Partnership consultation and employer domination in two British life and pensions firms

Abstract

Partnership agreements between employers and trade unions usually establish joint consultation committees for union representatives and managers to discuss workplace issues. According to conventional wisdom dominant employers use consultation under the rubric of partnership to reduce union influence and effectiveness.This article tests this assumption through a longitudinal study of new joint consultation committees introduced as part of partnership agreements in two employer dominant British life and pensions firms. Ineffective consultation in one firm reflected a conflictual industrial relations climate and management seeking retrenchment. In the other firm effective consultation developed notwithstanding employer dominance due to a more cooperative industrial relations climate, a history of cooperative management-union relations and management motives for adaptation. The findings suggest that consultation under partnership agreements enables effective union influence in such circumstances.

Keywords

employer dominance motives partnership power-distribution unions

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ackers, P. and Payne, J. (1998) `British Trade Unions and Social Partnership: Rhetoric, Reality and Strategy', International Journal of Human Resource Management 9(3): 529-50.

Danford, A. , Richardson, M. , Stewart, P. , Tailby, S. and Upchurch, M. (2005) Partnership and the High Performance Workplace: Work and Employment Relations in the Aerospace Industry. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Dietz, G. (2004) `Partnership and the Development of Trust in British Workplaces', Human Resource Management Journal 14(1): 5-24.

Guest, D.E. and Peccei, R. (2001) `Partnership at Work: Mutuality and the Balance of Advantage', British Journal of Industrial Relations 39(2): 207-36.

Haynes, P. and Allen, M. (2001) `Partnership as Union Strategy: A Preliminary Evaluation ', Employee Relations 23(2): 164-87.

Heery, E. (2002) `Partnership versus Organising: Alternative Futures for British Trade Unionism', Industrial Relations Journal 33(1): 20-35.

Kelly, J. (1998) Rethinking Industrial Relations: Collectivism, Mobilisation and Long Waves London: Routledge.

Kelly, J. (1999) `Social Partnership in Britain: Good for Profits , Bad for Jobs and Unions', Communist Review 30(3): 3-10.

Kelly, J. (2004) `Social Partnership Agreements in Britain: Labor Cooperation and Compliance', Industrial Relations 43(1): 267-92.

10.

Kochan, T.A. and Osterman, P. (1994) The Mutual Gains Enterprise. Boston MA: Harvard Business School Press.

11.

Marks, A. , Findlay, P. , Hine, J. , McKinlay, A. and Thompson, P. (1998) `The Politics of Partnership? Innovation in Employment Relations in the Scottish Spirits Industry', British Journal of Industrial Relations 36(2): 209-26.

12.

Martínez Lucio, M. and Stuart, P. (2005) `Partnership and New Industrial Relations in a Risk Society: an Age of Shotgun Weddings and Marriages of Convenience?', Work, Employment and Society 19(4): 797-817.

13.

Oxenbridge, S. and Brown, W. (2004) `Achieving a New Equilibrium? The Stability of Cooperative Employer-Union Relationships', Industrial Relations Journal 35(5): 388-402.

14.

Ramsay, H. (1977) `Cycles of Control: Worker Participation in Sociological and Historical Perspective', Sociology 11(3): 481-506.

15.

Roper, I. , James, P. and Higgins, P. (2005) `Workplace Partnership and Public Service Provision: the Case of the "Best Value" Performance Regime in British Local Government', Work, Employment and Society 19(3): 639-49.

16.

Samuel, P. (2005) `Partnership Working and the Cultivated Activist' , Industrial Relations Journal 36(1): 59-76.

17.

Samuel, P. (2008) The Dynamics of Partnership in Financial Services . Abingdon: Routledge.

18.

Sisson, K. and Martín Artiles, A. (2000) Handling Restructuring: Collective Agreements on Employment and Competitiveness. Dublin: European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions.

19.

Terry, M. (2003) `Can "Partnership" Reverse the Decline of British Trade Unions?', Work, Employment and Society 17(3): 459-72.

20.

Wills, J. (2004) `Trade Unionism and Partnership in Practice: Evidence from the Barclays-Unifi Agreement', Industrial Relations Journal 35(4): 329-43.