The Façade of Safety in California’s Shelter-In-Place Homes: History,Wildfire,and Social Consequence

Abstract

This article examines the seemingly incongruous ways in which Shelter-in-Place (SIP) practices have been sold, deployed, and discussed in Southern California to battle wildfire. In particular, this will be a critique of the technical literature and application of fire safety in housing, as well as the anthropocentric hubris that humans can outsmart wildfire. Rather than focus on the success or failure of SIP, I am situating the SIP within the context of architecture, the history of fire safety, and the push of neoliberalism. The purpose of this approach is to make SIP and fire safe home design less about technology and know-how, and more about broader social issues such as privatization and social inequality.

Keywords

architecture California environment fire safety neoliberalism sociology wildfire

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alagona

(2006) What makes a disaster ‘natural’? Space and Culture 9(1): 77 –79.

American Architect (1920) British architects and American architecture. November, p. 630.

American Architect (and Architectural Review) (1922) Editorial comment. 6 December, p. 497.

Apostol

(1994) El Alisal: Where History Lingers. Los Angeles, CA: Historical Society of Southern California.

Atlas Portland Cement Company (1909) Concrete Country Homes. New York, NY: Atlas Portland Cement Company.

Bakersfield Californian (2007) Editorial: tougher codes helped save southland homes. 27 October. Available (consulted October 21 2010) at: http://www.bakersfield.com/opinion/editorials/x792318871/Tougher-codes-helped-save-Southland-homes

Bakker

(1984) An Island Called California: An Ecological Introduction to Its Natural Communities. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

Banham

(1971) Los Angeles: The Architecture of Four Ecologies. Berkeley, CA: University of California.

Beck

(1992) Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

10.

Blau

(1984) Architects and Firms: A Sociological Perspective on Architectural Practice. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

11.

Bonds

(2011) The knowledge-shaping process: elite mobilization and environmental policy. Critical Sociology 37(4): 429–446.

12.

Braun

McCarthy

(2005) Hurricane Katrina and abandoned being. Environment and Planning D 23(6): 802–809.

13.

Buttel

(1987) New directions in environmental sociology. Annual Review of Sociology 13: 465–488.

14.

California Legislative Counsel Bureau (1922) Amendments to Constitution and Proposed Statutes with Arguments. Sacramento, CA: California State Printing Office.

15.

Čapek

(2010) Foregrounding nature: an invitation to think about shifting nature–city boundaries. City & Community 9(2): 208–224.

16.

Carter

May

Perry

(2007) The day after: action following a nuclear blast in a U.S. city. Washington Quarterly 30(4): 19–32.

17.

Catton

Dunlap

(1978) Environmental sociology: a new paradigm. American Sociologist 13: 41–49.

18.

Cova

(2005) Public safety in the urban–wildland interface: should fire-prone communities have a maximum occupancy? Natural Hazards Review 6(3): 99–108.

19.

Cova

Johnson

(2002) Microsimulation of neighborhood evacuations in the urban–wildland Interface. Environment and Planning A 34: 2211–2229.

20.

Cova

Drews

Siebeneck

Musters

(2009) Protective actions in wildfires: evacuate or shelter-in-place? Natural Hazards Review 10: 151–161.

21.

Cronon

(1996) Uncommon Ground: Rethinking the Human Place in Nature. New York, NY: WW Norton.

22.

Davis

(1998) Ecology of Fear: Los Angeles and the Imagination of Disaster. New York, NY: Metropolitan.

23.

Demeritt

(2002) What is the ‘social construction of nature’? A typology and sympathetic critique. Progress in Human Geography 26(6): 767–790.

24.

Deverell

Hise

(eds) (2005) Land of Sunshine: An Environmental History of Metropolitan Los Angeles. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.

25.

Dicus

Scott

(2006) Reduction of Potential Fire Behavior in Wildland–Urban Interface Communities in Southern California: A Collaborative Approach. USDA Forest Service Proceedings. USDA Forest Service, 729–738.

26.

Dyson

(2006) Come Hell or High Water: Hurricane Katrina and the Color of Disaster. New York, NY: Basic Civitas.

27.

Easterling

(2005) Enduring Innocence: Global Architecture and Its Political Masquerades. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

28.

Ellin

(1997) Architecture of Fear. Princeton, NJ: Princeton Architectural Press.

29.

Eves

(2003) The impact of natural disasters on residential property markets. Paper presented at the 10th European Real Estate Society Conference. Helsinki 10–13 June.

30.

FEMA (2009) Federal, state wildfire assistance tops $13.6 million: More information on California wildfires. Department of Homeland Security Documents, 2 January.

31.

Fogelson

(2005) Bourgeois Nightmares: Suburbia, 1870–1930. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

32.

Freudenburg

Frickel

Gramling

(1995) Beyond the nature/society divide: learning to think about a mountain. Sociological Forum 10(3): 361–392.

33.

Freudenburg

Gramling

Laska

Erikson

(2009) Organizing hazards, engineering disasters? improving the recognition of political-economic factors in the creation of disasters. Social Forces 87(2): 1015–1038.

34.

Funk

(2009) Too big to burn: AIG plays God in a man-made firestorm. Harper’s Magazine. Available (consulted 21 October 2010) at: http://www.harpers.org/archive/2009/10/0082671.

35.

Gill

Stephens

(2009) Scientific and social challenges for the management of fire-prone wildland–urban interfaces. Environmental Research Letters 4: 034014.

36.

Goetz

(1997) State theory and fire control: selection mechanisms in local government. Critical Sociology 23(2): 33–62.

37.

Goldman

Schurman

(2000) Closing the ‘great divide’: new social theory on society and nature. Annual Review of Sociology 26: 563–584.

38.

Goldstein

(2008) Skunkworks in the embers of the cedar fire: enhancing resilience in the aftermath of disaster. Human Ecology 36(1): 15–28.

39.

Griffiths

(2001) Forests of Ash: an Environmental History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

40.

Gustafson

(2008) Fire tax’s defeat puts supporters in a bind. San Diego Union-Tribune Available (consulted 18 June 2010) at: http://www.utsandiego.com/uniontrib/20081106/news_1m6firetax.html.

41.

Handmer

Tibbits

(2005) Is staying at home the safest option during bushfires? Historical evidence for an Australian approach. Global Environmental Change Part B: Environmental Hazards 6(2): 81–91.

42.

Hewitt

(1983) The idea of calamity in a technocratic age. In: Hewitt

(ed.) Interpretations of Calamity. Boston, MA: Allen & Unwin, 3–32.

43.

Hewitt

(1997) Regions of Risk: A Geographical Introduction to Disasters. Essex: Longman.

44.

House and Garden (1924) Milcor Metallic Building Products advertisement. April XLV(4): 26.

45.

Jasanoff

(1994) The Fifth Branch: Science Advisers as Policymakers. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

46.

Kaika

(2004) Interrogating the geographies of the familiar: domesticating nature and constructing the autonomy of the modern home. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 28(2): 265–286.

47.

Kerr

(1922) Supplement to Kerr’s Cyclopedic California Codes. San Francisco, CA: Bender-Moss.

48.

Klein

(2008) The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism. New York, NY: Macmillan.

49.

Kropp

(2006) California Vieja: Culture and Memory in a Modern American Place. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

50.

Lionello

Malanotte-Rizzoli

Boscolo

(2006) Mediterranean Climate Variability. San Diego: Elsevier.

51.

Los Angeles County Employees Association (1922) Riverside Portland Cement Co. advertisement. Historical Synopsis of Los Angeles County, p. 46.

52.

Los Angeles Times (1920) Fact and comment. 25 January, p. V1.

53.

Los Angeles Times (1923a) Fire Chief Ralph J. Scott plans rigid building restrictions to eliminate fire hazards. 21 October, p. v13.

54.

Los Angeles Times (1923b) Lumber body opposes new roofing plan. 4 November, p. v19.

55.

Los Angeles Times (1924) Views differ on designing. 31 August, p. D1.

56.

Los Angeles Times (1929) Cement stucco held ideal for exteriors. 13 October, p. D8.

57.

Low

(1997) Urban fear: building the fortress city. City & Society 9(1): 53–71.

58.

Lummis

(1923) Stand fast, Californians. California Southland (45): 7–10.

59.

Mall

Matzner

(2007) Safe at Home: Making the Federal Fire Safety Budget Work for Communities. Natural Resources Defense Council. September.

60.

Manolatos

(2007) Project fuels fire-safety debate. San Diego Union-Tribune, 11 March. Available (consulted 15 October 2010) at: http://www.signonsandiego.com/news/northcounty/20070311–9999-lz1mc11shelte.html.

61.

Maranghides

Mell

(2009) A Case Study of a Community Affected by the Witch and Guejito Fires. NIST Technical Note. Gaithersburg, MD: National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), US Department of Commerce.

62.

Martinez

Hoff

Nunez-Alvarez

(2009) Coming Out of the Dark: Emergency Preparedness Plan for Farmworker Communities in San Diego County. National Latino Research Center, California State University San Marcos. Available (consulted 17 March 2012) at: http://www.publichealthpractices.org/sites/cidrappractices.org/files/upload/27048/Coming%20Out%20of%20the%20Dark_0.pdf.

63.

McCaffrey

Rhodes

(2009) Public response to wildfire: is the Australian ‘stay and defend or leave early’ approach an option for wildfire management in the United States? Journal of Forestry 107(1): 9–15.

64.

McDonald

(2009) Property owners: county charges too much for cleanup. San Diego Union-Tribune, 28 December. Available (consulted 6 October 2010) at: http://www.utsandiego.com/news/2009/dec/28/cleanup-compliance-stirring-dust-ups/.

65.

McKenzie

(1994) Privatopia: Homeowner Associations and the rise of Residential Private Government. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

66.

McPhee

(1990) The Control of Nature. New York, NY: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

67.

Meighan

(1925) How well do you know the California Pines? Pacific Coast Architect, September XXVI(9): 35.

68.

Merchant

(ed.) (1998) Green Versus Gold: Sources in California’s Environmental History. Washington, DC: Island Press.

69.

Minnich

(1988) The Biogeography of Fire in the San Bernardino Mountains of California. Berkeley, CA: University of California Publications in Geography.

70.

Mitchell

(2007) The county’s ‘Shelter-in-Place’ gamble. San Diego Union-Tribune, 2 May. Available (consulted 11 January 2009) at: http://www.signonsandiego.com/uniontrib/20070502/news_lz1e2mitchell.html.

71.

Mol

APJ

(2006) From environmental sociologies to environmental sociology? a comparison of U.S. and European environmental sociology. Organization Environment 19(1): 5–27.

72.

Mol

APJ

Spaargaren

(1993) Environment, modernity and the risk-society: the apocalyptic horizon of environmental reform. International Sociology 8(4): 431–459.

73.

Murray

(2009) Fire and ice: unnatural disasters and the disposable urban poor in post-apartheid Johannesburg. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 33(1): 165–192.

74.

Mutch

Rogers

Stephens

Gill

(2011) Protecting lives and property in the wildland–urban interface: communities in Montana and Southern California adopt Australian paradigm. Fire Technology 47(2): 357–377.

75.

Nichols

(2011) County continues backcountry fire consolidation. North County Times, 25 January. Available (consulted 30 January 2011) at: http://www.nctimes.com/news/local/sdcounty/article_8e03e796–7628–5c7f-b6b8-e3dc3ecd4f2f.html.

76.

Pacific Coast Architect (1924a) Dickey Mastertile advertisement. February XXV(2): 30.

77.

Pacific Coast Architect (1924b) Riverside Portland Cement Co. advertisement. June XXV(6): 30.

78.

Paveglio

Carroll

Jakes

(2010a) Alternatives to evacuation during wildland fire: exploring adaptive capacity in one Idaho community. Environmental Hazards 9(4): 379–394.

79.

Paveglio

Carroll

Jakes

(2010b) Adoption and perceptions of shelter-in-place in California’s Rancho Santa Fe fire protection district. International Journal of Wildland Fire 19(6): 677–688.

80.

Pickering

(1996) Further beyond the society/nature divide: a comment on Freudenburg, Frickel, and Gramling. Sociological Forum 11(1): 153–159.

81.

Pritchard

(2008) Tough fire standards pay off in Calif. subdivision. Associated Press, 16 November. Available (consulted 19 April 2009) at: http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5hb7NAA_DI0mnqTIyyvFLQ8_wfH3gD94G8H3G0.

82.

SDRDF (2007) October 2007 Fires: Community Needs Assessment Report. San Diego Regional Disaster Fund, San Diego Foundation.

83.

Sexton

(1927) Spanish Influence on American Architecture and Decoration. New York, NY: Bretano.

84.

Smith

(2006) There’s no such thing as a natural disaster. Understanding Katrina: Perspectives from the Social Sciences. Available (consulted 4 September 2010) at: http://understandingkatrina.ssrc.org/Smith/.

85.

Soja

(2000) Postmetropolis: Critical Studies of Cities and Regions. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.

86.

Sorensen

Shumpert

Vogt

(2004) Planning for protective action decision making: evacuate or shelter-in-place. Journal of Hazardous Materials 109(1–3): 1–11.

87.

Steinberg

(2005) Rancho Santa Fe’s shelter-in-place program balances beauty, safety. San Diego Union-Tribune, 30 January, p. B–6.

88.

Stephens

Adams

Handmer

. (2009) Urban–wildland fires: how California and other regions of the US can learn from Australia. Environmental Research Letters 4: 1–5.

89.

Southwest Builder and Contractor (1923) Los Angeles Brick Co. advertisement. 25 May, p. 27.

90.

Syphard

Radeloff

Keeley

. (2007) Human influence on California fire regimes. Ecological Applications 17(5): 1388–1402.

91.

Taxin

(2009) California residents praised for home fire safety. Associated Press, 10 May.

92.

Tibbits

Whittaker

(2007) Stay and defend or leave early: policy problems and experiences during the 2003 Victorian bushfires. Environmental Hazards 7(4): 283–290.

93.

Troy

Romm

(2004) Assessing the price effects of flood hazard disclosure under the California natural hazard disclosure law (AB 1195). Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 47(1): 137–162.

94.

Troy

Romm

(2006) An Assessment of the 1998 California Natural Hazard Disclosure Law (AB 1195). Policy Research Program. Berkeley, CA: California Policy Research Center.

95.

Truesdell

(1926) Homes that are fire proof. California Home Owner, September, p. 12.

96.

Vaughn

Cortner

(2010) Funding fire: a losing proposition? California Journal of Politics and Policy 2(1). Available (consulted 17 January 2011) at: http://www.bepress.com/cjpp/vol2/iss1/6.

97.

Ward

Siegel

Corsi

(2005) The effectiveness of stand alone air cleaners for shelter-in-place. Indoor Air 15(2): 127–134.

98.

Waterman

(1903) The influence of an olden time. House Beautiful XIV(1): 3–8.

99.

Weisberg

Pierce

(2007) ‘Shelter in place’ kept flames at bay. San Diego Union-Tribune, 2 December. Available (consulted 18 June 2009) at: http://legacy.signonsandiego.com/news/metro/wildfires/20071202-9999-1n2shelter.html.

100.

Weisberg

Showley

Pierce

(2007) Exclusive homes emerge unscathed as fire-protection concept is tested. San Diego Union-Tribune, 25 October. Available (consulted 16 June 2009) at: http://legacy.signonsandiego.com/news/metro/20071025-9999-1n25stay.html.

101.

Welch

(2007) Surviving homes not just lucky. USA Today, 1 November, p. A3.

102.

Westerling

Bryant

(2007) Climate change and wildfire in California. Climatic Change 87(S1): 231–249.

103.

Whitnall

(1925) The significance of the recent Supreme Court zoning ruling. Los Angeles Realtor IV(7): 19.

104.

Willis

(1925) Construction lesson from Santa Barbara. Pacific Coast Architect. September XXVI(9): 5.

105.

Wisner

Blaikie

Cannon

Davis

(1994) At Risk: Natural Hazards, People’s Vulnerability and Disasters. Oxford: Routledge.

106.

Wood

(2008) California wildfire lessons: steps by homeowners cut damage. Christian Science Monitor, 19 November. Available (consulted 19 October 2010) at: http://www.csmonitor.com/2008/1119/p01s01-usgn.html.

107.

Wynne

(2002) Risk and environment as legitimatory discourses of technology: reflexivity inside out? Current Sociology 50(3): 459–477.

108.

Zurier

(1982) The American Firehouse: An Architectural and Social History. New York, NY: Abbeville.