Resurrecting Individual Differences: Toward a Theory of Police Officer Behavior

Abstract

The past century has produced abundant scholarship on policing. Glaringly absent, despite thousands of studies, has been an explicit attempt to build an interdisciplinary and causal theory of police behavior. Although theories about various aspects of policing exist, as a general rule they are cut-off from the insights of other behavioral sciences. There remains a need for a causal theory capable of explaining police behaviors and outcomes. We present a nascent theory of policing intended to provide a parsimonious, individual-level explanation of the complexities of policing. In the spirit of Popper, we offer “provisional” ideas that can be tested.

Keywords

arrest decision-making police police behavior theory

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Altikriti

(2021). The effects of individual differences on the perceived risks and rewards of offending: A meta-analysis [Unpublished doctoral dissertation]. University of Cincinnati.

Barnes

J. C.

Beaver

K. M.

Boutwell

B. B.

(2011). Examining the genetic underpinnings of Moffitt’s developmental taxonomy: A behavioral genetic analysis. Criminology, 49(4), 923–954.

Barnes

J. C.

Beaver

K. M.

Boutwell

B. B.

(2013). Average county-level IQ predicts county-level disadvantage and several county-level mortality risk rates. Intelligence, 41(1), 59–66.

Barnes

J. C.

Boutwell

B. B.

Beaver

K. M.

Gibson

C. L.

(2013). Analyzing the origins of childhood externalizing behavioral problems. Developmental Psychology, 49(12), 2272.

Barnes

J. C.

Boutwell

B. B.

Beaver

K. M.

Gibson

C. L.

Wright

J. P.

(2014). On the consequences of ignoring genetic influences in criminological research. Journal of Criminal Justice, 42(6), 471–482.

Beaver

K. M.

Barnes

J. C.

Schwartz

J. A.

Boutwell

B. B.

(2015). Enlisting in the military: The influential role of genetic factors. Sage Open, 5(2), 2158244015573352. https://doi.org/10.1177/2158244015573352

Beaver

K. M.

Boutwell

B. B.

Barnes

J. C.

Cooper

J. A.

(2009). The biosocial underpinnings to adolescent victimization: Results from a longitudinal sample of twins. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 7(3), 223–238.

Beaver

K. M.

DeLisi

Vaughn

M. G.

Wright

J. P.

Boutwell

B. B.

(2008). The relationship between self-control and language: Evidence of a shared etiological pathway. Criminology, 46(4), 939–970.

Beaver

K. M.

Schwartz

J. A.

Connolly

E. J.

Said Al-Ghamdi

Kobeisy

A. N.

Barnes

J. C.

Boutwell

B. B.

(2016). Intelligence and early life mortality: Findings from a longitudinal sample of youth. Death Studies, 40(5), 298–304.

10.

Bernard

T. J.

Engel

R. S.

(2001). Conceptualizing criminal justice theory. Justice Quarterly, 18(1), 1–30.

11.

Bolger

P. C.

Walters

G. D.

(2019). The relationship between police procedural justice, police legitimacy, and people’s willingness to cooperate with law enforcement: A meta-analysis. Journal of Criminal Justice, 60, 93–99.

12.

Bouffard

L. A.

Piquero

N. L.

(2010). Defiance theory and life course explanations of persistent offending. Crime and Delinquency, 56(2), 227–252.

13.

Brandl

S. G.

Stroshine

M. S.

(2013). The role of officer attributes, job characteristics, and arrest activity in explaining police use of force. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 24(5), 551–572.

14.

Brown

R. A.

(2003). Exploring the use of formal authority in police-citizen encounters [Unpublished doctoral dissertation]. University of Cincinnati.

15.

Brown

Frank

(2006). Race and officer decision making: Examining differences in arrest outcomes between black and white officers. Justice Quarterly, 23(1), 96–126.

16.

Caldero

Crank

(2010). Police ethics: The corruption of noble cause (3rd ed.). Anderson.

17.

Chabris

C. F.

Lee

J. J.

Cesarini

Benjamin

D. J.

Laibson

D. I.

(2015). The fourth law of behavior genetics. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 24(4), 304–312.

18.

Cullen

F.T.

(2011). Beyond adolesence-limited criminology: Choosing our future — the American society of criminology 2010 Sutherland address. Criminology, 49(2), 287–330.

19.

Cuttler

M. J.

Muchinsky

P. M.

(2006). Prediction of law enforcement training performance and dysfunctional job performance with general mental ability, personality, and life history variables. Criminal Justice & Behavior, 33(1), 3–25.

20.

Deary

I. J.

Penke

Johnson

(2010). The neuroscience of human intelligence differences. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 11(3), 201–211.

21.

Deary

I. J.

Strand

Smith

Fernandes

(2007). Intelligence and educational achievement. Intelligence, 35(1), 13–21.

22.

Deutsch

(2011). The beginning of infinity: Explanations that transform the world. Penguin UK.

23.

Diamond

(2013). Executive functions. Annual Review of Psychology, 64(1), 135–168.

24.

Donner

C. M.

Jennings

W. G.

(2014). Low self-control and police deviance: Applying Gottfredson and Hirschi’s general theory to officer misconduct. Police Quarterly, 17(3), 203–225.

25.

Donner

C. M.

Fridell

L. A.

Jennings

W. G.

(2016). The relationship between self-control and police misconduct: A multi-agency study of first-line police supervisors. Criminal Justice & Behavior, 43(7), 841–862.

26.

Donner

C. M.

Maskaly

Piquero

A. R.

Jennings

W. G.

(2017). Quick on the draw: Assessing the relationship between low self-control and officer-involved police shootings. Police Quarterly, 20(2), 213–234.

27.

Duffee

D. E.

Allan

(2007). Criminal justice, criminology, and criminal justice theory. In. Duffee

D. E.

Maguire

E. R.

(Eds.). Criminal justice theory: Explaining the nature and behavior of criminal justice (pp. 1–26). Routledge.

28.

Ebstein

R. P.

Israel

Chew

S. H.

Zhong

Knafo

(2010). Genetics of human social behavior. Neuron, 65(6), 831–844. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2010.02.020

29.

Eitle

(2005). The influence of mandatory arrest policies, police organizational characteristics, and situation variables on the probability of arrest in domestic violence cases. Crime & Delinquency 51, 573–597.

30.

Fahsing

I. A.

Ask

(2018). In search of indicators of detective aptitude: Police recruits’ logical reasoning and ability to generate investigative hypotheses. Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, 33, 21–34.

31.

Friedrich

R. J.

(1980). Police use of force: Individuals, situations, and organizations. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 452, 82–97.

32.

Gau

J. M.

Brunson

R. K.

(2010). Procedural justice and order maintenance policing: A study of inner-city young men’s perceptions of police legitimacy. Justice Quarterly, 27(2), 255–279.

33.

Gottfredson

L. S.

(2004). Life, death, and intelligence. Journal of Cognitive Education and Psychology, 4(1), 23–46.

34.

Gottfredson

M. R.

Hirschi

(1990). A general theory of crime. Stanford University Press.

35.

Greene

J. R.

Piquero

A. R.

Hickman

M. J.

Lawton

B. A.

(2004). Police integrity and accountability in Philadelphia: Predicting and assessing police misconduct. National Institute of Justice.

36.

Harris

J. R.

(2009). The nurture assumption: Why children turn out the way they do, revised and updated. Simon and Schuster (Original work published 1998).

37.

Hilal

Densley

J. A.

Jones

D. S.

(2017). A signaling theory of law enforcement hiring. Policing and Society, 27(5), 508–524. https://doi.org/10.1080/10439463.2015.1081388

38.

Holtfreter

Reisig

M. D.

Piquero

N. L.

Piquero

A. R.

(2010). Low self-control and fraud: Offending, victimization, and their overlap. Criminal Justice & Behavior, 37(2), 188–203.

39.

Ingram

J. R.

Terrill

Paoline

E. A.

III . (2018). Police culture and officer behavior: Application of a multilevel framework. Criminology, 56(4), 780–811.

40.

Jones

S. E.

Miller

J. D.

Lynam

D. R.

(2011). Personality, antisocial behavior, and aggression: A meta-analytic review. Journal of Criminal Justice, 39(4), 329–337.

41.

Kane

R. J.

(2002). The social ecology of police misconduct. Criminology, 40(4), 867–896.

42.

Kane

R. J.

White

M. D.

(2009). Bad cops: A study of career-ending misconduct among New York City police officers. Criminology & Public Policy, 8(4), 737–769.

43.

Katz

C. M.

Huff

(2023). The Achilles heel of police body-worn cameras: Understanding the factors that influence variation in body-worn camera activation. Justice Quarterly, 40(3), 315–336.

44.

Kendler

K. S.

Baker

J. H.

(2007). Genetic influences on measures of the environment: A systematic review. Psychological Medicine, 37(5), 615–626.

45.

Klahm

C. F.

Tillyer

(2010). Understanding police use of force: A review of the evidence. Southwest Journal of Criminal Justice, 7(2), 214–239.

46.

Klinger

(1996). Quantifying law in police-citizen encounters. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 12(4), 391–415.

47.

Klinger

D. A.

(1995). The micro-structure of nonlethal force: Baseline data from an observational study. Criminal Justice Review, 20(2), 169–186.

48.

Klockars

C. B.

(1980). The Dirty Harry problem. The Annals of the Academy of Political and Social Sciences, 452(1), 33–47.

49.

Langworthy

R. H.

(1986). The structure of police organizations. Praeger.

50.

Lee

Lim

Moore

D. D.

Kim

(2013). How police organizational structure correlates with frontline officers’ attitudes toward corruption: A multilevel model. Police Practice and Research, 14(5), 386–401.

51.

Lee

J. J.

(2012). Correlation and causation in the study of personality. European Journal of Personality, 26(4), 372–390.

52.

Maguire

E. R.

(2003). Organizational structure in American police agencies: Context, complexity, and control. SUNY Press.

53.

Mastrofski

S. D.

Parks

R. B.

(1990). Improving observational studies of police, Criminology, 28(3), 475–496.

54.

Mastrofski

S. D.

Reisig

M. D.

McCluskey

J. D.

(2002). Police disrespect toward the public: An encounter-based analysis. Criminology, 40(3), 519–551.

55.

Mastrofski

S. D.

Ritti

R. R.

Hoffmaster

(1987). Organizational determinants of police discretion: The case of drinking-driving. The Journal of Criminal Justice, 15(5), 387–402.

56.

McCluskey

J. D.

Mastrofski

S. D.

Parks

R. B.

(1999). To acquiesce or rebel: Predicting citizen compliance with police requests. Police Quarterly, 2(4), 389–416.

57.

McLean

Alikhan

Alpert

G. P.

(2023). Re-examining the use of force continuum: Why resistance is not the only driver of use of force decisions. Police Quarterly, 26(1), 85–110.

58.

Metchik

(1999). An analysis of the “screening out” model of police officer selection. Police Quarterly, 2(1), 79–95.

59.

Moffitt

T. E.

(1993). Adolescence-limited and life-course-persistent antisocial behavior: A developmental taxonomy. Psychological Review, 100(4), 674–701.

60.

Moffitt

T. E.

(2018). Male antisocial behaviour in adolescence and beyond. Nature Human Behaviour, 2(3), 177–186.

61.

Moffitt

T. E.

Arseneault

Belsky

Dickson

Hancox

Harrington

H. L.

Houts

Poulton

Roberts

Ross

Sears

Thomson

W. M.

Caspi

(2011). A gradient of childhood self-control predicts health, wealth, and public safety. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, 108(7), 2693–2698.

62.

Moffitt

T. E.

Caspi

Rutter

(2005). Strategy for investigating interactions between measured genes and measured environments. Archives of General Psychiatry, 62(5), 473–481.

63.

Muir

W. K.

Jr. (1977). Police: Streetcorner politicians. University of Chicago Press.

64.

National Research Council. (2004). Fairness and effectiveness in policing. Committee to review research on police policy and practices. In Skogan Frydll

(Eds.), Committee on Law and Justice, Division of Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education (pp. 1–413). The National Academies Press.

65.

Nedelec

J. L.

Boutwell

B. B.

Theocharidou

(2020). The intersection of individual differences, personality variation, & military service: A twin comparison design. Military Psychology, 32(5), 442–452.

66.

Nix

Wolfe

S. E.

Rojek

Kaminski

R. J.

(2015). Trust in the police: The influence of procedural justice and perceived collective efficacy. Crime & Delinquency, 61(4), 610–640. https://doi.org/10.1177/0011128714530548

67.

Novak

Boutwell

B. B.

Smith

T. B.

(2024). Taking the problem of colliders seriously in the study of crime: A research note. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 20, 1005–1014.

68.

Nowacki

J. S.

Spender

(2019). Police discretion, organizational characteristics, and traffic stops: An analysis of racial disparity in Illinois. International Journal of Police Science & Management, 21(1), 4–16.

69.

Ones

D. S.

Viswesvaran

Schmidt

F. L.

(2003). Personality and absenteeism: A meta-analysis of integrity tests. European Journal of Personality, 17(S1), S19–S38.

70.

Ono

Sachau

D. A.

Deal

W. P.

Englert

D. R.

Taylor

M. D.

(2011). Cognitive ability, emotional intelligence, and the big five personality dimensions as predictors of criminal investigator performance. Criminal Justice & Behavior, 38(5), 471–491.

71.

Paoline

E. A.

III . (2003). Taking stock: Toward a richer understanding of police culture. Journal of Criminal Justice, 31(3), 199–214.

72.

Paoline

E. A.

III Terrill

(2007). Police education, experience, and the use of force. Criminal Justice & Behavior, 34(2), 179–196.

73.

Parks

R. B.

Mastrofski

S. D.

Dejong

Gray

M. K.

(1999). How officers spend their time with the community. Justice Quarterly, 16(3), 483–518.

74.

Petkovsek

M. A.

Boutwell

B. B.

(2014). Childhood intelligence and the emergence of self-control. Criminal Justice & Behavior, 41(10), 1232–1249.

75.

Pilcher

J. J.

Morris

D. M.

Erikson

D. N.

(2023). Self-control measurement methodologies: An integrative approach. Psychological Reports, 126(3), 1108–1129.

76.

Piquero

A. R.

Moffitt

T. E.

(2010). Life-course persistent offending. In Adler

J. R.

Gray

J. M.

(Eds.), Forensic psychology: Concepts, debates, and practice (2^nd ed, pp. 233–254). Willan.

77.

Plomin

Deary

I. J.

(2015). Genetics and intelligence differences: Five special findings. Molecular Psychiatry, 20(1), 98–108.

78.

Popper

(1999). All life is problem solving. Routledge.

79.

Pratt

T. C.

Cullen

F. T.

(2000). The empirical status of Gottfredson and Hirschi’s general theory of crime: A meta-analysis. Criminology, 38(3), 931–964.

80.

Reisig

M. D.

McCluskey

J. D.

Mastrofski

S. D.

Terrill

(2004). Suspect disrespect toward the police. Justice Quarterly, 21(2), 241–268. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418820400095801

81.

Reisig

M. D.

Pratt

T. C.

(2011). Low self-control and imprudent behavior revisited. Deviant Behavior, 32(7), 589–625.

82.

Reiss

A. J.

Jr. (1971). The police and the public. Yale University Press.

83.

Reuss-Ianni

(1983). Two cultures of policing: Street cops and management cops. Transaction Publishers.

84.

Rhee

S. H.

Waldman

I. D.

(2002). Genetic and environmental influences on antisocial behavior: A meta-analysis of twin and adoption studies. Psychological Bulletin, 128(3), 490–529.

85.

Riksheim

E. C.

Chermak

S. M.

(1993). Causes of police behavior revisited. Journal of Criminal Justice, 21(4), 353–382.

86.

Sanders

B. A.

(2008). Using personality traits to predict police officer performance. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 31(1), 129–147.

87.

Sarchione

C. D.

Cuttler

M. J.

Muchinsky

P. M.

Nelson-Gray

R. O.

(1998). Prediction of dysfunctional job behaviors among law enforcement officers. Journal of Applied Psychology, 83(6), 904–912.

88.

Scarr

(1992). Developmental theories of the 1990s: Development and individual differences. Child Development, 63(1), 1–19.

89.

Sherman

(1980). Causes of police behavior: The current state of quantitative research, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 17(1), 69–100.

90.

Sherman

L. W.

(2025). The Farrington curve: A commentary on how David Farrington showed how to prioritise the most harmful offenders. Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health, 35(1), 3.

91.

Sleep

C. E.

Crowe

M. L.

Carter

N. T.

Lynam

D. R.

Miller

J. D.

(2021). Uncovering the structure of antagonism. Personality Disorders: Theory, Research, and Treatment, 12(4), 300.

92.

Smith

B. W.

Novak

K. J.

Frank

(2001). Community policing and the work routines of street-level officers. Criminal Justice Review, 26(1), 17–37.

93.

Smith

D. A.

(1987). Police response to interpersonal violence: Defining the parameters of legal control. Social Forces, 65(3), 767–782.

94.

Smith

D. A.

Visher

C. A.

(1981). Street-level justice: Situational determinants of police arrest decisions. Social Problems, 29(2), 167–177.

95.

Smith

D. A.

Visher

C. A.

Davidson

L. A.

(1984). Equity and discretionary justice: The influence of race on police arrest decisions. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 75(1), 234–249.

96.

Smith

T. B.

Stoffel

A. C. A.

Lopes

V. D. F.

Novak

Boutwell

B. B.

(2024). A weight-activated main path analysis of policing and life-course scholarship. CrimRxiv.

97.

Snipes

J. B.

Maguire

E. R.

(2007). Foundations of criminal justice theory. In Duffee

D. E.

Maguire

E. R.

(Eds.), Criminal justice theory: Explaining the nature and behavior of criminal justice (pp. 27–49). Routledge.

98.

Somers

L. J.

Terrill

(2022). Confidence in their craft: Assessing the relationship between officer work experience and their perceptions of self-efficacy. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 49(11), 1656–1675. https://doi.org/10.1177/00938548221105879

99.

Stinson

P. M.

Sr. Liederbach

Freiburger

T. L.

(2010). Exit strategy: An exploration of late-stage police crime. Police Quarterly, 13(4), 413–435.

100.

Swatt

M. L.

(2002). Demeanor and arrest revisited: Reconsidering the direct effect of demeanor. Journal of Crime and Justice, 25(1), 23–39.

101.

Tanksley

P. T.

Barnes

J. C.

Boutwell

B. B.

Arseneault

Caspi

Danese

Fisher

Moffitt

T. E.

(2020). Identifying psychological pathways to polyvictimization: Evidence from a longitudinal cohort study of twins from the UK. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 16(3), 431–461.

102.

Terpstra

White

M. D.

Fradella

H. F.

(2022). Finding good cops: The foundations of a screen-in (not out) hiring process for police. Policing: An International Journal, 46(4), 676–692. https://doi.org/10.1108/PIJPSM-08-2021-0116

103.

Terrill

Mastrofski

S. D.

(2002). Situational and officer-based determinants of police coercion. Justice Quarterly, 19(2), 215–248.

104.

Terrill

Paoline

E. A.

III . (2007). Nonarrest decision making in police-citizen encounters. Police Quarterly, 10(3), 308–331.

105.

Terrill

Reisig

M. D.

(2003). Neighborhood context and police use of force. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 40(3), 291–321.

106.

Terrill

Zimmerman

Somers

L. J.

(2023). Applying video-based systematic social observation to police use of force encounters: An assessment of de-escalation and escalation within the context of proportionality and incrementalism. Justice Quarterly, 40(7), 1045–1076.

107.

Thompson

G. J.

Jenkins

J. B.

(1993). Verbal judo: The gentle art of persuasion. William Morrow.

108.

van Zyl

C. J. J.

de Bruin

G. P.

(2018). Predicting counterproductive work behavior with narrow personality traits: A nuanced examination using quantile regression. Personality and Individual Differences, 131(1), 45–50. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.paid.2018.04.014

109.

Varela

J. G.

Boccaccini

M. T.

Scogin

Stump

Caputo

(2004). Personality testing in law enforcement employment settings: A meta-analytic review. Criminal Justice & Behavior, 31(6), 649–675.

110.

Visher

C. A.

(1983). Gender, police arrest decisions, and notions of chivalry. Criminology, 21(1), 5–28.

111.

Westley

W. A.

(1953). Violence and the police. American Journal of Sociology, 59(1), 34–41.

112.

Westley

W. A.

(1970). Violence and the police: A sociological study of law, custom, and morality. The MIT Press.

113.

White

M. D.

(2001). Controlling police decisions to use deadly force: Reexamining the importance of administrative policy. Crime & Delinquency, 47(1), 131–151.

114.

Willoughby

E. A.

Polderman

T. J.

Boutwell

B. B.

(2023). Behavioural genetics methods. Nature Reviews Methods Primers, 3(1), 10.

115.

Wilson

J. Q.

(1968). Varieties of police behavior: The management of law and order in eight communities. Harvard University Press.

116.

Wolfe

S. E.

Nix

Kaminski

Rojek

(2016). Is the effect of procedural justice on police legitimacy invariant? Testing the generality of procedural justice and competing antecedents of legitimacy. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 32, 253–282.

117.

Worden

R. E.

(1989). Situational and attitudinal explanations of police behavior: A theoretical reappraisal and empirical assessment. Law & Society Review, 23(4), 667–711.

118.

Worden

R. E.

Shepard

R. L.

(1996). Demeanor, crime, and police behavior: A reexamination of the police services study data. Criminology, 34(1), 83–105.

119.

Wright

J. P.

Beaver

K. M.

(2005). Do parents matter in creating self-control in their children? A genetically informed test of Gottfredson and Hirschi's theory of low self-control. Criminology, 43(4), 1169–1202.

120.

Zavala

Kurtz

D. L.

(2017). Using Gottfredson and Hirschi’s A General Theory of Crime to explain problematic alcohol consumption by police officers: A test of self-control as self-regulation. Journal of Drug Issues, 47(3), 505–522.