Are College-Educated Police Officers Different? A Study of Stops,Searches,and Arrests

Abstract

A study of more than 60,000 police traffic stops found that college-educated officers were more likely than other officers to stop drivers for less serious violations, perform consent searches, and make arrests on discretionary grounds. These results are consistent with those of prior research indicating that college-educated officers are more achievement-oriented and eager for advancement based on the traditional performance criteria of stops, searches, and arrests. The results raise questions regarding the recommendation of the President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing to improve police-community relations by hiring more college-educated police officers, especially in urban communities where concerns about over-policing are widespread. If community engagement were to become a primary basis for professional advancement, however, the current results suggest that college-educated officers may adapt to the new standards as diligently as they have to the traditional criteria for reward and promotion in U.S. police departments.

Keywords

policing college-educated officers arrests searches

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Albarano

R. F.

(2015). College education and officer performance: Do college educated police officers perform better than those without a college education? International Journal of Education and Social Science, 2(7), 41-48.

Allen

Monk-Turner

(2010). Citizen perceptions of the legitimacy of traffic stops. Journal of Criminal Justice, 38, 589-594.

Alpert

G. P.

MacDonald

J. M.

Dunham

R. G.

(2005). Police suspicion and discretionary decision making during citizen stops. Criminology, 43, 407-434.

Archbold

C. A.

Schulz

D. M.

(2008). Making rank: The lingering effects of tokenism on female police officers’ promotion aspirations. Police Quarterly, 11, 50-73.

Archbold

C. A.

Schulz

D. M.

(2012). Research on women in policing: A look at the past, present, and future. Sociology Compass, 6, 694-706.

Baro

A. L.

Burlingame

(1999). Law enforcement and higher education: Is there an impasse? Journal of Criminal Justice Education, 10, 57-73.

Bozza

C. M.

(1973). Motivations guiding policemen in the arrest process. Journal of Police Science and Administration, 1, 468-476.

Brown

R. A.

Frank

(2006). Race and officer decision making: Examining differences in arrest outcomes between Black and White officers. Justice Quarterly, 23, 96-126.

Brunson

R. K.

Wright

(2016). Straight outta Compton: The rise of criminal justice education and the policing of urban communities. The Criminologist, 41, 3-4.

10.

Buckley

L. B.

McGinnis

J. H.

Petrunik

M. G.

(1993). Police perceptions of education as an entitlement to promotion: An equity theory perspective. American Journal of Police, 12, 77-100.

11.

Carlan

P. E.

Byxbe

F. R.

(2000). The promise of humanistic policing: Is higher education living up to societal expectation? American Journal of Criminal Justice, 24, 235-246.

12.

Carter

D. L.

Sapp

A. D.

(1990). The evolution of higher education in law enforcement: Preliminary findings from a national study. Journal of Criminal Justice Education, 1, 59-85.

13.

Carter

D. L.

Sapp

A. D.

Stephens

D. W.

(1989). The state of police education: Policy direction for the 21st century. Washington, DC: Police Executive Research Forum.

14.

Cascio

W. F.

(1977). Formal education and police officer performance. Journal of Police Science and Administration, 5, 89-96.

15.

Charles

J. B.

(2017, September 28). Justice department ends era of pushing police reform. Governing. Retrieved from http://www.governing.com/topics/public-justice-safety/lc-sessions-justice-police-reforms-trump-doj-milwaukee.html

16.

B. R.

Mason

P. L.

(2006). After the traffic stops: Officer characteristics and enforcement actions. The B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis & Policy, 6(1), 1-43.

17.

Decker

S. H.

Rojek

(2002). Saint Louis Metropolitan Police Department traffic stop patterns. St. Louis: University of Missouri Press.

18.

Derks

Van Laar

Ellemers

(2016). The queen bee phenomenon: Why women leaders distance themselves from junior women. The Leadership Quarterly, 27, 456-469.

19.

Eagly

A. H.

Johnson

B. T.

(1990). Gender and leadership style: A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 108, 233-256.

20.

Eith

Durose

M. R.

(2011). Special report: Contacts between police and the public in 2008. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.

21.

Ercikti

Vito

G. F.

Walsh

W. F.

Higgins

G. E.

(2011). Major determinants of job satisfaction among police managers. Southwest Journal of Criminal Justice, 8, 97-111.

22.

Fallik

S. W.

Novak

K. J.

(2012). The decision to search: Is race or ethnicity important? Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 28, 146-165.

23.

Finckenauer

J. O.

(1975). Higher education and police discretion. Journal of Police Science and Administration, 3, 450-457.

24.

Fogelson

R. M.

(1977). Big-city police. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

25.

Fyfe

J. J.

Kane

R. J.

(2005). Bad cops: A study of career-ending misconduct among New York City police officers (Final report). Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.

26.

Gau

J. M.

Terrill

Paoline

E. A.

(2013). Looking up: Explaining police promotional aspirations. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 40, 247-269.

27.

Gibson

C. L.

Walker

Jennings

W. G.

Mitchell-Miller

(2010). The impact of traffic stops on calling the police for help. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 21, 139-159.

28.

Glasgow

Green

Knowles

(1973). Arrest performance among patrolmen in relation to job satisfaction and personal variables. Police Chief, 60(4), 28-34.

29.

Gumbhir

V. K.

(2007). But is it racial profiling? Policing, pretext stops, and the color of suspicion. New York, NY: LFB Scholarly Publishing.

30.

Gustafson

J. L.

(2008). Tokenism in policing: An empirical test of Kanter’s hypothesis. Journal of Criminal Justice, 36, 1-10.

31.

Harris

D. A.

(1997). “Driving while Black” and all other traffic offenses: The Supreme Court and pretextual traffic stops. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 87(2), 544-582.

32.

Harris

D. A.

(1999). Driving while Black: Racial profiling on our nation’s highways. New York, NY: American Civil Liberties Union.

33.

Hassell

K. D.

Brandl

S. G.

(2009). An examination of the workplace experiences of police patrol officers: The role of race, sex, and sexual orientation. Police Quarterly, 12, 408-430.

34.

Hawley

T. J.

III . (1998). The collegiate shield: Was the movement purely academic? Police Quarterly, 1(3), 35-59.

35.

Hayeslip

D. W.

(1989). Higher education and police performance revisited: The evidence examined through meta-analysis. American Journal of Police, 8(2), 49-62.

36.

Higgins

G. E.

Vito

G. F.

Walsh

W. F.

(2008). Searches: An understudied area of racial profiling. Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, 6, 23-39.

37.

Ingraham

(2017, February 10). In Trump’s “ruthless” vow, experts see a return to the days of the drug war. The Washington Post. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/02/10/in-trumps-ruthless-vow-experts-see-a-return-to-the-days-of-the-drug-war/

38.

Johnson

R. R.

(2011). Officer attitudes and management influences on police work productivity. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 36, 293-306.

39.

Johnson

R. R.

(2012). Police officer job satisfaction: A multidimensional analysis. Police Quarterly, 15, 157-176.

40.

Kakar

(1998). Self-evaluations of police performance: An analysis of the relationship between police officers’ education level and job performance. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 21, 632-647.

41.

Kakar

(2003). Race and police officers’ perceptions of their job performance: An analysis of the relationship between police officers’ race, education level, and job performance. Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, 18, 45-56.

42.

Kappeler

V. E.

Sapp

A. D.

Carter

D. L.

(1992). Police officer higher education, citizen complaints, and departmental rule violations. American Journal of Police, 11, 37-54.

43.

Lersch

K. M.

Kunzman

L. L.

(2001). Misconduct allegations and higher education in a southern sheriff’s department. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 25, 161-172.

44.

Manis

Archbold

C. A.

Hassell

K. D.

(2008). Exploring the impact of police officer education level on allegations of police misconduct. International Journal of Police Science & Management, 10, 509-523.

45.

Martin

S. E.

(1979). Policewomen and policewomen: Occupational role dilemmas and choices of female officers. Journal of Police Science and Administration, 7, 314-323.

46.

National Planning Association. (1978). A nationwide survey of law enforcement: Criminal justice personnel needs and resources. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

47.

National Research Council. (2004). Fairness and effectiveness in policing: The evidence. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.

48.

Oliver

W. M.

(2017). August Vollmer: The father of American policing. Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press.

49.

Olson

E. A.

Rosso

I. M.

Demers

L. A.

Divatia

Killgore

W. D.

(2016). Sex differences in psychological factors associated with social discounting. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 29, 60-66.

50.

Osborne

R. E.

(2014). Observations on police cynicism: Some preliminary findings. North American Journal of Psychology, 16, 607-628.

51.

Paoline

E. A.

(2001). Rethinking police culture: Officers’ occupational attitudes. New York, NY: LFB Scholarly Publishing.

52.

Paoline

E. A.

Myers

S. M.

Worden

R. E.

(2000). Police culture, individualism, and community policing: Evidence from two police departments. Justice Quarterly, 17, 575-605.

53.

Paoline

E. A.

Terrill

(2005). The impact of police culture on traffic stop searches: An analysis of attitudes and behavior. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 28, 455-472.

54.

Paoline

E. A.

Terrill

(2007). Police education, experience, and the use of force. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 34, 179-196.

55.

Paoline

E. A.

Terrill

Rossler

M. T.

(2015). Higher education, college degree major, and police occupational attitudes. Journal of Criminal Justice Education, 26, 49-73.

56.

Pelfrey

W. V.

(2004). The inchoate nature of community policing: Differences between community policing and traditional police officers. Justice Quarterly, 21, 579-601.

57.

Petrocelli

Piquero

A. R.

Smith

M. R.

(2003). Conflict theory and racial profiling: An empirical analysis of police traffic stop data. Journal of Criminal Justice, 31, 1-11.

58.

Police departments struggle to recruit enough officers. (2017, January 5). The Economist. Retrieved from https://www.economist.com/united-states/2017/01/05/police-departments-struggle-to-recruit-enough-officers/

59.

President’s Commission on Law Enforcement and the Administration of Justice. (1967). The challenge of crime in a free society. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

60.

President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing. (2015). Final report of the President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing. Washington, DC: Office of Community Oriented Policing Services.

61.

Reaves

(2015). Local police departments, 2013. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.

62.

Ren

Cao

Lovrich

Gaffney

(2005). Linking confidence in the police with the performance of the police: Community policing can make a difference. Journal of Criminal Justice, 33, 55-66.

63.

Roberg

Kuykendall

(1997). Police management. Roxbury, MA: Roxbury Publishing.

64.

Rojek

Decker

S. H.

(2009). Examining racial disparity in the police discipline process. Police Quarterly, 12, 388-407.

65.

Rojek

Rosenfeld

Decker

(2012). Policing race: The racial stratification of searches in police traffic stops. Criminology, 50, 993-1024.

66.

Rudas

(1998). Odds ratios in the analysis of contingency tables. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

67.

Rueckert

Naybar

(2008). Gender differences in empathy: The role of the right hemisphere. Brain and Cognition, 67, 162-167.

68.

Rydberg

Terrill

(2010). The effect of higher education on police behavior. Police Quarterly, 13, 92-120.

69.

Schafer

J. A.

Carter

D. L.

Katz-Bannister

A. J.

(2004). Studying traffic stop encounters. Journal of Criminal Justice, 32, 159-170.

70.

Schafer

J. A.

Carter

D. L.

Katz-Bannister

A. J.

Wells

W. M.

(2006). Decision making in traffic stop encounters: A multivariate analysis of police behavior. Police Quarterly, 9, 184-209.

71.

Seklecki

Paynich

(2007). A national survey of female police officers: An overview of findings. Police Practice & Research, 8, 17-30.

72.

Shelley

T. O. C.

Morabito

M. S.

Tobin-Gurley

(2011). Gendered institutions and gender roles: Understanding the experiences of women in policing. Criminal Justice Studies, 24, 351-367.

73.

Sherman

L. W.

Blumberg

(1981). Higher education and police use of deadly force. Journal of Criminal Justice, 9, 317-331.

74.

Sherwood

C. W.

(2000). Job design, community policing, and higher education: A tale of two cities. Police Quarterly, 3, 191-212.

75.

Smith

B. W.

Novak

K. J.

Frank

Lowenkamp

(2005). Explaining police officer discretionary activity. Criminal Justice Review, 30, 325-346.

76.

Smith

D. A.

Klein

J. R.

(1983). Police agency characteristics and arrest decisions. In Whitaker

G. P.

Phillips

C. D.

(Eds.), Evaluating performance of criminal justice agencies (pp. 63-98). Beverley Hills, CA: Sage.

77.

St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department. (2014). Annual report to the community: 2013. St. Louis, MO: St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department.

78.

Stroshine

M. S.

Brandl

S. G.

(2011). Race, gender, and tokenism in policing: An empirical elaboration. Police Quarterly, 14, 344-365.

79.

Sun

I. Y.

(2003). Police officers’ attitudes toward their role and work: A comparison of Black and White officers. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 28, 89-108.

80.

Telep

C. W.

(2011). The impact of higher education on police officer attitudes toward abuse of authority. Journal of Criminal Justice Education, 22, 392-419.

81.

Terrill

Mastrofski

S. D.

(2002). Situational and officer-based determinants of police coercion. Justice Quarterly, 19, 215-248.

82.

Texeira

M. T.

(2002). “Who protects and serves me?” A case study of sexual harassment of African American women in one US law enforcement agency. Gender & Society, 16, 524-545.

83.

Tillyer

Klahm

C. F.

IV. Engel

R. S.

(2012). The discretion to search: A multilevel examination of driver demographics and officer characteristics. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 28, 184-205.

84.

Truxillo

D. M.

Bennett

S. R.

Collins

M. L.

(1998). College education and police job performance: A ten-year study. Public Personnel Management, 27, 269-280.

85.

U.S. Bureau of the Census. (2010). Resident population data. Retrieved from https://www.census.gov/2010census/data/

86.

White

M. D.

(2008). Identifying good cops early: Predicting recruit performance in the academy. Police Quarterly, 11, 27-49.

87.

Worden

R. E.

(1989). Situational and attitudinal explanations of police behavior: A theoretical reappraisal and empirical assessment. Law & Society Review, 23, 667-711.

88.

Worden

R. E.

(1990). A badge and a baccalaureate: Policies, hypotheses, and further evidence. Justice Quarterly, 7, 565-592.

89.

Yoder

J. D.

Aniakudo

Berendsen

(1996). Looking beyond gender: The effects of racial differences on tokenism perceptions of women. Sex Roles, 35, 389-400.