Rawlsian Justice and the Ayers Settlement

Abstract

In 2004 a near 30-year legal battle over higher education desegregation in Mississippi was settled with the state’s historically Black colleges and universities (HBCUs) to receive US$503 million over the course of 17 years. Nearly 65% of this funding is directed toward the recruitment and support of White students, with a significant share of endowment funding tied to the attainment and maintenance of 10% non-Black enrollments. To analyze the fairness of this settlement, I use the theoretical framework of justice as fairness and apply the tenets of Rawlsian theory. I find a mismatch between settlement terms and justice as fairness. Thus, as Rawls predicts, while the settlement is final, it fails to bring closure.

Keywords

diversity higher education policy legal issues

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams v. Califano, 430 F.Supp. 118 (D. C. Cir. 1977).

Adams v. Richardson, 351 F.2d 636 (D. C. Cir. 1972).

Adams v. Richardson, 356 F.2d 92 (D. C. Cir. 1973); 480 F.2d 1159 (D. C. Cir. 1973).

Allen

W. R.

Jewell

J. O.

Griffin

K. A.

Wolf

D. S.

(2007). Historically Black colleges and universities: Honoring the past, engaging the present, touching the future. Journal of Negro Education, 76, 263-280.

Anderson

J. D.

(1988). The education of Blacks in the South, 1860-1935. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.

Anderson

J. D.

(2008). No sacrifice to great: The history of African American Education from slavery to the twenty-first century. New York, NY: Beacon Press.

Apple

M. W.

(2004). Ideology and curriculum (3rd ed.). New York, NY: RoutledgeFalmer.

Arnold

R. D.

(1990). The logic of congressional action. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

Associated Press. (2005, November 17). Alcorn State first to receive endowment money from Ayers settlement. Diverse Issues in Higher Education. Retrieved from http://diverseeducation.com/article/5100/

10.

Associated Press. (2010, October 26). Ayers funding to drop off in 2012. Diverse Issues in Higher Education. Retrieved from http://diverseeducation.com/article/14317/

11.

Avery

(2009). Taking the pulse of historically black colleges. Academic Questions, 22, 327-339.

12.

Ayers v. Allain, 674 F. Supp. 1523 (N.D. Miss. 1987), 898 F.2d 732 (1990).

13.

Ayers v. Fordice, 970 F.2s 1378 (5th Cir. 1992), 879 F. Supp. 1419 (N.D. Miss. 1995), 111 F.3d 1183 (5th Cir. 1997).

14.

Ayers v. Musgrove, 2001 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 9877 (2001).

15.

Ayers v. Thompson, 358 F.3d 356 (5th Cir. 2004), cert. denied, 543 U.S 951 (2004).

16.

Barry

(2002, November 28). The philosopher who transformed his subject. The Financial Times, p. 23.

17.

Blake

Jr. (1991). Is higher education desegregation a remedy for segregation but not educational inequality? A study of the Ayers v. Mabus desegregation case. Journal of Negro Education, 60, 538-565.

18.

Bourdieu

(1977). Cultural reproduction and social reproduction. In Karabel

Halsey

A. H.

(Eds.), Power and ideology in education (pp. 487-511). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

19.

Brady

(2009). Rich democracies, poor people: How politics explain poverty. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

20.

Brown

M. C.

II . (1999). The quest to define collegiate desegregation: Black colleges, Title IV Compliance, and post-Adams litigation. Westport, CT: Bergin and Garrey.

21.

Brown

M. C.

II. Davis

J. E.

(2001). The historically Black college as social contract, social capital and social equalizer. Peabody Journal of Education, 76, 31-49.

22.

Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483 (1954).

23.

Bureau of Economic Analysis. (2011). Current-dollar and “real” GDP. Retrieved from http://www.bea.gov/national/index.htm#gdp

24.

Chen

(2011). Occupy Wall Street: Social networks and the Arab Spring (Kindle ed.). Bristol, UK: Pearce Heart Group.

25.

Cheyney University. (2010). About CU. Retrieved from http://www.cheyney.edu/about%2Dcheyney%2Duniversity/

26.

City of Richmond v. J. A. Croson, 488 U.S. 469 (1989).

27.

Claus

J. F.

(1981). Radical reform within a liberal and democratic framework? Rawls and the radical critique of schooling. Educational Theory, 31, 153-165.

28.

Clinton

W. J.

(1999). Remarks by the president at presentation of the national medal of the arts and the national humanities medal. Washington, DC: White House Office of the Press Secretary. Retrieved from http://clinton4.nara.gov/WH/New/html/19990929.html

29.

Cohn

(1983). Social justice and social/political education: A theoretical exploration. International Journal of Political Education, 6(1), 1-23.

30.

Cook

K. S.

Hegtvedt

K. A.

(1986). Justice and power: An exchange analysis. In Bierhoff

H. W.

Cohen

R. L.

Greenberg

(Eds), Justice in social relations (pp. 19-42). New York, NY: Plenum.

31.

Dobbs

D. B.

(1993). Law of remedies: Damages—Equity—Restitution. St. Paul, MN: West.

32.

Dorf

M. C.

(2002). In praise of John Rawls, The man who made moral philosophy respectable again—and whose views also profoundly informed American legal thought. WritNews. Retrieved from http://writ.news.findlaw.com/dorf/20021211.html

33.

DuBois

W. E. B.

(1900). The college-bred negro (A report of social study made under the direction of Atlanta university) Proceedings of the fifth Conference for the study of the negro problems, held at Atlanta university. Atlanta, GA.

34.

Dworkin

(1989). Taking rights seriously. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

35.

Frazer

M. L.

(2007). John Rawls: Between two enlightenments. Political Theory, 35, 756-780.

36.

Freeman v. Pitts, 112 S. Ct. 1430 (1992).

37.

Gafford Muhammad

(2009). Mississippi higher education desegregation and the interest convergence principle: A CRT analysis of the “Ayers Settlement.” Race, Ethnicity, & Education, 12, 319-336.

38.

Gasman

M. B.

(2011). Questionable merger of Black colleges. Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved from http://chronicle.com/blogs/innovations/questionable-mergers-of-black-colleges/28466

39.

Hegtvedt

K. A.

(2005). Doing justice to the group: Examining the roles of the group in justice research. Annual Review of Sociology, 31, 25-45.

40.

Hegtvedt

K. A.

Markovsky

(1995). Justice and injustice. In Cook

K.S.

Fine

G. A.

House

J. S.

(Eds.), Sociological perspectives on social psychology (pp.257-280). Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.

41.

Hendrickson

(2003). Sons of Mississippi. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf.

42.

Hendrix

(2005). Permanent injustice: Rawls’ Theory of Justice and the digital divide. Educational Technology & Society, 8(1), 63-68.

43.

Jasso

(1983). Fairness of individual rewards and fairness of the reward distribution: Specifying the inconsistency between micro and macro principles of justice. Social Psychology Quarterly, 46, 185-199.

44.

Johnson

A. L.

Jr. (1993). Bid whist, tonk, and United States v. Fordice: Why integrationism fails African-Americans again. California Law Review, 81, 1401-1470.

45.

Johnston

J. S.

(2007). Right and goods: Procedural liberalism and educational policy. Educational Theory, 57, 469-488.

46.

Kim

M. M.

Conrad

C. F.

(2006). The impact of Historically Black colleges and universities on the academic success of African-American students. Research in Higher Education, 47, 399-427.

47.

Kleinberger

A. F.

(1976). The social-contract strategy for the justification of moral principles. Journal of Moral Education, 5(2), 107-126.

48.

Kluger

(1976). Simple justice: The history of Brown v. Board of Education and Black America’s struggle for equality (Special ed.). New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf.

49.

Lincoln University. (n.d.). About Lincoln. Retrieved from http://www.lincoln.edu/about.html

50.

Madrick

(2011). The age of greed: The triumph and decline of America, 1970 to the present. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf.

51.

Marbury v. Madison, 5 U.S. 137 (1803).

52.

Marens

(2007). Returning to Rawls: Social contracting, social justice, and transcending the limitations of Locke. Journal of Business Ethics, 75(1), 63-76.

53.

McLaurin v. Oklahoma State Regents, 339 U.S. 637 (1950).

54.

Meredith v. Fair, 202 F. Supp. 224, 227 (MI 1962a), 305 F.2d 341 (5th Cir. 1962b), 313 F.2d 534 (5th Cir. 1962c) cert. denied, 371 U.S. 828 (1962).

55.

Milliken v. Bradley, 418 U.S. 717 (1974).

56.

Minor

J. T.

(2008a). A contemporary perspective on the role of public HBCUs: Perspicacity from Mississippi. Journal of Negro Education, 77, 323-335.

57.

Minor

J. T.

(2008b). Contemporary HBCUs: Considering institutional capacity and state priorities. Retrieved from http://www.msu.edu/~jtminor/docs/MINORContemporary_HBCU_Report_2008.pdf.

58.

Morrison

H. B.

(1984). Some implications in Rawls’s theory for civic education. Journal of Negro Education, 53(1), 78-84.

59.

Nagel

S. S.

(Ed.). (1999). Policy analysis methods. Hauppauge, NY: Nova Science.

60.

Nagel

(2003, Spring). John Rawls and affirmative action. Journal of Blacks in Higher Education, 39, 82-84.

61.

North

C. E.

(2006). More than words? Delving into the substantive meaning(s) of “social Justice” in education. Review of Educational Research, 76, 507-535.

62.

Nozick

(1974). Anarchy, state, and utopia. New York, NY: Basic Books.

63.

Okin

S. M.

(1989). Reason and feeling in thinking about justice. Ethics, 99, 229-249.

64.

Palmer

J. C.

(2006). State apropriations for higher education, 2006-7. Chronicle of Higher Education, 53, A23-A26.

65.

Palmer

R. T.

Davis

R. J.

Maramba

D. C.

(2010). Role of an HBCU in supporting academic success for underprepared Black males. Negro Educational Review, 61(1-4), 85-106.

66.

Patterson

J. T.

(2001). Brown v. Board of Education: A civil rights milestone and its troubled legacy. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

67.

The persisting myth that the Black colleges are becoming Whiter. (2005, Spring). Journal of Blacks in Higher Education. Retrieved from http://www.jbhe.com/news_views/47_myth_blackcolleges.html

68.

Rawls

(1971/1999). A theory of justice (Rev. ed.). Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.

69.

Rawls

(1993). Political liberalism. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

70.

Rawls

(2001a). Justice as fairness: A restatement. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

71.

Rawls

(2001b). The law of peoples: with The idea of public reason revisited.” Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

72.

Reich

(2002). Bridging liberalism and multiculturalism in American education. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

73.

Samuels

A. O.

(2004). Is separate unequal? Black colleges and the challenge to desegregation. Lawrence: University of Kansas Press.

74.

Sears

J. B.

(2010). Philanthropy in the history of American higher education. Charleston, SC: Nabu Press.

75.

Shaw University. (2011). Homepage. Retrieved from http://www.shawu.edu/

76.

Southern Education Foundation. (1974). Ending discrimination in higher education: A report from ten states. Atlanta, GA: Author.

77.

St. John

(2000). The need for closure—Judge Neal Biggers Jr. rules that 65% of endowment money provided by Mississippi Legislature go to White students. Black Issues in Higher Education. Retrieved from http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0DXK/is_10_17/ai_63817011

78.

Stewart

Wright

Perry

Rankin

(2008). Historically Black colleges and universities: Caretakers of precious treasure. Journal of College Admission, 201, 24-29.

79.

Stolte

J. F.

(1983). The legitimation of structural inequality: Reformulation and test of the self-evaluation argument. American Sociological Review, 48, 331-342.

80.

Suitts

(2003). Fueling education reform: Historically Black colleges are meeting a national science imperative. Cell Biology Education, 2, 205-206.

81.

Thomas-Lester

(2004, October 31). Enrollment is shifting at Black universities. The Washington Post, p. C01.

82.

Tyler

T. R.

Boeckmann

R. J.

Smith

H. J.

Huo

Y. J.

(1997). Social justice in a diverse society. Boulder, CO: Westview.

83.

Ware

(1994). The most visible vestige: Black colleges after Fordice. Boston CollegeLaw Review, 35, 633-678.

84.

Weber

E. T.

(2008). Dewey and Rawls on education. Human Studies, 31, 361-382.

85.

Wilberforce University. (n.d.). About WU. Retrieved from http://www.wilberforce.edu/welcome/history.html

86.

Wilkins

B. T.

(1997). A third principle of justice. Journal of Ethics, 1, 355-374.

87.

Zuckert

(1981). Justice deserted: A critique of Rawls’ A Theory of Justice. Polity, 13, 466-483.