No smoke without fire: Public health,morality,and the civilized self

Abstract

The implementation of the smoking ban in Ireland has been championed as one of the major achievements of public health policy. Studies on the smoking ban have predominantly been undertaken from a public health perspective and have pointed out the associated health benefits of the ban, especially in terms of the reduction of second-hand smoking. While the rationale for the smoking ban was founded on health and medical reasons, this paper contends that going beyond health concerns, a collective process which drew upon notions of progress, purity and order was central to the introduction and successful implementation of the smoking ban. The relevance of discourses around the “civilized self” in tobacco control is also discussed in the context of recent debates over the use and regulation of electronic cigarettes in public spaces.

Keywords

Civilized self e-cigarettes governmentality smoking ban

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allwright

Paul

Greiner

(2005) Legislation for smoke-free workplaces and health of bar workers in Ireland: Before and after study. British Medical Journal 331: 1083–1152.

Armstrong J (2003) Smoking ban. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 3 March.

ASH Ireland (2003) ASH Ireland supports workplace ban. Press release, 30 January. Available at: http://www.ash.ie/News/Archived_News_2003/Workplace_Ban.html (accessed 1 July 2013).

Barrington B (2003) Plan to ban smoking in pubs. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 15 October.

Bell K (2011) Legislating abjection? Secondhand smoke, tobacco control policy and the public's health. Critical Public Health 21: 49–62.

Bell K (2014) Science, policy and the rise of “thirdhand smoke” as a public health issue. Health, Risk and Society 16: 154–170.

Bell K and Dennis S (2013) Editorial. Towards a critical anthropology of smoking: Exploring consequences of tobacco control. Contemporary Drug Problems 40: 3–19.

Bell K and Keane H (2012) Nicotine control: E-cigarettes, smoking and addiction. International Journal of Drug Policy 23: 242–247.

Bell K, McCullough L, Salmon A, et al. (2010) “Every space is claimed”: Smokers' experiences of tobacco denormalisation. Sociology of Health and Illness 32: 914–929.

10.

Berridge

(1998) Science and policy: The case of post-war British smoking policy. In: Lock

Reynolds

Tansey

(eds) Ashes to Ashes: The History of Smoking and Health, Amsterdam: Rodopi, pp. 143–162.

11.

Berridge

(1999) Passive smoking and its pre-history in Britain: Policy speaks to science? Social Science and Medicine 49: 1183–1195.

12.

Binkley

Dolan

Ernst

(2010) Of discipline and civilization: A roundatable discussion on the legacies of Norbert Elias and Michel Foucault. Foucault Studies 8: 53–77.

13.

Boers M (2004) Impending ban on smoking. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 24 March.

14.

Brandt AM (1998) Blow some my way: Passive smoking, risk and American culture. In: Lock S, Reynolds LA and Tansy EM (eds) Ashes to Ashes: The History of Smoking and Health. Amsterdam: Rodopi, pp. 164–191.

15.

Burke NM (2003) Plan to ban smoking in pubs. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 20 February.

16.

Clancy L (2004) Smoking ban can be health initiative of the century. Luke Clancy, Chairperson of ASH Ireland, Press release, 18 February. Available at: http://www.ash.ie/News/Archived_News_2004/Century.html (accessed 1 July 2013).

17.

Coghlan V (2003) Ban on smoking in pubs. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 5 August.

18.

Connolly

Carpenter

Travers

(2009) How smoke-free laws improve air quality: A global study of Irish pubs. Nicotine and Tobacco Research 11: 600–605.

19.

Corrigan

(2004) Marlboro man and the stigma of smoking. In: Gilman

Tun

(eds) Smoke: A Global History of Smoking, London: Reaktion Books, pp. 344–354.

20.

Coyne Research (2015) Irish Cancer Society E-Cigarette Research. Presented to the Irish Cancer Society on March 2015. Available at: http://www.cancer.ie/sites/default/files/content-attachments/e-cigarette_research_report_2015.pdf (accessed 1 June 2015).

21.

Curtis

(2007) Dirt, disgust and disease: A natural history of hygiene. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 61: 660–664.

22.

Davies H (2003) Banning smoking. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 1 February.

23.

Daykin

(1993) Young women and smoking: Towards a sociological account. Health Promotion International 8: 95–102.

24.

de Regt A (2015) Beschavingsoffensief (civilising offensive): from sociological concept to moral appeal. Civilising Offensives 4(1). http://hdl.handle.net/2027/spo.11217607.0004.103.

25.

Dean

(1995) Governing the unemployed self in an active society. Economy and Society 24: 559–583.

26.

Dignam T (2004) Impending ban on smoking in pubs. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 1 March.

27.

Doyle PD (2004) Ban on smoking in pubs. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 5 January.

28.

Drakeford M (2014) Mark Drakeford says e-cigarettes are “re-normalising” smoking. BBC News Wales, 2 February. Available at: http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-wales-26008450?prin=true (accessed 20 September 2014).

29.

Elias

(1978) The Civilizing Process: The History of Manners, Oxford: Blackwell.

30.

Fong

Hyland

Borland

(2006) Reductions in tobacco smoke pollution and increases in support for smoke-free public places following the implementation of comprehensive smoke-free workplace legislation in the Republic of Ireland: Findings from the ITC Ireland/UK Survey. Tobacco Control 15: 51–58.

31.

Foucault M (1988) Technologies of the Self. In: Martin LH, Gutman H and Hutton PH (eds) Technologies of the Self: A Seminar with Michel Foucault. London: Tavistock, pp. 3–8.

32.

Foucault M (1994) Dits et écris IV. Paris: Gallimard.

33.

Gilmore

(2005) Clearing the Air: The Battle over the Smoking Ban, Dublin: Liberties.

34.

Gordon

(1991) Governmental rationality: An introduction. In: Burchell

Gordon

Miller

(eds) The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmental Rationality, Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf, pp. 1–51.

35.

Goudsblom

(1986) Public health and the civilizing process. The Milbank Quarterly 64: 162–188.

36.

Graham

(1987) Women’s smoking and family health. Social Science and Medicine 25: 47–56.

37.

Graham

(1993) When Life's a Drag: Women, Smoking and Disadvantage, London: HMSO.

38.

Hennessy M (2003) FF TDs put pressure on Martin over ban on pub smoking. The Irish Times, 29 March.

39.

Holahan A (2003) Plan to ban smoking in pubs. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 17 February.

40.

Howell

(2005) Smoke-free bars in Ireland: A runaway success. Tobacco Control 14: 73–74.

41.

Hughes

(2003) Learning to Smoke: Tobacco Use in the West, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

42.

Hughes

(2014) E-cigarettes and the “civilising” of smoking. Cambio IV: 169–181.

43.

Irish Cancer Society (2014) E-cigarettes. Available at: http://www.cancer.ie/reduce-your-risk/smoking/electronic-cigarettes (accessed 20 October 2014).

44.

Irish Heart Foundation (2014) Position on electronic/E-cigarettes. Available at: http://www.irishheart.ie/iopen24/ecigarettes-t-38_1320_1408.html (accessed 20 October 2014).

45.

Jäger

Maier

(2009) Theoretical and methodological aspects of Foucauldian critical discourse analysis and dispositive analysis. In: Wodak

Meyer

(eds) Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis, London: Sage, pp. 34–61.

46.

Jordan D (2003) FF division over smoking ban. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 13 August.

47.

Jones

(1986) Social Hygiene in Twentieth Century Britain, Beckenham: Croom Helm.

48.

Kelly D (2003) Plan to ban smoking in pubs. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 16 July.

49.

King A (2014) Are e-cigarettes the answer? The Irish Times, 4 June 2014.

50.

Kitching

(2013) Governing “authentic” religiosity? The responsibilization of parents beyond religion and state in matters of school ethos in Ireland. Irish Journal of Sociology 21: 17–34.

51.

Klein

(1993) Cigarettes are Sublime, Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

52.

Kuzmics K (1988) The civilizing process. In: Keane J (ed.) Civil Society and the State: New European Perspectives. London: Verso.

53.

Kuhling

(2004) The smoking ban in Ireland: Smoke-free or smokescreen? Capital and Class 28: 211–216.

54.

Lupton

(1995) The Imperative of Health: Public Health and the Regulated Body, London: Sage.

55.

Lupton

Petersen

(1996) The New Public Health: Discourses, Knowledges, Strategies, London: Sage.

56.

McCarthy H (2003) “Political correctness” and the proposed smoking ban. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 26 September.

57.

Martin M (2003a) Speech by Micheal Martin at the launch of the Report on the Health Effects of Environmental Tobacco Smoke in the Workplace, 30 January. Available at: http://www.dohc.ie/press/speeches/2003/20030130.html (accessed 2 July 2013).

58.

Martin M (2003b) Speech at the opening of the Smokers – Attitudes, Behaviours and Cessation, seminar organized by the OTC, 4 March. Available at: http://www.dohc.ie/press/speeches/2003/20030304.html (accessed 2 July 2013).

59.

Martin M (2004a) Speech at the announcement of the commencement date for the smoke-free workplace regulations, 18 February. Available at: http://www.dohc.ie/press/speeches/2004/20040218.html (accessed 2 July 2013).

60.

Martin M (2004b) Minister Martin attends the launch of an information campaign prior to the commencement of Smoke Free legislation in Norway, Press Release, 25 May. Available at: http://www.dohc.ie/press/releases/2004/20040525.html (accessed 2 July 2013).

61.

Miller WI (1997) The Anatomy of Disgust. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

62.

Mulcahy M, Evans DS, Hammond SK, et al. (2005) Secondhand smoke exposure and risk following the Irish smoking ban: an assessment of salivary cotinine concentrations in hotel workers and air nicotine levels in bars. Tobacco Control 14(6): 384–388.

63.

Mullally

Greiner

Allwright

(2009) The effect of the Irish smoke-free workplace legislation on smoking among bar workers. European Journal of Public Health 19: 206–211.

64.

Nussbaum M (2004) Hiding from humanity disgust, shame, and the law. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

65.

O’Brien C and Duffy C (2003) Concern growing in FF over ban on smoking in workplace. The Irish Times, 12 August.

66.

O’Brien PJ (2004) Deasy in the Dáil bar. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 7 April.

67.

O’Donnell S (2004) Banning smoking in pubs. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 14 July.

68.

Ó Fátharta C (2014) Time to clear the air over use of e-cigarettes. Irish Examiner, 18 March.

69.

Poland

(1998) Smoking, stigma and the purification of public space. In: Kearns

Gesler

(eds) Putting Health into Place: Landscape, Identity and Well-being, New York: Syracuse University Press, pp. 208–225.

70.

Poland

Sotckton

Ashley

(1999) Interactions between smokers and non-smokers in public places: A qualitative study. Canadian Journal of Public Health 90: 330–333.

71.

Poland

(2000) The “considerate” smoker in public space: The micro-politics and political economy of “doing the right thing”. Health and Place 6: 1–14.

72.

Pursell

Allwright

O’Donovan

(2007) Before and after study of bar workers’ perceptions of the impact of smoke-free workplace legislation in the Republic of Ireland. BMC Public Health 29: 1–13.

73.

Reilly J (2014) 10th Anniversary of the Workplace Smoking Ban in Ireland – Statement by Dr. James Reilly TD, Minister for Health, Media release of the Department of Health, 24 March. Available at: http://www.dohc.ie/press/releases/2014/20140324.html (accessed 19 September 2014).

74.

Rooke

(2013) Harm reduction and the medicalisation of tobacco use. Sociology of Health and Illness 35: 361–376.

75.

RTÉ News (2014) HSE to ban sale and use of e-cigarettes in all health service facilities from 1 May. 24 April. Available at: http://www.rte.ie/news/2014/0424/610589-e-cigarettes/ (accessed 19 September 2014).

76.

Russell C (2014) E-cigarettes banned from DART and train services. Published by the journal, 11 March. Available at: http://news.ie.msn.com/ireland/e-cigarettes-banned-from-dart-and-train-services (accessed 19 September 2014).

77.

Tan

(2013) Smell in the city: Smoking and olfactory politics. Urban Studies 50: 55–71.

78.

The Irish Examiner (2003) Smoking ban survey. 24 July.

79.

Tuggle

Holmes

(2003) Blowing smoke: Status politics and the Shasta county smoking ban. In: Kelly

Clarke

(eds) Deviant Behaviours: A Text Reader in the Sociology of Deviance, New York: Worth Publishers, pp. 43–56.

80.

Satchell G (2013) Electronic cigarettes: Miracle or menace? BBC News, 11 February. Available at: http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-21406540 (accessed 19 September 2014).

81.

Sears

(1991) AIDS and the health of nations: The contradictions of public health. Critical Sociology 18: 31–50.

82.

Shanahan C (2004) Byrne rules out EU challenge to smoking ban. Irish Examiner, 26 February.

83.

Stallings-Smith

Zeka

Goodman

(2013) Reductions in cardiovascular, cerebrovascular and respiratory mortality following the national Irish smoking ban: Interrupted time-series analysis. PLoS ONE 8: e62063.

84.

Welshman

(2004) Smoking, science and medicine. In: Gilman Sander

Tun

(eds) Smoke: A Global History of Smoking, London: Reaktion Books, pp. 326–331.

85.

Woods B (2003) Smoking ban in pubs. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 26 July.

86.

Zdenkowski A (2004) Bouquet for the smoking ban. Letter to the Editor, The Irish Times, 18 August.