Doldor
E
(2010 ) The Female FTSE Report 2010 . Cranfield : School of Management, Cranfield University .
48.
Vogel
D
Wester
S
Heesacker
M
Madon
S
(2003 ) Confirming gender stereotypes . Sex Roles 48 : 519 –28 .
49.
Wajcman
J
(1998 ) Managing Like a Man . Oxford : Polity Press .
50.
Walters
S
(2002 ) Female part time workers’ attitudes to trade unions in Britain . Journal of Industrial Relations 40 (1 ): 49 –68 .
51.
Webb
J
Liff
S
(1988 ) Play the white man: the social construction of fairness and competition in equal opportunity policies . Sociological Review 36 (3 ): 532 –51 .
52.
Weidenfeller
N
(2012 ) Breaking through the glass wall: the experience of being a women enterprise leader . Human Resource Development International 15 (3 ): 365 –74 .