The ubiquity of biofilm and its classification as a microbial aggregate is discussed. Investigations into any microbial ecological problem operate at four levels: (i) in situ investigations, (ii) the use of microcosms, (iii) experimental model systems, and (iv) mathematical models. Each of these is defined and their use in biofilm research illustrated. It is concluded that all these approaches are valid and that scientific research in general and biofilm research in particular must profit by the use widely different methods if a complete understanding of a system is to be achieved.
Anwar H., van Biesen T., Dasgupta M., Lam K., Costerton JW (1989). Interaction of biofilm bacteria with antibiotics in a novel in vitro chemostat system. Antimicrob Agents Chemother33:1824-1826.
2.
Atkinson B., Fowler HW (1974). The significance of microbial film in fermenters . Adv Biochem Eng3:224-277.
3.
Bakke R., Trulear MG, Robinson JA, Characklis WG (1984). Activity of Pseudomonas aeruginosa in biofilms: steady state. Biotechnol Bioeng26:1418-1424.
4.
Bradshaw DJ, McKee AS, Marsh P. (1989). The use of defined inocula stored in liquid nitrogen for mixed culture chemostat studies. J Microbiol Meth9:123-128.
5.
Bradshaw DJ, Homer KA, Marsh PD, Beighton D. (1994). Metabolic cooperation in oral microbial communities during growth on mucin. Microbiol140:3407-3412.
6.
Characklis WG (1983). Process analysis in microbial systems: biofilms as a case study. In: Mathematics in microbiology. Bazin MJ, editor. London: Academic Press, pp. 171-234.
7.
Chen YS, Bungay HR (1981). Microelectrode studies of oxygen transfer in trickling filter slimes. Biotechnol Bioeng23:781-792.
8.
Coombe RA, Tatevossian A., Wimpenny Jwt (1981). Bacterial thin films as in vitro models for dental plaque. In: Surface and colloid phenomena in the oral cavity: methodological aspects. Frank RM, Leach SA, editors. London: Information Retrieval, pp. 239-249.
9.
Coombe RA, Tatevossian A., Wimpenny Jwt (1982). An in vitro model for dental plaque (abstract) . 30th Meeting, British Division of the International Association for Dental Research, University of Edinburgh , Scotland.
10.
Coombe RA, Tatevossian A., Wimpenny Jwt (1984). Factors affecting the growth of thin bacterial films in vitro. In: Bacterial adhesion and preventive dentistry . ten Cate JM, Leach SA, Arends J, editors. Oxford, UK: IRL Press, p. 193.
11.
Dibdin GH (1990a). Plaque fluid and diffusion: study of the cariogenic challenge by computer modeling. J Dent Res69:1324-1331.
12.
Dibdin GH (1990b). Computer modelling of dental plaque in relation to dental caries. Microb Ecol Hlth Dis3:5-8.
13.
Dibdin GH, Shellis RP, Wilson CM (1976). An apparatus for the continuous culture of micro-organisms on solid surfaces with special reference to dental plaque. J Appl Bacteriol40:261-268.
14.
Dietz VH (1943). In vitro production of plaques and caries. J Dent Res22:423-440.
15.
Donoghue HD, Hudson DE, Perrons CJ (1983). Effect of inoculation sequence and nutrients upon Streptococcus mutans BHT and Streptococcus mitior LPA-1 growing on human teeth in an artificial mouth. J Appl Bacteriol54:23-29.
16.
Feyerabend PK (1975). Against method: outline of an anarchistic theory of knowledge. London: New Left Books .
17.
Fowler HW (1988). Microbial adhesion to surfaces. In: Handbook of laboratory model systems for microbial ecosystems. Wimpenny JWT, editor. Vol. 1. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, pp. 139-153.
18.
Fry JC, Day MJ (1994). Transfer of natural plasmids in riverine biofilm . In: Bacterial biofilms and their control in medicine and industry. Cardiff, UK: Bioline, pp. 31-36.
19.
Gadani V., Villon P., Manem J., Rittman B. (1993). A new method to solve a non-steady-state multispecies biofilm model. Bull Math Biol55:1039-1061.
20.
Gilbert P., Allison DG, Evans DJ, Handley PS, Brown Mrw (1989). Growth rate control of adherent bacterial populations . Appl Env Microbiol55:1308-1311.
21.
Gjaltama A., Arts Pam, Vanloosdrecht Mcm, Kuenen JG, Heijnen JJ (1994). Heterogeneity of biofilms in rotating annular reactors. Biotechnol Bioeng44:194-204.
22.
Herles S., Olsen S., Afflitto C., Gaffar A. (1994). Chemostat flow system-an in vitro model for the evaluation of antiplaque agents. J Dent Res73:1748-1755.
23.
Hudson DE, Donoghue HD, Perrons CJ (1986). A laboratory microcosm (artificial mouth) for the culture and continuous pH measurement of oral bateria on surfaces. J Appl Bacteriol60:301-310.
24.
Kaiser D., Losick R. (1993). How and why bacteria talk to each other. Cell73:873-885.
25.
Keevil CW, Bradshaw DJ, Dowsett AB, Feary TW (1987). Microbial film formation: dental plaque deposition on acrylic tiles using continuous culture techniques. J Appl Bacteriol62:129-138.
26.
Keevil CW, Dowsett AB, Rogers J. (1993). Legionella biofilms and their control. In: Microbial biofilms: formation and control. Denyer SP, Gorman SP, Sussman M, editors. Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 201-215.
27.
Kell DB ( 1995). Pheromones, social-behaviour and the functions of secondary metabolism in bacteria. Trends Ecol Evolution10:126-129.
28.
Kinniment SL, Wimpenny Jwt (1990). Biofilms and biocides. Int Biodeter26:181-194.
29.
Kinniment SL, Wimpenny Jwt, Adams D., Marsh PD (1996). Development of a steady state oral microbial film dcommunity using the constant depth film fermenter. Microbiol142:631-638.
30.
Lewandowski Z., Stoodley P., Altobelli S., Fukushima E. (1994). Hydrodynamics and kinetics in biofilm systems-recent advances and new problems. Water Sci Technol29:223-229.
31.
Li YH, Bowden GH (1994). Characteristics of accumulation of oral Gram positive bacteria on mucin-conditioned glass surfaces in a model system. Oral Microbiol Immunol9:1-11.
32.
Lightfoot EN (1989). Minority opinion: Biofilms as dynamic transport-reaction systems. In: Structure and function of biofilms. Characklis WG, Wilderer PA , editors. Chichester: John Wiley , pp. 193-198.
33.
Marsh PD, Bradshaw DJ, Watson GK, Allison C. (1995). Community development in a mixed species biofilm . In: The life and death of biofilm. Wimpenny JWT, Handley PS, Gilbert P, Lappin-Scott HM, editors. Cardiff, UK: Bioline, pp. 65-69.
34.
McCoy WF, Bryers JD, Robbins J., Costerton JW (1981). Observations of fouling biofilm formation. Can J Microbiol29:910-917.
35.
Medawar P. (1969). Induction and intuition in scientific thought . London: Methuen.
36.
Peters AC, Wimpenny Jwt (1988a). A constant depth laboratory film fermenter. In: Handbook of laboratory model systems for microbial ecosystems. Vol. 1. Wimpenny JWT, editor. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, pp. 175-195.
37.
Peters AC, Wimpenny Jwt (1988b). A constant depth laboratory model film fermentor . Biotechnol Bioeng32:263-270.
38.
Pritchard PH, Bourquin AW (1984). The use of microcosms for evaluation of interactions between pollutants and microorganisms. Adv Microbial Ecol8:133-215.
39.
Revsbech NP (1989). Microsensors: spatial gradients in biofilms. In: Structure and function of biofilms. Characklis WG, Wilderer PA, editors. Chichester: John Wiley, pp. 129-144.
40.
Ruseska L., Robbins J., Costerton JW, Lashen E. (1982). Biocide testing against corrosion causing oil-field bacteria helps control plugging. Oil and Gas J (March): 153-164.
41.
Russell C., Coulter WA (1975). Continuous monitoring of pH and Eh bacterial plaque grown on a tooth on an artificial mouth. Appl Microbiol29:141-144.
42.
Russell C., Coulter WA (1977). Plaque formation by streptococci in an artificial mouth and factors influencing colonization. JAppl Bacteriol42:337-344.
43.
Shellis RP, Dibdin GH (1988). Analysis of buffering systems in dental plaque . J Dent Res67:438-446.
44.
Sudo SZ ( 1977). Continuous culture of mixed oral flora on hydroxyapatite-coated glass beads. Appl Env Microbiol33:450-458.
45.
Sutton NA, Hughes N., Handley PS (1994). A comparison of conventional SEM techniques, low temperature SEM and the electroscan electron microscope to study the structure of a biofilm of Streptococcus crista CR3. J Appl Bacteriol76:448-454.
46.
Tatevossian A. (1988). Film fermenters in dental research. In: Handbook of laboratory model systems for microbial ecosystems. Vol. I. Wimpenny JWT, editor. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, pp. 197-227.
47.
Trulear MG, Characklis WG (1982). Dynamics of biofilm formation. J Water Pollution Control Fed54:1288-1301.
48.
Walker JT, Wagner D., Fischer W., Keevil CW (1994). Rapid detection of biofilm on corroded copper pipes. Biofouling8:55-63.
49.
Wanner 0 (1989). Modelling population dynamics. In: Structure and function of biofilms. Characklis WG, Wilderer PA, editors. Chichester: John Wiley, pp. 91-110.
50.
Wanner 0, Reichert P. (1996). Mathematical modelling of mixed culture biofilms . Biotechnol Bioeng49:172-184.
51.
Wanner 0, Debus 0, Reichert P. (1994). Modelling the spatial distribution and dynamics of a xylene degrading microbial population in a membrane bound biofilm. Water Sci Technol29:243-251.
52.
Watson GK, Halliday D., Albiston I., Singleton S., Allison C. (1995).An in vitro biofilm system for the study of plaque ecology and physiology (abstract). J Dent Res74:853.
53.
Wimpenny Jwt, Kinniment SL, Scourfield MA (1993). The physiology and biochemistry of biofilm. Soc Appl Bacteriol Technical Series 30:51-94.
