Chile’s massive 2019 protests indicate a pronounced discrepancy between the country’s alleged establishment of social democracy and the public’s perception of pervasive inequity. To understand this discrepancy, this analysis evaluates the extent to which Chilean social welfare policy conforms to social democratic norms of promoting solidarity, equity, and universalism. Analysis of poverty reduction, pension, health care, and education policy demonstrates that Chile’s center-left governments succeeded in mitigating some of the more extreme elements of the social welfare policies inherited from the Pinochet regime. However, they failed to reverse their underlying logic, which reinforces stratification and inequity and undermines incentives for the cultivation of solidarity among the working and middle classes. As a result, social welfare policy in Chile continues to resemble the neoliberal welfare regime implemented by the Pinochet dictatorship while the establishment of a social democratic welfare regime remains an aspiration for present and future leftist governments to realize.
AndersonSUribeMValenzuelaJP (2023) Reforming public education in Chile: the creation of local education services. Educational Management Administration and Leadership51(2): 481–501.
2.
ÁvalosBBelleiC (2019) Recent education reforms in Chile: how much of a departure from market and new public management systems? In OrnelasC (ed.) Politics of Education in Latin America: Reforms, Resistance and Persistence. Leiden: Brill, pp. 43–71.
BoeningerE (1986) The Chilean road to democracy. Foreign Affairs64(4): 812–832.
6.
BorzutzkyS (2019) You win some, you lose some: pension reform in Bachelet’s first and second administrations. Journal of Politics in Latin America11(2): 204–230.
Bril-MascarenhasTMailletA (2019) How to build and wield business power: the political economy of pension regulation in Chile, 1990-2018. Latin American Politics and Society61(1): 101–125.
9.
BurtonG (2012) Hegemony and frustration: education policy making in Chile under the Concertación, 1990-2010. Latin American Perspectives39(4): 34–52.
10.
CastañedaJ (2006) Latin America’s left turn. Foreign Affairs85(3): 28–43.
11.
CastiglioniR (2018) Explaining uneven social policy expansion in democratic Chile. Latin American Politics and Society60(3): 54–76.
Esping-AndersenG (1985) Politics against Markets: The Social Democratic Road to Power. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
14.
Esping-AndersenG (1990) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
15.
EwigCPalmucciGA (2012) Inequality and the politics of social policy implementation: gender, age and Chile’s 2004 health reforms. World Development40(12): 2490–2504.
16.
Guzmán-ConchaC (2017) Undoing the neoliberal higher education system? Student protests and the Bachelet reforms in Chile. World Economic Review8: 32–43.
17.
KubalMRFisherE (2016) The politics of student protest and education reform in Chile: challenging the neoliberal state. The Latin Americanist60(2): 217–241.
18.
LagosR (1999) Mi Idea de País. Santiago, Chile: Prosa.
19.
LagosR (2011) The Chilean way. A look at social democracy in the 21st century. Harvard International Review33(3): 17–21.
20.
LanzaroJ (2011) Uruguay: a social democratic government in Latin America. In LevitskySRobertsKM (eds) The Resurgence of the Latin American Left. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, pp. 348–374.
21.
LarrañagaOContrerasDRuiz-TagleJ (2012) Impact evaluation of Chile solidario: lessons and policy recommendations. Journal of Latin American Studies44(2): 347–372.
22.
Martin MunchmeyerMP (2016) Cambio o continuidad de las políticas de protección social en Chile en gobiernos de centroizquierda y centroderecha. Revista de CLAD Reforma y Democracia64: 193–224.
23.
Mesa-LagoC (2002) Myth and reality of pension reform: the Latin American evidence. World Development30(8): 1309–1321.
24.
Ministerio de Desarrollo Social (2018) Síntesis de Resultados CASEN 2017. Santiago, Chile: Gobierno de Chile.
OECD (2017) Education at a Glance 2017: OECD Indicators. Paris: OECD Publishing.
27.
OECD and The World Bank (2009) Revisión de políticas nacionales de educación: le educación superior en chile. Paris: OECD and IRBD.
28.
OsorioCPuentesG (2017) Government appropriation of scientific knowledge: how the Chile solidario poverty-alleviation program incorporated social capital. Latin American Policy8(2): 263–277.
29.
PalmaJUrzúaR (2005) Anti-poverty policies and citizenry: the ‘Chile Solidario’ experience. UNESCO MOST-2 Policy Papers12: 7–33.
30.
PanizzaF (2005a) The social democratization of the Latin American left. Revista Europea De Estudios Latinoamericanos y del Caribe79: 95–103.
31.
PanizzaF (2005b) Unarmed Utopia Revisited: the resurgence of the left-of-center politics in Latin America. Political Studies53: 716–734.
32.
PosnerPW (2018) Labor market flexibility, employment, and inequality: lessons from Chile. In: PosnerPEPatroniVFrancois MayerJ (eds) Labor Politics in Latin America: Democracy and Worker Organization in the Neoliberal Era. Gainesville, FL: University of Florida Press, pp. 39–69.
33.
PribbleJ (2013) Welfare and Party Politics in Latin America. New York: Cambridge University Press.
34.
PrzeworskiASpragueJ (1986) Paper Stones: A History of Electoral Socialism. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
35.
RaczynskiD (2008) Sistema Chile Solidario y la Politica de Proteccion Social de Chile: Lecciones del Pasado y Agenda Para el Futuro. Santiago, Chile: iFHC/CIEPLAN.
36.
RiquelmeVValenzuelaME (2005) Chile Solidario y los Desafíos de la Igualdad. Santiago, Chile: Oficina Internacional del Trabajo.
37.
TaylorM (2006) From Pinochet to the ‘Third Way’: Neoliberalism and Social Transformation in Chile. Ann Arbor, MI: Pluto Press.
38.
TorresR (2022) Neoliberalism and the impact of student demonstrations in Chile: pushing the bounds of the post-Pinochet education project?Latin American Perspectives49(3): 146–161.
39.
ValenzuelaME (2003) Desigualdad de género y pobreza en América Latina. In: ValenzuelaME (ed.) Mujeres, pobreza y mercado de trabajo. Argentina y Paraguay. Santiago, Chile: OIT, pp. 15–62.
Zúñiga FajuriA (2014) When constitutional justice has the last word on health care: the case of Chile. International Journal of Health Services44(2): 373–381.
