This study compares post-1980 central city employment trends in the state of Michigan and the province of Ontario, similar-sized, closely linked by trade, and situated within the same natural region but in different federalist nations. Guided by interviews with 124 development officials, the study describes how variations in Michigan’s and Ontario’s central cities’ employment mix, “state” approach to development, framework for local authority, and sociodemographic dynamics (e.g., interracial relations, racial distribution, and others) have been among several embedded or contextual factors fostering divergent employment trends in their respective central cities.The study’s findings also demonstrate how state/provincial embeddedness has remained especially influential.To help bridge the gap between theory and concrete public policy making, the article’s conclusion offers a set of factors to be considered by scholars and practitioners in their efforts to understand and compare growth trends in urban areas.As a group, these elements are called the contextualized model of urban-regional development.
Andrew, C.,Graham, K., & Phillips, S. (Eds.). (2002). Urban affairs: Back on the policy agenda. Montreal, Quebec , Canada: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
2.
Balakrishnan, T. ( 2000). Residential segregation and Canada’s ethnic groups . In M. Kalbach & W. Kalbach (Eds.), Perspectives on ethnicity in Canada (pp. 121-136). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Harcourt.
3.
Bibby, R. ( 1990). Mosaic madness: Pluralism without a cause. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Stoddart.
4.
Boyd, M. ( 2000). Ethnicity and immigrant offspring. In M. Kalbach & W. Kalbach (Eds.), Perspectives on ethnicity in Canada (pp. 137-154). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Harcourt.
5.
Brampton Departments of Finance, Economic Development, and Communications. (2007). The corporation of the city of Brampton: Annual report 2007. Brampton, Ontario, Canada: Author.
6.
Brampton Economic Development Office. (2006 ). Brampton construction and development update. Brampton, Ontario, Canada: Author.
7.
Browne, W., & VerBurg, K. (Eds.). (1995). Michigan politics and government: Facing change in a complex state. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
8.
Business Development Bank of Canada. (2008 ). Annual reports 2005-2007. Retrieved September 22, 2008, from www.bdc.ca
9.
Clayton Research Associates. (2007, September 29). Employment, population, housing and non-residential construction projections, city of London, Ontario: 2006 update. London: Author.
10.
Cullingworth, J. ( 1993). The political culture of planning: American land use planning in comparative perspective. New York: Routledge.
11.
Darden, J. ( 2004). The significance of white supremacy in the Canadian metropolis. Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen Press.
12.
Darden, J. ( 2009). Race matters in metropolitan Detroit. In R. Schaetzl, J. Darden, & D. Brandt (Eds.), Michigan geography and geology (pp. 508-520). Boston: Pearson.
13.
Darden, J., Hill, R., Thomas, J., & Thomas, R. ( 1987). Race and uneven development. Philadelphia : Temple University Press.
14.
Darden, J., Stokes, C., & Thomas, R. (Eds.). (2007). The state of black Michigan, 1967-2007. East Lansing: Michigan State University Press.
15.
David, E. ( 2008). Charter townships in Michigan. Lansing, MI: Michigan Township Association. (Unpublished data as of November 16, 2008)
16.
Dear, M.,Drake, J., & Reeds, L. (Eds.). (1987). Steel city: Hamilton and Region. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: University of Toronto Press .
17.
Donald, B. ( 2005). The politics of local economic development in Canada’s city regions: New dependencies, new deals, and a new politics of scale. Space and Polity, 9, 261-281.
18.
Durham Region Office of Strategic Planning. ( 2008). Employment by place of work, 1991 to 2006. Whitby, Ontario, Canada: Author. (Unpublished data as of September 4, 2008)
19.
Evans, P. ( 1995). Embedded autonomy: States and industrial transformation . Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
20.
Farley, R., Danzinger, S., & Holzer, H. ( 2000). Detroit divided. New York: Russell Sage.
21.
Fong, E. (Ed.). (2006). Inside the mosaic. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: University of Toronto Press.
22.
Fong, E., & Gulia, M. ( 2000). Neighborhood change within the Canadian ethnic mosaic, 1986-1991. Population Research and Policy Review, 19, 155-177.
23.
Fowler, E. ( 1992). Building cities that work. Montreal, Quebec, Canada: McGill-Queen’s University Press .
24.
Friedmann, J. ( 1986). The world city. Development and Change , 17, 69-83.
25.
Friedmann, J., & Wolff, G. ( 1982). World city formation: An agenda for research and action . International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 6, 309-344.
26.
Frisken, F. ( 2001). The Toronto story: Sober reflections on fifty years of experiments with regional governance. Journal of Urban Affairs , 23, 513-541.
27.
Garber, J., & Imbroscio, D. ( 1996). The myth of the North American city reconsidered: Local constitutional regimes in Canada and the United States. Urban Affairs Review, 31, 595-624.
28.
Genesee County Metropolitan Planning Commission. ( 1994). Employment, population, and dwelling unit forecasts, 1995-2010. Flint, MI: Author. (Unpublished facsimile data as of April 1994)
29.
Genesee County Metropolitan Planning Commission. ( 2007). Flint-Genesee county 2035 long range regional transportation plan: Employment, population, and dwelling unit forecasts, 2005-2035. Flint, MI: Author. (Unpublished municipal data as of June 30, 2008)
30.
Goldberg, M., & Mercer, J. ( 1986). The myth of the North American city: Continentalism challenged. Vancouver, Canada: University of British Columbia Press.
31.
Granovetter, M. ( 1985). Economic action and social structure: The problem of embeddedness. American Journal of Sociology, 91, 481-510.
32.
Halton Region Planning & Public Works Department. ( 2007, August 29). Population and employment estimates for the Halton Region. Oakville, Ontario, Canada: Author.
33.
Hamilton Planning & Development Department. ( 2005, November 29). City of Hamilton environmental scan, 2005. Hamilton, Ontario, Canada: Author.
34.
Hamilton Planning & Development Department. ( 2008). City of Hamilton, employment by place of work and residence . Hamilton, Ontario, Canada: Author . (Unpublished spreadsheets from July 25)
35.
Hill, R. ( 1990). Federalism and urban policy: The intergovernmental dialectic . In T. Swartz & J. Peck (Eds.), The changing face of fiscal federalism (pp. 35-55). New York: M. E. Sharpe.
36.
Hill, R. ( 2004). Cities and nested hierarchies. International Social Science Journal, 56, 373-384.
37.
Hill, R., & Fujita, K. ( 2003). The nested city: Introduction. Urban Studies, 40, 207-217.
38.
Hill, R.C., & Kim, J.W. ( 2000). Global cities and developmental states: New York, Tokyo, and Seoul. Urban Studies, 37, 2167-2195.
39.
Hymer, S. ( 1971). The multinational corporation and the law of uneven development . In J. Bhagwati (Ed.), Economics and world order from the 1970s to 1990s (pp. 113-140). New York: Macmillan.
40.
Indergaard. M. ( 1998). Beyond the region: The rise and fall of economic regionalism in downriver Detroit. Urban Affairs Review, 34, 241-262.
41.
Jacobs, A.J. ( 2003). Embedded autonomy and uneven metropolitan development: A comparison of the Detroit and Nagoya auto regions, 1969-2000. Urban Studies, 40, 335-360.
42.
Jacobs, A.J. ( 2004). Inter-local relations and divergent growth: The Detroit and Tokai auto regions, 1969 to 1996. Journal of Urban Affairs , 26, 479-504.
43.
Jacobs, A.J. ( 2005). Has central Tokyo experienced uneven development? An examination of Tokyo’s 23 Ku relative to America’s largest urban centers. Journal of Urban Affairs, 27, 521-555.
44.
Jacobs, A.J. ( 2006). Embedded localities: Employment decline, inner city population growth, and declining place stratification among Japan’s mid-size and large cities. City & Community, 5, 269-282.
45.
Jacobs, A.J. ( 2008). Developmental state planning, sub-national nestedness, and reflexive public policymaking: Keys to employment growth in Saitama City, Japan. Cities, 25, 1-20.
46.
Jacobs, A.J. ( 2009). Embedded contrasts in race, municipal fragmentation, and planning: Divergent outcomes in the Detroit and Greater Toronto-Hamilton regions 1990-2000. Journal of Urban Affairs, 31, 147-173.
47.
Johnson, C. ( 1982). MITI and the Japanese miracle: The growth of industrial policy, 1925-1975. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
48.
Keating, M., & Mehrhoff, A. ( 1992). Canadian provincial and U.S. state roles in urban planning and development: A study of London, Ontario, and St. Cloud, Minnesota. Environment and Planning C, 10, 173-187.
49.
Keil, R. ( 2002). Common-sense neoliberalism: Progressive conservative urbanism in Toronto, Canada. Antiopode, 34, 578-601.
50.
Knox, P., & Taylor, P. (Eds.). (1995). World cities in a world system. New York: Cambridge University Press.
51.
Kushner, J., & Siegel, D. ( 2003). Effect of municipal amalgamation in Ontario on political representation and accessibility. Canadian Journal of Political Science, 36, 1035-1051.
52.
LaFaive, M., & Hicks, M. ( 2005). MEGA: A retrospective assessment. Midland, MI: Mackinac Center for Public Policy.
53.
Lapping, M. ( 1987). Peoples of plenty: A note on agriculture as a planning metaphor and national character in North America. Journal of Canadian Studies, 22, 121-128.
54.
Li, P. ( 2003). Destination Canada. Toronto, Ontario , Canada: Oxford University Press.
55.
Lightbody, J. (Ed.). (1995). Canadian metropolitics: Governing our cities. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Copp Clark.
56.
Lipset, S. ( 1990). Continental divide: The values and institutions of the United States and Canada. New York: Routledge.
57.
Mair, A., Florida, R., & Kennedy, M. ( 1988). The new geography of automobile production: Japanese transplants in North America. Economic Geography, 64, 352-373.
58.
Malizia, E., & Ke, S. ( 1993). The influence of economic diversity on unemployment and stability. Journal of Regional Science, 33, 221-235.
59.
McKenzie, R. ( 1927). The concept of dominance and world organization. American Journal of Sociology, 33, 18-42.
60.
McLaughlin, G. ( 1930). Industrial diversification inAmerican cities. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 45, 131-149.
61.
McMaster Innovation Park. (2008). Introduction. Retrieved September 30, 2008, from www.mcmasterinnovationpark.ca
62.
Michigan Economic Development Corporation. ( 2009). Business incentives, MEGA. Lansing, MI: Author. Retrieved March 28, 2009, from www.ref.michigan.org
63.
Michigan State Office of the Great Seal. ( 2007). Unpublished information on incorporations, charter townships, annexations, and detachments.
64.
Michigan Township Association. (2005). General law or charter townships?Lansing, MI: Author.
65.
Mississauga Planning & Building Department. ( 1983, January). City of Mississauga: Survey of employers, 1981. Mississauga, Ontario, Canada: Author.
66.
Mississauga Planning & Building Department. ( 2006, December). City ofMississauga: 2006 employment profile. Mississauga, Ontario, Canada: Author.
67.
Myles, J., & Hou, F. ( 2004). Changing colours: Spatial assimilation and new racial minority immigrants. Canadian Journal of Sociology, 29, 29-58.
68.
Office of the Legislative Assembly of Ontario. ( 2005a). Greenbelt Act. S.O., 2005, Chapter 1. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Author.
69.
Office of the Legislative Assembly of Ontario. ( 2005b). Places to Grow Act. S.O., 2005, Chapter 13. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Author.
70.
Office of the Legislative Assembly of Ontario. ( 2005c). Planning Act. S.O., 1990, Chapter 13. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Author. (Last revised in 2005)
71.
Office of the Legislative Assembly of Ontario. ( 2008). Municipal Act. S. O., 2001, Chapter 25. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Author. (Revisions through January 2008)
72.
Ontario Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing. ( 1996a). 1996 provincial policy statement. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Author.
73.
Ontario Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing. ( 1996b). A guide to municipal restructuring. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Author.
74.
Ontario Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing. ( 2005). 2005 provincial policy statement. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Author.
75.
Ontario Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing. ( 2007). Municipal restructuring. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Author. Retrieved January 22, 2007, from www.mah.gov.on.ca
76.
Ontario Ministry of Public Infrastructure Renewal. ( 2006). Places to grow, better choices, brighter future: Growth plan for the greater golden horseshoe. Toronto, Ontario , Canada: Author.
77.
Ottawa City Research and Forecasting Division. ( 2008). Employment in Ottawa: Results from the 1976-2006 employment surveys, with adjusted city figures as of August 20, 2008. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Author.
78.
Peel Region Planning Department. (2003, August). Peel region official plan. Oakville, Ontario , Canada: Author.
79.
Peel Region Planning Department. (2008). Employment growth in Peel region. Brampton, Ontario, Canada: Author. Retrieved July 20, 2008, from www.peelregion.ca/planning
80.
Reese, L. ( 1992). Economic development strategies in Ontario: A comparative perspective. American Review of Canadian Studies, 22, 215-233.
81.
Reese, L. ( 2006). The planning-policy connection in US and Canadian economic development. Environment and Planning C, 24, 553-573.
82.
Reese, L., & Rosenfeld, R. ( 2004). Local economic development in the US and Canada: Institutionalizing policy approaches. American Review of Public Administration , 34, 277-292.
83.
Rothblatt, D., & Sancton, A. (Eds.). (1993). American/Canadian governance: Metropolitan intergovernmental perspectives. Berkley: University of California Press.
84.
Rubin, H., & Rubin, I. ( 1995). Qualitative interviewing: The art of hearing data. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
85.
Rusk, D. ( 2003). Cities without suburbs: A Census 2000 update. Washington, DC: Woodrow Wilson Center Press.
86.
Sancton, A. ( 2000). The assault on local government. Montreal, Quebec, Canada: McGill-Queen’s Press .
87.
Sancton, A. ( 2001). Canadian cities and the new regionalism. Journal of Urban Affairs, 23, 543-555.
88.
Sassen, S. ( 2001). The global city. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
89.
Siegel, D. ( 1997). Local government in Ontario. In G. White (Ed.), The government and politics of Ontario (pp. 126-157). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: University of Toronto Press .
90.
Siegel, D. ( 2005). Municipal reform in Ontario. In J. Garcea & E. LeSage (Eds.), Municipal reform in Canada: Reconfiguration, re-empowerment, and rebalancing (pp. 127-148). New York: Oxford University Press.
91.
Simmie, J. ( 2001). Innovative cities. New York. Routledge.
92.
Skogstad, G. ( 2003). Who governs? Who should govern? Political authority and legitimacy in Canada in the 21st century. Canadian Journal of Political Science, 36, 955-973.
93.
Smith, D., & Timberlake, M. (1995). Conceptualising and mapping the structure of the world system’s city system. Urban Studies, 32, 287-302.
94.
Southeast Michigan Council of Governments. ( 1980). Small area forecast, minor civil division report. Detroit, MI: Author.
95.
Southeast Michigan Council of Governments. ( 2003). Employment change by community, Southeast Michigan, 1999-2002. Detroit, MI: Author.
96.
Southeast Michigan Council of Governments. ( 2008). Employment change by community, Southeast Michigan, 1999-2002. Detroit, MI: Author.
97.
Statistics Canada. (2008). Census of Canada. Retrieved January 24, 2008, from www.statcan.gc.ca (Includes population and employment data back to 1981)
98.
Stelter, G., & Artibise, A. (Eds.). (1986). Power and place: Canadian urban development in the North American context. Vancouver , Canada: University of British Columbia Press.
99.
Sugrue, T. ( 1996). The origins of the urban crisis: Race and in equality in postwar Detroit. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
100.
Thomas, J. ( 1997). Redevelopment and race: Planning a finer city in postwar Detroit. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
101.
Toronto City Planning Division, Policy & Research Section, Research & Information Staff. (2008). Toronto employment survey 1983-2006. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Author.
102.
U.S. Census Bureau. (1982-2007 ). County business patterns [1980-2005]. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
103.
U.S. Census Bureau. (1981-2008 ). Census of population [1980-2000]. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. Retrieved October 10, 2008, from www.census.gov (includes Journey to Work data and 2006 population estimates)
104.
Vojonic, I. ( 2000). The transitional impacts of municipal consolidation. Journal of Urban Affairs, 22, 361-384.
105.
Wakefield, S. ( 2007). Great expectations: Waterfront redevelopment and the Hamilton Harbour waterfront trail. Cities, 24, 298-310.
106.
Walks, R., & Bourne, L. ( 2006). Ghettos in Canada’s cities? Racial segregation, ethnic enclaves and poverty concentration inCanadian urban areas. Canadian Geographer, 50, 273-297.
107.
Wallerstein, I. ( 1974). The rise and future demise of the world capitalist system: Concepts for comparative analysis. Comparative Studies in Society and History, 16, 387-415.
Ward’s Automotive Group. (2008). Ward’s U.S. light vehicle sales by company. Retrieved September 17, 2008, from www.wards.com
110.
Wolfson, J., & Frisken, F. ( 2000). Local response to global challenge: Comparing local economic development in a regional context. Journal of Urban Affairs , 22, 361-384.
111.
York Region Department of Planning and Development. ( 2008). York region employment growth. Newmarket, Ontario, Canada: Author. Retrieved August 28, 2008, from http://www.york.ca/Planning+and+Development/default+PDS+Splash.htm
