Organizational Dissent Dynamics in Universities: Simulations With a System Dynamics Model

Abstract

This article investigates how universities may evolve into high- or low-performance institutions by taking different approaches to dissent tolerance and processing. We explore different dissent management policies related to growth and productivity. We experiment with a dynamic model of dissent creation and processing in organizations presented in an earlier paper by the authors. Computer simulations with the model suggest that as universities attempt to improve their performance through growth, they may devolve into low-performance institutions with degrading management responsiveness and low organizational productivity. Only when organizations invest in their dissent processing capability will they engage their members productively for improving performance.

Keywords

administrative work university administration university faculty organizational productivity computer simulation voice

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Arnett

(2016, May 13). Education spotlight: ASU President Michael Crow on innovation, tenure and meeting demands. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved from http://www.educationdive.com/news/eduvation-spotlight-asu-president-michael-crow-on-innovation-tenure-and-m/418153/

Baty

. (2014, February 15). Caltech: Secrets of the world’s number one university. Retrieved from https://talk.collegeconfidential.com/california-institute-technology/1615917-caltech-secrets-of-the-worlds-number-one-university.html

Bok

(2013). Higher education in America. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Burns

Wagner

(2013). Organizational dissent. Principal Leadership, 14(4), 28-32.

Christensen

C. M.

Eyring

H. J.

(2011). The innovative university: Changing the DNA of higher education from the inside out. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Cooper

C. L.

Burke

R. J.

(2013). Voice and Whistleblowing in Organizations : Overcoming Fear, Fostering Courage and Unleashing Candour. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Pub.

Cosenz

(2013). Designing performance management systems in academic institutions: A dynamic performance management view. Proceedings from ASPA 2013 Annual Conference, New Orleans, LA, 19-23 September. ASPA: Washington, DC.

De Dreu

C. K.

West

M. A

. (2001). Minority dissent and team innovation: The importance of participation in decision making. Journal of Applied Psychology, 86, 1191-1201. doi:10.1037/0021-9010.86.6.1191

Detert

J. R.

Burris

E. R.

Harrison

D. A.

Martin

S. R.

(2013). Voice flows to and around leaders: Understanding when units are helped or hurt by employee voice. Administrative Science Quarterly, 58, 624-668. doi:10.1177/0001839213510151.

10.

Dooley

R. S.

Fryxell

G. E.

(1999). Attaining decision quality and commitment from dissent: The moderating effects of loyalty and competence in strategic decision-making teams. The Academy of Management Journal, 42, 389-402. doi:10.2307/257010

11.

Dvorak

Busteed

(2015, August 11). It’s hard to differentiate one higher-ed brand from another. Gallup.com. Retrieved from http://www.gallup.com/businessjournal/184538/hard-differentiate-one-higher-brand.aspx

12.

Farrell

(1983). Exit, voice, loyalty, and neglect as responses to job dissatisfaction: A multidimensional scaling study. The Academy of Management Journal, 26, 596-607. doi:10.5465/255909

13.

Forrester

J. W.

(1968). Principles of systems. Cambridge, MA: Productivity Press.

14.

Frost

(2015). The Modern University, Ltd. The Journal Jurisprudence, 27, 335-364. Retrieved from http://www.jurisprudence.com.au/juris27/frost.pdf

15.

Garner

J. T.

(2013). Dissenters, managers, and coworkers: The process of co-constructing organizational dissent and dissent effectiveness. Management Communication Quarterly, 27, 373-395. doi:10.1177/0893318913488946

16.

Garner

J. T.

(2015). Different ways to disagree: A study of organizational dissent to explore connections between mixed methods research and engaged scholarship. Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 9, 178-195. doi:10.1177/1558689813515333

17.

Garner

J. T.

(2016a). Open doors and iron cages: Supervisors’ responses to employee dissent. International Journal of Business Communication, 53, 27-54. doi:10.1177/2329488414525466

18.

Garner

J. T.

(2016b). Simulating dissent: Mapping the life span of organizational dissent using agent-based modeling. Western Journal of Communication, 80, 414-434. doi:10.1080/10570314.2016.1159325

19.

Garner

J. T.

(2017). An examination of organizational dissent events and communication channels: Perspectives of a dissenter, supervisors, and coworkers. Communication Reports, 30, 26-38. doi:10.1080/08934215.2015.1128454

20.

Ginsberg

(2011). The fall of the faculty: The rise of the all-administrative university and why it matters. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

21.

Glaser

(2015). Bureaucracy: Why won’t scholars break their paper chains? Retrieved from https://www.timeshighereducation.com/features/bureaucracy-why-wont-scholars-break-their-paper-chains/2020256.article

22.

Gouldner

A. W.

(1957). Cosmopolitans and locals: Toward an analysis of latent social roles. I. Administrative Science Quarterly, 2, 281-306. doi:10.2307/2391000

23.

Gouldner

A. W.

(1958). Cosmopolitans and locals: Toward an analysis of latent social roles. II. Administrative Science Quarterly, 2, 444-480. doi:10.2307/2390795

24.

Graham

J. W

. (1986). Principled organizational dissent: A theoretical essay. Research in Organizational Behavior, 8, 1-52.

25.

Gruman

J. A.

Saks

A. M.

(2011). Performance management and employee engagement. Human Resource Management Review, 21(2), 123-136.

26.

Hackman

J. R.

Morris

C. G.

(1975). Group tasks, group interaction process, and group performance effectiveness: A review and proposed integration. In Berkowitz

(Ed.), Advances in experimental social psychology (vol. 8, pp. 45-99). New York, NY: Academic Press.

27.

Hegstrom

T. G.

(1995). Focus on organizational dissent: A functionalist response to criticism. In Lehtonen

Lahtinen

(Eds.), Critical perspectives on communication research and pedagogy (pp. 83-94). St. Ingbert, Germany: Röhrig Universitätsverlag.

28.

Hegstrom

T. G.

(1999). Reasons for rocking the boat: Principles and personal problems. In Geissner

H. K.

Herbig

A. F.

Wessela

(Eds.), Business communication in Europe (pp. 179-194). Tostedt, Germany: Attikon Verlag.

29.

Hirschman

A. O.

(1970). Exit, voice, and loyalty; responses to decline in firms, organizations, and states. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

30.

Hodgkinson

H. L.

Meeth

L. R.

(1976). Power and authority: transformation of campus governance. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

31.

Hoffman

J. D.

(2001). Numerical methods for engineers and scientists. New York, NY: Marcel Dekker.

32.

Horibe

F. D.

(2001). Creating the innovation culture: Leveraging visionaries, dissenters and other useful troublemakers in your organization. Toronto, Canada: John Wiley.

33.

Jain

Triandis

H. C.

Weick

C. W.

(2010). Managing research, development and innovation: Managing the unmanageable. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.

34.

Joselow

(2016). Helping faculty “get it.” Retrieved from https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2016/08/10/birmingham-southern-tries-help-its-faculty-understand-higher-ed-big-picture

35.

Kassing

J. W.

(1997). Articulating, antagonizing, and displacing: A model of employee dissent. Communication Studies, 48, 311-332. doi:10.1080/10510979709368510

36.

Kassing

J. W.

(2000). Investigating the relationship between superior-subordinate relationship quality and employee dissent. Communication Research Reports, 17, 58-69. doi:10.1080/08824090009388751

37.

Kassing

J. W.

(2009a). Breaking the chain of command: Making sense of employee circumvention. The Journal of Business Communication, 46, 311-334. doi:10.1177/0021943609333521

38.

Kassing

J. W.

(2009b). “In case you didn’t hear me the first time”: An examination of repetitious upward dissent. Management Communication Quarterly, 22, 416-436. doi:10.1177/0893318908327008

39.

Kassing

J. W.

(2011). Dissent in organizations. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.

40.

Kassing

J. W.

DiCioccio

R. L.

(2004). Testing a workplace experience explanation of displaced dissent. Communication Reports, 17, 113-120. doi:10.1080/08934210409389380

41.

Kassing

J. W.

Kava

(2013). Assessing disagreement expressed to management: Development of the upward dissent scale. Communication Research Reports, 30, 46-56. doi:10.1080/08824096.2012.746225

42.

Kassing

J. W.

Piemonte

N. M.

Goman

C. C.

Mitchell

C. A.

(2012). Dissent expression as an indicator of work engagement and intention to leave. Journal of Business Communication, 49, 237-253. doi:10.1177/0021943612446751

43.

Kim

Rehg

(2018). Faculty performance and morale in higher education: A systems approach. Systems Research and Behavioral Science, 35, 308-323. doi:10.1002/sres.2495

44.

Kish-Gephart

J. J.

Detert

J. R.

Treviño

L. K.

Edmondson

A. C.

(2009). Silenced by fear: The nature, sources, and consequences of fear at work. Research in Organizational Behavior, 29, 163-193. doi:10.1016/j.riob.2009.07.002

45.

Landier

Sraer

Thesmar

(2009). Optimal dissent in organizations. The Review of Economic Studies, 76, 761-794. doi:10.1111/j.1467-937X.2009.00544.x

46.

Legon

Lombardi

J. V.

Rhoades

(2013). Leading the university: The roles of trustees, presidents, and faculty. Change: The Magazine of Higher Learning, 45, 24-32. doi:10.1080/00091383.2013.749144

47.

Marcus

(2013, May 20). Spiraling cost: Higher ed budgets up in admin category. Worcester Telegram & Gazette. p. A1. Retrieved from https://www.thefreelibrary.com/Spiraling cost; Higher ed budgets up in admin category.-a0330420079

48.

Mathewson

T. G.

(2015, May 27). Adjunct positions swell in U.S. higher ed job postings. Education Dive. Retrieved from http://www.educationdive.com/news/adjunct-positions-swell-in-us-higher-ed-job-postings/399810/

49.

Mathewson

T. G.

(2016, January 19). Higher ed teaching force continues to shift away from tenure. Education Dive. Retrieved from http://www.educationdive.com/news/higher-ed-teaching-force-continues-to-shift-away-from-tenure/412238/

50.

Mills

(2012). The corporatization of higher education. Dissent, 59(4), 6-9. doi:10.1353/dss.2012.0087

51.

Parker

(2014). University, Ltd: Changing a business school. Organization, 21, 281-292. doi:10.1177/1350508413502646

52.

Postma

Blignaut

(2013). Silencing dissent in an online discussion forum of a higher education institution. The Journal for Transdisciplinary Research in Southern Africa, 9, 277-294. doi:10.4102/td.v9i2.207

53.

Readings

(1996). The University in Ruins. Cambridge, UK: Harvard University Press.

54.

Richardson

G. P.

(1999). Feedback thought in social science and systems theory. Waltham, MA: Pegasus Communications.

55.

Richmond

(2004). An introduction to systems thinking: Stella software guidebook. Lebanon, NH: isee systems.

56.

Rosovsky

(1990). The university: An owner’s manual. Irvine, CA: UC Irvine Libraries.

57.

Rowlinson

Booth

Clark

Delahaye

Procter

(2010). Social remembering and organizational memory. Organization Studies, 31, 69-87. doi:10.1177/0170840609347056

58.

Saeed

(1998). Maintaining professional competence in innovation organizations. Human Systems Management, 17, 69-87.

59.

Saeed

(2008). Limits to growth concepts in classical economics. doi:10.2139/ssrn.806227. Retrieved from https://ssrn.com/abstract=806227

60.

Senor

Singer

(2011). Start-up nation: The story of Israel’s economic miracle. New York, NY: Random House LLC.

61.

Salmi

(2009). The Challenge of Establishing World-class Universities. World Bank, Washington, DC.

62.

Stancill

(2016, March 18). Non-tenured Duke faculty vote to unionize. The News & Observer. Retrieved from http://www.newsobserver.com/news/local/education/article66936772.html

63.

Stein

E. W.

(1995). Organization memory: Review of concepts and recommendations for management. International Journal of Information Management, 15, 17-32. doi:10.1016/0268-4012(94)00003-C

64.

Sterman

(2000). Business dynamics: Systems thinking and modeling for a complex world. Boston, MA: Irwin/McGraw-Hill.

65.

Sutner

(2013, May 19). Local college costs are up, except for two schools: Others cite reasons for administration growth. Worcester Telegram & Gazette. Retrieved from http://www.telegram.com/article/20130519/NEWS/105199913/1101&Template=printart

66.

Sypher

B. D.

(1990). Case studies in organizational communication. New York, NY: Guilford Press.

67.

Taylor

(2015, May 28). Laurie Taylor on academics v administrators. Times Higher Education. Retrieved from https://www.timeshighereducation.com/content/laurie-taylor-on-academics-v-administrators

68.

Uhl-Bien

Riggio

R. E.

Lowe

K. B.

Carsten

M. K.

(2014). Followership theory: A review and research agenda. The Leadership Quarterly, 25, 83-104. doi:10.1016/j.leaqua.2013.11.007

69.

Warren

(2008). Strategic management dynamics. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.

70.

Watson

(2000). Managing in higher education: The “wicked issues.” Higher Education Quarterly, 54, 5-21. doi:10.1111/1468-2273.00142

71.

Zaini

R. M.

(2017). Modeling manifest and latent structures in a university: Understanding resources and dissent dynamics (Unpublished Doctoral dissertation). Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, MA.

72.

Zaini

R. M.

Lyan

D. E.

Rebentisch

(2015). Start-up research universities, high aspirations in a complex reality: A Russian start-up university case analysis using stakeholder value analysis and system dynamics modeling. Triple Helix, 2, 1-31. doi:10.1186/s40604-014-0016-8

73.

Zaini

R. M.

Elmes

M. B.

Pavlov

O. V.

Saeed

(2016a). Organizational Dissent Dynamics: A Conceptual Framework. Management Communication Quarterly. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1177/0893318916671216

74.

Zaini

R. M.

Pavlov

O. V.

Saeed

Radzicki

M. J.

Hoffman

A. H.

Tichenor

K. R.

(2016b). Let’s talk change in a university: A simple model for addressing a complex agenda. Systems Research and Behavioral Science, 34, 250-266. doi:10.1002/sres.2408