Transfer of Development Rights for Coastal Adaptation: Conceptual Design and Practical Applications in the United States

Abstract

In response to the risk of sea level rise, planning organizations advocate for Transfer of Development Rights (TDR) Programs as a tool for coastal climate adaptation. But are they effective? In this paper, we conducted a comparative study of coastal TDR programs in the United States and developed program prototypes. We found that TDR programs are better suited for coastal management and accommodation, but less effective for complete retreat. Meanwhile, success is more likely when single-zone and dual-zone approaches are combined in program design: the single-zone approach leverages market demand for coastal real estate, while the dual-zone approach safeguards environmental benefits.

Keywords

transfer of development rights coastal adaptation program design comparative study U.S.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bakkensen

L. A.

2020. “Sorting Over Flood Risk and Implications for Policy Reform.” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 104:102362. doi:10.1016/j.jeem.2020.102362.

Bedsworth

L. W.

Hanak

2010. “Adaptation to Climate Change: A Review of Challenges and Tradeoffs in Six Areas.” Journal of the American Planning Association 76 (4): 477–95.

Been

Infranca

2012. “Transferable Development Rights Programs: ‘Post-Zoning’?” Brooklyn Law Review 78:12–50. https://ssrn.com/abstract=2144808

Berke

P. R.

Stevens

M. R.

2016. “Land Use Planning for Climate Adaptation: Theory and Practice.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 36 (3): 283–89.

Bruno

Falco

Shahab

Geneletti

2023. “Integrating Ecosystem Services in Transfer of Development Rights: A Literature Review.” Land Use Policy 131:106694. doi:10.1016/j.landusepol.2023.106694.

Colavitti

A. M.

Serra

2018. “The Transfer of Development Rights as a Tool for the Urban Growth Containment: A Comparison between the United States and Italy.” Papers in Regional Science 97 (4): 1247–66.

Corbin

J. M.

Strauss

1990. “Grounded Theory Research: Procedures, Canons, and Evaluative Criteria.” Qualitative Sociology 13 (1): 3–21.

Elliott

J. R.

Brown

P. L.

Loughran

2020. “Racial Inequities in the Federal Buyout of Flood-Prone Homes: A Nationwide Assessment of Environmental Adaptation.” Socius 6 (1): 237802312090543. doi:10.1177/2378023120905439.

Fang

Howland

Kim

Peng

2019. “Can Transfer of Development Rights Programs Save Farmland in Metropolitan Counties?” Growth and Change 50 (3): 926–46.

10.

Georgetown Climate Center. 2022a. “Managed Retreat Toolkit” (georgetownclimatecenter.org). https://www.georgetownclimate.org/adaptation/toolkits/managed-retreat-toolkit/transfer-of-development-rights.html

11.

Georgetown Climate Center. 2022b. “State of New York Senate Bill S6424A: Identifying Lands at Risk from Sea-Level Rise or Flooding as Eligible Sending Districts for Transfer of Development Rights (TDR) Programs.” https://www.adaptationclearinghouse.org/resources/state-of-new-york-senate-bill-s6424a-identifying-lands-at-risk-from-sea-level-rise-or-flooding-as-eligible-sending-districts-for-transfer-of-development-rights-tdr-programs.html

12.

Gibbs

M. T.

2016. “Why is Coastal Retreat So Hard to Implement? Understanding the Political Risk of Coastal Adaptation Pathways.” Ocean & Coastal Management 130:107–14.

13.

Giordano

1988. “Over-Stuffing the Envelope: The Problems With Creative Transfer of Development Rights.” Fordham Urban Law Journal 43 (16): 43–66.

14.

Horton

B. P.

Khan

N. S.

Cahill

Lee

J. S. H.

Shaw

T. A.

Garner

A. J.

Kemp

A. C.

Engelhart

S. E.

Rahmstorf

2020. “Estimating Global Mean Sea-Level Rise and Its Uncertainties by 2100 and 2300 From an Expert Survey.” Npj Climate and Atmospheric Science 3:18. doi:10.1038/s41612-020-0121-5.

15.

Johnston

R. A.

Madison

M. E.

1997. “From Land Marks to Landscapes: A Review of Current Practices in the Transfer of Development Rights.” Journal of the American Planning Association 63 (3): 365–78.

16.

Kulp

S. A.

Strauss

B. H.

2019. “New Elevation Data Triple Estimates of Global Vulnerability to Sea-Level Rise and Coastal Flooding.” Nature Communications 10 (1): 1–12.

17.

Lancaster Farmland Trust. 2021. https://issuu.com/lancasterfarmlandtrust/docs/sfp_report_v16

18.

Lang

Rothenberg

2017. “Neoliberal Urbanism, Public Space, and the Greening of the Growth Machine: New York City’s High Line park.” Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 49 (8): 1743–61.

19.

Lester

2013. “CZM in California: Successes and Challenges Ahead.” Coastal Management 41 (3): 219–44.

20.

Linkous

E. R.

Chapin

T. S.

2014. “TDR Program Performance in Florida.” Journal of the American Planning Association 80 (3): 253–67.

21.

Lung

Killius

2016. Tools for a Resilient Virginia Coast: Designing a Successful TDR Program for Virginia’s Middle Peninsula. Williamsburg, VA: Virginia Coastal Policy Center. https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/vcpclinic/25

22.

Machemer

Kaplowitz

2002. “A Framework for Evaluating Transferable Development Rights Programmes.” Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 45 (6): 773–95.

23.

Macintosh

Foerster

A. C.

McDonald

2013. “Limp, Leap or Learn? Developing Legal Frameworks for Climate Change Adaptation Planning in Australia.” University of Tasmania 12:45. https://hdl.handle.net/102.100.100/539501

24.

Mcconnell

Walls

Kelly

2007. “Markets for Preserving Farmland in Maryland.” https://agnr.umd.edu/sites/agnr.umd.edu/files/files/documents/Hughes%20Center/Scientific%20Research/Virginia%20McConnell’s%20Final%20Report%20HRHCAE%20Pub%202007-03.pdf

25.

Meerow

Woodruff

S. C.

2020. “Seven Principles of Strong Climate Change Planning.” Journal of the American Planning Association 86 (1): 39–46.

26.

Montgomery County Government. 2025. https://www.montgomerycountymd.gov/agservices/ag-preservation.html

27.

Nellermoe

E. M.

2016. “Coastal TDRs: A Solution for Shifting Sands on Folly Beach?” Coastal Management 44 (3): 223–40.

28.

Nelson

A. C.

Pruetz

Woodruff

2012. The TDR Handbook: Designing and Implementing Transfer of Development Rights Programs. Washington, DC: Island Press.

29.

Oxnard California—Smart Preservation. 2022. https://smartpreservation.net/oxnard-california/

30.

Pruetz

2021. Climate Action and Transferable Development Rights. New York: Arje Press.

31.

Pruetz

Standridge

2008. “What Makes Transfer of Development Rights Work? Success Factors from Research and Practice.” Journal of the American Planning Association 75 (1): 78–87.

32.

Schechtman

Brady

2013. “Cost-Efficient Climate Change Adaptation in the North Atlantic.” https://repository.library.noaa.gov/view/noaa/40905/noaa_40905_DS1.pdf

33.

Shahab

Clinch

J. P.

O’Neill

2018. “Estimates of Transaction Costs in Transfer of Development Rights Programs.” Journal of the American Planning Association 84 (1): 61–75.

34.

Shi

Fisher

Brenner

R. M.

Greiner-Safi

Shepard

Vanucchi

2022. “Equitable Buyouts? Learning from State, County, and Local Floodplain Management Programs.” Climatic Change 174 (3): 29. doi:10.1007/s10584-022-03453-5.

35.

Smart Preservation. 2022. “TDR Updates.” https://smartpreservation.net/tdr-updates/

36.

Smith

M. H.

2020. “Creating a Market for Retreat: Transfer of Development Rights as a Climate Adaptation Tool in Coastal Massachusetts.” Thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology. https://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/127623

37.

Urban Land Institute. 2016. “A ULI Advisory Services Panel Report: Arch Creek Basin Miami-Dade County, Florida.” https://americas.uli.org/miami-florida-advisory-services-panel/

38.

Urban Land Institute. 2017. “Exploring Transfer of Development Rights as a Possible Climate Adaptation Strategy: Urban Land Institute Resilience Panel Focus Group with Miami-Dade County.” https://seflorida.uli.org/exploring-transfer-development-rights-possible-climate-adaptation-strategy/

39.

Williams

N. R.

2014. “Coastal TDRs and Takings in a Changing Climate.” Urban Law 46:139.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.02 MB