The potential for error in survey responses obtained from people involved with environmental personal injury litigation was examined in a registry of persons exposed to the chemical trichloroethylene. Two subgroups were selected and compared: environmental personal injury plaintiffs and nonlitigants residing in the same community. Self-reported information on demographic characteristics revealed no statistically significant differences. Although plaintiffs reported higher rates of symptoms and health problems, only 2 of the 20 comparisons on health were statistically significant. The overall similarity between the two groups suggests that environmental personal injury plaintiffs may be no more likely than nonlitigants to provide inaccurate information in health surveys.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Agency For Toxic Substances And Disease Registry (Atsdr) (1994). Division of Health Studies. National Exposure Registry Trichloroethylene (TCE) Subregistry Baseline Report (Revised). Atlanta, GA.
2.
Belli, M.M. (1982). Modem Trials. 2nd ed. West Publishing Co., St. Paul, MN.
3.
Bishop, G.F. (1990). "Issue involvement and response effects in public opinion surveys." Publ. Opinion Q.54:209-218.
4.
Bradburn, N.M., Rips, L.J., and Shevell, S.K. (1987). "Answering autobiographical questions: the impact of memory and inference on surveys." Science236:157-161.
5.
Bradway, J.S. (1958). The History of a Lawsuit. Duke University Press, Durham, NC.
6.
Colditz, G.A., Martin, P., and Stampfer, M.J. (1986). "Validation of questionnaire information on risk factors and disease outcomes in a prospective cohort study of women." Am. J. Epidem.123:894-900.
7.
Collins, D.L., Baum, A., and Singer, J.E. (1983). "Coping with chronic stress at Three Mile Island: psychological and biochemical evidence." Health Psychology2(2):149-166.
8.
Dudnik, R.M. (ed.) (1968). Anatomy of a Personal Injury Suit: A Handbook of Basic Trial Advocacy. American Trial Lawyers' Association, Boston, MA.
9.
Greer, E., Freedman, W., and Levin, S. (1989). Toxic Tort Litigation. Prentice Hall, New York, NY.
10.
Groves, R.M., Cialdini, R.B., and Couper, M.P. (1992). "Understanding the decision to participate in a survey." Publ. Opinion Q.56:475-495.
11.
Harlow, S.D. and Linet, M.S. (1989). "Agreement between questionnaire data and medical records." Am. J. Epidem.129:233-248.
12.
Jackman, M.R. and Muha, M.J. (1984). "Education and intergroup attitudes: Moral enlightenment, superficial democratic commitment, or ideological refinement?" Am. Sociol. Rev.49(6):751-769.
13.
Kaye, W.E., Hall, H.I., and Lybarger, J.A. (1994). "Recall bias in disease status associated with perceived exposure to hazardous substances." Ann. Epidem.4:393-397.
14.
Kehoe, R., Suh-Yuh, W., Leske, M.C., and Chylack L.T., JR. (1994). "Comparing self-reported and physician-reported medical history." Am. J. Epidem.139:813-818.
15.
Krosnick, J.A. and Schuman, H. (1988). "Attitude intensity, importance, and certainty and susceptibility to response effects." J. Personality Soc. Psychology54(6):940-952.
16.
Lipscomb, J.A., Satin, K.P., and Neutra, R.R. (1992). "Reported symptom prevalence rates from comparison populations in community-based environmental studies." Arch. Environ. Health47(4):263-269.
17.
Loftus, E.F., Klinger, M.R., Smith, K.D., and Fiedler, J. (1990). "A tale of two questions: benefits of asking more than one question." Publ. Opinion Q.54:330-345.
18.
Nader, R., Brownstein, R., and Richards, J. (1981). Who's Poisoning America? Corporate Polluters and their Victims in the Chemical Age. Sierra Club Books, San Francisco, CA.
19.
Odell, R. (1980). Environmental Awakening: The New Revolution to Protect the Earth. 1st ed. Conservation Foundation, Washington, DC and Ballinger Publishing Co., Cambridge, MA.
20.
Paganini-Hill, A. and Chao, A. (1993). "Accuracy of recall of hip fracture, heart attack, and cancer: a comparison of postal survey data and medical records." Am. J. Epidem.138:101-106.
21.
Peskin, S.H. (1989). How to Settle for Top Dollar. Michie Co., Charlottesville, VA.
22.
Presser, S. (1984). "Is inaccuracy on factual survey items item-specific or respondent-specific?" Publ. Opinion Q.48:344-355.
23.
Presser, S. and Traugott, M. (1992). "Little white lies and social science models: correlated response errors in a panel study of voting." Publ. Opinion Q.56:77-86.
24.
Roht, L.H., Vernon, S.W., Weir, F.W., Pier, S.M., Sullivan, P., and Reed, L.J. (1985). "Community exposure to hazardous waste disposal sites: assessing reporting bias." Am. J. Epidem.122:418-433.
25.
Rosenkranz, E.J. (1986). "The pollution exclusion clause through the looking glass." Georgetown Law J.74:1237-1300.
26.
Schweitzer, S., Hodkin, S., Smith, J., and Swetlow, G. (1933). Trial Manual for Negligence Actions. Baker, Voorhis, New York, NY.
