Side-effects from dental materials are a minor problem, but should be recognized. In recent questionnaire surveys about side-effects, the incidence was estimated to be 1:300 in periodontics and 1:2600 in pedodontics. None of these reactions was related to dental casting alloys. In prosthodontics, the incidence was calculated to be about 1:400, and about 27% were related to base-metal alloys forremovable partial dentures (cobalt, chromium, nickel) and to noble/goldbased alloys for porcelain-fused-to-metal restorations. The complaints consisted of intra-oral reactions (such as redness, swelling, and pain of the oral mucosa and lips), oral/gingival lichenoid reactions, and a few instances of systemic reactions. In orthodontics, the incidence was 1:100, and most reactions (85%) were related to metal parts of the extra-oral anchorage devices.
Even though the extensive use of base-metal alloys has been of major concern to the dental profession, relatively few case reports substantiate this concern. Allergy to gold-based dental restorations has been more commonly reported. Palladium-based alloys have been associated with several cases of stomatitis and oral lichenoid reactions. Palladium allergy seems to occur mainly in patients who are very sensitive to nickel. All casting alloys, except titanium, seem to have a potential for eliciting adverse reactions in individual hypersensitive patients. Tolerance induction may be a possible benefit of the use of intra-orally placed alloys. In non-sensitized individuals, oral antigenic contacts to nickel and chromium may induce tolerance rather than sensitization.
A variety of systemic diseases and reactions has been claimed to be caused by dental materials. The claims are generally poorly documented. Further controlled clinical trials are necessary for assessment of the problems associated with metal allergy and dental treatment procedures, and for development of a scientific basis for training clinicians in proper treatment planning for hypersensitive patients.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Augthun M., Lichtenstein M., Kammerer G. (1990). Untersuchungen zur allergenen potenz von palladium-legierungen . Dtsch Zahnärztl Z45:480-482.
2.
Axell T., Spiechowicz E., Glantz P.-O, Andersson G., Larsson A. (1986). A new method for intraoral patch testing. Contact Dermatitis15:58-62.
3.
Baurle G., Schonberger A. (1985). Glossodynie-indikation zur epikutantestung? Z Hautkr61:1175-1184.
4.
Bergman M. (1990). Side-effects of amalgam and its alternatives: local, systemic and environmental. Int Dent J40:4-10.
5.
Brendlinger D., Tarsitano J. (1970). Generalized dermatitis due to sensitivity to a chrome-cobalt removable partial denture. J Am Dent Assoc81:392.
6.
Brune D., Beltesbrekke H. (1980a). Dust in dental laboratories. Part I: types and levels in specific operations. J Prosthet Dent44:687-692.
7.
Brune D., Beltsbrekke H. (1980b). Dust in dental laboratories. Part III: Efficiency of ventilation systems and face masks. J Prosthet Dent44:211-215.
8.
Brune D., Beltesbrekke H., Strand G. (1980). Dust in dental laboratories. Part II: Measurement of particle size distributions. J Prosthet Dent44:82-87.
9.
Burrows D. (1986). Hypersensitivity to mercury, nickel and chromium in relation to dental materials. Int Dent J36 :30-34.
10.
Burrows D. (1989). Mischievous Metals-Chromate, Cobalt, Nickel and Mercury. Clin Exp Dermatol14:266-272.
11.
Castelain PY, Castelain M. (1987). Contact dermatitis to palladium. Contact Dermatitis16:46.
12.
Dahl B., Hensten-Pettersen A., Lyberg T. (1990). Assessment of adverse reactions to prosthodontic materials. J Oral Rehabil17:279-286.
13.
De Melo JF, Gjerdet NR, Erichsen ES (1983). Metal release from cobalt-chromium partial dentures in the mouth. Acta Odontol Scand41:71-74.
14.
Downey D. (1989). Contact mucositis due to palladium. Contact Dermatitis21:54.
15.
Duxbury AJ, Watts DD, Wastell EA (1982). Allergie au mercure dans l'amalgame dentaire. Med Hyg40 :3416-3418.
16.
Eggleston DW (1984). Effect of dental amalgam and nickel alloys on T-lymphocytes: preliminary report. J Prosthet Dent51:617-623.
Fenton AH, Jeffry JD (1978). Allergy to a partial denture casting: case report . Dent J44:466-468.
19.
Fernandez JP, Veron C., Hildebrand HF, Martin P. (1986). Nickel allergy to dental prosthesis. Contact Dermatitis14:312.
20.
Fisher AA (1974). Contact stomatitis, glossitis, and cheilitis. Otolaryngol Clin North Am7:827-843.
21.
Forck G. (1976). Allergische reaktionen der mundschleimhaut bei prothesenträgern. Dtsch Zahnärtzl Z31:10.
22.
Franz G. (1982). The frequency of allergy to dental materials. J Dent Assoc S Afr37:805-810.
23.
Fregert S., Kollander M., Poulsen J. (1979). Allergic contact stomatitis from gold dentures . Contact Dermatitis5:63-64.
24.
Galandi ME (1984). Zur allergenitat nickelhaltiger nichtedelmetallegierungen-ergebnisse vergleichender epikutan- und epimukosatestungen. Dtsch Zahnärztl Z39:825-827.
25.
Gasser F. (1983). Allergische patientreaktionen auf zahnarztliche behandlungen und materialien. Quintessenz5:1035-1044.
26.
Greppi L., Smith DC, Woodside DG, Varrela T., Lugowski S. (1991). Nickel hypersensitivity reactions in orthodontic patients (abstract). J Dent Res70 (Spec Iss):361.
27.
Grimsdottir MR, Gjerdet NR, Hensten-Pettersen (1992 ). Composition and in vitro corrosion of orthodontic appliances . Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop (in press).
28.
Hensten-Pettersen A. (1984). Allergiske reaksjoner på dentale materialer. Norwegian Dent J94:573-578.
29.
Hensten-Pettersen A. (1986). General Toxicology. In: Lang BR, Morris HF, Razzoog ME, editors. International Workshop. Biocompatibility, Toxicity and Hypersensitivity to Alloy Systems Used in Dentistry . Ann Arbor (MI): University of Michigan School of Dentistry, 141-172.
30.
Hensten-Pettersen A. (1989a). Replacement of restorations based on material allergies. In: Anusavice KJ, editor. Quality Evaluation of Dental Restorations. Chicago : Quintessence Publishing Co., 357-372.
31.
Hensten-Pettersen A. (1989b). Nickel allergy and dental treatment procedures . In: Maibach HI, Menne T, editors. Nickel and the Skin: Immunology and Toxicology . Boca Raton (FL): CRC Press, 195-205.
32.
Hensten-Pettersen A., Jacobsen N. (1991a). Perceived side effects of biomaterials in prosthetic dentistry. J Prosthet Dent65:138-144.
33.
Hensten-Pettersen A., Jacobsen N. (1991b). Toxic effects of dental materials. Int Dent J41:265-273.
34.
Hildebrand HF, Veron C., Martin P. (1989). Les alliages dentaires en metaux non precieux et l'allergie. J Biol Buccale17:227-243.
35.
Holland-Moritz R., Rimpler M., Rudolph P-O. (1980). Allergie gegenüber gold in der mundhohle?Dtsch Zahnärztl Z35:963-967.
36.
Izumi AK (1982). Allergic gingivostomatitis due to gold. Arch Dermatol Res272:387-391.
37.
Jacobsen N., Asenden R., Hensten-Pettersen A. (1991). Occupational health complaints and adverse patient reactions as perceived by personnel in public dentistry. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol19:155-159.
38.
Jacobsen N., Hensten-Pettersen A. (1989a). Occupational health problems and adverse patient reactions in orthodontics. Eur J Orthod11:254-264.
39.
Jacobsen N., Hensten-Pettersen A. (1989b). Occupational health problems and adverse patient reactions in periodontics. J Clin Periodontol16:428-433.
40.
Jacobsen N., Hensten-Pettersen A. (1990). The role of biomaterials as occupational hazards in dentistry. Int Dent J40:159-166.
41.
Jobling AP (1982). Contact allergy, the dental surgeon and his patient . Br Dent J153:59-64.
42.
Johansson BL (1986). Electrochemical action due to short-circuiting of dental alloys (thesis). SwedDentJ (Suppl 33).
43.
Jones TK, Hansen CA, Singer MT, Kessler HP (1986). Dental implications of nickel hypersensitivity . J Prosthet Dent56:507-509.
44.
Jones TK, Pinnell DC, Netti CA (1991). Erosive lichen planus exacerbated by full-metal restorations. Gen Dent39:28-30.
45.
Kaaber S., Thulin H., Nielsen E. (1979). Skin sensitivity to denture base materials in the burning mouth syndrome. Contact Dermatitis5:90-96.
Kallus T, Mjor IA (1991). Incidence of adverse reactions to dental materials. Scand J Dent Res 99:236-240. KlaschkaF(1975). Contact allergy to gold. Contact Dermatitis 1:264-265.
48.
Klotzer WT, Reuling N. (1990). Biokompatibiltätzahnärztlicher materialien: Teil II. Materialien mit schleimhautkontakt. Dtsch Zahnärztl Z45:437-442.
49.
Lamster IB, Kalfus DI, Steigerwald PJ, Chasens AI (1987). Rapid loss of alveolar bone associated with nonprecious alloy crowns in two patients with nickel hypersensitivity. J Periodontol58:486-492.
50.
Levantine A. (1974). Sensitivity to dental metal plate. Proc R Soc Med67:1007.
51.
Lundstrom Imc (1984). Oral lichen planus. A clinical, odontological and medical study (thesis). Stockholm (Sweden): Karolinska Institute.
52.
Magnusson B., Bergman M.Bergman B., Soremark R. (1982). Nickel allergy and nickel containing dental alloys . Scand J Dent Res90:163-167.
53.
Merritt K. (1986). Biochemistry. Hypersensitivity. Clinical reaction . In: Lang BR, Morris HF, Razzoog ME , editors. International Workshop. Biocompatibility, Toxicity and Hypersensitivity to Alloy Systems Used in Dentistry. Ann Arbor (MI): University of Michigan School of Dentistry , 193-223.
54.
Moffa JP, Beck WD, Hoke AW ( 1977). Allergic response to nickel containing dental alloys (abstract). J Dent Res56:B78.
55.
Morgenroth K., Kronenberger H. (1984). Lung changes from dental materials. Quint Dent Technol8:45-48.
56.
Molin M. (1990). Mercury release from dental amalgam in man. Influences on selenium, glutathione peroxidase and some other blood and urine components (thesis). Swed Dent J (Suppl 71).
57.
Nakayama H. (1982). Hypersensitivity to palladium is linked to oral lichen planus. Dermatol News Iss. 2.
58.
Namikoshi T., Yoshimatsu T., Suga K., Fujii H., Yasuda K. (1990). The prevalence of sensitivity to constituents of dental alloys. J Oral Rehabil17:377-381.
59.
Nilner K. (1981). Studies of electrochemical action in the oral cavity (thesis). Swed Dent J (Suppl 9).
60.
Oshima H., Kawahara D., Kosugi H., Nakamura M., Sugai T., Tamaki T. (1991). Epidemiologic study on occupational allergy in the dental clinic. Contact Dermatitis24:138.
61.
Ovrutsky GD, Ulyanov AD (1976). Allergy to chromium in using steel dental prosthesis . Stomatologia (Moscow)55 :60-62.
62.
Pevny I., Binzenhofer A. (1983). Mundschleimhautkontaktallergien. Z Hautkr59:245-251.
63.
Re S. (1960). Allergic reactions to steel prosthesis. Minerva Stomatol9:53.
64.
Schof E., Wex O., Schulz KH (1971). Allergische kontaktstomatitis mit spezifischer lymfocytenstimulation durch gold. Hautarzt21:422-424.
65.
Schwickerath H., Merk HF ( 1986). Ergebnisse des epikutan-testes mit verschiedenen legierungen . Dtsch Zahnärztl Z41:1253-1256.
66.
Spiechowicz E., Glantz P.-O, Axell T., Chmielewski W. (1984). Oral exposure to a nickel-containing dental alloy of persons with hypersensitive skin reactions to nickel. Contact Dermatitis10:206-211.
67.
Spreng M. (1959). Allergie und zahnmedizin. Leipzig (Germany): Johann Ambrosius Barth Verlag, 137 pp. Staerkj aer L, Menne T (1990). Nickel allergy and orthodontic treatment. Eur J Orthodont12:284-289.
68.
Stenberg T. (1982). Release of cobalt from cobalt-chromium alloy constructions in the oral cavity of man. Scand J Dent Res90:472-479.
69.
Stenman E., Bergman M. (1989). Hypersensitivity reactions to dental materials in a referred group of patients. Scand J Dent Res97:76-83.
70.
Törnell SO (1962). Allergiska reaktioner i munslemhinnan av dentalguld . J Swed Dent Assoc54:151-154.
71.
Turrell Ajw (1966). Allergy to denture base materials-fallacy or reality . Br Dent J120:415-422.
72.
Van der Burg Ckh, Bruynzeel DP, Vreeburg Kjj, von Blomberg Bme, Scheper RJ (1986). Hand eczema in hairdressers and nurses: a prospective study. I. Evaluation of atopy and nickel hypersensitivity at the start of apprenticeship. Contact Dermatitis14:275-279.
73.
Van Joost T., Roesyanto-Mahadi ID (1990). Combined sensitization to palladium and nickel . Contact Dermatitis22:227-228.
74.
Van Ketel WG, Niebber C. (1981). Allergy to palladium in dental alloys. Contact Dermatitis7:331.
75.
Van Loon Laj, Van Elsas PW, Van Joost T., Davidson CL (1984). Contact stomatitis and dermatitis to nickel and palladium. Contact Dermatitis11:294-297.
76.
Van Loon Laj, Van Elsas PW, Van Joost T., Davidson CL (1986). The use of a test battery for metal allergy in dentistry. Contact Dermatitis14:158-161.
77.
Veron C., Hildebrand HF, Martin P. (1986). Amalgame dentaire et allergie. J Bioi Buccale14:83-100.
78.
Vitsentzos SJ, Vlahogiannis E., Glaros D., Vlahomitros J. (1988). The effect of fixed partial dentures made of silver-palladium alloy on serum immunoglobulins IgA, IgG and IgM. J Prosthet Dent59:597-589.
79.
Vreeburg Kjj, de Groot K., von Blomberg Bme, Scheper RJ (1984). Induction of immunological tolerance by oral administration of nickel and chromium. J Dent Res63:124-128.
80.
Vreeburg Kjj, Van Hoogstraten Imv, von Blomberg Bme, de Groot K., Scheper RJ (1990). Oral induction of immunological tolerance to chromium in the guinea pig. J Dent Res69:1634-1639.
81.
Weiss PA (1983). State-of-the-art metal ceramics. Utilizing nickel chromium superalloy frameworks. In: McLean JW, editor. Dental Ceramics, Proceedings, 1st International Symposium on Ceramics. Chicago (IL): Quintessence, 231.
82.
Wirz J., Adler A., Schmidli F. (1989). Metallunvertraglichkeit. Klinische erscheinungsformen und ursachen von metallunvertraglichkeit. Schweiz Monatsschr Zahnmed99:72-82.
83.
Witte M. (1986). Die allergenitat von NEM-legierungen. Quintessenz37:2119-2125.
Yontchev EA (1986). Studies on individuals with orofacial discomfort complaints. An investigation of a group of patients who related their sufferings to effects of dental materials and constructions (thesis). Swed Dent J (Suppl 38).
86.
Young E. (1974). Contact hypersensitivity to metallic gold. Dermatologia149:294-298.
