Are Buzzed Drivers Really the Problem: A Quasi-Experimental Multilevel Assessment of the Involvement of Drivers With Low Blood Alcohol Levels in Fatal Crashes

Abstract

Controversy over drivers with low blood alcohol concentrations (BAC) have become a highly salient issue since the proposal to reduce the per se BAC limit to .05 for driving under the influence (DUI) convictions. However, little traffic safety, and no criminological research, has examined this phenomenon. This study fills a deficiency in the literature by utilizing quasi-experimental propensity score matching techniques in combination with multilevel modeling to examine the extent of involvement of low BAC drivers in fatal crashes. The results indicate that low BAC drivers are only involved in a very small portion of crashes and are not at fault in many. In addition, although drivers with low BAC have an increased odds of responsibility for a crash than drivers with no BAC, this increase is much lower than other factors such as age, speed, distractions, drug use, and high BAC. This study discusses the implications of focusing resources on drivers that are not considerable contributors to crashes, such as a predicted increase in arrests.

Keywords

driving under the influence drunk driving alcohol policy traffic safety

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abdel-Aty

Dilmore

Dhindsa

(2006). Evaluation of variable speed limits for real-time freeway safety improvement. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 38, 335-345.

Alabama Epidemiological Outcomes Workgroup. (2011). Alcohol, tobacco, and other drugs: Consumption and consequences in Alabama communities. Montgomery, AL: Substance Abuse Services Division, Office of Prevention.

Alexander

(2010). The new Jim Crow. New York, NY: The New Press.

Alliance Against Intoxicated Drivers. (2013). Illinois 2013 DUI counts. Retrieved from http://www.aaim1.org/stats_dui.asp

Beccaria

(2003). On crimes and punishments and other writings ( Bellamy

Davies

, Trans.). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. (Original work published 1764)

Becker

H. S.

(1963). Outsiders: Studies in the sociology and deviance. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster.

Bertelli

A. M.

Richardson

L. E.

(2007). Measuring the propensity to drink and drive. Evaluation review, 31, 311-337.

Blomberg

R. D.

Peck

R. C.

Moskowitz

Burns

Fiorentino

(2005). Crash risk of alcohol involved driving: A case-control study. Retrieved from http://dunlapandassociatesinc.com/crashriskofalcoholinvolveddriving.pdf

Borkenstein

R. F.

Crowther

Shumate

(1974). The role of the drinking driver in traffic accidents (The Grand Rapids Study). Blutalkohol, 11(Suppl.), 1-131.

10.

Chermack

S. T.

Giancola

P. R.

(1997). The relation between alcohol and aggression: An integrated biopsychosocial conceptualization. Clinical Psychology Review, 17, 621-649.

11.

Compton

R. P.

Blomberg

R. D.

Moskowitz

Burns

Peck

R. C.

Fiorentino

(2002, August). Crash rate of alcohol impaired driving. Proceedings of the Sixteenth International Conference on Alcohol, Drugs and Traffic Safety ICADTS, Montreal, Québec, Canada.

12.

Corfitsen

M. T.

(2003). Tiredness! A natural explanation to The Grand Rapid “DIP.” Accident Analysis & Prevention, 35, 401-406.

13.

DeMichele

Lowe

N. C.

Payne

B. K.

(2014). A criminological approach to explain chronic drunk driving. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 39, 292-314.

14.

DeMichele

Payne

(2013). If I had a hammer, I would not use it to control drunk driving. Criminology & Public Policy, 12, 213-225.

15.

Dula

C. S.

Dwyer

W. O.

LeVerne

(2007). Policing the drunk driver: Measuring law enforcement involvement in reducing alcohol-impaired driving. Journal of Safety Research, 38, 267-272.

16.

Eisenberg

(2003). Evaluating the effectiveness of policies related to drunk driving. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 22, 249-274.

17.

Fell

J. C.

(2014). Update: Repeat DWI offenders involvement in fatal crashes in 2010. Traffic Injury Prevention, 15, 431-433. doi:10.1080/15389588.2013.838230

18.

Fell

J. C.

Tippetts

A. S.

Voas

R. B.

(2009). Fatal traffic crashes involving drinking drivers: What have we learned? Annals of Advances in Automotive Medicine/Annual Scientific Conference, 53, 63-76.

19.

Fell

J. C.

Voas

R. B.

(2006). The effectiveness of reducing illegal blood alcohol concentration (BAC) limits for driving: Evidence for lowering the limit to .05 BAC. Journal of Safety Research, 37, 233-243.

20.

Fell

J. C.

Voas

R. B.

(2013). Deterring DUI behavior in the first place. Criminology & Public Policy, 12, 203-211.

21.

Fell

J. C.

Voas

R. B.

(2014). The effectiveness of a 0.05 blood alcohol concentration (BAC) limit for driving in the United States. Addiction, 109, 869-874.

22.

Fone

D. L.

Farewell

D. M.

White

Lyons

R. A.

Dunstan

F. D.

(2013). Socioeconomic patterning of excess alcohol consumption and binge drinking: A cross-sectional study of multilevel associations with neighbourhood deprivation. BMJ Open, 3(4), e002337.

23.

Freeman

D. G.

(2007). Drunk driving legislation and traffic fatalities: New evidence on BAC 08 laws. Contemporary Economic Policy, 25, 293-308.

24.

Freeman

Watson

(2006). An application of Stafford and Warr’s reconceptualisation of deterrence to a group of recidivist drink drivers. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 38, 462-471. doi:10.1016/j.aap.2005.11.001

25.

Goode

(1975). On behalf of labeling theory. Social Problems, 22, 570-583.

26.

Goodfellow

Kilgore

(2014). DUI offenders’ beliefs about DUI statutes and DUI law enforcement: Implications for deterrence. Journal of Drug Issues, 44, 269-280.

27.

Gruenewald

P. J.

Johnson

F. W.

Millar

Mitchell

P. R.

(2000). Drinking and driving: Explaining beverage-specific risks. Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 61, 515-523.

28.

Gulliver

Begg

(2007). Personality factors as predictors of persistent risky driving behavior and crash involvement among young adults. Injury Prevention, 13, 376-381.

29.

Gusfield

J. R.

(1963). Symbolic crusade: Status politics and the American temperance movement. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press.

30.

Gusfield

J. R.

(1981). The culture of public problems: Drinking-driving and the symbolic order. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

31.

Gusfield

J. R.

(1985). Social and cultural contexts of the drinking-driving event. Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs, 10, 70-77.

32.

Gusfield

J. R.

(1996). Contested meanings: The construction of alcohol problems. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.

33.

Haddon

Jr. (1972). A logical framework for categorizing highway safety phenomena and activity. Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery, 12, 193-207.

34.

Haight

F. A.

(1985). Current problems in drinking-driving: Research and intervention. Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs, 10, 13-18.

35.

Harrison

E. L. R.

Fillmore

M. T.

(2005). Are bad drivers more impaired by alcohol? Sober driving precision predicts impairment from alcohol in a simulated driving task. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 37, 882-889.

36.

Harrison

E. L. R.

Fillmore

M. T.

(2011). Alcohol and distraction interact to impair driving performance. Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 117, 31-37.

37.

Haviland

Nagin

D. S.

Rosenbaum

P. R.

(2007). Combining propensity score matching and group-based trajectory analysis in an observational study. Psychological Methods, 12, 247-267.

38.

Houston

D. J.

Richardson

D. F.

Jr. (2004). Drinking-and-driving in America: A test of behavioral assumptions underlying public policy. Political Research Quarterly, 57, 53-64.

39.

Hurst

P. M.

Harte

Frith

W. J.

(1994). The grand rapids dip revisited. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 26, 647-654.

40.

Ibrahim

J. K.

Anderson

E. D.

Burris

S. C.

Wagenaar

A. C.

(2011). State laws restricting driver use of mobile communications devices: Distracted-driving provisions, 1992–2010. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 40, 659-665.

41.

Inciardi

J. A.

(2008). The war on drugs IV: The continuing saga of the mysteries and miseries of intoxication, addiction, crime, and public policy. Boston, MA: Pearson.

42.

Ivan

J. N.

Pasupathy

R. K.

Ossenbruggen

P. J.

(1999). Differences in causality factors for single and multi-vehicle crashes on two-lane roads. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 31, 695-704.

43.

Jacobs

J. B.

(1989). Drunk driving: An American dilemma. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

44.

Jonah

B. A.

(1997). Sensation seeking and risky driving: A review and synthesis of the literature. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 29, 651-665.

45.

Kappeler

V. E.

Potter

G. W.

Blumberg

(2005). Mythology of crime and criminal justice. Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press.

46.

Kelley-Baker

Lacey

J. H.

Voas

R. B.

Romano

Yao

Berning

(2013). Drinking and driving in the United States: Comparing results from the 2007 and 1996 national roadside surveys. Traffic Injury Prevention, 14, 117-126.

47.

Kleiman

M. A.

Caulkins

J. P.

Hawken

(2011). Drugs and drug policy: What everyone needs to know. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

48.

Lacey

J. H.

Kelley-Baker

Furr-Holden

Voas

R. B.

Romano

Ramirez

Berning

(2009). 2007 National roadside survey of alcohol and drug use by drivers: Drug results (NHTSA Technical Report No. HS-811 249). Retrieved from http://www.nhtsa.gov/DOT/NHTSA/Traffic%20Injury%20Control/Articles/Associated%20Files/811249.pdf

49.

Lakins

N. E.

LaVallee

R. A.

Williams

G. D.

H.-y.

(2008). Surveillance report# 85: Apparent per capita alcohol consumption: National, state, and regional trends, 1977-2006. Bethesda, MD: National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, Division of Epidemiology and Prevention Research, Alcohol Epidemiologic Data System.

50.

LaVallee

R. A.

H.-y.

(2010). Apparent per capita alcohol consumption: National, state, and regional trends, 1977–2010. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Services, National Institutes of Health. Retrieved from http://pubs.niaaa.nih.gov/publications/Surveillance95/CONS10.htm#top

51.

Lerner

B. H.

(2011). One for the road: Drunk driving since 1900. Baltimore, MA: Johns Hopkins University Press.

52.

Lewis

J. A.

(2009). A zero-tolerance juvenile alcohol law: Why legislation won’t work. El Paso, TX: LFB Scholarly.

53.

Lofland

(1969). Deviance and identity. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.

54.

MacCoun

R. J.

Reuter

(2001). Drug war heresies: Learning from other vices, times, and places. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

55.

Mann

R. E.

Macdonald

Stoduto

Bondy

Jonah

Shaikh

(2001). The effects of introducing or lowering legal per se blood alcohol limits for driving: An international review. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 33, 569-583.

56.

Mann

R. E.

Stoduto

Vingilis

Asbridge

Wickens

C. M.

Ialomiteanu

. . . Smart

R. G.

(2010). Alcohol and driving factors in collision risk. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 42, 1538-1544.

57.

Martin

T. L.

Solbeck

P. A.

Mayers

D. J.

Langille

R. M.

Buczek

Pelletier

M. R.

(2013). A review of alcohol impaired driving: The role of blood alcohol concentration and complexity of the driving task. Journal of Forensic Sciences, 58, 1238-1250.

58.

Morgan

S. L.

Winship

(2014). Counterfactuals and causal inference. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

59.

Moskowitz

Fiorentino

(2000). A review of the literature on the effects of low doses of alcohol on driving-related skills (NHTSA Technical Report No. HS-809 028). Retrieved from http://www.nhtsa.gov/people/injury/research/pub/Hs809028/Title.htm

60.

Moskowitz

Zador

Smiley

Fiorentino

Burns

(2000). Driver characteristics and impairment at various BAC’s. Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.

61.

Mounce

N. H.

Pendleton

O. J.

(1992). The relationship between blood alcohol concentration and crash responsibility for fatally injured drivers. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 24, 201-210.

62.

Movig

Mathijssen

Nagel

Van Egmond

De Gier

J. J.

Leufkens

Egberts

A. C.

(2004). Psychoactive substance use and the risk of motor vehicle accidents. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 36, 631-636.

63.

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (1994). Computing a BAC estimate. Washington, DC: Department of Transportation.

64.

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2011). Time of day and demographic perspective of fatal alcohol-impaired-driving crashes (Technical Report Number DOT HS 811 523). Washington, DC: Department of Transportation.

65.

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2014a). Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS) analytical user’s manual 1975-2012 (Technical Report Number DOT HS 811 855). Washington, DC: Department of Transportation.

66.

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2014b). Traffic safety facts: Alcohol-impaired driving (2013 data) (Technical Report Number DOT HS 812 102). Washington, DC: Department of Transportation.

67.

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. (2015). Buzzed. Busted. Broke: Buzzed driving is drunk driving. Available from http://buzzeddriving.adcouncil.org/#

68.

National Priorities Program. (2014). Federal spending in your state, 2012-2014. Retrieved from https://www.nationalpriorities.org/analysis/2013/federal-spending-your-state-2012-2014/

69.

National Safety Council. (2012). Annual estimate of cell phone crashes 2011. Itasca, IL: The National Safety Council. Retrieved from http://www.nsc.org/safety_road/Distracted_Driving/Pages/distracted_driving.aspx

70.

National Transportation Safety Board. (2013). Reaching zero: Actions to eliminate alcohol-impaired driving. Safety Report NTSB/SR-13/01. Washington, DC: NTSB.

71.

New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services. (2015). Adult arrests: 2005—2014. Retrieved from http://criminaljustice.ny.gov/crimnet/ojsa/arrests/index.htm

72.

Nikolaev

A. G.

Robbins

M. J.

Jacobson

S. H.

(2010). Evaluating the impact of legislation prohibiting hand-held cell phone use while driving. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 44, 182-193.

73.

Ogden

E. J.

Moskowitz

(2004). Effects of alcohol and other drugs on driver performance. Traffic Injury Prevention, 5, 185-198.

74.

O’Neill

Kyrychenko

S. Y.

(2006). Use and misuse of motor-vehicle crash death rates in assessing highway-safety performance. Traffic Injury Prevention, 7, 307-318.

75.

Ossiander

E. M.

Cummings

(2002). Freeway speed limits and traffic fatalities in Washington State. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 34, 13-18.

76.

Peck

R. C.

Gebers

M. A.

Voas

R. B.

Romano

(2008). The relationship between blood alcohol concentration (BAC), age, and crash risk. Journal of Safety Research, 39, 311-319. doi:10.1016/j.jsr.2008.02.030

77.

Phillips

D. P.

Sousa

A. L. R.

Moshfegh

R. T.

(2014). Official blame for drivers with very low blood alcohol content: There is no safe combination of drinking and driving. Injury Prevention. Retrieved from http://injuryprevention.bmj.com/content/early/2014/01/07/injuryprev-2013-040925.short

78.

Pratt

T. C.

Cullen

F. T.

Blevins

K. R.

Daigle

L. E.

Madensen

T. D.

(2006). The empirical status of deterrence theory: A meta-analysis. In Cullen

F. T.

Wright

Blevins

(Eds.), Taking stock: The status of criminological theory (pp. 367-396). New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.

79.

Quinney

(1970). The social reality of crime. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction publishers.

80.

Rakauskas

M. E.

Ward

N. J.

Boer

E. R.

Bernat

E. M.

Cadwallader

Patrick

C. J.

(2008). Combined effects of alcohol and distraction on driving performance. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 40, 1742-1749.

81.

Raudenbush

S. W.

Bryk

A. S.

(2002). Hierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods (Vol. 1). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

82.

Raudenbush

S. W.

Bryk

A. S.

Congdon

(2004). HLM 7 for Windows [computer software]. Skokie, IL: Scientific Software International Inc. Retrieved from http://www.ssicentral.com/hlm/index.html

83.

Reinarman

(1988). The social construction of an alcohol problem. Theory and Society, 17, 91-120.

84.

Romano

Torres-Saavedra

Voas

R. B.

Lacey

J. H.

(2014). Drugs and alcohol: Their relative crash risk. Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs, 75, 56-64.

85.

Romano

Voas

R. B.

(2011). Drug and alcohol involvement in four types of fatal crashes. Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs, 72, 567-576.

86.

Rosenbaum

P. R.

Rubin

D. B.

(1983). The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects. Biometrika, 70, 41-55.

87.

Rosenbaum

P. R.

Rubin

D. B.

(1985). Constructing a control group using multivariate matched sampling methods that incorporate the propensity score. The American Statistician, 39, 33-38.

88.

Ross

H. L.

(1992). Confronting drunk driving: Social policy for saving lives. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

89.

Shyhalla

(2014). Alcohol involvement and other risky driver behaviors: Effects on crash initiation and crash severity. Traffic Injury Prevention, 15, 325-334.

90.

Simon

(2007). Governing through crime: How the war on crime transformed American democracy and created a culture of fear. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

91.

Spector

Kitsuse

J. I.

(1987). Constructing social problems. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.

92.

Subramanian

(2002, January). Transitioning to multiple imputation—A new method to estimate missing Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) values in FARS NHTSA (Technical Report No. HS-809 403). Retrieved from http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/Pubs/809-403.PDF

93.

Subramanian

(2003, April). Alcohol involvement in fatal crashes 2001 (NHTSA Technical Report No. HS-809 579). Retrieved from http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/Pubs/809-579.pdf

94.

Tannenbaum

(1938). Crime and the community. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

95.

Taxman

F. S.

Piquero

(1998). On preventing drunk driving recidivism: An examination of rehabilitation and punishment approaches. Journal of Criminal Justice, 26, 129-143. doi:10.1016/S0047-2352(97)00075-5

96.

Terhune

Fell

J. C.

(1981). The role of alcohol, marijuana, and other drugs in the accidents of injured drivers. American Association for Automotive Medicine Annual Conference, 25, 117-132.

97.

Thoemmes

F. J.

West

S. G.

(2011). The use of propensity scores for nonrandomized designs with clustered data. Multivariate Behavioral Research, 46, 514-543.

98.

Tippetts

A. S.

Voas

R. B.

Fell

J. C.

Nichols

J. L.

(2005). A meta-analysis of .08 BAC laws in 19 jurisdictions in the United States. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 37, 149-161.

99.

Turner

McClure

Pirozzo

(2004). Injury and risk-taking behavior—A systematic review. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 36, 93-101.

100.

Uniform Crime Reports. (2012). Crime in the United States. U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation. Retrieved from http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2011/crime-in-the-u.s.-2011/tables/table_69_arrest_by_state_2011.xls

101.

Uniform Crime Reports. (2014). Crime in the United States. U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation. Retrieved from https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2014/crime-in-the-u.s.-2014/tables/table-29

102.

U.S. Census Bureau. (2008). 2008 American Community Survey; R1701. Percent of people below poverty level in the past 12 months (For Whom Poverty Status is Determined). Retrieved from https://www.census.gov/prod/2009pubs/acsbr08-1.pdf

103.

U.S. Census Bureau. (2010). 2010 census urban and rural classification and urban area criteria. Author. Retrieved from http://www.census.gov/geo/reference/ua/urban-rural-2010.html

104.

Voas

R. B.

Tippetts

A. S.

Fell

(2000). The relationship of alcohol safety laws to drinking drivers in fatal crashes. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 32, 483-492.

105.

Voas

R. B.

Torres

Romano

Lacey

J. H.

(2012). Alcohol-related risk of driver fatalities: An update using 2007 data. Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs, 73, 341-350.

106.

Wagenaar

A. C.

Maldonado-Molina

M. M.

Tobler

A. L.

Komro

K. A.

(2007). Effects of legal BAC limits on fatal crash involvement: Analyses of 28 states from 1976 through 2002. Journal of Safety Research, 38, 493-499.

107.

Williams

A. F.

(2006). Alcohol-impaired driving and its consequences in the United States: The past 25 years. Journal of Safety Research, 37, 123-138.

108.

Williams

A. F.

Shabanova

V. I.

(2003). Responsibility of drivers, by age and gender, for motor-vehicle crash deaths. Journal of Safety Research, 34, 527-531.

109.

Wilson

F. A.

Stimpson

J. P.

(2010). Trends in fatalities from distracted driving in the United States, 1999 to 2008. American Journal of Public Health, 100, 2213-2219.

110.

(2000). Punishment and alcohol problems: Recidivism among drinking-driving offenders. Journal of Criminal Justice, 28, 261-270.

111.

Evans

P. C.

Clark

L. P.

(2006). Alcohol addiction and perceived sanction risks: Deterring drinking drivers. Journal of Criminal Justice, 34, 165-174.

112.

Yung-Ching

Shing-Mei

(2007). Changes in driving behavior and cognitive performance with different breath alcohol concentration levels. Traffic Injury Prevention, 8, 153-161.

113.

Zador

P. L.

Krawchuk

S. A.

Voas

R. B.

(2000). Alcohol-related relative risk of driver fatalities and driver involvement in fatal crashes in relation to driver age and gender: An update using 1996 data. Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs, 61, 387-395.

114.

Zylman

(1968). Accidents, alcohol and single-cause explanations. Lesions from the Grand Rapids study. Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 4, 212-233.

115.

Zylman

(1972a). Age is more important than alcohol in the collision-involvement of young and old drivers. Journal of Traffic Safety Education, 20(1), 7-8.

116.

Zylman

(1972b). The variability of collision involvement at low blood alcohol concentrations: The Grand Rapids Curve explained (HS-011 643). Blutalkohol, 9, 25-32.