This article examines the concept of limited equity housing cooperatives (LECs) and their potential niche in the housing stock of the United States. The authors discuss problems related to the success of housing cooperatives, as well as policy implications and opportunities for development of LECs. The research evidence that exists shows that LECs have a strong record of providing high-quality, safe, affordable housing for low- and moderate-income populations. The authors conclude that LECs constitute a valuable, if underused, form of housing ownership with the potential to improve the quality of life for certain low- and moderate-income households and to contribute to the physical and social quality of the larger community.
Altus, Deborah. 1995. A look at student housing cooperatives [online]. http://www.ic.org/pnp/cdir/1995/32altus.html.
2.
Calhoun, Charles, and Chris Walker. 1994. Final report: Loan performance of management cooperatives. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
3.
Capone, Charles A., Jr.2001. Research into mortgage default and affordable housing: A primer. Home Ownership Summit 2001: Research Series. Congressional Budget Office. http://www.lisc.org/resources/assets/asset_upload_file755_793.pdf.
4.
Clark, Helene. 1994. Taking up space: Redefining political legitimacy in New York City. Environment and Planning26:937-955.
5.
Coleman, James S.1988. Social capital in the creation of human capital. American Journal of Sociology94:S95-S120.
6.
Cooper-Levy, Herb. 2000. Meeting affordable housing needs in the military with cooperatives. Journal of Cooperative Development2,3:4.
7.
Cooper, Matthew, and Margaret Rodman. 1992. New neighbors: A case study of cooperative housing. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
8.
DeFilippis, James. 2001. The myth of social capital in community development. Housing Policy Debate12, 4: 781-806.
9.
Eversole-Nolan, Jill, and Thomas Blaine. 2001. Rural cooperative housing for older adults: An emerging challenge for extension educators [online]. Journal of Extension39, 2. http://www.joe.org/joe/2001april/a3.html.
10.
Forslund, Elizabeth, and Carolyn Keith. 1988. Awoman’s place home ownership option. Women and EnvironmentsSpring: 18-20.
11.
Glunt, Eric K., Helene Clark, and Susan Saegert. 1995. Stabilizing the future of limited equity cooperative housing in New York City. In The hidden history of housing cooperatives, edited by Allan Heskin and Jacqueline Leavitt.Berkeley: Center for Cooperatives, University of California.
12.
Hammond-Ketilson, Lou, and Ian McPherson. 2001. Areporton Aboriginal cooperatives in Canada: Current situation and potential for growth [online]. Saskatchewan: Center for the Study of Cooperatives, University of Saskatchewan. http://www.wisc.edu/uwcc/info/fra/case.html.
13.
Helm, John, Sanford M. Horvitz, and Nefertiti Ben-Egypt. 1993. Cooperative homeownership: An affordable alternative. Journal of Housing50 (6): 238-240.
14.
Heskin, Allan. 1991. The struggle for community. Boulder, CO: Westview.
15.
Heskin, Allan. 1995. Ethnicity, race, class, and immigration in cooperatives. In The hidden history of housing cooperatives, edited by Allan Heskin and Jacqueline Leavitt.Berkeley: Center for Cooperatives, University of California.
16.
Hevesi, Alan B.1998. Audit report on the New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development’s Tenant Interim Lease Program. Comptroller of the city of New York.
17.
Joint Center for Housing Studies. 2001. The state of the nation’s housing. Cambridge MA: Harvard University.
18.
Joint Center for Housing Studies. 2002. The state of the nation’s housing. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University.
19.
Joint Center for Housing Studies. 2003. The state of the nation’s housing. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University.
20.
Kane, Richard J.1999. The financing of cooperatives and condominiums: A retrospective. St. John’s Law Review73 [database online]. Available from LEXIS-NEXIS® Academic Universe, a division of Reed Elsevier.
21.
Kane, Richard J.2001. Urban housing cooperatives—Benefits beyond the walls. Journal of Cooperative Development2 (4): 12.
22.
Leavitt, Jaqueline, and Susan Saegert. 1990. From abandonment to hope: Community-households in Harlem. New York: Columbia University Press.
23.
Levinger, George. 2001. Community land trusts owning a community land trust home: A survey report on homeowner satisfaction. Springfield, MA: Institute for Community Economics.
24.
Lewis, Terry. 1998. Limited equity cooperative housing in a senior housing setting. Journal of Cooperative Development1, 2: 4.
25.
Listokin, David, Elvin K. Wyly, Brian Schmitt, and Ioan Voicu. 2001. The potential and limitations of mortgage innovation in fostering homeownership in the United States. Housing Policy Debate12, 3: 465-513.
26.
Maldonado, Rosemarie, and Robert D. Rose. 1996. The application of civil rights laws to housing cooperatives: Are co-ops bastions of discriminatory exclusion or self-selecting models of community-based living?Fordham Urban Law Journal23 [database online]. Available from LEXIS-NEXIS® Academic Universe, a division of Reed Elsevier.
27.
Massey, Douglas S., and Nancy A. Denton. 1993. American apartheid: Segregation and the making of the underclass. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Miceli, Thomas J., Gerald Sazama, and C. F. Sirmans. 1994. The role of limited equity cooperatives in providing affordable housing. Housing Policy Debate5, 4: 469-490.
30.
Moss, Michael, and Andrew Jacobs. 2004. Blue skies and green yards, all lost to red ink. New York Times, April 11, 1.
31.
Mushrush, Paula, Mark A. Larson, and Jerry D. Krause. 1997. Social benefits of affordable housing cooperatives. Davis: Center for Cooperatives, University of California.
32.
Orlebeke, Charles J.2000. The evolution of low-income housing policy, 1949 to 1999. Housing Policy Debate11, 2: 489-520.
33.
Quercia, Roberto B., William M. Rohe, and Diane K. Levy. 2000. Anew look at creative finance. Housing Policy Debate11, 4: 943-972.
34.
Rae, Ruth. 1997. Ownership and equity: Perceptions of ownership by low-income owners of limited equity co-operative housing. PhD diss., City University of New York Graduate Center.
35.
Reynolds, Ann, and Hugh Jeffers. 1999. An assessment of loan regulations for rural housing cooperatives. Research conducted for the United States Department of Agriculture Rural Business-Cooperative Service. Madison: University of Wisconsin Center for Cooperatives.
36.
Rodman, Margaret, and Matthew Cooper. 1995. Accessibility as a discourse of space in Canadian housing cooperatives. American Ethnologist22, 3: 589-601.
37.
Rohe, William M.1995. Converting public housing to cooperatives: The experience of three developments. Housing Policy Debate6, 2: 439-479.
38.
Rohe, William M., George McCarthy, and Shannon Van Zandt. 2000. The social benefits and costs of homeownership: A critical assessment of the research [online]. Working Paper No. 00-01. Washington, DC: Research Institute for Housing America 2000. http://www.housingamerica.org/pub/html.
39.
Rohe, William M., and Leslie S. Stewart. 1996. Home ownership and neighborhood stability. Housing Policy Debate7, 1: 37-82.
40.
Saegert, Susan1989. Unlikely leaders, extreme circumstances: Older black women building community households. American Journal of Community Psychology17, 3: 295-316.
41.
Saegert, Susan. 1993. Survey of residents of currently and previously city-owned buildings in the Bronx. In Housing in the balance: Seeking a comprehensive policy for city-owned housing, edited by M. Cotton.New York: Task Force on City Owned Housing.
42.
Saegert, Susan. 1996. What we have to work with: The lessons of the Task Force surveys. In No more housing of last resort: The importance of affordability and resident participation in rem housing, edited by M. Cotton.New York: Task Force on City Owned Property.
43.
Saegert, Susan, and Gary Winkel. 1996. Paths to community empowerment: Organizing at home. American Journal of Community Psychology24, 4: 517-550.
44.
Saegert, Susan, and Gary Winkel. 1998. Social capital and the revitalization of New York City’s distressed inner-city housing. Housing Policy Debate9 (1): 17-60.
45.
Saegert, Susan, and Gary Winkel. 2000. Co-ops are acting as an alternative to abandonment and displacement in New York City. Journal of Cooperative Development2 (3): 10-11.
46.
Saegert, Susan, and Heléne Clark. Forthcoming. Women and housing. In Housing: Foundation of a new social agenda, edited by R. Bratt, C. Hartman, and M. Stone.Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
47.
Saegert, Susan, Efrat Eizenberg, Melissa Extein, Tsai-Shiou Hsieh, Lymari Benítez, and Chung Chang. 2003. Limited equity co-ops as bulwarks against gentrification. Paper presented at the 2003conference of the Urban Affairs Association, March 28, Cleveland, OH.
48.
Saegert, Susan, Gary Winkel, and Charles Swartz. 2002. Social capital and crime in New York City’s low-income housing. Housing Policy Debate13 (1): 189-226.
49.
Sazama, Gerald, and Roger Willcox. 1995. An evaluation of limited equity housing cooperatives in the United States. Paper funded by a grant from the University of Connecticut Center for Real Estate and Urban Economic Studies. http://www.econ.uconn.edu/working/1995-02.pdf.
50.
Siegler, Richard, and Herbert J. Levy. 1986. Brief history of cooperative housing. Cooperative Housing Journal of the National Association of Housing Cooperatives, 12-20.
51.
Simmons, Patrick A.1997. Housing statistics of the United States: First edition. Lanham, MD: Bernan.
52.
Turner, Margery A.1998. Moving out of poverty: Expanding mobility and choice through tenant-based housing assistance. Housing Policy Debate9, 2: 373-394.
53.
Van Ryzin, Greg. 1991. The social consequences of self-management in a mutual housing association for older people. Dissertation submitted to the Graduate Faculty of Psychology, City University of New York.
54.
Van Ryzin, Greg. 1994. Residents’ sense of control and ownership in a mutual housing association. Journal of Urban Affairs16 (3): 241-253.
55.
Weicher, John. 2001. Edited remarks to the home ownership summit, 2001: Keeping the American dream alive, pp. 22-23. Washington, DC: Local Initiatives Support Corporation Center for Home Ownership, Neighborhood Reinvestment Corporation and the Neighborhood Works Campaign for Home Ownership 2002, National Cooperative Bank, NCB Development Corporation.
56.
Wray, Ken. 1998. Helping low-income NYC seniors through limited equity co-ops. Journal of Cooperative Development1 (2): 11.
