A Weight-of-Evidence Approach for Assessing Interactions in Chemical Mixtures

Abstract

The risk assessment process must encompass all available toxicological data and scientific evidence on the plausible toxicities of a chemical or chemical mixture. As an extension to the approaches used to conduct risk assessments on chemical mixtures, a preliminary scheme, analogous to the IARC classification of carcinogens, is proposed to express the weight of evidence for the interactions in binary mixtures. This scheme is based on composite representation of all the toxicological evidence from animal bioassays and human data, pharmacokinetics studies, metabolism studies, and structure activity relationships. In addition, factors such as the relevance of route, duration and sequence of exposure, toxicological significance of interactions and the quality of in vivo and in vitro data are taken into consideration. The scheme yields an alphanumeric classification that can be used for qualitative risk assessment, and has the potential, as demonstrated in this paper, for quantitative application to site-specific risk assessments. Furthermore, the scheme can be used to estimate interactions or form hypotheses concerning binary interactions. It is flexible and allows all pertinent information to be incorporated in a methodical and consistent manner. Research is needed to identify interaction patterns for simultaneous and sequential exposure scenarios of chemical pollutants in order that this scheme may be developed further and its usefulness and limitations may be tested.

Keywords

risk assessment weight-of-evidence interactions binary mixtures

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Borzelleca

J.F.

, O'HARA

T.M.

, Gennings

, Granger

R.H.

, Sheppard

M.A.

, and Condie

L.W.

Jr. , (1990). “Interactions of water contaminants. I. Plasma enzyme activity and response surface methodology following gavage administration of CCl₄ and CHCl₃ or TCE singly and in combination in the rat.” Fund. Appl. Toxicol. 14:477–490.

Durkin

P.R.

(1981). “An approach to the analysis of toxicant interactions in the aquatic environment.” In: Proc. 4th Ann. Symp. Aquatic Toxicology American Society for Testing and Materials, p. 24.

Finney

D.J.

(1971). Probit Analysis. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, Great Britain.

Harris

E.N.

, Ratnayake

J.H.

, Feey

V.F.

, and Anders

M.W.

(1982). “Interactive hepatotoxicity of chloroform and carbon tetrachloride.” Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 63:281–291.

Mason

K.E.

and Young

J.O.

(1967). “Effectiveness of selenium and zinc in protecting against cadmium-induced injury of the rat testis.” In: Selenium in Biomedicine, Proc. of Symp. ( Muth

O. H.

, ed.). pp. 383–394.

MUMTAZ

M.M.

, PEIRANO

W.B.

, DEROSA

C.T.

, and DURKIN

P.R.

(1991). “Assessment of interactions and toxicity of chemical mixtures.” Toxicologist 11(1):217.

NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES (NAS). (1989). “Risk assessment of mixtures of systemic toxicants in drinking water.” In: Drinking Water and Health, Vol. 9, pp. 121–132. Safe Drinking Water Committee, National Research Council, National Academy of Sciences, National Academy Press, Washington, DC.

NATIONAL RESEARCH COUNCIL (NRC). (1983). Risk Assessment in the Federal Government: Managing the Process. National Research Council, National Academy Press, Washington, DC.

RICHARD

A.M.

, RABINOWITZ

J.R.

, and WATERS

M.D.

(1989). “Strategies for the use of computational SAR methods in assessing genotoxicity.” Mutat. Res. 221:181–196.

10.

STACEY

N.H.

(1989). “Toxicity of combinations of chlorinated aliphatic hydrocarbons in vitro and in vivo.” Toxic. In Vitro 3(2):137–143.

11.

U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY (U.S. EPA). (1986). “Guidelines for the health risk assessment of chemical mixtures.” Federal Register 51(185):34014–34025.

12.

U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY (U.S. EPA). (1989). Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund, Vol. 1, Part A. EPA/540/1-89/002.

13.

U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY (U.S. EPA). (1990). Technical Support Document on Health Risk Assessment of Chemical Mixtures. Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, Environmental Assessment and Criteria Office, Cincinnati, OH. EPA/600/8-90/064.

14.

U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY (U.S. EPA). (1992). Integrated Risk Information System (IRIS), Online. Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, Environmental Criteria and Assessment Office, Cincinnati, OH.