Most young children in the United States regularly spend time in early care and education (ECE) settings. Institutionalized messages surrounding ECE claim that it has the potential to promote children’s life-long success, especially among low-income children. I examine the legitimacy of these claims by reviewing empirical evidence that bears on them and find that most are based on results of a small set of impressive but outdated studies. More recent literature reveals positive, short-term effects of ECE programs on children’s development that weaken over time. Efforts to support children’s long-term success must extend beyond the ECE setting into elementary school.
Ackerman, D.J., Barnett, W.S., Hawkinson, L.E., Brown, K., & McGonigle, E.A. (2009). Providing preschool education for all 4-year-olds: Lessons from six state journeys. New Brunswick, NJ: National Institute for Early Education Research.
2.
Administration for Children and Families. ( 2006). Preliminary findings from the Early Head Start prekindergarten followup. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
3.
Anderson, M.L. ( 2008). Multiple inference and gender differences in the effects of early intervention: A re-evaluation of the Abecedarian, Perry Preschool, and Early Training Projects. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 103, 1481-1495.
4.
Barnett, W.S., Epstein, D.J., Friedman, A.H., Sansanelli, R., & Hustedt, J.T. ( 2009). The state of preschool 2009: State preschool yearbook . New Brunswick, NJ: National Institute for Early Education Research.
5.
Barnett, W.S., Jung, K., Wong, V., Cook, T., & Lamy, C. ( 2007, October). Effects of five state prekindergarten programs on early learning. Retrieved from http://nieer.org/docs/?DocID=129
6.
Barnett, W.S., Robin, K.B., Hustedt, J.T., & Schulman, K.L. (2003). The state of preschool: 2003 state preschool yearbook. New Brunswick, NJ: National Institute for Early Education Research.
7.
Belfield, C.R., Nores, M., Barnett, W.S., & Schweinhart, L.J. (2006). The High/ Scope Perry Preschool Program: Cost-benefit analysis using data from the age 40 follow-up . Journal of Human Resources, 41, 162-190.
8.
Belsky, J., Vandell, D.L., Burchinal, M., Clarke-Stewart, K.A., McCartney, K., & Tresch-Owen, M. (2007). Are there long-term effects of early child care? Child Development, 78, 681-701.
9.
Blank, R.M., & Schmidt, L. ( 2001). Work, wages, and welfare. In R. M. Blank & R. Haskins (Eds.), The new world of welfare (pp. 70-102). Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
10.
Bloom, B.S. ( 1964). Stability and change in human characteristics . New York, NY: Wiley.
11.
Brooks-Gunn, J. ( 2003). Do you believe in magic? What we can expect from early childhood intervention programs. SRCD Social Policy Report , 17(1), 3-14.
12.
Brown, C.A., & Wright, T.S. ( 2011). The rush toward universal pre-k: A media analysis . Educational Policy, 25(1), 115-133.
13.
Cahan, E.D. ( 1989, January). Past caring. A history of U.S. preschool care and education for the poor, 1820-1965. New York, NY : National Center for Children in Poverty.
14.
Campbell, F.A., Ramey, C.T., Pungello, E., Sparling, J., & Miller-Johnson, S. (2002). Early childhood education: Young adult outcomes from the Abecedarian Project. Applied Developmental Science, 6(1), 42-57.
15.
Capizzano, J., Adams, G., & Sonenstein, F. (2000). Child care arrangements for children under five: Variation across states. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.
16.
Capizzano, J., & Main, R. ( 2005, April). Many young children spend long hours in child care. Snapshots of America’s families (No. 22). Washington, DC: The Urban Institute .
17.
Clifford, R.M., Barbarin, O., Chang, F., Early, D., Bryant, D., Howes, C., . . . Pianta, R. ( 2005). What is pre-kindergarten? Characteristics of public pre-kindergarten programs. Applied Developmental Science, 9, 126-143.
18.
Cohen, S.S. ( 2001). Championing child care. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
19.
Cost, Quality, & Outcomes Team . (1995). Cost, quality, and child outcomes in child care centers. Denver, CO: University of Colorado.
20.
Côté, S.M., Borge, A.I., Geoffroy, M.-C., Rutter, M., & Tremblay, R.E. (2008). Nonmaternal care in infancy and emotional/behavioral difficulties at 4 years old: Moderation by family risk characteristics. Developmental Psychology, 44, 155-168.
21.
Cunha, F., & Heckman, J. ( 2007, May). The technology of skill formation. American Economic Review, 97(2), 31-47.
22.
Currie, J., & Thomas, D. ( 2000). School quality and the longer-term effects of Head Start . Journal of Human Resources, 35, 755-774.
23.
Dillon, S. ( 2008, December 17). Obama pledge stirs hope in early education . The New York Times. Retrieved from: http://www.nytimes.com
24.
Ewen, D.(2010, July). Senate subcommittee increases funding for child care and early education. Washington, DC: Center for Law and Social Policy (CLASP). Retrieved from http://www.clasp.org/issues/in_focus?type=child_care_and_early_education&id=0256
25.
Fight Crime: Invest in Kids New York. (2006 ). Preventing crime with pre-kindergarten: A critical investment in New York’s safety. Albany, NY: Author. Retrieved from http://www.fightcrime.org/sites/default/files/reports/nyprekbrief.pdf
26.
Gormley, W.T., Gayer, T., Phillips, D., & Dawson, B. ( 2005). The effects of universal pre-k on cognitive development . Developmental Psychology, 41, 872-884.
27.
Gormley, W.T., Phillips, D.A., Newmark, K., Perper, K., & Adelstein, S. (in press). Social-emotional effects of early childhood education programs in Tulsa. Child Development.
28.
Greenberg, M., Ewen, D., & Matthews, H. ( 2006). Using TANF for early childhood programs. Washington, DC: Center for Law and Social Policy.
29.
Guernsey, L. ( 2010, February 12). A closer look at Obama’s FY11 budget: Head Start. Washington, DC: The New America Foundation. Retrieved from http://earlyed.newamerica.net/node/27490
30.
Heckman, J.J. ( 2006). Skill formation and the economics of investing in disadvantaged children. Science, 312, 1900-1902.
31.
Hunt, J.M. ( 1961). Intelligence and experience. New York, NY: Ronald Press.
32.
Jacobson, L. ( 2010, April). Advocates weigh Obama’s commitment to early ed. Education Week, 29. Retrieved from http://www.edweek.org
33.
Kagan, S.L., & Cohen, N.E. ( 1997). Not by chance: Creating an early care and education system for America’s children. New Haven, CT: The Bush Center in Child Development and Social Policy at Yale University .
34.
Kagan, S.L., Moore, E., & Bredekamp, S. ( 1995). Reconsidering children’s early development and learning: Toward common views and vocabulary. Washington, DC: National Education Goals Panel.
35.
Kagan, S.L., & Rigby, E. ( 2003). Policy matters: Improving the readiness of children for school. Washington, DC: Center for the Study of Social Policy.
36.
Lamb, M.E., & Ahnert, L. ( 2006). Nonparental child care: Context, concepts, correlates, and consequences. In W. Damon, R. M. Lerner, K. A. Renninger , & I. E. Sigel (Eds.), Handbook of child psychology: Vol. 4. Child psychology in practice (pp. 950-1016, 6th ed.). Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
37.
Lee, V.E., Brooks-Gunn, J., Schnur, E., & Liaw, F. ( 1990). Are Head Start effects sustained? A longitudinal follow-up comparison of disadvantaged children attending Head Start, no preschool, and other preschool programs. Child Development, 61, 495-407.
38.
Loeb, S., Bridges, M., Bassok, D., Fuller, B., & Rumberger, R.W. (2007). How much is too much? The influence of preschool centers on children’s social and cognitive development . Economics of Education Review, 26, 52-66.
39.
Loeb, S., Fuller, B., Kagan, S.L., & Carrol, B. ( 2004). Child care in poor communities: Early learning effects of type, quality, and stability. Child Development , 75, 47-65.
40.
Love, J.M., Tarullo, L.B., Raikes, H., & Chazan-Cohen, R. (2006). Head Start: What do we know about its effectiveness? What do we need to know? In K. McCartney & D. Phillips (Eds.), Handbook of early childhood development (pp. 550-575). Malden, MA: Blackwell.
41.
Lowenstein, A.E., Phillips, D.A., & Gormley, W.T. ( 2009, April). Fostering the socio-emotional adjustment of low-income children: The effects of universal pre-K and Head Start in Oklahoma . Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Denver, CO.
42.
Magnuson, K., Ruhm, C., & Waldfogel, J. ( 2007). Does prekindergarten improve school preparation and performance ? Economics of Education Review, 26, 33-51.
43.
McCartney, K., Burchinal, M., Clarke-Stewart, A., Bub, K.L., Owen, M.T., Belsky, J., & the NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. (2010). Testing a series of causal propositions relating time in child care to children’s externalizing behavior. Developmental Psychology, 46, 1-17.
44.
Mosisa, A., & Hipple, S. ( 2006, October). Trends in labor force participation in the United States. Monthly Labor Review, 35-57.
45.
National Education Goals Panel. (1999). The National Education Goals report: Building a nation of learners . Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved from http://govinfo.library.unt.edu/negp/reports/99rpt.pdf
46.
National Education Goals Panel. (2000). Promising practices: Progress toward the Goals 2000. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved from http://govinfo.library.unt.edu/negp/promprac/promprac00/promprac00.pdf
47.
National Forum on Early Childhood Policy and Programs. ( 2010). Understanding the Head Start Impact Study. Retrieved from http://www.developingchild.harvard.edu/
48.
National Head Start Association. (2007). Head Start basics. Alexandria, VA: Author. Retrieved from http://www.nhsa.org/download/advocacy/fact/HSBasics.pdf
49.
National Scientific Council on the Developing Child. ( 2007). Science briefs: How early child care affects later development . Retrieved from http://www.developingchild.net
50.
NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. ( 1998). Early child care and self-control, compliance, and problem behavior at twenty-four and thirty-six months. Child Development , 69, 1145-1170.
51.
NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. ( 2000a). Characteristics and quality of child care for toddlers and preschoolers. Applied Developmental Science, 4, 116-135.
52.
NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. ( 2000b). The relation of child care to cognitive and language development. Child Development, 71, 960-980.
53.
NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. ( 2002). Early child care and children’s development prior to school entry: Results from the NICHD Study of Early Child Care. American Educational Research Journal, 39, 133-164.
54.
NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. ( 2003). Does amount of time spent in child care predict socio-emotional adjustment during the transition to kindergarten? Child Development , 74, 976-1005.
55.
NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. ( 2005a). Child care and child development: Results from the NICHD Study of Early Child Care and Youth Development. New York, NY: Guildford.
56.
NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. ( 2005b). Early child care and children’s development in the primary grades: Results from the NICHD Study of Early Child Care. American Educational Research Journal, 43, 537-570.
57.
NICHD Early Child Care Research Network, & Duncan, G. J. (2003). Modeling the impacts of child care quality on children’s preschool cognitive development. Child Development, 74, 1454-1475.
58.
Peisner-Feinberg, E.S., Burchinal, M.R., Clifford, R.M., Culkin, M.L., Howes, C., Kagan, S.L., & Yazejian, N. ( 2001). The relation of preschool child-care quality to children’s cognitive and social developmental trajectories through second grade. Child Development, 72, 1534-1553.
59.
Phillips, D., McCartney, K., & Sussman, A. ( 2006). Child care and early development. In K. McCartney, & D. Phillips (Eds.), Handbook of early childhood development (pp. 471-489). Malden, MA: Blackwell.
60.
Pianta, R.C. ( 2005). A new elementary school forAmerican children. SRCD Social Policy Report, 19(3), 4-5.
61.
Reynolds, A.J., Temple, J.A., Robertson, D.L., & Mann, E.A. ( 2001). Long-term effects of an early childhood intervention on educational achievement and juvenile arrest: A 15-year follow-up of low-income children in public schools. Journal of the American Medical Association, 285, 2339-2346.
62.
Rolnick, A., & Grunewald, R. ( 2003). Early childhood development: Economic development with a high public return. Minneapolis, MN: Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis. Retrieved from http://www.minneapolisfed.org/publications_papers/studies/earlychild/abc-part2.pdf
63.
Rolnick, A., & Grunewald, R. ( 2007). Early intervention on a large scale. Minneapolis, MN: Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis . Retrieved from http://www.minneapolisfed.org/publications_papers/studies/earlychild/early_intervention.cfm#top
64.
Schweinhart, L.J. ( 2004). The High/Scope Perry Preschool Study through age 40: Summary, conclusions, and frequently asked questions. Ypsilanti, MI: High/Scope Educational Research Foundation.
65.
Shonkoff, J. P., & Phillips, D. A. (Eds.). (2000). From neurons to neighborhoods: The science of early childhood development. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
66.
Shore, R. ( 1997). Rethinking the brain: New insights into early development . New York, NY: Families and Work Institute.
67.
The Business Roundtable and Corporate Voices for Working Families. (2003). Early childhood education: A call to action from the business community. Washington, DC: The Business Roundtable. Retrieved from http://www.businessroundtable.org/position_statement/early_education_policy_statement
68.
U.S. Census Bureau. (2005). Who’s minding the kids? Child care arrangements: Spring 2002. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Commerce .
69.
U.S. Census Bureau. (2008). Who’s minding the kids? Child care arrangements: Spring 2005 detailed tables. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Commerce.
70.
U.S. Department of Education. (2009, July). The Early Learning Challenge Fund: Results-oriented, standards reform of state early learning programs. Retrieved from http://www.2.ed.gov
71.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. ( 2005, May). Head Start Impact Study: First year findings. Washington, DC: Author.
72.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. ( 2010, January). Head Start Impact Study: Final report. Washington, DC: Author.
73.
U.S. Department or Labor. (2009). Women in the labor force: A databook. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved from http://www.bls.gov/cps/wlf-databook2009.htm
74.
U.S. Department or Labor. (2010). Labor force participation rates among mothers. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved from http://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2010/ted_20100507.htm
75.
Vandell, D.L. ( 2004). Early child care: The known and the unknown. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 50, 387-414.
76.
Vandell, D.L., Belsky, J., Burchinal, M., Steinberg, L., Vandergrift, N., & NICHD Early Child Care Research Network. (2010). Do effects of early child care extend to age 15 years? Results from the NICHD Study of Early Child Care and Youth Development. Child Development , 81, 737-756.
77.
Vandell, D.L., & Corasaniti, M.A. (1990). Variations in early child care: Do they predict subsequent social, emotional, and cognitive differences?Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 5, 555-572.
78.
Vandell, D.L., & Wolfe, B. ( 2000). Child care quality: Does it matter and does it need to be improved?Madison, WI: Institute for Research on Poverty.
79.
Votruba-Drzal, E., Coley, R.L., & Chase-Lansdale, P.L. (2004). Child care and low-income children’s development: Direct and moderated effects. Child Development, 75, 296-312.
80.
Willen, L. ( 2010, May). Hard times derail growth of state-funded preschool . Education Week, 29(31). Retrieved from http://www.edweek.org
81.
Zigler, E. ( 2003). Forty years of believing in magic is enough. SRCD Social Policy Report, 17(1), 10.
82.
Zigler, E., Gilliam, W. S. , & Jones, S. M. (Eds.). (2006). A vision for universal preschool education. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press .
83.
Zigler, E., & Hall, N. ( 2000). Child development and social policy. Boston, MA: McGraw-Hill.
84.
Zigler, E., & Muenchow, S. ( 1992). Head Start: The inside story of America’s most successful educational experiment. New York, NY: Basic Books.
85.
Zill, N., Resnick, G., Kim, K., O’Donnell, K., Sorongon, A., McKey, R.H., . . . D’Elio, M.A. (2003, May). Head Start FACES 2000: A whole-child perspective on program performance. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
