This paper inquires the moral and political ambivalences of migrant support located between contentious politics and humanitarian aid. Comparing Save Me and Seebrücke, two cases of pro-migrant activism in Germany claiming the safe passage of migrants to Europe, we develop the notion of ‘strategic humanitarianism’, a hybrid form of migrant support, in which actors combine the strategic employment of predominantly depoliticizing, narrow and humanitarian framing with a contentious repertoire of action. It entails deliberately sacrificing a ‘deep’ politicization of fundamental critique against contemporary migration regimes in order to achieve a ‘wide’ politicization and broad consensus for progressive social change. Furthermore, we carve out how distinct political contexts, in this case the issue salience and polarization of migration, influence the dynamics of mobilization and the configuration of humanitarianism and contentious politics. Despite a similar focus, thus, the ‘strategic humanitarianism’ of Save Me has developed a less contentious and disobedient character than Seebrücke.
AtaçIRygielKStierlM (2016) Introduction: the contentious politics of refugee and migrant protest and solidarity movements: remaking citizenship from the margins. Citizenship Studies20(5): 527–544.
4.
BauderHDarlingJ (eds) (2019) Sanctuary Cities and Urban Struggles. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
5.
BauderHJuffsL (2019) “Solidarity” in the migration and refugee literature: analysis of a concept. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, Online First, doi: 10.1080/1369183X.2019.1627862.
BraunK (2019) Urban citizenship und Kämpfe für eine solidarische Stadt. Neue Netzwerke und Zugehörigkeiten jenseits des Nationalen. In: BookCHukeNKlaukeSTietjeO (eds) Alltägliche Grenzziehungen. Zum Konzept der “imperialen Lebensweise“, Externalisierung und exklusive Solidarität. Münster: Westfälisches Dampfboot, 73–93.
CuttittaP (2018) Repoliticization through search and rescue? Humanitarian NGOs and migration management in the central mediterranean. Geopolitics23(3): 632–660.
10.
della PortaD (2018a) Contentious moves: mobilizing for refugees’ rights. In: della PortaD (ed.) Solidarity Mobilizations in the ‘Refugee Crisis’. Contentious Moves. London: Palgrave, 1–38.
11.
della PortaD (ed.) (2018b) Solidarity Mobilizations in the ‘Refugee Crisis’. Contentious Moves. London: Palgrave.
12.
della PortaDSteinhilperE (eds) Shrinking Spaces for Migrant Solidarity. London: Routledge, forthcoming.
13.
della PortaDSteinhilperESolidarities in motion: the hybrid dynamics of migrant support. Critical Sociology, forthcoming.
14.
den HeijerMRijpmaJSpijkerboerT (2016) Coercion, prohibition, and great expectations: the continuing failure of the common European asylum system. Common Market Law Review, 53(3): 607–642.
FassinD (2012) Humanitarian Reason: A Moral History of the Present. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
17.
FleischmannL (2017) The politics of helping refugees emerging meanings of political action around the German “Summer of Welcome”. Mondi Migranti3/2017: 7–27.
18.
FleischmannLSteinhilperE (2017) The myth of apolitical volunteering for refugees: German welcome culture and a new dispositif of helping. Social Inclusion5(3): 17–27.
19.
GarelliGSciurbaATazzioliM (2018) Introduction: mediterranean movements and the reconfiguration of the military-humanitarian border in 2015. Antipode50(3): 662–672.
20.
GarnierA (2014) Migration management and humanitarian protection: the UNHCR’s ‘Resettlement Expansionism’ and its impact on policy-making in the EU and Australia. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies40(6): 942–959.
21.
GeiselbergerH (ed.) (2017) The Great Regression. Cambridge: Polity.
22.
GibneyM (2009) The Ethics and Politics of Asylum. Liberal Democracy and the Response to Refugees. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
JäckleSKönigP (2016) The dark side of the German “welcome culture”: investigating the causes behind attacks on refugees in 2015’. West European Politics40(2): 223–251.
28.
JasperJ (1997) The Art of Moral Protest. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
29.
KarakayaliS (2017) “Infra-Politik” der Willkommensgesellschaft. Forschungsjournal Soziale Bewegungen30(3): 16–24.
30.
KarakayaliSSteinhilperE (2018) L’ « été de l’accueil » en Allemagne: les deux versants du bénévolat en temps de « crise des réfugiés ». In: LendaroARodierCVertongenY (eds.) De la crise des réfugiés à la crise de l’accueil. Frontières, droits, résistances. Paris: La Découverte, 251–271.
31.
KasparekBKirchhoffMNeuhauserJSchwiertzH (2017) The return of the national? migration borders and nationalism. Movements. Journal für kritische Migrations- und Grenzregimeforschung3(2): 147–161.
KleistOKarakayaliS (2016) European refugee policy from below? Volunteers and asylum seekers. Forced Migration Review51: 65–67.
34.
LewickiA (2017) “The dead are coming”: acts of citizenship at Europe’s borders. Citizenship Studies21(3): 275–290.
35.
Neue Württembergische Zeitung (2008) Patenschaft für Flüchtlinge, 23June.
36.
PichlM (2016) Die Asylpakete I und II: Der politische und rechtliche Kampf um die Asylrechtsverschärfungen. In: HessSKasparekBKronSRodatzMSchwertlMSontowskiS (eds.) Der lange Sommer der Migration. Grenzregime III. Berlin: Assoziation A, 163–175.
37.
Pro Asyl (2009) Für ein Programm zur Aufnahme von Flüchtlingen in Deutschland. Fakten, Hintergründe, Forderungen zum Resettlement. Berlin: Pro Asyl.
38.
ReaA (ed.) (2019) The Refugee Reception Crisis in Europe. Polarized Opinions and Mobilizations. Brussels: Éditions de l’Université de Bruxelles.
39.
SchwenkenHSchwiertzH (2020) Introduction: inclusive solidarity and citizenship along migratory routes in Europe and the Americas. Citizenship Studies, 24(4): 405–423.
40.
SchwiertzHRatfischP (2016) Antimigrantische Politik und der ‘Sommer der Migration’. Berlin: Rosa Luxemburg Stiftung. Available at: http://www.rosalux.de/publication/42062 (accessed 18 April 2016).
41.
SchwiertzHSchwenkenH (2020) Mobilizing for safe passages and escape aid: challenging the ‘asylum paradox’ between active and activist citizenship, humanitarianism and solidarity. Citizenship Studies 24(4): 493–511.
SteinhilperEGruijtersR (2018) A contested crisis: policy narratives and empirical evidence on border deaths in the mediterranean. Sociology52(3): 515–533.
46.
StierlM (2018) A fleet of Mediterranean border humanitarians. Antipode50(3): 704–724.
47.
StjepandićKSteinhilperE (2019) Pluralität in Bewegung. #unteilbar und co. als neue Form zivilgesellschaftlicher Mobilisierung?zeichen (3/2019).
48.
TicktinM (2011) Casualties of Care. Immigration and Politics of Humanitarianism in France. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
VandevoordtRVerschraegenG (2019) Subversive humanitarianism and its challenges: notes on the political ambiguities of civil refugee support. In: FeischmidtMPriesLCantatC (eds) Refugee Protection and Civil Society in Europe. Basingstoke: Palgrave, 101–128.
52.
VandevoordtRFleischmannLImpossible Futures? The Ambivalent temporalities of grassroots humanitarian action. Critical Sociology, forthcoming.
53.
WaltersW (2011) Foucault and frontiers: notes on the birth of the humanitarian borders. In: BröcklingUKrasmannLLemkeT (eds) Governmentality: Current Issues and Future Challenges. London: Routledge: 138–164.
