This paper focuses on the ways in which recent comprehensive planning efforts in legacy cities address issues of historic preservation. Using 15 comprehensive plans as archival sources, we conduct textual analysis to explore how each of the plans incorporates historic preservation. The findings confirm existing research that suggests historic preservation has grown into an integral component of city planning efforts. The research offers insights into the current relationship between preservation and city planning, particularly within the context of legacy cities, and suggests that, despite recent practice, preservation remains a more palatable strategy than widespread demolition.
AudiracIvonne. 2018. “Shrinking Cities: An Unfit Term for American Urban Policy?” Cities75:12–19.
5.
BerglundLisa. 2020. “Critiques of the Shrinking Cities Literature from an Urban Political Economy Framework.” Journal of Planning Literature35 (4): 423–39.
6.
BerkePhilip R.ConroyMaria Manta. 2000. “Are We Planning for Sustainable Development? An Evaluation of 30 Comprehensive Plans.” Journal of the American Planning Association66 (1): 21–33.
7.
BerkePhilip R.GodschalkDavid. 2009. “Searching for the Good Plan: A Meta-Analysis of Plan Quality Studies.” Journal of Planning Literature23 (3): 227–40.
8.
BertronCaraRypkemaDonovan. 2012. Historic Preservation and Rightsizing: Current Practices and Resources Survey. Washington, DC: Advisory Council on Historic Preservation.
BirchEugenie L.RobyDouglass. 1984. “The Planner and the Preservationist: An Uneasy Alliance.” Journal of the American Planning Association50 (2): 194–207.
CampoDaniel. 2016. “Historic Preservation in an Economic Void: Reviving Buffalo’s Concrete Atlantis.” Journal of Planning History15 (4): 314–45.
15.
CardosoRodrigoSobhaniAliMeijersEvert. 2022. “The Cities We Need: Towards an Urbanism Guided by Human Needs Satisfaction.” Urban Studies59 (13): 2638–59.
EhrenfeuchtReniaNelsonMarla. 2020. “Just Revitalization in Shrinking and Shrunken Cities? Observations on Gentrification from New Orleans and Cincinnati.” Journal of Urban Affairs42 (3): 435–49.
29.
EraydinAydaÖzatağanGüldem. 2021. “Pathways to a Resilient Future: A Review of Policy Agendas and Governance Practices in Shrinking Cities.” Cities115:103–226.
30.
GanningJoanna P.TigheJ. Rosie. 2021. “Moving toward a Shared Understanding of the US Shrinking City.” Journal of Planning Education and Research41 (2): 188–201.
31.
HaarCharles M.1955. “The Master Plan: An Impermanent Constitution.” Law and Contemporary Problems20(3): 353–418.
32.
HackworthJason. 2016. “Demolition as Urban Policy in the American Rust Belt.” Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space48 (11): 2201–22.
33.
HollanderJustin B.CahillBernard. 2011. “Confronting Population Decline in the Buffalo, New York, Region: A Close Reading of the ‘Erie-Niagara Framework for Regional Growth.’”Journal of Architectural and Planning Research28 (3): 252–67.
KimSaehoon. 2019. “Design Strategies to Respond to the Challenges of Shrinking City.” Journal of Urban Design24 (1): 49–64.
36.
KinahanKelly L.2019a. “Historic Preservation as a Community Development Tool in Legacy City Neighbourhoods.” Community Development Journal54 (4): 581–604.
37.
KinahanKelly L.2019b. “The Neighborhood Effects of Federal Historic Tax Credits in Six Legacy Cities.” Housing Policy Debate29 (1): 166–80.
38.
KinahanKelly L.2019c. “The Neighborhood Investment Patterns of Legacy City Historic Preservation.” In Legacy Cities: Continuity and Change amid Decline and Revival, edited by TigheJ. RosieRyberg-WebsterStephanie, 67–80. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
39.
KinahanKelly L.MawhorterSarah. 2024. “Tensions between Demolition and Preservation in Philadelphia.” Journal of Planning Education and Research44 (3): 1303–15. doi:10.1177/0739456X-211042068.
40.
KinahanKelly L.Ryberg-WebsterStephanie. 2023. “Reviving Cleveland’s Commercial Corridors: Analyzing the Storefront Renovation Program, 1983-2016.” Journal of Urban Affairs45 (6): 1188–1207. doi:10.1080/07352166.2021.1915152.
41.
LaFromboisHeimMegan E.ParkYunmiYurcabaDaniel. 2019. “How US Shrinking Cities Plan for Change: Comparing Population Projections and Planning Strategies in Depopulating US Cities.” Journal of Planning Education and Research41 (1): 81–93.
42.
LeeJaekyungParkYunmiKimHyun Woo. 2019. “Evaluation of Local Comprehensive Plans to Vacancy Issue in a Growing and Shrinking City.” Sustainability11 (18): 4966.
LohCarolyn G.KimRose. 2021. “Are We Planning for Equity? Equity Goals and Recommendations in Local Comprehensive Plans.” Journal of the American Planning Association87 (2): 181–96.
45.
MallachAlan. 2017. “What We Talk about When We Talk about Shrinking Cities: The Ambiguity of Discourse and Policy Response in the United States.” Cities69:109–15.
46.
MallachAlanHaaseAnnegretHattoriKeiro. 2017. “The Shrinking City in Comparative Perspective: Contrasting Dynamics and Responses to Urban Shrinkage.” Cities69:102–108.
47.
MarkowiczMelanie A.2013. “Making the Connections: Historic Preservation in Detroit’s Rightsizing.” Forum Journal27 (4): 14–22.
48.
Martinez-FernandezCristinaWeymanTamaraFolSylvieAudiracIvonneCunningham-SabotEmmanuèleWiechmannThorstenYahagiHiroshi. 2016. “Shrinking Cities in Australia, Japan, Europe and the USA: From a Global Process to Local Policy Responses.” Progress in Planning105:1–48.
QuattroChristineDanielsThomas. 2022. “The Constellation of Plans: Toward a New Structure of Comprehensive Plans in US Cities.” Land11 (10): 1767.
54.
RedaelliEleonora. 2021. “Including Preservation in Planning: Albina and Portland’s Comprehensive Plan.” Journal of the American Planning Association87 (2): 266–81.
55.
RyanBrent D.GaoShuqi. 2019. “Plan Implementation Cha-llenges in a Shrinking City.” Journal of the American Planning Association85 (4): 424–44.
56.
RybergStephanie R.2013. “Historic Preservation’s Urban Renewal Roots: Preservation and Planning in Midcentury Philadelphia.” Journal of Urban History39 (2): 193–213.
57.
Ryberg-WebsterStephanie. 2013. “Preserving Downtown America: Federal Rehabilitation Tax Credits and the Transformation of U.S. Cities.” Journal of the American Planning Association79 (4): 266–79.
58.
Ryberg-WebsterStephanie. 2015. “Urban Policy in Disguise: A History of the Federal Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credit.” Journal of Planning History14 (3): 204–23.
59.
Ryberg-WebsterStephanie. 2016. “Heritage Amid an Urban Crisis: Historic Preservation in Cleveland, Ohio’s Slavic Village Neighborhood.” Cities58:10–25.
60.
Ryberg-WebsterStephanie. 2019. “Combatting Decline Preservation and Community Development in Pittsburgh and Cincinnati.” In Giving Preservation a History: Histories of Historic Preservation in the United States, edited by MasonRandall F.PageMax, 227–47. New York:Routledge.
61.
Ryberg-WebsterStephanie. 2023. Preserving the Vanishing City: Historic Preservation Amid Urban Decline in Cleveland, Ohio. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
62.
Ryberg-WebsterStephanieKinahanKelly L.2014. “Historic Preservation and Urban Revitalization in the Twenty-First Century.” Journal of Planning Literature29 (2): 119–39.
63.
Ryberg-WebsterStephanieKinahanKelly L.2017. “Historic Preservation in Declining City Neighbourhoods: Analysing Rehabilitation Tax Credit Investments in Six U.S. Cities.” Urban Studies54 (7): 1673–91.
64.
SilverChristopher. 1991. “Revitalizing the Urban South Neigh-borhood Preservation and Planning Since the 1920s.” Journal of the American Planning Association57 (1): 69–84.
65.
The American Assembly. 2011. Reinventing America’s Legacy Cities: Strategies for Cities Losing Population. New York, NY: The American Assembly.
66.
RosieTighe, J.Ryberg-WebsterStephanie. 2019. Legacy Cities: Continuity and Change Amid Decline and Revival. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
67.
WangKyungsoonLeeSamsu. 2019. “Policy Responses to Shrinking Cities in the United States and Some Implications for Urban Regeneration: Focused on Housing Vacancy and Land Bank.” Journal of Korea Planning Association54 (1): 159–72.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
