Existing locally unwanted land uses (ELULUs) are disproportionately located in low-income communities of color. As ELULUs fall into disrepair, can planners redevelop them in ways that advance environmental justice and, if so, how? Through a case study of a San Francisco ELULU redevelopment planning process, this article highlights the central role of community-based organizing in generating policy changes that promoted certain environmental justice outcomes. A reconceptualization of the agency-neighborhood relationship was key. Findings also identify the obduracy of infrastructure and directed redress as central planning considerations and tensions.
AnguelovskiIsabelleShiLindaChuEricGallagherDanielGohKianLambZacharyReeveKaraTeicherHannah. 2016. “Equity Impacts of Urban Land Use Planning for Climate Adaptation: Critical Perspectives from the Global North and South.” Journal of Planning Education and Research36 (3): 333–48.
2.
Atay KayaİlgiErolNursen Kaya. 2016. “Conflicts over Locally Unwanted Land Uses (LULUs): Reasons and Solutions for Case Studies in Izmir (Turkey).” Land Use Policy 58 (December): 83–94. doi:10.1016/j.landusepol.2016.07.011.
3.
BeenV., 2010. Community benefits: A new local government tool or another variation on the exactions theme. U. Chi. L. Rev., 77, p.5.
4.
BondsAnne. 2009. “Discipline and Devolution: Constructions of Poverty, Race, and Criminality in the Politics of Rural Prison Development.” Antipode41 (3): 416–38.
5.
BuchbergerStevenClarkRobertGraymanWalterLiZhiweiMcCutcheonMatthewYangJeff. 2009. “Needs and Trends of the Nation’s Water Infrastructure—The Utility Perspective.” In World Environmental and Water Resources Congress 2009@ SGreat Rivers, 700–708. American Society of Civil Engineers. http://ascelibrary.org/doi/abs/10.1061/41036(342)69.
6.
BullardRobert D.1996. “Environmental Justice: It’s More than Waste Facility Siting.” Social Science Quarterly77:493–99.
7.
BullardRobert D.2008. Dumping in Dixie: Race, Class, and Environmental Quality. Boulder: Westview Press.
8.
California Metropolitan Transportation Commission. 2010. TIGER/Line Shapefiles.
9.
ChappleKarenEliasRenee Roy. 2018. “Analyzing Investment Flows in Comprehensive Community Revitalization: The Case of Bayview Hunters Point, San Francisco.” Journal of Urban Affairs40 (4): 494–517.
10.
ChiuCarolynHumphreyHoJonesBonnieMoehleMelissaMooreGregSierra.Natalie2010. “San Francisco Sewer System Master Plan.” San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, San Francisco.
11.
Citizen’s Advisory Committee. n.d. “A Resolution of the Citizen’s Advisory Committee of the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission Supporting the SFPUC to Conduct Robust Community Engagement to Determine the Community’s Preference for Remodeling Southeast Community Facility at 1800 Oakdale or Building a New Community Center at 1550 Evans.” San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, San Francisco.
CoatesT.N.2014. The case for reparations. The Atlantic, 313 (5), pp. 54–71.
14.
ClaroEdmundo. 2007. “Exchange Relationships and the Environment: The Acceptability of Compensation in the Siting of Waste Disposal Facilities.” Environmental Values16 (2): 187–208.
15.
ColeHelenShokryGaliaConnollyJames J. T.Pérez-del-PulgarCarmenAlonsoJordiAnguelovskiIsabelle. 2017. “Can Healthy Cities Be Made Really Healthy?” The Lancet Public Health2 (9): E394–95. doi:10.1016/S2468-2667(17)30166-4.
16.
CorburnJason. 2017. “Concepts for Studying Urban Environmental Justice.” Current Environmental Health Reports4 (1):61–67.
17.
DillonLindsey. 2014. “Race, Waste, and Space: Brownfield Redevelopment and Environmental Justice at the Hunters Point Shipyard.” Antipode46 (5): 1205–21.
18.
DotsonTaylor. 2016. “Trial-and-Error Urbanism: Addressing Obduracy, Uncertainty and Complexity in Urban Planning and Design.” Journal of Urbanism: International Research on Placemaking and Urban Sustainability9 (2): 148–65.
19.
FarberStephen. 1998. “Undesirable Facilities and Property Values: A Summary of Empirical Studies.” Ecological Economics24 (1): 1–14.
20.
FastStewart. 2017. “Assessing Public Participation Tools during Wind Energy Siting.” Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences7 (3): 386–93. doi:10.1007/s13412-016-0419-0.
21.
FieldPatrickRaiffaHowardSusskindLawrence. 1996. “Risk and Justice: Rethinking the Concept of Compensation.” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science545:156–64.
22.
FineIvy Vanessa. 2012. “RE: Protest of RFP Selection Process for Agreement No. CS-169, Planning and Engineering Services, Central Bayside Improvement Project (the ‘Project’).” San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, San Francisco.
FosterSheila. 1998. “Justice from the Ground Up: Distributive Inequities, Grassroots Resistance, and the Transformative Politics of the Environmental Justice Movement.” California Law Review86:775–842.
25.
GroothuisPeter A.Van HoutvenGeorgeWhiteheadJohn C.1998. “Using Contingent Valuation to Measure the Compensation Required to Gain Community Acceptance of a LULU: The Case of a Hazardous Waste Disposal Facility.” Public Finance Review26 (3): 231–49.
26.
GrossJulianLeRoyGregJanis-AparicioMadeline. 2005. “Community Benefits Agreements: Making Development Projects Accountable.” Good Jobs First and the California Partnership for Working Families, Washington, DC, May.
27.
H.Res.702. 2019. “Recognizing that the United States has a moral obligation to meet its foundational promise of guaranteed justice for all.” 116th Congress.
28.
HamiltonJames T.1995. “Testing for Environmental Racism: Prejudice, Profits, Political Power?” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management14 (1): 107–32.
29.
HommelsAnique. 2005. “Studying Obduracy in the City: Toward a Productive Fusion between Technology Studies and Urban Studies.” Science, Technology, & Human Values30 (3):323–51.
30.
HorstMeganMcClintockNathanHoeyLesli. 2017. “The Intersection of Planning, Urban Agriculture, and Food Justice: A Review of the Literature.” Journal of the American Planning Association83 (3): 277–95.
JohnsonJason B.2005. “Poor Face More Pollution Risks, Study Says—Underprivileged Groups Have Higher Contact with Unsafe Water, According to Report.” San Francisco Chronicle, August23.
36.
JohnsonLizzie. 2015. “S.F. Starts Sewer Project Many Hope Will Clear Neighborhood’s Air a Whiff of Progress.” San Francisco Chronicle, July16.
37.
KallisGiorgosGómez-BaggethunErikZografosChristos. 2013. “To Value or Not to Value? That Is Not the Question.” Ecological Economics94:97–105.
38.
KaufmanS.SmithJ. L.1997. Implementing change in locally unwanted land use: The case of GSX. Journal of Planning Education and Research16 (3): 188–200.
39.
KingRyan ScottMauerMarcHulingTracy. 2004. “An Analysis of the Economics of Prison Siting in Rural Communities.” Criminology & Public Policy3 (3): 453–80. doi:10.1111/j.1745-9133.2004.tb00054.x
LarsenLarissa. 2009. “The Pursuit of Responsible Development: Addressing Anticipated Benefits and Unwanted Burdens through Community Benefit Agreements.” CLOSUP Working Paper Series No. 9. Center for Local, State, and Urban Policy, Ann Arbor.
42.
LiebertLarry. 1975a. “Bayview Protests New Sewage Plant.” San Francisco Chronicle, March21.
43.
LiebertLarry. 1975b. “Mixed Vote on Bayview Sewer Plant.” San Francisco Chronicle, April11.
44.
LiuYongSunChenjunyanXiaBoCuiCaiyunCoffeyVaughan. 2018. “Impact of Community Engagement on Public Acceptance towards Waste-to-Energy Incineration Projects: Empirical Evidence from China.” Waste Management76:431–42.
45.
Lung-AmamWillowPendallRolfKnaapElijah. 2019. “Mi Casa No Es Su Casa: The Fight for Equitable Transit-Oriented Development in an Inner-Ring Suburb.” Journal of Planning Education and Research39: 442-455.
MeenarMahbuburHowellJordan P.HachadorianJason. 2019. “Economic, Ecological, and Equity Dimensions of Brownfield Redevelopment Plans for Environmental Justice Communities in the USA.” Local Environment24 (9): 901–15. doi:10.1080/13549839.2019.1652803.
48.
MohaiPaulSahaRobin. 2007. “Racial Inequality in the Distribution of Hazardous Waste: A National-Level Reassessment.” Social Problems54 (3): 343–70.
49.
Morello-FroschR.PastorM.SaddJ.2001. Environmental justice and Southern California’s “riskscape” the distribution of air toxics exposures and health risks among diverse communities. Urban Affairs Review36 (4): 551–578.
50.
Morello-FroschRachelShenassaEdmond D.2006. “The Environmental ‘Riskscape’ and Social Inequality: Implications for Explaining Maternal and Child Health Disparities.” Environmental Health Perspectives114 (8): 1150–53. doi:10.1289/ehp.8930.
51.
NakazawaTakashi. 2018. “Conflicting Views on Opposition to LULUs: Distributive Justice in Three Japanese Cases of Waste Disposal Facility Siting.” Local Environment23 (8): 846–60. doi:10.1080/13549839.2018.1480597.
52.
PellowDavid N.2000. “Environmental Inequality Formation: Toward a Theory of Environmental Injustice.” American Behavioral Scientist43 (4): 581–601.
53.
PellowDavid N.2003. Garbage Wars: The Struggle for Environmental Justice in Chicago. Cambridge: MIT Press.
54.
PerdueRobert ToddSanchagrinKenneth. 2016. “Imprisoning Appalachia: The Socio-Economic Impacts of Prison Develop-ment.” Journal of Appalachian Studies22 (2): 210–23.
55.
PopperFrank J.1985. “The Environmentalist and the LULU.” Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development27 (2): 7–40.
PopperFrank, J. Forthcoming. “The LULU: A Broadened Theory.”
58.
RanganathanMaliniBalazsCarolina. 2015. “Water Marginalization at the Urban Fringe: Environmental Justice and Urban Political Ecology across the North–South Divide.” Urban Geography36 (3): 403–23. doi:10.1080/02723638.2015.1005414.
59.
RechtschaffenClifford. 1995. “Fighting Back against a Power Plant: Some Lessons from the Legal and Organizing Efforts of the Bayview-Hunters Point Community.” Hastings West Northwest Journal of Environmental Law and Policy3:407.
60.
ReidEloise. 2019. “Over Priced or Under Water: Green Gentrification in Gentilly, New Orleans.” PhD thesis, University of Michigan.
61.
RichardsonTim. 2005. “Environmental Assessment and Planning Theory: Four Short Stories about Power, Multiple Rationality, and Ethics.” Environmental Impact Assessment Review25 (4): 341–65. doi:10.1016/j.eiar.2004.09.006.
62.
RosenJovannaSchweitzerLisa. 2018. “Benefits-Sharing Agreements and Nonideal Theory: The Warning Signs of Agreement Co-optation.” Planning Theory17:396–417.
63.
RubensteinSteve. 1995. “S.F. Rally against Cancer—High Rates in Bayview-Hunters Point.” San Francisco Chronicle, September22.
64.
San Francisco Chronicle. 1987. “Sewage Plant Chemical Fumes Blamed on Trucker’s Error.” March21.
65.
San Francisco Human Rights Commission. 2003. “Environmental Racism: A Status Report & Recommendations.” San Francisco Human Rights Commission, San Francisco.
SchivelyCarissa. 2007. “Understanding the NIMBY and LULU Phenomena: Reassessing Our Knowledge Base and Informing Future Research.” Journal of Planning Literature21 (3): 255–66. doi:10.1177/0885412206295845.
69.
SchroederRichard A.2008. “Environmental Justice and the Market: The Politics of Sharing Wildlife Revenues in Tanzania.” Society and Natural Resources21 (7): 583–96.
70.
SchweitzerLisaValenzuelaAbel. 2004. “Environmental Injustice and Transportation: The Claims and the Evidence.” Journal of Planning Literature18 (4): 383–98.
71.
Southeast Community Facility. 2010. “Review of the Biosolids Digester Facility Project by the Southeast Digester Task Force for the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission.” Southeast Digester Task Force. https://sfwater.org/modules/showdocument.aspx?documentid=985.
72.
SmardonRichardMoranSharonBaptisteApril K.2019. “Revitalizing Urban Waterway’s Community Greenspace: Streams of Environmental Justice.” Proceedings of the Fábos Conference on Landscape and Greenway Planning6:19.
73.
SusskindLawrence E.McKearnenSarahThomas-LamarJennifer. 1999. The Consensus Building Handbook: A Compre-hensive Guide to Reaching Agreement. Thousand Oaks: SAGE.
74.
SzeJulie. 2006. Noxious New York: The Racial Politics of Urban Health and Environmental Justice. Cambridge: MIT Press.
75.
TalbotPeterKleinStephen. 2011. “Re: Central Bayside System Improvement Project, CS—169—Protest of Selection Process Ranking Decision Pursuant to RFP §XI.B.” HDR/Jacobs Associates Joint Venture, Omaha, NE.
76.
Ter MorsEmmaTerwelBart W.DaamenDancker D. L.2012. “The Potential of Host Community Compensation in Facility Siting.” International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control11:S130–38.
77.
TerwelBart W.MorsEmma Ter. 2015. “Host Community Compensation in a Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage (CCS) Context: Comparing the Preferences of Dutch Citizens and Local Government Authorities.” Environmental Science & Policy50:15–23.
78.
ThomasJune Manning. 2006. “Teaching Planning History as a Path to Social Justice.” Journal of Planning History5 (4): 314–22. doi:10.1177/1538513206293710.
VaughanElaine. 1995. “The Significance of Socioeconomic and Ethnic Diversity for the Risk Communication Process.” Risk Analysis15 (2): 169–80. doi:10.1111/j.1539-6924.1995.tb00311.x.
81.
YuanQuan. 2019. “Planning Matters.” Journal of the American Planning Association85 (4): 525–43. doi:10.1080/01944363.2019.1645614.
