Abstract
This study examines how three Native women politicians were portrayed in Native newspapers. The analysis found striking differences in how national Native media cover women politicians compared with prior findings in mainstream newspapers. The data illustrate the influence of Indigenous standpoint theory on the journalistic norms of Native media and its distinct lack of gendered politics, revealing significant prioritization of policy over personal and contrasts in the coverage amount and tone for conservative women politicians.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abernathy
P.
(2022 ). Where are the ethnic voices? The Center for Innovation and Sustainability in Local Media, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill . https://www.usnewsdeserts.com/#1591281825217-2139af59-2beb
2.
3.
4.
Agoyo
A.
(2021 , December 8 ). Indian country continues push to strengthen violence against Women Act . Indianz.com . https://www.indianz.com/News/2021/12/08/indian-country-continues-push-to-strengthen-violence-against-women-act/
5.
Allen
B.
(1996 ). Feminist standpoint theory: A Black woman’s review of organizational socialization . Communication Studies , 47 (4 ), 257 –271 .
6.
Alvarez
D.
(2019 , December 19 ). 7 tips for non-Native journalists covering Indigenous communities . International Journalists’ Network . https://ijnet.org/en/story/7-tips-non-native-journalists-covering-indigenous-communities
7.
Ardill
A.
(2013 ). Australian sovereignty, indigenous standpoint theory and feminist standpoint theory . Griffith Law Review , 22 (2 ), 315 –343 . https://doi.org/10.1080/10383441.2013.10854778
8.
Astor
M.
(2020 , November 3 ). Kamala Harris and the “double bind” of racism and sexism . The New York Times . https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/09/us/politics/kamala-harris-racism-sexism.html
9.“Blackfeet Chairman Calls Out DOJ, DOI, and U.S. senate committee on Indian affairs for “horrendous failings” in murdered and missing indigenous women response.” (2021 , October 11 ). Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/blackfeet-chairman-calls-out-doj-doi-and-us-senate-committee-on-indian-affairs-for-horrendous-failings-in-murdered-and-missing-indigenous-women-response
10.“Bingo.” (2018 ). Native American Journalists Association . https://najanewsroom.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/BINGO-card-rev180927.pdf
11.
Blazina
C.
DeSilver
D.
(2021 , January 15 ). A record number of women are serving in the 117th Congress . Pew Research Center . https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/01/15/a-record-number-of-women-are-serving-in-the-117th-congress/
12.
Boomgaarden
H.
Boukes
M.
Iorgoveanu
A.
(2016 ). Image versus text: How newspaper reports affect evaluations of political candidates . International Journal of Communication , 10 , 2529 –2555 .
13.“Bryan Newland ceremonially sworn in as interior department assistant secretary for Indian affairs.” (2021 , September 9 ). Indian Country Today . https://indiancountrytoday.com/the-press-pool/bryan-newland-ceremonially-sworn-in-as-interior-department-assistant-secretary-for-indian-affairs
14.
Buzzanell
P.
(2003 ). A feminist standpoint analysis of maternity and maternity leave for women with disabilities . Women and Language , 26 (2 ), 53 –65 .
15.
Cameron
D.
(1996 ). Style policy and style politics: A neglected aspect of the language of News . Media, Culture and Society , 18 (2 ), 315 –333 .
16.
Carter Olson
C. S.
LaPoe
B.
LaPoe
V.
Azocar
C. L.
Hazarika
B
. (2022 ). “Mothers are medicine”: U.S. indigenous media emphasizing indigenous women’s roles in COVID-19 coverage . Journal of Communication Inquiry , 46 , 289 –310 . https://doi.org/10.1177/01968599221083239
17.
Cassese
E.
Conroy
M.
Mehta
D.
Nestor
F.
(2022 ). Media coverage of female candidates’ traits in the 2020 democratic presidential primary . Journal of Women, Politics & Policy , 43 (1 ), 42 –63 .
18.“Congressional Native American caucus co-chairs Cole, Davids celebrate Native American Heritage Month.” (2021 , November 3 ). https://indiancountrytoday.com/the-press-pool/congressional-native-american-caucus-co-chairs-cole-davids-celebrate-native-american-heritage-month
19.
Coward
J.
(1999 ). The newspaper Indian: Native American identity in the press, 1820-90 . University of Illinois Press .
20.
Cox
G. R.
FireMoon
P.
Anastario
M. P.
Ricker
A.
Escarcega-Growing Thunder
R.
Baldwin
J. A.
Rink
E.
(2021 ). Indigenous standpoint theory as a theoretical framework for decolonizing social science health research with American Indian communities . Alter Native: An International Journal of Indigenous Peoples , 17 (4 ), 460 –468 .
21.Cultural Survival . (2020 b). Community media . https://www.culturalsurvival.org/programs/community-media
22.
Davenport
C.
(2021 , June 2 ). Fight over Deb Haaland, first Native American cabinet pick, reflects partisan divide . The New York Times . www.nytimes.com/2021/02/22/climate/deb-haaland-interior.html?searchResultPosition=3
23.“Davids and cole lead introduction of the Frank Harrison, Elizabeth Peratrovich, and Miguel Trujillo Native American Voting Rights Act of 2021.” (2021 , August 17 ). Indianz.com . https://indiancountrytoday.com/the-press-pool/davids-and-cole-lead-introduction-of-the-frank-harrison-elizabeth-peratrovich-and-miguel-trujillo-native-american-voting-rights-act-of-2021
24.“Davids highlights Indian Country infrastructure needs during committee hearing.” (2020 , February 7 ). Office of Sharice Davids . https://davids.house.gov/media/press-releases/davids-highlights-indian-country-infrastructure-needs-during-committee-hearing
25.
Emerson
R. M.
Fretz
R. I.
Shaw
L. L.
(1995 ). Writing ethnographic fieldnotes . University of Chicago Press .
26.
Falk
E.
(2010 ). Women for president: Media bias in nine campaigns . University of Illinois Press .
27.
Fears
D.
(2021 , February 19 ). Deb Haaland’s nomination to lead Interior is a historic first for Native Americans. The GOP wants Biden to cancel it . The Washington Post . www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2021/02/19/haaland-interior-native-american/
28.
Finneman
T.
(2015 ). Press portrayals of women politicians, 1870s–2000s: From “lunatic” woodhull to “polarizing” palin . Lexington Books .
29.
Finneman
T. (Host)
. (2019 , March 4 ). Coward podcast: Press portrayals of Native Americans (No. 17) [Audio podcast episode] . Journalism History . https://journalism-history.org/2019/03/04/coward-podcast-press-portrayals-of-native-americans/
30.
Foley
D.
(2003 ). Indigenous epistemology and Indigenous standpoint theory . Social Alternatives , 22 (1 ), 44 –52 .
31.
Foucault
M.
(1980 ). Two lectures . In
Gordon
C.
(Ed.), Power/knowledge: Selected interviews and other writings, 1972- 1977 by Michel Foucault (pp. 78 –108 ). Pantheon Books .
32.
Gibbons
S.
(2022 ). Gender on the agenda: Media framing of women and women of color in the 2020 U.S. presidential election . Newspaper Research Journal , 43 , 102 –128 . https://doi.org/10.1177/07395329221077253
33.
González
J.
Torres
J.
(2012 ). News for all the people: The epic story of race and the American media . Verso Books .
34.
Greco Larson
S
. (2006 ). Media & minorities: The politics of race in news and entertainment . Rowman & Littlefield .
35.
Green
R.
(1975 ). The Pocahontas perplex: The image of Indian women in American culture . The Massachusetts Review , 16 (4 ), 698 –714 . http://www.jstor.org/stable/25088595
36.
Green
R.
(1980 ). Native American women . Signs , 6 (2 ), 248 –267 .
37.
Hall
S.
(1975 ). Introduction . In
Smith
A. C. H.
(Ed.), Paper voices: The popular press and social change, 1935-1965 (pp. 1 –33 ). Chatto & Windus .
38.
Harding
S.
(1995 ). “Strong objectivity”: A response to the new objectivity question . Synthese , 104 (3 ), 331 –349 .
39.
Hartsock
N.
(1997 ). Comment on Hekman’s “Truth and method: Feminist standpoint theory revisited”: Truth or justice? Signs , 22 (2 ), 367 –374 .
40.“Healing with horses and voices.” (2021 , June 18 ). Indian Country Today . https://indiancountrytoday.com/newscasts/weekend-edition-06-18-2021
41.“History made: Interior Secretary Deb Haaland sworn in by Vice President Harris.” (2021 , March 18 ). Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/history-made-interior-secretary-deb-haaland-sworn-in-by-vice-president-harris
42.
43.
Hunt
D.
Schilling
V.
(2021 , September 30 ). Remembrance Day brings new push for U.S. boarding school commission . Indian Country Today . https://indiancountrytoday.com/news/remembrance-day-brings-new-push-for-u-s-boarding-school-commission
44.“I know that this process will be painful: Secretary Haaland announces Indian boarding school review.” (2021 , June 22 ). Indianz.com. www.indianz.com/News/2021/06/22/i-know-that-this-process-will-be-painful-secretary-haaland-announces-indian-boarding-school-review/
45.“Indian boarding school legislation reintroduced in Congress.” (2021 , March 30 ). Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/
46.“Indigenous Film+ Online and more 2021.” (2021 , September 15 ). Indian Country Today . https://indiancountrytoday.com/lifestyle/indigenous-film-online-and-more-2021
47.“Interior Sec. Haaland announces Federal Indian Boarding School initiative to shed light on the dark history of the boarding school system.” (2021 , June 22 ). Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/
48.“Interior Secretary Deb Haaland marries longtime partner on Saturday.” (2021 , August 30 ). Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/interior-secretary-deb-haaland-marries-longtime-partner-on-saturday
49.
Jamieson
K.
(1995 ). Beyond the double bind: Women and leadership . Oxford University Press .
50.
Kahn
K.
(1996 ). The political consequences of being a woman . Columbia University Press .
51.“Kamala Harris, Deb Haaland call on Congress to pass Indigenous voting rights legislation.” (2021 , July 28 ). Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/kamala-harris-deb-haaland-call-on-congress-to-pass-indigenous-voting-rights-legislation
52.
Kennedy
D.
(2022 , March 23 ). What the New York Times gets wrong—and right—in its editorial about free speech . WGBH . https://www.wgbh.org/news/commentary/2022/03/23/what-the-new-york-times-gets-wrong-and-right-in-its-editorial-about-free-speech
53.
Kim
K.
McCombs
M.
(2007 ). News story descriptions and the public’s opinions of political candidates . Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly , 84 (2 ), 299 –314 .
54.
Klein
L.
Ackerman
L.
(1995 ). Women and power in Native North America . University of Oklahoma Press .
55.
LaFromboise
T.
(1989 ). Circles of women: Professional skills training with American Indian women . Women’s Educational Equity Act Publishing Center .
56.
LaFromboise
T.
Heyle
A.
Ozer
E.
(1990 ). Changing and diverse roles of women in American Indian cultures . Sex Roles , 22 (7–8 ), 455 –476 .
57.
Lajimodiere
D.
(2011 ). Ogimah Ikwe: Native women and their path to leadership . Wicazo Sa Review , 26 (2 ), 57 –82 . www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/wicazosareview.26.2.0057
58.
LaPoe
V.
(2013 ). American-Indian media: The past, the present, and the promise of digital (Publication No. 1552) [Doctoral dissertation, Louisiana State University]. LSU Digital Commons . https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2551&context=gradschool_dissertations
59.
Lawrence
R. G.
Rose
M.
(2010 ). Hillary Clinton’s race for the White House: Gender politics and the media on the campaign trail . Lynne Rienner Publishers .
60.
Lincoln
Y.
Guba
E.
(1985 ). Naturalistic inquiry . SAGE .
61.
Lindlof
T.
Taylor
B.
(2002 ). Qualitative communication research methods (2nd ed. ). SAGE .
62.
Lucht
T.
Davis
C.
(2021 ). Gender, race, and place in newspaper coverage of women “firsts” after the Nineteenth Amendment . Journalism History , 47 (4 ), 333 –352 . https://doi.org/10.1080/00947679.2021.1982564
63.“Mary Toya, mother of Secretary Deb Haaland, passes on.” (2021 , October 18 ). Indianz.com . https://www.indianz.com/News/2021/10/18/mary-toya-mother-of-secretary-deb-haaland-passes-on/
64.
McGuire
P. D.
(2010 ). Exploring resilience and Indigenous ways of knowing . Pimatisiwin: A Journal of Aboriginal and Indigenous Community Health , 8 (2 ), 117 –131 .
65.NAJA Media Spotlight Report . (2020 ). Native American journalists association . https://najanewsroom.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/2020-2-5-Media-Spotlight.pdf
66.
Nakata
M.
(2007 ). Disciplining the savages: Savaging the disciplines . Aboriginal Studies Press .
67.“Native America calling: Native in the spotlight.” (2021 , July 7 ). Indianz.com . https://www.indianz.com/News/2021/07/07/native-america-calling-native-in-the-spotlight-3/
68.Native News Online Staff . (2021 , April 28 ). Sec. Deb Haaland announces funding for six tribal youth environmental and economic empowerment projects . Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/sec-deb-haaland-announces-funding-for-six-tribal-youth-environmental-and-economic-empowerment-projects
69.“Navajo Nation Council delegate Eugenia Charles-Newton continues search for missing and murdered indigenous women.” (2021 , October 7 ). Indian Country Today . https://indiancountrytoday.com/the-press-pool/navajo-nation-council-delegate-eugenia-charles-newton-continues-search-for-missing-and-murdered-indigenous-women
70.
Pember
M. A.
(2021 , December 8 ). Interior department announces collaboration on boarding schools . Indian Country Today . https://indiancountrytoday.com/news/interior-department-announces-collaboration-on-indian-boarding-schools
71.
Polhaus
G.
(2002 ). Knowing communities: An investigation of Harding’s standpoint epistemology . Social Epistemology , 16 (3 ), 283 –298 .
72.“Representatives Cole and Davids lead Native American Voting Rights Act of 2021 Legislation.” (2021 , August 16 ). Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/representatives-cole-and-davids-lead-native-american-voting-rights-act-of-2021-legislation
73.“Representative Sharice Davids statement on Senate markup of the For the People Act.” (2021 , May 13 ). Indian Country Today . https://indiancountrytoday.com/the-press-pool/representative-sharice-davids-statement-on-senate-markup-of-the-for-the-people-act
74.“Rep. Sharice Davids hopes to inspire youth with new children’s book.” (2021 , June 5 ). https://nativenewsonline.net/arts-entertainment/rep-sharice-davids-new-book
75.“Rep. Sharice Davids named vice chair of House Committee on Transportation & Infrastructure.” (2021 , Jauary 28 ). Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/rep-sharice-davids-named-vice-chair-of-house-committee-on-transportation-infrastructure
76.
Rickert
L.
(2021 a, March 20 ). Rep. Yvette Herrell: Only Native American in Congress to vote no on violence against women reauthorization act . Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/rep-yvette-herrell-only-native-american-in-congress-to-vote-no-on-violence-against-women-reauthorization-act
77.
Rickert
L.
(2021 b, March 13 ). All three GOP members of Congress who are Native Americans voted no on $31.2 billion that is going to Indian Country . Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/all-three-gop-who-are-native-americans-in-congress-voted-no-on-31-2-billion-that-is-going-to-indian-country
78.
Rowley
D.
(2021 , March 19 ). Yvette Herrell first Native GOP woman elected to House . Indian Country Today . https://indiancountrytoday.com/news/yvette-herrell-first-native-gop-woman-elected-to-house
79.
Scott
E.
(2021 , February 27 ). Republicans call Deb Haaland a “radical.” Polls show their views on climate are out of the mainstream . The Washington Post . www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/02/27/republicans-call-deb-haaland-radical-polls-show-their-views-climate-are-out-mainstream/
80.“Secretary Deb Haaland launches missing & murdered unit at interior dept.” (2021 , April 2 ). Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/secretary-deb-haaland-announces-missing-murdered-unit-at-interior-dept
81.“Secretary Haaland takes action against racist and derogatory place names.” (2021 , November 19 ). Indianz.com . https://www.indianz.com/News/2021/11/19/secretary-haaland-takes-action-against-racist-and-derogatory-place-names/
82.Sicangu CDC . (2020 ). #MMIW: Missing and murdered indigenous women . https://sicangucdc.org/blog/f/mmiw-missing-and-murdered-indigenous-women?gclid=CjwKCAiA1JGRBhBSEiwAxXblwXiUqXhPCgBlnvOztua_h_euQQOw87iN_g2-Gmrs6Z9kbNfHpUFxNBoC4TwQAvD_BwE
83.
Steiner
L.
Kitch
C.
Kroeger
B.
(2020 ). Front pages, front lines: Media and the fight for women’s suffrage . University of Illinois Press .
84.
Strauss
A. L.
Corbin
J.
(1998 ). Basics of qualitative research: Techniques and procedures for developing grounded theory (2nd ed. ). SAGE .
85.
Thomas
R. J.
Finneman
T.
(2014 ). Who watches the watchdogs? Journalism Studies , 15 (2 ), 172 –186 .
86.
Thompson
D.
(2021 a, January 25 ). First-term New Mexico Rep. Yvette Herrell slams Biden’s ban on new oil & gas leases . Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/first-term-new-mexico-rep-yvette-herrell-slams-biden-s-ban-on-new-oil-gas-leases
87.
Thompson
D.
(2021 b, January 23 ). First-term New Mexico Rep. Yvette Herrell (Cherokee) condemns Biden’s plan to stop Southern border wall . Native News Online . https://nativenewsonline.net/currents/first-term-new-mexico-rep-yvette-herrell-cherokee-condemns-biden-s-plan-to-stop-southern-border-wall
88.“Two wrongs do not make a right.” (2021 , January 13 ). Indianz.com . www.indianz.com/News/2021/01/13/two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right-rep-yvette-herrell-r-new-mexico-on-impeaching-donald-trump/
89.“U.S. Senator Tina Smith, U.S. Representatives Sharice Davids and Gwen Moore push to empower tribes to pursue justice for Native survivors of sexual violence.” (2021 , December 8 ). Indian Country Today . https://indiancountrytoday.com/the-press-pool/u-s-senator-tina-smith-u-s-representatives-sharice-davids-and-gwen-moore-push-to-empower-tribes-to-pursue-justice-for-native-survivors-of-sexual-violence