Historic preservation in declining city neighbourhoods: Analysing rehabilitation tax credit investments in six US cities

Abstract

Historic preservation is common practice across the world, including in US cities. At the same time, population decline, economic distress and vacancy prevalent in declining cities, also known as legacy, shrinking or post-industrial cities, creates a pressing threat to a vast array of urban historic buildings. In the USA, recent planning and policy emphasises strategic demolition and/or targeting resources in potentially viable neighbourhoods, with little attention paid to historic preservation. To fill this gap, we use a comparative case study of federal historic rehabilitation tax credit (RTC) investments from 2000 to 2010 across the neighbourhoods of six legacy cities: Baltimore, Cleveland, Philadelphia, Providence, Richmond and St. Louis. This is the first study to use disaggregated, longitudinal RTC data to analyse investment at the neighbourhood scale. We use the Hirschman-Herfindahl Index to evaluate investment concentration and US Census 2000 data to characterise neighbourhoods where developers chose to undertake RTC projects. The findings show that RTC investments occurred across a wide range of places, including very low- and low-income neighbourhoods, and produced both market-rate and affordable housing across each city’s neighbourhoods. The findings indicate that preservation occurs across a wide range of legacy city neighbourhoods and inform urban planners and policymakers about locations where the private sector is willing to invest with favourable financing.

Keywords

affordable housing built environment historic preservation neighbourhood planning shrinking cities tax incentives urban decline

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Accordino

Fasulo

(2013) Fusing technical and political rationality in community development: A prescriptive model of efficiency-based strategic geographic targeting. Housing Policy Debate 23(4): 615–642.

Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP) (2014) Task Force on Rightsizing and Historic Preservation. Available at: http://www.achp.gov/achpTaskForceRightsizing.html.

Allison

(2005) Gentrification and historic districts: Public policy considerations in the designation of historic districts in New York City. Doctoral dissertation, Columbia University.

American Assembly (2011) Reinventing America’s Legacy Cities: Strategies for Cities Losing Population. New York: American Assembly.

Birch

(2002) Having a longer view on downtown living. Journal of the American Planning Association 68(1): 5–21.

Birch

(2005) Who Lives Downtown. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.

Birch

(2009) Downtown in the ‘new American city’. The annals of the American academy of political and social science 626(1): 134–153.

Birch

Roby

(1984) The planner and the preservationist. Journal of the American Planning Association 50(2): 194–207.

Blakely

(2001) Competitive advantage for the 21st-century city: Can a place-based approach to economic development survive in a cyberspace age? Journal of the American Planning Association 67(2): 133–141.

10.

Brophy

Burnett

Richardson

(2003) Building a New Framework for Community Development in Weak Market Cities. Denver, CO: Community Development Partnership Network

11.

Carr

Servon

(2009) Vernacular culture and urban economic development. Journal of the American Planning Association 75(1): 28–40.

12.

Center for Urban Policy Research (CUPR) (2014) Annual Report on the Economic Impact of the Federal Historic Tax Credit for FY 2013. Rutgers Edward J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy, National Parks Service Technical Preservation Division.

13.

Clark

Lloyd

Wong

. (2002) Amenities drive urban growth. Journal of Urban Affairs 24(5): 493–515.

14.

Cohen

(1998) Combining historic preservation and income class integration: A case study of the Butchers Hill neighborhood of Baltimore. Housing Policy Debate 9(3): 663–697.

15.

Coulson

Leichenko

(2001) The internal and external impact of historical designation on property values. The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 23(1): 113–124.

16.

Cronyn

Paull

(2009) Heritage tax credits: Maryland’s own stimulus to renovate buildings for productive use and create jobs. The Abell Report 22(1): 1–8.

17.

Curran

Wolman

Hill

. (2006) Economic wellbeing and where we live: Accounting for geographical cost-of-living differences in the US. Urban Studies 43(13): 2443–2466.

18.

Dewar

Thomas

(eds) (2012) The City After Abandonment. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.

19.

Domer

(2009) Old but not good old: History, prospects and problems of freezing time in old buildings. Journal of Architectural and Planning Research 26(2): 95–110.

20.

Ellen

O’Regan

(2008) Reversal of fortunes? Lower-income urban neighbourhoods in the US in the 1990s. Urban Studies 45(4): 845–869.

21.

Filion

Hoernig

Bunting

. (2004) The successful few: Healthy downtowns of small metropolitan regions. Journal of the American Planning Association 70(3): 328–343.

22.

Galster

Tatian

Accordino

(2006) Targeting investments for neighborhood revitalization. Journal of the American Planning Association 72(4): 457–474.

23.

Gilli

(2009) Sprawl or reagglomeration? The dynamics of employment deconcentration and industrial transformation in Greater Paris. Urban Studies 46(7): 1385–1420.

24.

Górny

Toruńczyk-Ruiz

(2014) Neighbourhood attachment in ethnically diverse areas: The role of interethnic ties. Urban Studies 51(5): 1000–1018.

25.

Heintzelman

Altieri

(2013) Historic preservation: Preserving value? The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 46(3): 543–563.

26.

Hill

Wolman

Kowalczyk

. (2012) Forces affecting city population growth or decline: The effects of inter-regional and inter-municipal competition. In: Mallach

(ed.) Defining a Future for American Cities Experiencing Severe Population Loss. New York: American Assembly, pp. 33–85.

27.

Hipp

(2010) What is the ‘neighbourhood’ in neighbourhood satisfaction? Comparing the effects of structural characteristics measured at the micro-neighbourhood and tract levels. Urban Studies 47(12): 2517–2536.

28.

Ijla

Ryberg

Rosentraub

. (2011) Historic designation and the rebuilding of neighborhoods: New evidence of the value of an old policy tool. Journal of Urbanism: International Research on Placemaking and Urban Sustainability 4(3): 263–284.

29.

Katz

(2006) Revitalizing weak market cities in the U.S. Presentation to the Council on Foundations. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution, Metropolitan Policy Program.

30.

King

(2013) Jane Jacobs and ‘The Need for Aged Buildings’: Neighbourhood Historical Development Pace and Community Social Relations. Urban Studies 50(12): 2407–2424.

31.

Legacy City Design (LCD) (2015) Where are legacy cities? Available at: http://www.legacycitydesign.org/cities.

32.

Legacy City Partnership (LCP) (2015) What are legacy cities? The facts. Available at: http://www.legacycities.org/.

33.

Listokin

Lahr

(1998) The contributions of historic preservation to housing and economic development. Housing Policy Debate 9(3): 431–478.

34.

Logan

(2012) Beyond a boundary: Washington’s historic districts and their racial contents. Urban History Review/Revue d’histoire urbaine 41(1): 57–68.

35.

McGahey

Vey

(eds) (2008) Retooling for Growth: Building a 21st Century Economy in America’s Older Industrial Areas. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.

36.

Mallach

(2011) Demolition and preservation in shrinking US industrial cities. Building Research & Information 39(4): 380–394.

37.

Mallach

(2012a) Depopulation, market collapse and property abandonment: Surplus land and buildings in legacy cities. In: Mallach

(ed.) Rebuilding America’s Legacy Cities: New Directions for the Industrial Heartland. New York: The American Assembly, pp. 85–110.

38.

Mallach

(ed.) (2012b) Defining a Future for American Cities Experiencing Severe Population Loss. New York: American Assembly.

39.

Mallach

(2015) The uncoupling of the economic city: Increasing spatial and economic polarization in American older industrial cities. Urban Affairs Review 51(4): 443–473.

40.

Mallach

Brachman

(2013) Regenerating America’s Legacy Cities. Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.

41.

National Park Service (NPS) (2015) Federal Tax Incentives for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings: Statistical Report and Analysis for Fiscal Year 2014.Washington, DC: US Department of the Interior, National Park Service, Technical Preservation Services.

42.

Noonan

Krupka

(2011) Making – or picking – winners: Evidence of internal and external price effects in historic preservation policies. Real Estate Economics 39(2): 379–407.

43.

Page

Mason

(2004) Giving Preservation a History: Histories of Historic Preservation in the United States. New York: Routledge.

44.

Pastor

Benner

(2008) Been down so long: Weak market cities and regional equity. In: McGahey

Vey

(eds) Retooling for Growth: Building a 21st Century Economy in America’s Older Industrial Areas. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press, pp. 89–118.

45.

Pistor

NJC

(2014) City to rip down 26 buildings in north St. Louis. St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 9 June. Available at: http://www.stltoday.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/nick-pistor/city-to-rip-down-buildings-in-north-st-louis/article_2ab0165d-1290–56a1–86dc-8462d063ea0d.html.

46.

Qian

(2013) Diversity versus tolerance: The social drivers of innovation and entrepreneurship in US cities. Urban Studies 50(13): 2718–2735.

47.

Rhoades

(1993) The Herfindahl-Hirschman Index. Fed Res Bull 79: 188.

48.

Robinson

(2015) Tear down Baltimore’s abandoned buildings to help rebuild the city. The Washington Post, 30 April. Available at: http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/tear-down-baltimores-abandoned-buildings-to-help-rebuild-the-city/2015/04/30/225b87f0-ef5c-11e4-a55f-38924fca94f9_story.html.

49.

Ryan

Campo

(2013) Autopia’s end: The decline and fall of Detroit’s automotive manufacturing landscape. Journal of Planning History 12(2): 95–132.

50.

Ryberg

(2011) Preservation at the grassroots: Pittsburgh’s Manchester and Cincinnati’s Mt. Auburn Neighborhoods. Journal of Planning History 10(2): 139–163.

51.

Ryberg-Webster

(2013) Preserving downtown America: Federal rehabilitation tax credits and the transformation of US cities. Journal of the American Planning Association 79(4): 266–279.

52.

Ryberg-Webster

(2015a) The landscape of urban preservation: A spatial analysis of federal rehabilitation tax incentives in Richmond, Virginia. Journal of Urban Affairs 37(4): 410–435.

53.

Ryberg-Webster

(2015b) Urban policy in disguise: A history of the federal historic rehabilitation tax credit. Journal of Planning History 14(3): 204–223.

54.

Ryberg-Webster

Kinahan

(2014) Historic preservation and urban revitalization in the twenty-first century. Journal of Planning Literature 29(2): 119–139.

55.

Rypkema

(1991) The Economics of Rehabilitation. Washington, DC: National Trust for Historic Preservation.

56.

Saito

(2009) From ‘blighted’ to ‘historic’ race, economic development, and historic preservation in San Diego, California. Urban Affairs Review 45(2): 166–187.

57.

Silver

Crowley

(1991) Revitalizing the urban south: Neighborhood preservation and planning since the 1920s. Journal of the American Planning Association 57(1): 69–84.

58.

Sohmer

Lang

(1998) Beyond This Old House: Historic preservation in community development. Housing Policy Debate 9(3): 425–430.

59.

Stake

(2003) Case studies. In: Denzin

Lincoln

(eds) Strategies of Qualitative Inquiry. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, pp. 86–109.

60.

Thomson

(2012) Targeting neighborhoods, stimulating markets: The role of political, institutional, and technical factors in three cities. In: Dewar

Thomas

(eds) The City After Abandonment. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press, pp. 104–132.

61.

Thomson

(2008) Strategic, geographic targeting of housing and community development resources: A conceptual framework and critical review. Urban Affairs Review 43(5): 629–662.

62.

Thompson

Rosenbaum

Schmitz

(2011) Property values on the plains: The impact of historic preservation. The Annals of Regional Science 47(2): 477–491.

63.

Tobias

(2014). Cuyahoga County Council approves tweaks to $50 million demolition plan. Cleveland.com, 14 October. Available at: http://www.cleveland.com/cuyahoga-county/index.ssf/2014/10/cuyahoga_county_council_approves_tweaks_to_50_million_demolition_plan_final_passage_likely_coming_so.html.

64.

US Department of Justice (DOJ) and Federal Trade Commission (FTC) (2010) Horizontal merger guidelines. Available at: http://www.justice.gov/atr/public/guidelines/hmg-2010.html.

65.

Verderber

(2009) The unbuilding of historic neighbourhoods in post-Katrina New Orleans. Journal of Urban Design 14(3): 257–277.

66.

Wojno

(1991) Historic preservation and economic development. Journal of Planning Literature 5(3): 296–306.

67.

Yin

(2014) Case Study Research: Design and Methods. 5th edition. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

68.

Zahirovic-Herbert

Chatterjee

(2012) Historic preservation and residential property values: Evidence from quantile regression. Urban Studies 49(2): 369–382.

69.

Zhang

(2011) Boundaries of power: Politics of urban preservation in two Chicago neighborhoods. Urban Affairs Review 47(4): 511–540.