Primary health care nurse practitioners (PHCNPs) can play a key role in chronic disease management. However, little is known about the challenges they face.
Purpose
The study aimed to describe PHCNPs’ perspectives on their role for patients with chronic health conditions, the barriers they face, and facilitating factors.
Methods
A qualitative descriptive exploratory study was conducted with 24 PHCNPs in the Canadian province of Quebec.
Results
PHCNPs believe that they are in an optimal position to address the needs of patients with chronic health conditions, especially in providing self-management support. However, PHCNPs reported feeling pressured to practice according to a biomedical model and to constantly defend their role in chronic disease management. They feel that they are frequently being diverted from their role to compensate for the lack of family doctors. PHCNPs made concrete recommendations to optimize their autonomous practice and quality of care: promoting strong interprofessional communication skills, genuine mentoring relationships between PHCNPs and partner physicians, managers upholding the full scope of PHCNPs’ practice, and a more flexible legislative framework.
Conclusions
The original conception of PHCNPs as health professionals with unique characteristics is at stake. The factors that should be targeted to support the autonomy of PHCNPs were identified.
AlmostJ.Spence LaschingerH. K. (2002).
Workplace empowerment, collaborative work relationships, and job strain in nurse practitioners. Journal of the American Association of Nurse Practitioners,
14(9), 408–420.
2.
AndersonH. (2017). Professional identity and the advanced nurse practitioner in primary care: A qualitative study. (Master thesis). University of York, Heslington, England.
3.
AndregårdA. C.JanglandE. (2015).
The tortuous journey of introducing the nurse practitioner as a new member of the healthcare team: A meta‐synthesis. Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences,
29(1), 3–14.
4.
BahadoriA.FitzpatrickJ. J. (2009).
Level of autonomy of primary care nurse practitioners. Journal of the American Academy of Nurse Practitioners,
21(9), 513–519.
5.
BodenheimerT.BauerL. (2016).
Rethinking the primary care workforce—an expanded role for nurses. New England Journal of Medicine,
375(11), 1015–1017.
6.
CarryerJ.YarwoodJ. (2015).
The nurse practitioner role: Solution or servant in improving primary health care service delivery. Collegian,
22(2), 169–174.
7.
ChanH. (2017). An underutilized resource: Investigating the role implementation of nurse practitioners in BC’s primary care system (Master’s thesis). Simon Fraser University, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
8.
ChouinardV. (2015). Le soutien au développement de la pratique des infirmières praticiennes spécialisées de première ligne au Québec [Support for the development of primary health care nurse practitioners in Quebec] (Master’s thesis), Université de Montréal, Montréal, Québec, Canada.
9.
ChouinardV.ContandriopoulosD.PerrouxM.LaroucheC. (2017).
Supporting nurse practitioners’ practice in primary healthcare settings: A three-level qualitative model. BMC Health Services Research,
17(1), 437–445.
10.
ContandriopoulosD.BrousselleA.DuboisC.-A.PerrouxM.BeaulieuM.-D.BraultI., … Sansgter-GormleyE. (2015).
A process-based framework to guide nurse practitioners integration into primary healthcare teams: Results from a logic analysis. BMC Health Services Research,
15(1), 78–88.
11.
DahrougeS.MuldoonL.WardN.HoggW.RussellG.Taylor-SussexR. (2014).
Roles of nurse practitioners and family physicians in community health centres. Canadian Family Physician,
60(11), 1020–1027.
12.
DelamaireM.-L.LafortuneG. (2010). Nurses in advanced roles: A description and evaluation of experiences in 12 developed countries (Vol. 54).
Paris, France:
OECD.
13.
DiCensoA.MatthewsS. (2007). Report of the nurse practitioner integration task team submitted to the Ontario minister of health and long-term care.
Toronto, Canada:
Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care.
14.
DiCicco-BloomB.CunninghamR. S. (2015).
Complex patients and interprofessional relationships: Perceptions of primary care nurse practitioners and primary care physicians. Journal of the American Association of Nurse Practitioners,
27(11), 646–652.
15.
HeitzL. J.SteinerS. H.BurmanM. E. (2004).
RN to FNP: A qualitative study of role transition. Journal of Nursing Education,
43(9), 416–420.
16.
HorrocksS.AndersonE.SalisburyC. (2002).
Systematic review of whether nurse practitioners working in primary care can provide equivalent care to doctors. British Medical Journal,
324(7341), 819–823.
17.
HudonC.ChouinardM.-C.DuboisM.-F.RobergeP.LoignonC.TchouaketÉ., … BoulianeD. (2018).
Case management in primary care for frequent users of health care services: A mixed methods Study. The Annals of Family Medicine,
16(3), 232–239.
18.
KrausE.DuBoisJ. M. (2017).
Knowing your limits: A qualitative study of physician and nurse practitioner perspectives on NP independence in primary care. Journal of General Internal Medicine,
32(3), 284–290.
19.
LaurantM.van der BiezenM.WijersN.WatananirunK.KontopantelisE.van VughtA. J. (2018).
Nurses as substitutes for doctors in primary care. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews,
7, CD001271.
20.
LevesqueJ.-F.FeldmanD.DufresneC.BergeronP.PinardB. (2007). L’implantation d’un modèle intégré de prévention et de gestion des maladies chroniques au Québec: Barrières et éléments facilitant. The implementation of an integrated model for chronic disease prevention and management in Quebec: Barriers and facilitators (unofficial translation)
Montreal, Canada:
Institut national de santé publique du Québec.
21.
LindbladE.HallmanE. B.GillsjoC.LindbladU.FagerstromL. (2010).
Experiences of the new role of advanced practice nurses in Swedish primary health care: A qualitative study. International Journal of Nursing Practice,
16(1), 69–74.
22.
LiuN.FinkelsteinS. R.PoghosyanL. (2014).
A new model for nurse practitioner utilization in primary care: Increased efficiency and implications. Health Care Management Review,
39(1), 10–20.
23.
MacLellanL.HigginsI.Levett‐JonesT. (2015).
Medical acceptance of the nurse practitioner role in Australia: A decade on. Journal of the American Association of Nurse Practitioners,
27(3), 152–159.
24.
MaierC. B. (2015).
The role of governance in implementing task-shifting from physicians to nurses in advanced roles in Europe, US, Canada, New Zealand and Australia. Health Policy,
119(12), 1627–1635.
25.
MaierC. B.AikenL. H.BusseR. (2017). Nurses in advanced roles in primary care (Vol. 98).
Paris, France:
OECD Health Working Papers.
26.
MarsdenJ.StreetC. (2004).
A primary health care team’s views of the nurse practitioner role in primary care. Primary Health Care Research & Development,
5(1), 17–27.
27.
Martin-MisenerR.HarbmanP.DonaldF.ReidK.KilpatrickK.CarterN., … Charbonneau-SmithR. (2015).
Cost-effectiveness of nurse practitioners in primary and specialised ambulatory care: Systematic review. British Medical Journal,
5(6), 1–14.
28.
Martin-MisenerR.KilpatrickK.DonaldF.Bryant-LukosiusD.RaynerJ.ValaitisR., … LambA. (2016).
Nurse practitioner caseload in primary health care: Scoping review. International Journal of Nursing Studies,
62, 170–182.
29.
Martin-MisenerR.ReillyS. M.VollmanA. R. (2010).
Defining the role of primary health care nurse practitioners in rural Nova Scotia. Canadian Journal of Nursing Research,
42(2), 30–47.
MorganD. (1997). Focus groups as qualitative research. Qualitative Research Methods Series (Vol. 16).
Thousand Oaks, CA:
Sage.
32.
NiezenM. G.MathijssenJ. J. (2014).
Reframing professional boundaries in healthcare: A systematic review of facilitators and barriers to task reallocation from the domain of medicine to the nursing domain. Health Policy,
117(2), 151–169.
33.
OffredyM.TownsendJ. (2000).
Nurse practitioners in primary care. Family Practice,
17(6), 564–569.
34.
Ordre des Infirmières et Infirmiers du Québec. (2017). Rapport statistique sur l’effectif infirmier 2016–2017. Statistical report on the nursing workforce 2016–2017 (unofficial translation)
Montréal, Canada:
Author. OIIQ.
35.
Ordre des Infirmières et Infirmiers du Québec. (2019). Age, gender and working location of primary health care nurse practitioners in Québec—Unpublished work.
Montréal, Canada:
Author.
36.
Ordre des infirmières et infirmiers du Québec et Conseil des médecins du Québec. (2018). Pratique clinique de l’infirmière praticienne spécialisée en soins de première ligne: Lignes directrices. Clinical practice of the primary health care nurse practitioner: Guidelines (unofficial translation)
Montréal, Canada:
Author OIIQ.
37.
Paré-PlanteA.-A.BoivinA.BerbicheD.BretonM.GuayM. (2018).
Primary health care organizational characteristics associated with better accessibility: Data from the QUALICO-PC survey in Quebec. BMC Family Practice,
19(1), 188.
38.
Pelletier, J., Vermette, S., Lauzier, S., Bujold, M., Bujold, L., Martin, É., & Guillaumie, L. (2019). Challenges faced by Canadian primary health care nurse practitioners in chronic disease management: A qualitative study among key informants. Journal of the American Association of Nurse Practitioners, 31(5), 300–308.
39.
PoghosyanL.NanniniA.SmaldoneA.ClarkeS.O’RourkeN. C.RosatoB. G.BerkowitzB. (2013).
Revisiting scope of practice facilitators and barriers for primary care nurse practitioners: A qualitative investigation. Policy, Politics, & Nursing Practice,
14(1), 6–15.
40.
PoghosyanL.NanniniA.StoneP. W.SmaldoneA. (2013).
Nurse practitioner organizational climate in primary care settings: Implications for professional practice. Journal of Professional Nursing,
29(6), 338–349.
41.
PoghosyanL.NorfulA. A.MartsolfG. R. (2017).
Primary care nurse practitioner practice characteristics: Barriers and opportunities for interprofessional teamwork. Journal of Ambulatory Care Management,
40(1), 77–86.
42.
PoitrasM. E.ChouinardM.-C.GallagherF.FortinM. (2018).
Nursing activities for patients with chronic disease in primary care settings: A practice analysis. Nursing Research,
67(1), 35–42.
43.
PoitrasM. E.ChouinardM. C.FortinM.GirardA.CrossmanS.GallagherF. (2018).
Nursing activities for patients with chronic disease in family medicine groups: A multiple‐case study. Nursing Inquiry,
25(4), e12250.
44.
Public Health Agency of Canada. (2014). Economic burden of illness in Canada, 2005–2008.
Ottawa, Canada:
Author.
45.
Sangster-GormleyE. (2015).
Interprofessional collaboration: Co-workers’ perceptions of adding nurse practitioners to primary care teams. Quality in Primary Care,
23(3), 122–126.
46.
SargentL.OlmedoM. (2013).
Meeting the needs of new-graduate nurse practitioners: A model to support transition. Journal of Nursing Administration,
43(11), 603–610.
47.
SchadewaldtV.McInnesE.HillerJ. E.GardnerA. (2013).
Views and experiences of nurse practitioners and medical practitioners with collaborative practice in primary health care: An integrative review. BMC Family Practice,
14, 132–142.
48.
Stanik-HuttJ.NewhouseR. P.WhiteK. M.JohantgenM.BassE. B.ZangaroG., … HeindelL. (2013).
The quality and effectiveness of care provided by nurse practitioners. Journal for Nurse Practitioner,
9(8), 492–500.
49.
Sullivan-BentzM.HumbertJ.CraggB.LegaultF.LaflammeC.BaileyP.DoucetteS. (2010).
Supporting primary health care nurse practitioners’ transition to practice. Canadian Family Physician,
56(11), 1176–1182.
50.
Tracy, M.F., & O’Grady, E.T. (2018). Hamric and Hanson’s Advanced Practice Nursing: An Integrative Approach. Elsevier Health Sciences.
51.
WagnerE. H.GlasgowR. E.DavisC.BonomiA. E.ProvostL.McCullochD., … SixtaC. (2001).
Quality improvement in chronic illness care: A collaborative approach. Joint Commission Journal on Quality Improvement,
27(2), 63–80.
52.
ZapatkaS. A.ConeliusJ.EdwardsJ.MeyerE.BrienzaR. (2014).
Pioneering a primary care adult nurse practitioner interprofessional fellowship. Journal of Nurse Practitioner,
10(6), 378–386.
