Election Poli Methodology and the 2007 French Presidential Elections - Chronicle of a Recurring Problem: The 2002 presidential élection polls will be remembered for a long time because their error in predictions had dramatic consequences. What influence did those elections have on French opinion poli research and was it able to revise its methods? Was it able to improve its voting estimates? Research has shown that French polis are now more able to distinguish between voting for the left and the right than in 2002. However, French polls have not improved their capability to estimate intentions to vote for major candidates. The discrepancies between means for twelve polis published during the last week before voting vary from 1.8 points for Royal to 3.2 points for Sarkozy and 3.8 points for Le Pen. These results show that the estimation error for Le Pen is the same in 2007 as in 2002, but in the opposite direction. As in 2002, samples were biased concerning level of education - strong under-representation of the less educated - as well as for voting profile - strong non-declaration of voting for Le Pen. One can thus conclude that the problem of estimating the extreme right vote remains in its entirety and that polling institute methods have not changed greatly. Cooperation between the institutes and researchers should permit further explanations and possible solutions.
Bachelet, Daniel ( 2007), "Propositions de nouvelles méthodes pour estimer les intentions de vote : Application au duel Le Pen - Jospin dans le premier tour de l'élection présidentielle de 2002", Revue française du marketing, février2007, 11-30.
2.
Blais, André ( 2004), "Y a-t-il un vote stratégique en France ?", dans Bruno Cautrès et Nonna Mayer (sous la direction de), Le nouveau désordre électoral: les leçons du 21 avril 2002, Paris : Presses de Sciences Po.
3.
Cautrès, Bruno et Nonna Mayer ( 2004), Le nouveau désordre électoral : les leçons du 21 avril 2002, Paris : Presses de Sciences Po.
4.
Commission des sondages (2002), Rapport annuel 2002, http://www.commission-des-sondages.fr/
5.
Curtice, John and Nick Sparrow, (1997), "How Accurate Are Traditional Quota Opinion Polls? ", Journal of the Market Research Society, 39, 433-448.
6.
Durand, Claire ( 2007a), "French Polls and the Aftermath of 2002", Wapor Newsletter, 2nd quarter, 2007.
7.
Durand, Claire ( 2007b), La méthodologie des sondages préélectoraux français, a-t-elle changé ?, présenté au Colloque francophone sur les sondages, Marseille, France, 5 novembre 2007, disponible sur http://www.mapageweb.umontreal.ca/durandc/
8.
Durand, Claire (soumis), The Polls of the 2007 French Presidential Campaign: Were Lessons Learned from the 2002 Catastrophe?, 29-page manuscript.
9.
Durand, Claire, André Blais and Mylène Larochelle ( 2005); "The Polls of the French Presidential Election: An Autopsy" , Public Opinion Quarterly, 68 (4) 602-22.
10.
Durand, Claire, André Blais et Mylène Larochelle ( 2004), "Sondages et estimation du vote: une analyse de l'élection présidentielle française de 2002", dans Ardilly, P. (sous la direction de), Échantillonnage et méthodes d'enquêtes , Dunod Editeur, Paris, 313-320.
11.
Durand, Claire, André Blais and Sébastien Vachon. (2001), "A Late Campaign Swing of the Failure of Polls: The Case of the 1998 Quebec Election", Public Opinion Quarterly, 65 (1) 108-23.
12.
Jowell, Roger, Barry Hedges, Peter Lynn, Graham Farrant, and Anthony Heath ( 1993), "The 1992 British Election: The Failure of the Polls ", Public Opinion Quarterly, 57 (2) 238-63.
13.
Lau, Richard R. ( 1994), "An Analysis of the Accuracy of 'Trial Heat' Polls During The 1992 Presidential Election", Public Opinion Quarterly , 58, 2-20.
14.
Le Hingue, Patrick ( 2003), "L'objectivation statistique des électorats : que savons-nous des électeurs du Front National ?", in Jacques Lagroye (sous la direction de), La politisation, Paris, Belin, 147-278.
15.
Mayer, Nonna ( 2002), Ces Français qui votent Le Pen, Paris, Flammarion.
16.
McElroy, Gail and Michael Marsh, (2003), "Why the Opinion Polls Got it Wrong in 2002", in Michael Gallagher, Michael Marsh and Paul Mitchell (editors), How Ireland Voted 2002, London, Palgrave, 159-176.
17.
Mitofsky, Warren J. ( 1998), "The Polls - Review: Was 1996 a Worse Year for Polls than 1948?", Public Opinion Quarterly, 62 (2) 230-49.
18.
Perrineau, Pascal et Colette Ysmal (sous la direction de) (2003), Le vote de tous les refus: les élections présidentielles et législatives d'avril-mai , Paris, Presses de Sciences Po .
19.
Taylor, Humphrey ( 1995), "Horses for Courses: How Survey Firms in Different Countries Measure Public Opinion with Different Methods", Journal of the Market Research society, 37 (3) 211-219.
20.
Traugott, Michael W. ( 2001), "Assessing Poli Performance in the 2000 Campaign ", Public Opinion Quarterly, 65 (3) 389-419.
21.
Traugott, Michael W. ( 2005), "The Accuracy of the National Preelection Polls in the 2004 Presidential Election", Public Opinion Quarterly , 69 (5) 642-654.
