More than 20 years ago, state legislation began moving toward a mandatory arrest approach for police officers who handle domestic violence. It is expected that officers have shifted from an “underenforcement” orientation toward proenforcement. To examine this hypothesis, this study integrated elements of New York State domestic violence legislation into vignettes. Officers from one large department in New York State completed surveys with multiple vignettes. More than 80% of the officers were likely or very likely to arrest in all vignettes. Arrest was more likely when there was a visible injury, when there was an order of protection, and when the suspect was disrespectful. The victim’s preference for no arrest is not significant in officers’ decision making. Policy implications and directions for additional research are discussed.
Agresti, A. ( 1990). Categorical data analysis. New York : John Wiley.
2.
Alpert, G.P., Dunham, R.G., & MacDonald, J.M. (2004). Interactive police-citizen encounters that result in force. Police Quarterly, 7(4), 475-488.
3.
Applegate, B.K., Cullen, F.T., Link, B.G., Richards, P.J., & Lanza-Kaduce, L. (1996). Determinants of public punitiveness toward drunk driving: A factorial survey approach. Justice Quarterly, 13(1), 57-79.
4.
Applegate, B.K., Wright, J.P., Dunaway, R.G., Cullen, F.T., & Wooldredge, J.D. (1993). Victim-offender race and support for capital punishment: A factorial design approach. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 18(1), 95-115.
5.
Balos, B., & Trotsky, K. ( 1988). Enforcement of the domestic abuse act in Minnesota: A preliminary study. Law & Inequality, 6(1), 83-125.
6.
Belknap, J. ( 1995). Law enforcement officers’ attitudes about the appropriate responses to woman battering. International Review of Victimology , 4(1), 47-62.
7.
Berk, A.F., & Loseke, D.R. ( 1981). "Handling" family violence: Situational determinants of police arrest in domestic violence. Law & Society Review , 15(2), 317-346.
8.
Berk, R.A., Campbell, A., Klap, R., & Western, B. ( 1992). The deterrent effect of arrest in incidents of domestic violence: A Bayesian analysis of four field experiments. American Sociological Review, 57(5), 698-708.
9.
Borooah, V.K. ( 2001). Logit and probit: Ordered and multinomial models. Quantitative applications in the social sciences. Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage.
10.
Bracher, P.B. ( 1996). Mandatory arrests for domestic violence: The city of Cincinnati’s simple solution to a complex problem. Cincinnati Law Review, 65, 155-182.
11.
Breci, M.G. ( 1989). The effect of training on police attitudes toward family violence: Where does mandatory arrest fit in? Journal of Criminal Justice, 12(1), 35-49.
12.
Brown, M. ( 1981). Working the streets: Police discretion and the dilemmas of reform. New York: Russell Sage .
13.
Bruno v. Codd, 47 N.Y. 2d 582; 393 N.E. 2d 976; 419 N.Y.S. 2d 901 (Supp. Ct., 1977).
14.
Bryk, A.S., & Raudenbush, S.W. (1992). Hierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods. Newbury Park, CA : Sage.
15.
Buzawa, E.S. ( 1982). Police officer response to domestic violence legislation in Michigan. Journal of Police Science and Administration , 10(4), 415-424.
16.
Buzawa, E., & Austin, T. ( 1993). Determining police response to domestic violence victims . American Behavioral Scientist, 36(5), 610-623.
17.
Buzawa, E., Austin, T.L., & Buzawa, C.G. ( 1995). Responding to crimes on violence against woman: Gender differences versus organizational imperatives. Crime & Delinquency, 41(4), 443-466.
18.
Buzawa, E.S., & Buzawa, C.G. ( 1993). Opening the doors: The changing police response to domestic violence. In R. G. Dunham & G. P. Alpert (Eds.), Critical issues in policing: Contemporary readings (pp. 551-567). Prospect Heights, IL: Waveland.
19.
Chaudhuri, M., & Daly, K. ( 1992). Do restraining orders help? Battered women’s experience with male violence and legal process. In E. S. Buzawa & C. G. Buzawa (Eds.), Domestic violence: The changing criminal justice response (pp. 227-252). Westport, CT: Greenwood.
20.
Cochran, J.K., Boots, D.P., & Heide, K.M. ( 2003). Attribution styles and attitudes toward capital punishment for juveniles, the mentally incompetent, and the mentally retarded. Justice Quarterly, 20(1), 65-93.
21.
Crespi, I. ( 1971). What kinds of attitude measures are predictive of behavior ? Public Opinion Quarterly, 35(3), 327-334.
22.
Dunford, F.W., Huizinga, D., & Elliott, D.S. ( 1990). The role of arrest in domestic violence: The Omaha police experiment. Criminology, 28(2), 183-206.
23.
Eifler, S. ( 2007). Evaluation the validity of self-reported deviant behavior using vignette analysis. Quality & Quantity, 41(2), 303-318.
24.
Ellis, D., Choi, A., & Blaus, C. ( 1993). Injuries to police officers attending domestic disturbances: An empirical study. Canadian Journal of Criminology, 35(2), 149-168.
25.
Engel, R., Sobol, J., & Worden, R. ( 2000). Further exploration of the demeanor hypothesis: The interaction effects of suspects characteristics and demeanor on police behavior. Justice Quarterly, 17(2), 235-258.
26.
Eterno, J. ( 2003). Policing within the law: A case study of the New York City Police Department. Westport, CT: Praeger.
27.
Feder, L. ( 1996). Police handling of domestic calls: The importance of offender’s presence in the arrest decision. Journal of Criminal Justice, 24(6), 481-490.
28.
Feder, L. ( 1999). Police handling of domestic violence calls: An overview and further investigation. Women and Criminal Justice, 10(2), 49-68.
29.
Ferraro, K.J. ( 1989a). The legal response to woman battering in the United States. In J. Hanmer, J. Radfore, & E. A. Stanko (Eds.), Women, policing, and male violence: International perspectives (pp. 155-184). London: Routledge .
Finn, P., & Colson, S. ( 1990). Civil protection orders: Legislation, current court practices, and enforcement (NCJ No. 123236). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice.
Grau, J. ( 1982). Restraining order legislation for battered women: A reassessment . University of San Francisco Law Review, 16, 703-741.
36.
Grau, J., Fagan, J., & Wexler, S. ( 1985). Restraining orders for battered women: Issues of access and efficacy. Women and Politics, 4(1), 13-28.
37.
Hedeker, D., & Gibbons, R.D. ( 1996). MIXREG: A computer program for mixed-effects regression analysis with autocorrelated errors. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, 49(3), 229-252.
38.
Hedeker, D., Gibbons, R.D., & Flay, B.R. ( 1994). Random-effects regression models for clustered data with an example from smoking prevention research. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 62(4), 757-765.
Hosmer, D.W., & Lemeshow, S. ( 2000). Applied logistic regression. New York : John Wiley.
43.
Jacoby, J.E., & Cullen, F.T. ( 1999). The structure of punishment norms: Applying the Rossi-Berk model. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 89(1), 245-312.
44.
Kane, R.J. ( 2000). Police responses to restraining orders in domestic violence incidents: Identifying the custody-threshold thesis. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 27(5), 561-580.
45.
Klinger, D.A. ( 1996). More on demeanor and arrest in Dade County. Criminology, 34(1), 61-82.
46.
Klinger, D.A. ( 1997). Negotiating order in patrol work: An ecological theory of police response to deviance. Criminology, 35(2), 277-306.
47.
Liao, T.F. ( 1994). Interpreting probability models: Logit, probit and other generalized linear models. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
48.
Long, J.S. ( 1997). Regression models for categorical and limited dependent variables. London: Sage.
49.
Long, J.S., & Freese, J. ( 2006). Regression models for categorical dependent variables using STATA. College Station, TX: STATA Press.
Miller, J.L., Rossi, P.H., & Simpson, J.E. ( 1986). Perceptions of justice: Race and gender differences in judgments of appropriate prison sentences. Law & Society Review, 20(3), 313-334.
52.
Miller, N. ( 1997, June). Domestic violence legislation affecting police and prosecutor responsibilities in the United States: Inferences from a 50-state review of state statutory codes. Paper presented at the 5th International Family Violence Conference, Durham, NH.
53.
Mitchell, D.B. ( 1992). Contemporary police practices in domestic violence cases: Arresting the abuser: Is it enough? Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 83(1), 241-253.
54.
Murphy, P. ( 1997). Domestic violence legislation and the police: The role of socio-economic indicators, political factors and women’s political activism on state policy adoption. Women and Politics, 18(2), 27-53.
55.
New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Office for the Prevention of Domestic Violence, and the University of Albany, School of Criminal Justice. (1997). Family Protection and Domestic Violence Intervention Act of 1994: Evaluation of the mandatory arrest provisions-First interim rep. to the governor and the legislature. Albany: State of New York.
56.
New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Office for the Prevention of Domestic Violence, and the University of Albany, School of Criminal Justice. (1998). Family Protection and Domestic Violence Intervention Act of 1994: Evaluation of the mandatory arrest provisions-Second interim rep. to the governor and the legislature. Albany: State of New York.
57.
New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Office for the Prevention of Domestic Violence, and the University of Albany, School of Criminal Justice. (2001). Family Protection and Domestic Violence Intervention Act of 1994: Evaluation of the Mandatory Arrest Provisions-Final interim rep. to the governor and the legislature. Albany: State of New York.
Paoline, E.A., III, Myers, S.M., & Worden, R.E. ( 2000). Police culture, individualism, and community policing: Evidence from two police departments. Justice Quarterly, 17(3), 575-605.
60.
Pate, A.M., & Hamilton, E.E. (1992). Formal and informal deterrents to domestic violence: The Date County spouse assault experiment. American Sociological Review, 57(5), 691-697.
61.
Phillips, S.W., & Varano, S.P. (in press). Police criminal charging decisions: An examination of post-arrest decision making. Journal of Criminal Justice.
62.
Reaves, B.A., & Hickman, M.J. ( 2002). Census of state and local law enforcement agencies, 2000 (NCJ 194066). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics
63.
Robinson, A. ( 2000). The effect of a domestic violence policy change on police officer’s schemata. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 27(5), 600-624.
64.
Robinson, A., & Chandek, M.S. ( 2000). The domestic violence arrest decision: Examining demographic, attitudinal, and situational variables. Crime & Delinquency , 46(1), 18-37.
65.
Rogers, W.H. ( 1993). Regression standard errors in clustered samples. Stata Technical Bulletin, 13, 19-23.
66.
Rossi, P.H., & Anderson, A.B. (1982). The factorial survey approach: An introduction. In P. H. Rossi & S. L. Nock (Eds.), Measuring social judgment: The factorial survey approach (pp. 15-67). Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
67.
Schmidt, J.D., & Sherman, L.W. ( 1993). Does arrest deter domestic violence? American Behavioral Scientist, 36(5), 601-609.
68.
Scott v. Hart, C-76-2395, N.D. Cal. (October 28, 1976).
69.
Sherman, L. ( 1992). Policing domestic violence: Experiments and dilemmas . New York: Free Press.
70.
Sherman, L.W., & Berk, R.A. ( 1984). The specific deterrent effects of arrest for domestic violence. American Sociological Review, 49(2), 261-272.
71.
Sherman, L.W., & Cohn, E.G. ( 1989). The impact of research on legal policy: The Minneapolis Domestic Violence Experiment. Law & Society Review, 23(1), 117-144.
72.
Sherman, L.W., & Smith, D.A. ( 1992). Crime, punishment, and stake in conformity: Legal and informal control of domestic violence. American Sociological Review, 57(5), 680-690.
73.
Smith, D.A. ( 1987). Police response to interpersonal violence: Defining the parameters of legal control. Social Forces, 65(3), 767-782.
74.
Stalans, L., & Finn, M.A. ( 1995). How novice and experienced officers interpret wife assaults: Normative and efficiency frames. Law & Society Review , 29(2), 287-321.
75.
StataCorp. (2006). Stata SE (Version 9.0). College Station, TX: Author .
76.
Stojkovic, S., Kalinich, D., & Klofas, J. ( 2003). Criminal justice organizations: Administration and management (3rd ed.). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth /Thomson.
77.
Thurman v. Torrington, 595 F. Supp. 1521 (D. Conn., 1984)
78.
U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. (1982). Under the rule of thumb: Battered women and the administration of justice . Washington, DC: Author.
79.
Waaland, P., & Keeley, S. ( 1985). Police decision making in wife abuse: The impact of legal and extralegal factors. Law and Human Behavior, 9(4), 355-366.
80.
Williams, R.L. ( 2000). A note on robust variance estimation for cluster-correlated data. Biometrics, 56, 645-646.
81.
Winship, C., & Mare, R.D. ( 1984). Regression models with ordinal variables. American Sociological Review, 49(4), 512-525.
82.
Worden, R.E. ( 1995). The causes of police brutality: Theory and evidence on police use of force. In W. A. Geller & H. Toch (Eds.), And justice for all: Understanding and controlling police abuse of force (pp. 31-60). Washington, DC : Police Executive Research Forum.
83.
Worden, R., & Pollitz, A. ( 1984). Police arrests in domestic disturbances: A further look . Law & Society Review, 18(1), 105-119.
84.
Worden, R.E., & Shepard, R.L. ( 1996). Demeanor, crime, and police behavior: A reexamination of the police services study data. Criminology, 34(1), 83-105.
85.
Zorza, J. ( 1992). The criminal law of misdemeanor domestic violence, 1970-1990 . Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 83(1), 46-72.
