What audit tools are available to assess neighborhood suitability for aging in place? Drawing on theories from environmental gerontology, the article outlines physical and social environmental characteristics influencing aging. Eight research audit tools and three community/practitioner tools were identified using a Boolean search strategy. They emphasize walkability and the physical attributes of places. Areas for further development include addressing specific features related to aging, a wider range of environments, additional physical and social dimensions, and conducting audits using technologies and participatory processes to better incorporate aging experiences. For planners, these audit tools raise awareness of how environments can better support aging populations.
AlmeidaM. F.2016. “Age-friendly Walkable Urban Spaces: A Participatory Assessment Tool.” Journal of Housing for the Elderly30 (4): 396–411.
7.
AltmanI.RogoffB.1987. “World Views in Psychology: Trait, Interactionist, Organismic, and Transactional Perspectives.” In Handbook of Environmental Psychology, Vol. 1, edited by StokelsD.AltmanI., 1–40. New York: Wiley.
8.
BaltesM. M.MaasI.WilmsH. U.BorcheltM.LittleT.1999. “Everyday Competence in Old and Very Old Age: Theoretical Considerations and Empirical Findings.” In The Berlin Aging Study: Aging from 70 to 100, edited by BaltesP. B.MayerK. U., 384–402. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
9.
BaltesP. B.BaltesM. M.1990. “Psychological Perspectives on Successful Aging: The Model of Selective Optimization with Compensation.” In Successful Aging: Perspectives from the Behavioral Sciences, edited by BaltesP. B.BaltesM. M., 1–34. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
10.
BoarnetM.DayK.AlfonzoM.ForsythA.OakesM.2006. “The Irvine-Minnesota Inventory to Measure Built Environments: Reliability Tests.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine30 (2): 153–59.
11.
BoldyD.GrenadeL.LreingG.KarolE.BurtonE.2010. “Older People’s Decisions Regarding ‘Ageing in Place’: A Western Australian Case Study.” Australasian Journal on Ageing30 (3): 136–42.
12.
BorstH. C.de VriesS. I.GrahamJ. M. A.van DongenJ. E. F.BakkerI.MiedemaH. M. E.2009. “Influence of Environmental Street Characteristics on Walking Route Choice of Elderly People.” Journal of Environmental Psychology29 (4): 477–84.
13.
BrookfieldK.TilleyS.. 2016. “Using Virtual Street Audits to Understand the Walkability of Older Adults’ Route Choices by Gender and Age.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health13 (11): 1061. Accessed July 1, 2018. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5129271/.
14.
BrownsonR. C.HoehnerC. M.BrennanL. K.CookR. A.ElliottM. B.McMullenK. M.2004. “Reliability of 2 Instruments for Auditing the Environment for Physical Activity.” Journal of Physical Activity and Health1 (3): 191–208.
15.
BrownsonR. C.HoehnerC. M.DayK.ForsythA.SallisJ. F.2009. “Measuring the Built Environment for Physical Activity: State of the Science.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine36 (4S): S99–123.c12.
16.
BurtonE. J.MitchellL.StrideC. B.2011. “Good Places for Ageing in Place: Development of Objective Built Environment Measures for Investigating Links with Older People’s Wellbeing.” BMC Public Health11:839.
17.
BurtonE. J.WeichS.BlanchardM.PrinceM.2005. “Measuring Physical Characteristics of Housing: The Built Environment Site Survey Checklist (BESSC).” Environment and Planning B. 32 (2): 265–280.
CainK. L.MillsteinR. A.SallisJ. F.ConwayT. L.GavandK. A.FrankL. D.SaelensB. E.GeremiaC. M.ChapmanJ.AdamsM. A.GlanzK.KingA. C.2014. “Contribution of Streetscape Audits to Explanation of Physical Activity in Four Age Groups Based on the Microscale Audit of Pedestrian Streetscapes (MAPS).” Social Science and Medicine116 (Sep): 82–92.
20.
CaughyM. O.O’CampoP. J.PattersonJ.2001. “A Brief Observational Measure for Urban Neighborhoods.” Health & Place7 (3): 225–36.
ChaudhuryH.SarteA. F. I.MichaelY. L.MahmoodA.KeastE. M.DogaruC.WisterA.2011. “Use of a Systematic Observational Measure to Assess and Compare Walkability for Older Adults in Vancouver British Columbia and Portland Oregon Neighborhoods.” Journal of Urban Design16:433–54.
24.
ChowC. K.CorsiD. J.LockK.MadhavanM.MackieP.LiW.YiS.WangY.SwaminathanS.Lopez-JaramilloP.Gomez-ArbelaezD.AvezumA.LearS. A.DagenaisG.TeoK.McKeeM.YusufS.2014. “A Novel Method to Evaluate the Community Built Environment Using Photographs—Environmental Profile of a Community Health (EPOCH) Photo Neighborhood Evaluation Tool.” PLoS One9 (11): e110042. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0110042
25.
CunninghamG. O.MichaelY. L.2004. “Concepts Guiding the Study of the Impact of the Built Environment on Physical Activity for Older Adults: A Review of the Literature.” American Journal of Health Promotion18 (6): 435–43.
26.
CunninghamG. O.MichaelY. L.FarquharS. A.LapidusJ.2005. “Developing a Reliable Senior Walking Environmental Assessment Tool.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine29 (3): 215–17.
27.
CutchinM. P.2003. “The Process of Mediated Aging-in-place: A Theoretically and Empirically Based Model.”Social Science & Medicine57:1077–90.
28.
CutlerL. J.KaneR. A.DegenholtzH. B.MillerM. J.GrantL.2006. “Assessing and Comparing Physical Environments for Nursing Home Residents: Using New tools for Greater Research Specificity.” The Gerontologist46 (1): 42–51.
29.
DayK.BoarnetM.AlfonzoM.ForsythA.2006. “The Irvine-Minnesota Inventory to Measure Built Environments.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine30 (2): 144–52.
30.
Diaz MooreK.2014. “An Ecological Framework of Place: Situating Environmental Gerontology Within a Life Course Perspective.” International Journal of Aging and Human Development79 (3): 183–209.
31.
ElfM.NordinS.WijkH.MckeeK. J.2017. “A Systematic Review of the Psychometric Properties of Instruments for Assessing the Quality of the Physical Environment in Healthcare.” Journal of Advanced Nursing73 (12): 2796–816.
32.
European Commission. 2012. Taking Forward the Strategic Implementation Plan of the European Innovation Partnership on Active and Healthy Ageing. Brussels, Belgium: European Commission. Accessed January 24, 2017. http://ec.europa.eu/health/ageing/docs/com_2012_83_en.pdf.
33.
Fernández-BallesterosR.RobineJ. M.WalkerA.KalacheA.2013. “Active Aging: A Global Goal.” Current Gerontology and Geriatrics Review2013:298012.
34.
FinlayJ. M.BowmanJ. A.2017. “Geographies on the Move: A Practical and Theoretical Approach to the Mobile Interview.” The Professional Geographer69 (2): 263–74.
35.
FisherK. J.PickeringM. A.LiF.2002. “Healthy Aging Through Active Leisure: Design and Methods of SHAPE—A Randomized Controlled Trial of a Neighborhood-based Walking Project.” World Leisure Journal44 (1): 19–28.
ForsythA.KanH. Y.MolinskyJ.2019. “Improving Housing and Neighborhood Design for the Vulnerable: Older People, Small Households, Urban Design, and Planning.” Urban Design International24:171–186.
39.
ForsythA.SalomanE.SmeadL.2017. Creating Healthy Neighborhoods: Evidence-based Planning and Design Strategies. New York: American Planning Association/Routledge.
40.
FriesJ. F.CrapoL. M.1981. Vitality and Aging. New York: Freeman.
41.
Giles-CortiB.TimperioA.BullF.PikoraT.2005. “Understanding Physical Activity Environmental Correlates: Increased Specificity for Ecological Models.” Exercise and Sports Sciences Review33 (4): 175–81.
42.
GlassT. A.BalfourJ. L.2003. “Neighborhoods, Aging, and Functional Limitations.” In Neighborhoods and Health, edited by KawachiI.BerkmanL. F.303–34. New York: Oxford University Press.
43.
HandyS.CliftonK.2007. “Planning and the Built Environment Implications for Obesity Prevention.” In the Handbook of Obesity Prevention: A Resource for Health Professionals, edited by KumanyikaS.BrownsonR., 167–88. New York: Springer.
44.
HareK.1970. “How Should We Treat Environment?” Science167 (3917): 352–55.
45.
HoflandA. C. L.DevileeJ.van KempenE.den BroederL.2017. “Resident Participation in Neighborhood Audit Tools—A Scoping Review.” European Journal of Public Health28 (1): 23–29.
46.
IwarssonS.HaakM.SlaugB.2012. “Current Developments of the Housing Enabler Methodology.” British Journal of Occupation Therapy75 (11): 517–521.
KerrJ.CarlsonJ. A.RosenbergD. E.WithersA.2012. “Identifying and Promoting Safe Walking Routes in Older Adults.” Health4:720–24.
49.
KerrJ.CarlsonJ. A.SallisJ. F.RosenbergD.LeakC. R.SaelensB. E.ChapmanJ. E.FrankL. D.KingA. C.2011. “Assessing Health-related Resources in Senior Living Residences.” Journal of Aging Studies25:206–14.
50.
KingD. K.2008. “Neighborhood and Individual Factors in Activity in Older Adults: Results from the Neighborhood and Senior Health Study.” Journal of Aging and Physical Activity16 (2): 144–170.
51.
KurkaJ. M.AdamsM. A.GeremiaC.ZhuW.CainK. L.ConwayT. L.SallisJ. F.2016. “Comparing Field and Online Observations for Measuring Land Uses Using the Microscale Audit of Pedestrian Streetscapes (MAPS).” Journal of Transport and Health3 (3): 278–86.
52.
LawtonM. P. 1980. Environment and Aging. Albany: Center for the Study of Aging.
53.
LawtonM.P. 1982. “Competence, Environmental Press, and the Adaptation of Older People.” In Aging and the Environment, edited by LawtonM.WindleyP.ByertsT., 33–59. New York: Springer.
54.
LawtonM.P.NahemowL.1973. “Ecology and the Aging Process.” In The Psychology of Adult Development and Aging, edited by EisdorferC.LawtonM., 619–74. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
55.
LawtonM. P.WeismanG. D.SloaneP.Norris-BakerC.CalkinsM.ZimmermanS. I.2000. “Professional Environmental Assessment Procedure for Special Care Units for Elders with Dementing Illness.” Alzheimer’s Disease and Associated Disorders14 (1): 28–38.
56.
LeeS.TalenE.2014. “Measuring Walkability: A Note on Auditing Methods.” Journal of Urban Design19 (3): 368–88.
57.
LehnertT.HeuchertM.HussainK.KonigH-H.2018. “Stated Preferences for Long-Term Care: A Literature Review.” Ageing & Society39 (9): 1873–1913.
58.
LienL. L.SteggellC. D.IwarssonS.2015. “Adaptive Strategies and Person-Environment Fit Among Functionally Limited Older Adults Aging in Place: A Mixed Methods Approach.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health12 (9): 11954–74.
59.
McMillanT. E.CubbinC.ParmenterB.MedinaA. V.LeeR. E.2010. “Neighborhood Sampling: How Many Streets Must an Auditor Walk?” International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity7:20. Accessed September 1, 2018. https://ijbnpa.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1479-5868-7-20.
60.
MichaelY. L.KeastE. M.ChaudhuryH.DayK.MahmoodA.SarteA. F. I.2009. “Revising the Seniors Walking Environmental Assessment Tool.” Preventive Medicine48 (3): 247–49.
MillsteinR. A.CainK. L.SallisJ. F.ConwayT. L.GeremiaC.FrankL. D.ChapmanJ.Van DyckD.DipzinskiL. R.KerrJ.GlanzK.SaelensB. E.2013. “Development, Scoring, and Reliability of the Microscale Audit of Pedestrian Streetscapes (MAPS).” BMC Public Health13:403.
63.
MoosR. H.LemkeS.1982. “The Multiphasic Environmental Assessment Procedure.” In Community Mental Health and Behavioral-Ecology, edited by JegerA. M.SlotnickR. S., 357–71. Boston, MA: Springer.
64.
NickelsonJ.WangA. R.QshequillaP. M.HendricksK.PaschalA.2013. “Inventory of the Physical Environment Domains and Subdomains Measured by Neighborhood Audit Tools: A Systematic Literature Review.” Journal of Environmental Psychology36:179–89.
65.
NyuntM. S. Z.ShuovoF. K.EngJ. Y.YapK. B.SchererS.HeeL. M., et al.2015. “Objective and Subjective Measures of Neighborhood Environment: Relationships with Transportation and Physical Activity Among Older Persons.” International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity12 (1): 108.
OswaldF.WahlH. W.2004. “Housing and Health in Later Life.” Review of Environmental Health19 (3–4): 223–52.
68.
OswaldF.WahlH.-W.SchillingO.NygrenC.FängeA.SixsmithA.SixsmithJ.SzémanZ.TomsoneS.IwarssonS.2007. “Relationships between Housing and Healthy Aging in Very Old Age.” The Gerontologist47 (1): 96–107.
69.
PikoraT.Giles-CortiB.BullF.JamrozikK.DonovanR.2003. “Developing a Framework for Assessment of the Environmental Determinants of Walking and Cycling.” Social Science Medicine56:1693–703.
70.
PliakasT.HawkesworthS.SilverwoodR. J.NanchanalK.GrundyC.ArmstrongB., et al.2017. “Optimising Measurement of Health-Related Characteristics of the Built Environment: Comparing Data Collected by Foot-Based Street Audits, Virtual Street Audits and Routine Secondary Data Sources.” Health and Place43:75–84.
71.
PoortingaW.CalveT.JonesN.LannonS.ReesT.RodgersS. E.LyonsR. A.2017. “Neighborhood Quality and Attachment: Validation of the Revised Residential Environment Assessment Tool.” Environment and Behavior49 (3): 255–82.
72.
RossoA. L.AuchinclossA. H.MichaelY. L.2011. “The Urban Built Environment and Mobility in Older Adults: A Comprehensive Review.” Journal of Aging Research2011:1–10. doi:10.4061/2011/816106
73.
RoweJ. W.KahnR. L.1998. Successful Aging. New York: Pantheon Books.
74.
RubinsteinR.de MedeirosK.2004. “Ecology and the Aging Self.” Annual Review of Gerontology and Geriatrics23:59–84.
75.
RyffC. D.1989. “Beyond Ponce de Leon and Life Satisfaction: New Directions in Quest of Successful Ageing.” International Journal of Behavioral Development12 (1): 35–55.
Schaefer-McDanielN.CaughyM. O.O’CampoP.GeareyW.2010. “Examining Methodological Details of Neighbourhood Observations and the Relationship to Health: A Literature Review.” Social Science and Medicine70 (2): 277–92.
79.
ShresthaB. P.MillonigA.HounsellN. B.McDonaldM.2017. “Review of Public Transport Needs of Older People in the European Context.” Population Ageing10:343–61.
SloaneP. D.MatthewL. J.1990. “The Therapeutic Environment Screening Scale: An Observational Screening Instrument to Assess the Quality of Nursing Home Environments for Residents with Dementia.” American Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease & Other Dementias5 (6): 22–26.
82.
SloaneP. D.MitchellC. M.WeismanG.ZimmermanS.Long FoleyK. M.LynnM.CalkinsM.LawtonM. P.TeresiJ.GrantL.LindemanD.MontgomeryR.2002. “The Therapeutic Environment Screening Survey for Nursing Homes (TESS-NH): An Observational Instrument for Assessing the Physical Environment of Institutional Settings for Persons with Dementia.” Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences57B (2): S69–78.
83.
StarkS. L.SomervilleE. K.MorrisJ. C.2010. “In Home Occupational Performance Evaluation (I-HOPE).” American Journal of Occupational Therapy64 (4): 580–89.
84.
StockolsD.1992. “Establishing and Maintaining Healthy Environments: Toward a Social Ecology of Health Promotion.” American Psychologist47 (1): 6–22.
85.
SuM.DuY.-K.LiuQ.-M.RenY.-J.KawachiI.LvJ.LiL.-M.2014. “Objective Assessment of Urban Built Environment Related to Physical Activity—Development, Reliability, and Validity of the China Urban Built Environment Scan Tool (CUBEST).” BMC Public Health14:109. Accessed January 24, 2017. http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/14/109.
Van CauwenbergJ.de GuesB.DeforcheB.2018. “Cycling for Transport Among Older Adults: Health Benefits, Prevalence, Determinants, Injuries, and the Potential of E-bikes.” In Geographies of Transport and Aging, edited by CurlA.MusselwhiteC., 133–51. Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan.
88.
WahlH. W.2001. “Environmental Influences on Aging and Behavior.” In Handbook of the Psychology of Aging, edited by BirrenJ. E.SchaieK. W., 215–37. San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
89.
WahlH. W.LangF. R.2003. “Aging in Context Across the Adult Life Course: Integrating Physical and Social Environmental Research Perspectives.” Annual Review of Gerontology and Geriatrics23:1–33.
90.
WahlH. W.WeismanG. D.2003. “Environmental Gerontology at the Beginning of the New Millennium: Reflections on its Historical, Empirical, and Theoretical Development.” The Gerontologist43 (5): 616–27.
91.
WalfordN.PhillipsJ.HockeyA.PrattS.2017. “Assessing the Needs of Older People in Urban Settings: Integration of Emotive, Physiological and Built Environment Data.” Geography and Environment4 (1): e00037. doi:10.1002/geo2.37
92.
WeichS.BurtonD.BlanchardM.PrinceM.SprostonK.ErensB.2001. “Measuring the Built Environment: Validity of a Site Survey Instrument for Use in Urban Settings.” Health Place7 (4): 283–92.
93.
WeissR. A.MaantayJ. A.FahsM.2010. “Promoting Active Urban Aging: A Measurement Approach to Neighborhood Walkability for Older Adults.” Cities Environment3 (1): 12.
94.
WilesJ.LeibingA.GubermanN.ReeveJ.AllenR. E. S.2012. “The Meaning of Aging in Place to Older People.” The Gerontologist52 (3): 357–66.
WHO (World Health Organization). 2015. World Report on Ageing and Health. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO.
98.
YenI. H.MichaelY. L.PerdueL.2009. “Neighborhood Environment in Studies of Health in Older Adults: A Systematic Review.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine37 (5): 455–63.
99.
ZeiselJ.HydeJ.LevkoffS.1994. “Best Practices: An Environment-Behavior (E-B) Model for Alzheimer Special Care Units.” The American Journal of Alzheimer’s Care and Related Disorders & Research9 (2): 4–21.
100.
ZenkS. N.SchulzA. J.MentzG.HouseJ. S.GraveleeC. C.MirandaP. Y.MillerP.KannanS.2007. “Inter-rater and Test-retest Reliability: Methods and Results for the Neighborhood Observational Checklist.” Health and Place13:452–65.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
