The (Uneven) Spatial Distribution of Entrepreneurial Support Organizations in the Regional Ecosystem

Abstract

Existing research recognizes the importance of entrepreneurial support organizations (ESOs) in facilitating entrepreneurial activity and economic development in regional entrepreneurial ecosystems. We have insufficient knowledge, however, of the accessibility to such resources by different entrepreneur groups, especially spatially. This study uses the diversifying Atlanta Metropolitan Area to examine this question. Spatial visualizations and statistical analyses reveal uneven geographic clustering of all, and racial minority-targeting, ESOs. Neighborhoods with worsening poverty rates do not attract ESOs. Since the spatial distribution of ESOs might hinder access, we urge planners to strategically coordinate ESO efforts through better understanding their locations, services, and clientele.

Keywords

entrepreneurial ecosystem minority entrepreneurship entrepreneurial support organization spatial analysis metropolitan area economic development planning

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aldrich

H. E.

Kim

P. H.

2007. “Small Worlds, Infinite Possibilities? How Social Networks Affect Entrepreneurial Team Formation and Search.” Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal 1 (1–2): 147–65.

Aldrich

H. E.

Martinez

M. A.

2005. “Entrepreneurship as Social Construction: A Multi-level Evolutionary Approach.” In Handbook of Entrepreneurship Research, edited by Acs

Audretsch

D. B.

, 350–99. Dordrecht: Kluwer.

Amezcua

A. S.

Grimes

M. G.

Bradley

S. W.

Wiklund

2013. “Organizational Sponsorship and Founding Environments: A Contingency View on the Survival of Business-incubated Firms, 1994–2007.” Academy of Management Journal 56 (6): 1628–54.

Amezcua

A. S.

Pandey

Simarasl

2019. “Are Business Incubators’ Ecosystems Inclusive of Women Entrepreneurs?” In Go-to-market Strategies for Women Entrepreneurs: Creating and Exploring Success, edited by Crittenden

V. L.

, 57–66. Leeds: Emerald.

Bates

Robb

2014. “Small-business Viability in America’s Urban Minority Communities.” Urban Studies 51 (3): 2844–62.

Bates

Robb

2016. “Impacts of Owner Race and Geographic Context on Access to Small-business Financing.” Economic Development Quarterly 30 (2): 159–70.

Bento

Hwang

2023. “Barriers to Black Entrepreneurship: Implications for Welfare and Aggregate Output over Time.” Journal of Monetary Economics 134:16–34.

Bergman

B. J.

McMullen

J. S.

2022. “Helping Entrepreneurs Help Themselves: A Review and Relational Research Agenda on Entrepreneurial Support Organizations.” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 6 (3): 688–728.

Bradford

W. D.

2003. “The Wealth Dynamics of Entrepreneurship for Black and White Families in the US.” Review of Income and Wealth 49 (1): 89–116.

10.

Breznitz

S. M.

Clayton

P. A.

Defazio

Isett

K. R.

2018. “Have You Been Served? The Impact of University Entrepreneurial Support on Start-ups’ Network Formation.” The Journal of Technology Transfer 43:343–67.

11.

Breznitz

S. M.

Feldman

M. P.

2012. “The Engaged University.” The Journal of Technology Transfer 37:139–57.

12.

Cantner

Cunningham

J. A.

Lehmann

E. E.

Menter

2021. “Entrepreneurial Ecosystems: A Dynamic Lifecycle Model.” Small Business Economics 57 (1): 407–23.

13.

Castells

Hall

P. G.

1994. Technopoles of the World: The Making of Twenty-first-century Industrial Complexes. Abingdon: Routledge.

14.

Clayton

2023. “Innovation Ecosystem Database–Georgia.” Harvard Dataverse, V1. doi:10.7910/DVN/IAPK0B.

15.

Clayton

2024a. “Different Outcomes for Different Founders: Local Organizational Sponsorship and Entrepreneurial Finance.” Small Business Economics 62 (1): 23–62.

16.

Clayton

2024b. “Mentored without Incubation: Start-up Survival, Funding, and the Role of Entrepreneurial Support Organization Services.” Research Policy 53 (4): 104975.

17.

Clayton

Feldman

M. P.

Lowe

N. J.

2018. “Behind the Scenes: Intermediary Organizations That Facilitate Science Commercialization through Entrepreneurship.” Academy of Management Perspectives 32 (1): 104–24.

18.

Cohen

S. L.

Bingham

C. B.

Hallen

B. L.

2019. “The Role of Accelerator Designs in Mitigating Bounded Rationality in New Ventures.” Administrative Science Quarterly 64 (4): 810–54.

19.

Colombo

M. G.

d’Adda

Quas

2019. “The Geography of Venture Capital and Entrepreneurial Ventures’ Demand for External Equity.” Research Policy 48 (5): 1150–70.

20.

Crowley

Jordan

2022. “Do Local Start-ups and Knowledge Spillovers Matter for Firm-level R&D Investment?” Urban Studies 59 (5): 1085–102.

21.

Donegan

Lowe

2020. “Going Local: Placing Entrepreneurial Microgeographies in a Larger Regional Context.” Industry and Innovation 27 (8): 871–91.

22.

Eesley

Wang

2017. “Social Influence in Career Choice: Evidence from a Randomized Field Experiment on Entrepreneurial Mentorship.” Research Policy 46 (3): 636–50.

23.

Eisinger

1993. “State Venture Capitalism, State Politics, and the World of High-risk Investment.” Economic Development Quarterly 7 (2): 131–39.

24.

Fairlie

R. W.

Robb

A. M.

2008. Race and Entrepreneurial Success: Black, Asian, and White Owned Businesses in the United States. Cambridge: MIT Press.

25.

Fairlie

R. W.

Robb

A. M.

Robinson

D. T.

2021. “Black and White: Access to Capital among Minority Owned Start-ups.” Management Science 68 (4): 2377–400.

26.

Fang

Adelakun

Goetemann

2022. “Brewing Entrepreneurship: Coffee and Startups.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 443:1401–14. doi:10.1177/0739456X211067272.

27.

Feldman

1994. The Geography of Innovation. Vol. 2. Berlin: Springer Science & Business Media.

28.

Feldman

2001. “The Entrepreneurial Event Revisited: Firm Formation in a Regional Context.” Industrial and Corporate Change 10:861–91.

29.

Feldman

Lowe

2015. “Triangulating Regional Economies: Realizing the Promise of Digital Data.” Research Policy 44 (9): 1785–93.

30.

Feldman

Siegel

D. S.

Wright

2019. “New Developments in Innovation and Entrepreneurial Ecosystems.” Industrial and Corporate Change 28 (4): 817–26.

31.

Fesselmeyer

Seah

K. Y.

2017. “Neighborhood Segregation and Black Entrepreneurship.” Economic Letters 154:88–91.

32.

Firth

1993. “Bias Reduction of Maximum Likelihood Estimates.” Biometrika 80 (1): 27–38.

33.

Florida

Adler

Mellander

2018. “The City as Innovation Machine.” In Transitions in Regional Economic Development, edited by Turok

Bailey

Clark

Fratesi

Fritsch

Harrison

Kemeny

Kogler

Lagendijk

, 151–70. Abingdon: Routledge.

34.

Glaeser

Kallal

Scheinkman

Shleifer

1992. “Growth in Cities.” Journal of Political Economy 100 (6): 1126–52.

35.

Hallen

B. L.

Cohen

S. L.

Bingham

C. B.

2020. “Do Accelerators Work? If so, How?” Organization Science 31 (2): 378–414.

36.

Haltiwanger

2012. “Job Creation and Firm Dynamics in the U.S.” Innovation Policy and the Economy 12:17–38.

37.

Haltiwanger

Jarmin

R. S.

Miranda

2013. “Who Creates Jobs? Small vs. Large vs. Young.” Review of Economics and Statistics 95 (2): 347–61.

38.

Harper-Anderson

2019. “Contemporary Black Entrepreneurship in the Professional Service Sector of Chicago: Intersections of Race, Entrepreneurship, and Economic Transformation.” Urban Affairs Review 55 (3): 800–31.

39.

Harper-Anderson

Lewis

D. A.

2018. “What Makes Business Incubation Work? Measuring the Influence of Incubator Quality and Regional Capacity on Incubator Outcomes.” Economic Development Quarterly 32 (1): 60–77.

40.

Heinze

Ploner

2004. A SAS Macro, S-PLUS Library and R Package to Perform Logistic Regression without Convergence Problems. Technical Report 2. Medical University of Vienna, Austria. http://tinyurl.com/fllogistfTR.

41.

Herrmann

Avdeitchikova

Hjertström

2016. “The Influence of Functional and Relational Proximity on Business Angel Investments.” International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Small Business 29 (3): 468–90.

42.

Hruskova

Mason

Herzog

2022. “Mapping Entrepreneurship Support Organisations: An Examination of the ‘Cluttered Landscape’ Critique.” Local Economy 37 (7): 541–63.

43.

Huang

Liu

C. Y.

2019. “Immigrant Entrepreneurship and Economic Development: A Local Policy Perspective.” Journal of the American Planning Association 85 (4): 564–84.

44.

Kauffman Foundation. 2008. An Overview of the Kauffman Firm Survey: Results from the 2004-2008 Data. Kansas City: Kauffman Foundation.

45.

Krueger

2021. “Beyond “Getting Asked to Dance”: Inclusive Entrepreneurial Ecosystems.” In The Palgrave Handbook of Minority Entrepreneurship, edited by Cooney

T. M.

, 117–35. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.

46.

Liu

C. Y.

2012. “Inrametropolitan Opportunity Structure and the Self-employment of Asian and Latino Immigrants.” Economic Development Quarterly 26 (2): 178–92.

47.

Liu

C. Y.

2014. Minority-owned and Immigrant-owned Businesses in Georgia’s Economy. Report No. 7, November 2014. GSU Center for State and Local Finance, Atlanta.

48.

Liu

C. Y.

Jeong

2024. “Are Minority-owned Businesses Moving to Suburbs? Intrametropolitan Spatial Shifts and Their Courses.” Journal of Small Business & Entrepreneurship 36:574–98.

49.

Liu

C. Y.

Renzy

2024. “Suburbanization and Migrant Entrepreneurship in the United States.” In Migration and Cities: Conceptual and Policy Advances, IMISCOE, edited by Triandafyllidou

Moghadam

Kelly

Şahin-Mencütek

, 161–82. Cham: Springer.

50.

Lowe

N. J.

2009. “Challenging Tradition: Unlocking New Paths to Regional Industrial Upgrading.” Environment and Planning A 41 (1): 128–45.

51.

Lowe

N. J.

Feldman

2018. “Breaking the Waves: Innovating at the Intersections of Economic Development.” Economic Development Quarterly 32 (3): 183–94.

52.

Lowe

N. J.

Gertler

2005. “Diversity and the Evolution of a Life Science Innovation System: The Toronto Region in Comparative Perspective.” In Global Networks and Local Linkages: The Paradox of Clusters in an Open Economy, edited by Wolfe

D. A.

Lucas

, 25–55. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.

53.

Mack

Mayer

2016. “The Evolutionary Dynamics of Entrepreneurial Ecosystems.” Urban Studies 53 (10): 2118–33.

54.

Madaleno

Nathan

Overman

Waights

2022. “Incubators, Accelerators and Urban Economic Development.” Urban Studies 59 (2): 281–300.

55.

Malecki

E. J.

2018. “Entrepreneurship and Entrepreneurial Ecosys-tems.” Geography Compass 12 (3): e12359.

56.

Malizia

Motoyama

2016. “The Economic Development–Vibrant Center Connection: Tracking High-growth Firms in the D.C. Region.” Professional Geographer 68 (3): 349–55.

57.

Malizia

Motoyama

2019. “Vibrant Centers as Locations for High-growth Firms: An Analysis of 30 U.S. Metropolitan Areas.” Professional Geographer 71 (1): 15–28.

58.

Marlow

McAdam

2012. “Analyzing the Influence of Gender upon High-technology Venturing within the Context of Business Incubation.” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 36 (4): 655–76.

59.

Mason

Brown

2014. Entrepreneurial Ecosystems and Growth Oriented Entrepreneurship. Paris: Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development.

60.

Mervis

2015. “NIH Program Fails to Launch Blacks in Biotech.” Science 350 (6263): 896.

61.

Motoyama

2023. “Where Do High-growth Firms Go?” GeoJournal 88 (1): 493–510.

62.

Motoyama

. 2024. “The Evolution of an Entrepreneurship Ecosystem in St. Louis, United States.” In Entrepreneurial Ecosystems in Cities and Regions: Emergence, Evolution, and Future, edited by Huggins

Kitagawa

Prokop

Theodoraki

Thompson

(pp. 277–297). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

63.

Motoyama

Muntean

S. Clark

Knowlton

Ozkanac-Pan

2021. “Causes of the Gender Divide within Entrepreneurship Ecosystem.” Local Economy 36 (3): 3187–204.

64.

Motoyama

Knowlton

2016. “From Resource Munificence to Ecosystem Integration: The Case of Government Sponsorship in St. Louis.” Entrepreneurship & Regional Development 28 (5–6): 448–70.

65.

Motoyama

Knowlton

2017. “Examining Connections within the Startup Ecosystem: A Case Study of St. Louis.” Entrepreneurship Research Journal 7 (1): 1–32.

66.

Neck

H. M.

Meyer

G. D.

Cohen

Corbett

2004. “An Entrepreneurial System View of New Venture Creation.” Journal of Small Business Management 42 (2): 190–208.

67.

Neumeyer

Santos

S. C.

Caetano

Kalbfleisch

2019. “Entrepreneurship Ecosystems and Women Entrepreneurs: A Social Capital and Network Approach.” Small Business Economics 53:475–89.

68.

Neville

Forrester

J. K.

O’Toole

Riding

2018. “‘Why Even Bother Trying?’ Examining Discouragement among Racial-minority Entrepreneurs.” Journal of Management Studies 55 (3): 424–56.

69.

Clayton

Feldman

2022. “Accelerator Niches in an Emerging Entrepreneurial Ecosystem: New York City.” Local Economy 37 (4): 233–58.

70.

Qian

2020. “Entrepreneurship and the Economic Geography of Intergenerational Mobility in US Cities.” In Development Studies in Regional Science, edited by Chen

Bowen

W. M.

Whittington

373–85. Singapore: Springer.

71.

Ratinho

2020. “The Domains of Entrepreneurship Support.” In Research Handbook on Start-up Incubation Ecosystems, edited by Novotny

Rasmussen

Clausen

T. H.

Wiklund

60–73. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

72.

Rodríguez-Modroño

2021. “Non-standard Work in Unconventional Workspaces: Self-employed Women in Home-based Businesses and Coworking Spaces.” Urban Studies 58 (11): 2258–75.

73.

Roundy

P. T.

Brockman

B. K.

Bradshaw

2017. “The Resilience of Entrepreneurial Ecosystems.” Journal of Business Venturing Insights 8:99–104.

74.

Schumpeter

J. A.

1926. The Theory of Economic Development: An Inquiry into Profits, Capital, Credit, Interest, and the Business Cycle. Piscataway: Transaction Books.

75.

Sperber

Linder

2019. “Gender-specifics in Start-up Strategies and the Role of the Entrepreneurial Ecosystem.” Small Business Economics 53:533–46.

76.

Spigel

2017. “The Relational Organization of Entrepreneurial Ecosystems.” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 41:49–72.

77.

Spigel

Harrison

R. T.

2017. “Towards a Process Theory of Entrepreneurial Ecosystems.” Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal 12 (1): 151–68.

78.

Spigel

Vinodrai

2021. “Meeting its Waterloo? Recycling in Entrepreneurial Ecosystems after Anchor Firm Collapse.” Entrepreneurship & Regional Development 33 (7–8): 599–622.

79.

Stam

2007. “Why Butterflies Don’t Leave: Locational Behavior of Entrepreneurial Firms.” Economic Geography 83 (1): 27–50.

80.

Theodoraki

Messeghem

2017. “Exploring the Entrepreneurial Ecosystem in the Field of Entrepreneurial Support: A Multi-level Approach.” International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Small Business 31:47–66.

81.

Theodoraki

Messeghem

Rice

M. P.

2018. “A Social Capital Approach to the Development of Sustainable Entrepreneurial Ecosystems: An Explorative Study.” Small Business Economics 51:153–70.

82.

Walls & Associates. 2021. “National Establishment Time Series Data.”

83.

Wang

2022. “Planning for an Inclusive Entrepreneurial Eco-system: COVID-19 and Business Resilience in Underserved Communities.” Journal of the American Planning Association 89:295–309.

84.

Witt

2004. “Entrepreneurs’ Networks and the Success of Startups.” Entrepreneurship & Regional Development 16 (5): 391–412.

85.

Yang

Aldrich

H. E.

2017. ““The Liability of Newness” Revisited: Theoretical Restatement and Empirical Testing in Emergent Organizations.” Social Science Research 63:36–53.