Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Advocates often predict that school choice policies will expand access to high-quality schools, particularly for marginalized communities. To interrogate this assumption, we employed a sequential mixed-methods analysis examining the state of charter reform in the District of Columbia. We observed that stakeholders consistently defined equity as uniform processes, evident in data distribution and enrollment practices. We also uncovered persistent disparities in where students live versus learn. We conclude that race-neutral conceptions of equity may hinder attempts to improve school access by ignoring structural inequalities tied to race, place, and income and by overlooking privileged households’ efforts to remain separate.

Keywords

charter schools educational equity education reform policy implementation segregation urban schools

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

A+ Colorado. (2018). Unequal choices: School model diversity in Denver Public Schools. http://apluscolorado.org/reports/unequal-choices-school-model-diversity-in-denver-public-schools/

Akerlof

G. A.

Dickens

W. T.

(1982). The economic consequences of cognitive dissonance. The American Economic Review, 72(3), 307–319.

Allender

Estacion

Nabors

(2017). Working together to support equitable access to charter schools: Research and recommendations. Mid-Atlantic Comprehensive Center at WestEd. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED589982.pdf

Annamma

S. A.

Jackson

D. D.

Morrison

(2017). Conceptualizing color-evasiveness: Using dis/ability critical race theory to expand a color-blind racial ideology in education and society. Race Ethnicity and Education, 20(2), 147–162.

Asch

C. M.

Musgrove

G. D.

(2017). Chocolate city: A history of race and democracy in the nation’s capital. UNC Press Books.

Ball

S. J.

Vincent

(1998). “I heard it on the grapevine”: “Hot” knowledge and school choice. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 19(3), 377–400.

Bell

C. A.

(2007). Space and place: Urban parents’ geographical preferences for schools. The Urban Review, 39(4), 375–404.

Bell

C. A.

(2009). All choices created equal? The role of choice sets in the selection of schools. Peabody Journal of Education, 84(2), 191–208.

Bell

D. A.

Jr. (1980). Brown v. Board of Education and the interest-convergence dilemma. Harvard Law Review, 93, 518–533.

10.

Biddle

Berliner

D. C.

(2002). Unequal school. Educational Leadership, 59(8), 48–59.

11.

Bifulco

Ladd

H. F.

(2007). School choice, racial segregation, and test-score gaps: Evidence from North Carolina’s charter school program. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 26(1), 31–56.

12.

Boarnet

M. G.

Bostic

R. W.

Rodnyansky

Burinskiy

Eisenlohr

Jamme

H. T.

Santiago-Bartolomei

(2020). Do high income households reduce driving more when living near rail transit? Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment, 80, 102244. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.trd.2020.102244

13.

Bouker

(2008, December). Building the best capital city in the world: Appendix one. The Brookings Institution. https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/appendix-1.pdf

14.

Bulkley

K. E.

(2013). Conceptions of equity: How influential actors view a contested concept. Peabody Journal of Education, 88(1), 10–21.

15.

Bulkley

K. E.

Marsh

J. A.

Strunk

K. O.

Harris

D. N.

Hashim

A. K.

(2020). Challenging the one best system: The portfolio management model and urban school governance. Harvard Education Press.

16.

Bulkley

K. E.

Travers

(2013). Variations on a theme: The shift from distinction to commonality in Philadelphia’s diverse provider model 2002–2008. Journal of School Choice, 7(4), 532–559. https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2013.837767

17.

Carman

(2020, February 27). After 30 years, Horace & Dickie’s is saying goodbye to a neighborhood its owner no longer recognizes. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/food/after-30-years-horace-and-dickies-is-saying-goodbye-to-a-neighborhood-its-owner-no-longer-recognizes/2020/02/27/d8f0fb92-5809-11ea-9b35-def5a027d470_story.html

18.

Charmaz

(2014). Constructing grounded theory (2nd ed.). SAGE.

19.

Chubb

J. E.

Moe

T. M.

(1990). Politics, markets, and America’s schools. Brookings Institution Press.

20.

Cobb

C. D.

Glass

G. V.

(2009). School choice in a post-desegregation world. Peabody Journal of Education, 84(2), 262–278.

21.

Coons

J. E.

Sugarman

S. D.

(1978). Education by choice. University of California Press.

22.

Creswell

J. W.

Plano Clark

V. L.

(2018). Designing and conducting mixed methods research. SAGE.

23.

Diem

Young

M. D.

Sampson

(2019). Where critical policy meets the politics of education: An introduction. Educational Policy, 33(1), 3–15.

24.

Diem

Young

M. D.

Welton

A. D.

Mansfield

K. C.

Lee

P. L.

(2014). The intellectual landscape of critical policy analysis. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 27(9), 1068–1090.

25.

Dixson

A. D.

Donnor

J. K.

Anderson

C. R.

(2011). Introduction to the special issue the race for educational equity. Teachers College Record, 113(4), 699–702.

26.

Eisenlohr

(2023). Detecting patterns in charter school closure in the District of Columbia (Working Paper).

27.

Faber

J. W.

(2020). We built this: Consequences of new deal era intervention in America’s racial geography. American Sociological Review, 85(5), 739–775.

28.

Feagin

J. R.

(2012). White party, white government: Race, class, and US politics. Routledge.

29.

Felix

E. R.

Trinidad

(2020). The decentralization of race: Tracing the dilution of racial equity in educational policy. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 33(4), 465–490.

30.

Fleming

D. J.

Cowen

J. M.

Witte

J. F.

Wolf

P. J.

(2015). Similar students, different choices: Who uses a school voucher in an otherwise similar population of students? Education and Urban Society, 47(7), 785–812.

31.

Forman

Jr. (2004). The secret history of school choice: How progressives got there first. The Georgetown Law Journal, 93, 1287–1319.

32.

Frankenberg

(2013). The role of residential segregation in contemporary school segregation. Education and Urban Society, 45(5), 548–570.

33.

Friedman

(1962). The role of government in education. In Capitalism and freedom (pp. 85–107). University of Chicago Press.

34.

Geertz

(1972). Notes on the Balinese cockfight. Daedalus, 134(4), 56–86.

35.

Golub

Marcantonio

R. A.

Sanchez

T. W.

(2013). Race, space, and struggles for mobility: transportation impacts on African Americans in Oakland and the East Bay. Urban Geography, 34(5), 699–728.

36.

Grable

S. W.

(1979). Applying urban history to city planning: A case study in Atlanta. The Public Historian, 1, 45–59.

37.

Guerrieri

Hartley

Hurst

(2013). Endogenous gentrification and housing price dynamics. Journal of Public Economics, 100, 45–60.

38.

Gunderson

(1995a, August 10). Lawmaker offers schools plan. The Washington Post, DC3.

39.

Gunderson

(1995b, October 9). World class schools for Washington. The Washington Post, A27.

40.

Hanks

Solomon

Weller

C. E.

(2018, February 21). Systematic inequality: How American’s structural racism helped create the Black-White wealth gap. Center for American Progress. https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/race/reports/2018/02/21/447051/systematic-inequality/

41.

Hill

P. T.

Campbell

Gross

(2013). Strife and progress: Portfolio strategies for managing urban schools. Brookings Institution Press.

42.

Holme

J. J.

(2002). Buying homes, buying schools: School choice and the social construction of school quality. Harvard Educational Review, 72(2), 177–206.

43.

Horwitz

(1994, March 5). A public defeat on privatization. The Washington Post, B1.

44.

Hoxby

C. M.

(1996). Are efficiency and equity in school finance substitutes or complements? Journal of Economic Perspectives, 10(4), 51–72.

45.

Hoxby

C. M.

(2003). School choice and school productivity. Could school choice be a tide that lifts all boats? In Hoxby

C. M.

(Ed.), The economics of school choice (pp. 287–342). University of Chicago Press.

46.

Jabbar

(2015). “Every kid is money”: Market-like competition and school leader strategies in New Orleans. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 37(4), 638–659.

47.

Jabbar

Daramola

E. J.

Marsh

J. A.

Enoch-Stevens

Alonso

Allbright

T. N.

(2022). Social construction is racial construction: Examining the target populations in school-choice policies. American Journal of Education, 128(3), 487–518.

48.

Kahlenberg

R. D.

(2001). Socioeconomic school integration through public school choice: A progressive alternative to vouchers. Howard Law Journal, 45, 247.

49.

Kahlenberg

R. D.

(2016, February 10). School integration’s comeback. The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2016/02/breaking-up-school-poverty/462066/

50.

Kleitz

Weiher

G. R.

Tedin

Matland

(2000). Choice, charter schools, and household preferences. Social Science Quarterly, 81(3), 846–854.

51.

Kotok

Frankenberg

Schafft

K. A.

Mann

B. A.

Fuller

E. J.

(2017). School choice, racial segregation, and poverty concentration: Evidence from Pennsylvania charter school transfers. Educational Policy, 31(4), 415–447.

52.

Kozol

(1991). Savage inequalities: Children in America’s schools. Broadway Books.

53.

Lacireno-Paquet

Holyoke

T. T.

Moser

Henig

J. R.

(2002). Creaming versus cropping: Charter school enrollment practices in response to market incentives. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 24(2), 145–158.

54.

Ladd

H. F.

Clotfelter

C. T.

Holbein

J. B.

(2017). The growing segmentation of the charter school sector in North Carolina. Education Finance and Policy, 12(4), 536–563.

55.

Liu

Taylor

W. L.

(2005). School choice to achieve desegregation. Fordham Law Review, 74, 791–823.

56.

Lubienski

Gulosino

Weitzel

(2009). School choice and competitive incentives: Mapping the distribution of educational opportunities across local education markets. American Journal of Education, 115(4), 601–647.

57.

Marcotte

D. E.

Dalane

(2019). Socioeconomic segregation and school choice in American public schools. Educational Researcher, 48(8), 493–503.

58.

Marsh

J. A.

Allbright

T. N.

Brown

D. R.

Bulkley

K. E.

Strunk

K. O.

Harris

D. N.

(2021). The process and politics of educational governance change in New Orleans, Los Angeles, and Denver. American Educational Research Journal, 58(1), 107–159. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831220921475

59.

Masur

(2011, March 28). Capital injustice. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/29/opinion/29masur.html

60.

McCluskey

(2019, August 30). Segregation and the school choice movement. Education Next. https://www.educationnext.org/segregation-and-school-choice-movement/

61.

McFadden

(1973). Conditional logit analysis of qualitative choice behavior. In Zarembka

(ed.), Frontiers in economics (pp. 105–135). Wiley.

62.

McShane

M. Q.

Shaw

(2020, March). Transporting school choice students: A primer on states' transportation policies related to private, charter, and open enrollment students. EdChoice. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED605559.pdf

63.

Merriam

S. B.

Tisdell

E. J.

(2016). Qualitative research: A guide to design and implementation. Jossey-Bass.

64.

Mickelson

R. A.

Bottia

Southworth

(2012). School choice and segregation by race, ethnicity, class, and achievement. In Miron

Welner

K. G.

Hinchey

P. H.

Mathis

W. J.

(Eds.), Exploring the school choice universe: Evidence and recommendations (pp. 167–192). National Education Policy Center and Information Age Publishing, Inc.

65.

Miles

M. B.

Huberman

A. M.

Saldaña

(2020). Qualitative data analysis: A methods sourcebook (4th ed.). SAGE.

66.

National Center for Research on Education Access and Choice Project (REACH Project). (2019). Improving policy, implementation, and outcomes for disadvantaged students. Ongoing Research Project. University of Southern California, Michigan State University, Tulane University, University of Texas at Austin, Florida State University, Montclair State University.

67.

National Council on Disability (NCD). (2018a, November 15). School choice series: Charter schools—implications for students with disabilities. https://ncd.gov/sites/default/files/NCD_Charter-Schools-Report_508_0.pdf

68.

National Council on Disability (NCD). (2018b, November 15). School choice series: Choice & vouchers—implications for students with disabilities. https://ncd.gov/sites/default/files/NCD_Choice-Vouchers_508_0.pdf

69.

Office of the State Superintendent of Education (OSSE). (2020). District of Columbia report. DC School Report Card. Retrieved November 18, 2020, from https://dcschoolreportcard.org/state/99999-0000/pcsb_profile?lang=en

70.

Orfield

(2014). Tenth annual Brown lecture in education research: A new civil rights agenda for American education. Educational Researcher, 43(6), 273–292.

71.

Orfield

(2017). Our segregated capital: An increasingly diverse city with racially polarized schools. Civil Rights Project/Proyecto Derechos Civiles. https://escholarship.org/content/qt3m9315v6/qt3m9315v6.pdf

72.

Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No 1, 551 U.S. 701 (2007). https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/06pdf/05-908.pdf

73.

Posey-Maddox

de Royston

M. M.

Holman

A. R.

Rall

R. M.

Johnson

R. A.

(2021). No choice is the “right” choice: Black parents’ educational decision-making in their search for a “good” school. Harvard Educational Review, 91(1), 38–61.

74.

Potter

Quick

(2018, May 15). Diverse-by-design charter schools. The Century Foundation. https://tcf.org/content/report/diverse-design-charter-schools/?session=1&agreed=1

75.

Richardson

Mitchell

Franco

(2019, March 19). Shifting neighborhoods: Gentrification and cultural displacement in American cities. National Community Reinvestment Coalition. https://ncrc.org/gentrification/

76.

Roda

Wells

A. S.

(2013). School choice policies and racial segregation: Where white parents’ good intentions, anxiety, and privilege collide. American Journal of Education, 119(2), 261–293.

77.

Ryan

J. E.

Heise

(2002). The political economy of school choice. The Yale Law Journal, 111(8), 2043–2136.

78.

Saldaña

(2016). The coding manual for qualitative researchers (3rd ed.). SAGE.

79.

Saporito

(2003). Private choices, public consequences: Magnet school choice and segregation by race and poverty. Social Problems, 50(2), 181–203.

80.

Schneider

Ingram

(1993). Social construction of target populations: Implications for politics and policy. American political science review, 87(2), 334–347.

81.

Schneider

Vise

(1995, August 2). Speaker comes out of the House to air his ideas for the District. The Washington Post, D1, D6.

82.

Scott

J. T.

(2011). Market-driven education reform and the racial politics of advocacy. Peabody Journal of Education, 86(5), 580–599.

83.

Scott

J. T.

(2013). A Rosa Parks moment? School choice and the marketization of civil rights. Critical Studies in Education, 54(1), 5–18.

84.

Sen

A. K.

(1999). Development as freedom. Alfred A. Knopf Publishing.

85.

Senator Tim Scott. (2021, January 25). Scott and colleagues introduce national school choice week resolution. https://www.scott.senate.gov/media-center/press-releases/scott-and-colleagues-introduce-national-school-choice-week-resolution

86.

Shapiro

Meschede

Osoro

(2013, February). The roots of the widening racial wealth gap: Explaining the black-white economic divide. Institute on Assets and Social Policy. https://drum.lib.umd.edu/bitstream/handle/1903/24590/racialwealthgapbrief.pdf

87.

Singer

Lenhoff

S. W.

(2022). Race, geography, and school choice policy: A critical analysis of Detroit students’ suburban school choices. AERA Open, 8, 23328584211067202.

88.

Teddlie

Tashakkori

(2006). A general typology of research designs featuring mixed methods. Research in the Schools, 13(1), 12–28.

89.

Thornton

P. H.

Ocasio

(1999). Institutional logics and the historical contingency of power in organizations: Executive succession in the higher education publishing industry, 1958–1990. American Journal of Sociology, 105(3), 801–843.

90.

Valant

Lincove

J. A.

(2018, September). New Orleans students’ commute times by car, public transit, and school bus. Urban Institute. https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/99051/new_orleans_students_commute_times_by_car_public_transit_and_school_bus_0.pdf

91.

Viner

(1927). Adam Smith and laissez faire. Journal of Political Economy, 35(2), 198–232.

92.

Washington Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights. (2005, March). Separate and unequal: The state of the District of Columbia Public Schools fifty years after Brown and Bolling (A Parents United for the D.C. Public Schools Civic Leader Advisory Committee Report). http://www.washlaw.org/pdf/Separate_and_Unequal_Report.pdf

93.

Wilson

Bridge

(2019). School choice and the city: Geographies of allocation and segregation. Urban Studies, 56(15), 3198–3215.

94.

Yin

R. K.

(2014). Case study research: Designs and methods. SAGE.

95.

Yoon

E. S.

Lubienski

(2017). How do marginalized families engage in school choice in inequitable urban landscapes? A critical geographic approach. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 25(42), 1–26.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

1.38 MB

A Tale of Two Systems: Choice and Equity in the District of Columbia’s Charter Schools

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References

Supplementary Material