Becoming HOPEless in the 2-year sector addresses the question: what happens when a state-wide policy removes merit-based financial aid from low-income students making satisfactory academic progress? To assess the magnitude of this HOPEless effect, we compared credits attempted, attained, and persistence and graduation indicators of HOPEless students against the outcomes of their not targeted/affected peers. Relying on multiple quasi-experimental analytic techniques (difference in differences [DD], DD in differences, Fuzzy regression discontinuity, and multi-treatment propensity score weighting), two mutually exclusive analytic samples (one longitudinal and one cross-sectional), and over one million observations across four academic years (2009–2010 to 2012–2013), we consistently found that HOPEless students realized worse outcomes and even persisted fewer terms/semesters than students on academic probation. The State saved about $150 million in lottery money (largely funded by lower-income households) but did so at the expense of 665,192 credit hours that would have been attained by HOPEless (low-income) students.
ArellanoM. (2003). Panel data econometrics. Oxford University Press.
4.
BarberisN. C. (2013). Thirty years of prospect theory in economics: A review and assessment. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 27(1), 173–196.
5.
BarrowL.Richburg-HayesL.RouseC. E.BrockT. (2014). Paying for performance: The education impacts of a community college scholarship program for low-income adults. Journal of Labor Economics, 32(3), 563–599.
6.
BartenA. P.BöhmV. (1982). Consumer theory. In ArrowK. J. (Ed.), Handbook of mathematical economics (Vol. 2, pp. 381–429). North Holland.
7.
BaumolW.BlinderA. (2011). Microeconomics: Principles and policy. Cengage Learning.
BaumS.MaJ.PayeaK. (2010). Education pays, 2010: The benefits of higher education for individuals and society. Trends in higher education series. College Board Advocacy & Policy Center.
10.
BelfieldC. R. (2013). Student loans and repayment rates: The role of for-profit colleges. Research in Higher Education, 54, 1–29.
11.
BertrandM.DufloE.MullainathanS. (2004). How much should we trust differences-in-differences estimates?The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 119(1), 249–275. https://doi.org/10.1162/003355304772839588
12.
BilinskiA.HatfieldL. A. (2018). Nothing to see here? Non-inferiority approaches to parallel trends and other model assumptions. arXiv preprint arXiv:1805.03273.
13.
BraggD. D.KimE.BarnettE. A. (2006). Creating access and success: Academic pathways reaching underserved students. New Directions for Community Colleges, 2006(135), 5–19.
14.
BrandJ. E.PfefferF. T.Goldrick-RabS. (2014). The community college effect revisited: The importance of attending to heterogeneity and complex counterfactuals. Sociological Science, 1, 448–465.
15.
BruceD. J.CarruthersC. K. (2014). Jackpot? The impact of lottery scholarships on enrollment in tennessee. Journal of Urban Economics, 81, 30–44.
16.
CalonicoS.CattaneoM.TitiunikR. (2015). Rdrobust: An R package for robust nonparametric inference in regression-discontinuity designs. The R Journal, 7(1), 38–51. https://doi.org/10.32614/RJ-2015-004
17.
CalonicoS.CattaneoM. D.FarrellM. H.TitiunikR. (2019). Regression discontinuity designs using covariates. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 101(3), 442–451.
CantorJ. C.MonheitA. C.DeLiaD.LloydK. (2012). Early impact of the affordable care act on health insurance coverage of young adults. Health Services Research, 47(5), 1773–1790.
20.
CarruthersC. K.ÖzekU. (2016). Losing hope: Financial aid and the line between college and work. Economics of Education Review, 53, 1–15.
21.
CornwellC.MustardD.SridharD. (2006). The enrollment effects of merit-based financial aid: Evidence from georgia’s hope program. Journal of Labor Economics, 24(4), 761–786.
22.
CornwellC.MustardD. B. (2007). Merit-based college scholarships and car sales. Education Finance and Policy, 2(2), 133–151.
23.
CunninghamA. F.SantiagoD. A. (2008). Student aversion to borrowing: Who borrows and who doesn’t. Institute for Higher Education Policy.
24.
DaviesE.LeaS. E. G. (1995). Student attitudes to student debt. Journal of Economic Psychology, 16(4), 663–679.
25.
DemingD. J.GoldinC.KatzL. F. (2011). The for-profit postsecondary school sector: Nimble critters or agile predators? (Technical report). National Bureau of Economic Research.
26.
DesJardinsS. L.AhlburgD. A.McCallB. P. (2002). A temporal investigation of factors related to timely degree completion. The Journal of Higher Education, 73, 555–581.
27.
DietrichC. C.LichtenbergerE. J. (2015). Using propensity score matching to test the community college penalty assumption. The Review of Higher Education, 38(2), 193–219.
DowdA. C.CouryT. (2006). The effect of loans on the persistence and attainment of community college students. Research in Higher Education, 47(1), 33–62.
30.
DoyleW. R. (2009). The effect of community college enrollment on bachelor’s degree completion. Economics of Education Review, 28(2), 199–206.
31.
DusheikoM.GravelleH.JacobsR.SmithP. (2006). The effect of financial incentives on gatekeeping doctors: Evidence from a natural experiment. Journal of Health Economics, 25(3), 449–478.
32.
DynarskiS. (2000). Hope for whom? Financial Aid for the middle class and its impact on college attendance. National Tax Journal, 53(3.2), 629–661.
33.
FieldK. (2010). Government vastly undercounts defaults (p. 11). The Chronicle of Higher Education.
GladieuxL.PernaL. (2005). Borrowers who drop out: A neglected aspect of the college student loan trend. National center report# 05-2. National Center for Public Policy and Higher Education.
36.
GoldmanA. L.McCormickD.HaasJ. S.SommersB. D. (2018). Effects of the aca’s health insurance marketplaces on the previously uninsured: A quasi-experimental analysis. Health Affairs, 37(4), 591–599.
37.
Goldrick-RabS. (2010). Challenges and opportunities for improving community college student success. Review of Educational Research, 80(3), 437–469.
38.
Goldrick-RabS.HarrisD.N.TrostelP.A. (2009). Why financial aid matters (or Does Not) for college success: Toward a new interdisciplinary perspective. In: SmartJ. C. (Ed.), Higher education: Handbook of theory and research (Vol.24). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4020-9628-0_1
39.
González CanchéM. S. (2012). Community colleges, catalysts for mobility or engines for inequality? addressing selection bias in the estimation of their effects on educational and occupational outcomes [PhD thesis]. The University of Arizona.
40.
González CanchéM. S. (2014). Is the community college a less expensive path toward a bachelor’s degree?: Public 2-and 4-year colleges’ impact on loan debt. The Journal of Higher Education, 85(5), 723–759.
41.
González CanchéM. S. (2018). Reassessing the two-year sector’s role in the amelioration of a persistent socioeconomic gap: A proposed analytical framework for the study of community college effects in the big and geocoded data and quasi-experimental era. Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and Research. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-72490-4_5
42.
González CanchéM. S. (2020). Community college students who attained a 4-year degree accrued lower student loan debt than 4-year entrants over 2 decades: Is a 10 percent debt accumulation reduction worth the added “risk”? if so, for whom?Research in Higher Education, 61(7), 871–915.
43.
González CanchéM. S. (2022). Post-purchase federal financial aid: How (in) effective is the irs’s student loan interest deduction (slid) in reaching lower-income taxpayers and students?Research in Higher Education. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11162-021-09672-6
44.
GruberJ. (1994). The incidence of mandated maternity benefits. The American Economic Review, 84(3), 622–641. http://www.jstor.org/stable/2118071
HenryG. T.RubensteinR.BuglerD. T. (2004). Is hope enough? Impacts of receiving and losing merit-based financial aid. Educational Policy, 18(5), 686–709.
47.
HillmanN. W. (2014). College on credit: A multi-level analysis of student loan default. The Review of Higher Education, 37, 169–195.
48.
HryshkoD.Luengo-PradoM. J.SørensenB. E. (2011). Childhood determinants of risk aversion: The long shadow of compulsory education. Quantitative Economics, 2(1), 37–72.
49.
HuX.OrtagusJ. C.KramerD. A. (2018). The community college pathway: An analysis of the costs associated with enrolling initially at a community college before transferring to a 4-year institution. Higher Education Policy, 31, 359–380.
50.
ImbensG.WooldridgeJ. M. (2007). What’s new in econometrics?NBER.
51.
JonesT. R.KreismanD.RubensteinR.SearcyC.BhattR. (2022). The effects of financial aid loss on persistence and graduation: A multi-dimensional regression discontinuity approach. Education Finance and Policy, 17, 206–231. https://docs.iza.org/dp13849.pdf
52.
KahnemanD.KnetschJ. L.ThalerR. H. (1990). Experimental tests of the endowment effect and the coase theorem. Journal of Political Economy, 98(6), 1325–1348.
53.
LaSotaR. R.PolaninJ. R.PernaL. W.AustinM. J.SteingutR. R.RodgersM. A. (2022). The effects of losing postsecondary student grant aid: Results from a systematic review. Educational Researcher, 51, 160–168.
54.
LefebvreP.MerriganP.VerstraeteM. (2009). Dynamic labour supply effects of childcare subsidies: Evidence from a canadian natural experiment on low-fee universal child care. Labour Economics, 16(5), 490–502.
55.
LongB. T.KurlaenderM. (2009). Do community colleges provide a viable pathway to a baccalaureate degree?Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 31(1), 30–53.
MatthewsD. (2010). A stronger nation through higher education. Lumina Foundation.
58.
MayerA.PatelR.RuddT.RatledgeA. (2015). Designing scholarships to improve college success: Final report on the performance-based scholarship demonstration. MDRC.
59.
McCaffreyD. F.GriffinB. A.AlmirallD.SlaughterM. E.RamchandR.BurgetteL. F. (2013). A tutorial on propensity score estimation for multiple treatments using generalized boosted models. Statistics in Medicine, 32(19), 3388–3414.
60.
MetcalfH. (2005). Paying for university: The impact of increasing costs on student employment, debt and satisfaction. National Institute Economic Review, 191(1), 106–117.
61.
National Center for Education Statistics. (2020). Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System: Directory information (HD2020) and Student charges for academic year programs (IC2020_AY). National Center for Education Statistics, Institute of Education Sciences, US Dept. of Education. Retrieved March 5, 2011, from https://nces.ed.gov/ipeds/datacenter/data/IC2020_AY.zip
62.
Richburg-HayesL.BrockT.LeBlancA.PaxsonC. H.RouseC. E.BarrowL. (2009). Rewarding persistence: Effects of a performance-based scholarship program for low-income parents. SSRN Electronic Journal. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.2139/SSRN.1353360
63.
RosnowR. L.RosenthalR.RubinD. B. (2000). Contrasts and correlations in effect-size estimation. Psychological Science, 11(6), 446–453.
64.
Scott-ClaytonJ. (2011). On money and motivation: A quasi-experimental analysis of financial incentives for college achievement. Journal of Human Resources, 46(3), 614–646.
65.
Scott-ClaytonJ.SchuddeL. (2020). The consequences of performance standards in need-based aid evidence from community colleges. Journal of Human Resources, 55(4), 1105–1136.
66.
StephanJ. L.RosenbaumJ. E.PersonA. E. (2009). Stratification in college entry and completion. Social Science Research, 38(3), 572–593.
VarianH. (2010). Intermediate microeconomics: A modern approach (Vol. 7). WW Norton New York.
72.
WooldridgeJ. M. (2010). Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. MIT press.
73.
YurukogluA.LiebmanE.RidleyD. B. (2017). The role of government reimbursement in drug shortages. American Economic Journal Economic Policy, 9(2), 348–382.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
