Water Shutoffs in Older American Cities: Causes,Extent,and Remedies

Abstract

Spanish

Chinese

We highlight a worrisome situation in American cities—rising water bills that growing numbers of residents cannot afford to pay, leading to water shutoffs. A study of each state’s two largest water utilities suggested fifteen million Americans experienced water shutoffs in 2016. We describe how utility responses to financial challenges facing older cities have caused shutoffs that disproportionally hurt low-income customers. We present new data from public records requests illustrating the scale and distribution of shutoffs in Baltimore, Philadelphia, and Detroit, and discuss the potential of income-based pricing to solve the water affordability challenge.

Keywords

affordability infrastructure utility shutoffs water rates

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alliance for Water Efficiency. 2012. “Declining Water Sales and Utility Revenues: A Framework for Understanding and Adapting.” Racine: National Water Rates Summit.

American Society of Civil Engineers. 2017. “ASCE’s 2017 Infrastructure Report Card.” https://www.infrastructurereportcard.org/cat-item/drinking-water/.

American Water Works Association. 2016. “Water and Wastewater Rate Survey 2016.” https://www.bookdepository.com/Water-Wastewater-Rate-Survey-2016/9781625762078.

Amirhadji

Jason

Burcat

Leah

Halpert

Samuel

Lam

Natalie

McAleer

David

Schur

Catherine

Smith

Daniel

Sperling

Erik

. 2013. “Tapped Out: Threats to the Human Right to Water in the Urban United States.” Georgetown Law Human Rights Institute. https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/hri_papers/7/.

Baltimore City Department of Public Works. 2019a. “Water and Waste Water Billing Information.” https://publicworks.baltimorecity.gov/waterbilling_Information.

Baltimore City Department of Public Works. 2019b. “Water Bill Payment Plan Program.” https://publicworks.baltimorecity.gov/water-bill-payment-plan-program.

Baltimore City Department of Public Works. n.d. “Baltimore DPW.” https://publicworks.baltimorecity.gov/baltimore-h2o-faqs.

Beecher

Janice A.

2010. “The Conservation Conundrum: How Declining Demand Affects Water Utilities.” Journal–American Water Works Association 102 (2): 78–80.

Black & Veatch Management Consulting. 2018. “Direct Testimony on Behalf of the Philadelphia Water Department.” https://www.phila.gov/media/20180314143332/PWDStatementNo9A_DirectTestimonyandSchedulesofBlackVeatch.pdf

10.

Bolt v. City of Lansing . (1998). 459 Mich. 152.

11.

Boyle

Christine E.

2014. “Adapting to Change: Water Utility Financial Practices in the Early Twenty-first Century.” Journal–American Water Works Association 106:E1–E9.

12.

Cenname

Robert

. 2019. “Council Bill 18-0307—Water Accountability and Equity Act.” https://baltimore.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=7228599&GUID=D6FD1878-F269-422D-A6F3-28A54C2D8FB1.

13.

Center for Water Security and Cooperation. 2019. “The Accessibility Trap: Maryland’s Invisible Water Crisis.” www.ourwatersecurity.org

14.

Chapman

Mary M.

2014. “Hundreds in Detroit Protest over Move to Shut Off Water.” The New York Times, July 18. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/19/us/protesters-picket-detroit-over-move-to-shut-off-water.html.

15.

Chow

R. S.

2019. “Memorandum Re: City Council Bill 18-0307.” https://baltimore.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=3769175&GUID=4A3F24AF-7CC7-442B-86C5-B01AF0A148F7&Options=&Search=

16.

City of Chicago. 2019. “General Billing Questions.” https://www.chicago.gov/city/en/depts/fin/supp_info/utility-billing/common-questions-on-utility-services.html.

17.

City of Detroit. Detroit Municipal Code, Section 48.1, Division 3. “Security for Collection of Water Charges and Assessments.” https://library.municode.com/mi/detroit/codes/code_of_ordinances?nodeId=PTIVDECO_CH48UT_ARTIWA_DIV3SECOWACHAS

18.

City of Philadelphia. 2018. “Comprehensive Annual Financial Report.” https://www.phila.gov/finance/pdfs/2018ComprehensiveAnnualFinancialReport(CAFR)withGAASOpinion.pdf.

19.

Colton

Roger

. 2005. “A Water Affordability Program for the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department (DWSD).” Belmont: Fisher Sheehan & Colton.

20.

Colton

Roger

. 2015. “Water Bill Affordability for the City of Philadelphia.” Presented to Philadelphia City Council, April 9.

21.

Colton

Roger

. 2017. “Baltimore’s Conundrum: Charging for Water/wastewater Services That Community Residents Cannot Afford to Pay.” Baltimore: Food & Water Watch.

22.

Congressional Budget Office. 2018. “Public Spending on Transportation and Water Infrastructure, 1956 to 2017.” www.cbo.gov/publication/49910

23.

Cwiek

Sarah

. 2018. “More Detroiters Avoid Water shutoffs, But Help Eludes Some Who Need It.” Michigan Radio, January. https://www.michiganradio.org/post/more-detroiters-avoid-water-shutoffs-help-eludes-some-who-need-it.

24.

Davis

Martha Frances

. 2016. “Let Justice Roll down: A Case Study of the Legal Infrastructure for Water Equality and Affordability.” Georgetown Journal on Poverty Law and Policy 23 (3): 355–93.

25.

de Albuquerque

Catarina

. 2014. “Detroit’s Water Shut-Offs Target the Poor, Vulnerable and African Americans.” https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=15190&LangID=E.

26.

Detroit Blue Ribbon Panel on Affordability. 2016. “Final Report of Detroit Ribbon Panel on Affordability.” http://ipu.msu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/BRPA-Final-Report-incl-Transmittal-and-App.pdf.

27.

Detroit Free Press Staff. 2016. “What Will Happen to My Kids If My Water Is Shut Off?” Detroit Free Press, February 28. https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/flint-water-crisis/2016/02/28/flint-water-crisis-water-shut-child-custody/80991060/.

28.

Faust

Kasey M.

Abraham

Dulcy M.

McElmurry

Shawn P

. 2015. “Water and Wastewater Infrastructure Management in Shrinking Cities.” Public Works Management & Policy 21 (2): 128–56.

29.

Ferretti

Christine

. 2019. “Fewer Detroit Water Customers at Risk of Shutoffs.” The Detroit News, April 11. https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/detroit-city/2019/04/11/fewer-detroit-water-customers-risk-shutoffs/3415996002/.

30.

Food & Water Watch. 2018. “America’s Secret Water Crisis.” https://www.foodandwaterwatch.org/sites/default/files/rpt_1810_watershutoffs-web2.pdf.

31.

Hackman

Rose

. 2014. “What Happens When Detroit Shuts off the Water of 100,000 People.” The Atlantic, July 17. https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/07/what-happens-when-detroit-shuts-off-the-water-of-100000-people/374548/.

32.

Hollander

Justin B.

Pallagst

Karina M.

Schwarz

Terry

Popper

Frank J

. 2009. “Planning Shrinking Cities.” Progress in Planning 72:223–32.

33.

Jones

Patricia A.

Moulton

Amber

. 2016. “The Invisible Crisis: Water Unaffordability in the United States.” Unitarian Universalist Service Committee. https://www.uusc.org/press/the-crisis-of-unaffordable-water-in-the-u-s/.

34.

Kane

Joseph W.

2016. “Investing in Water: Comparing Utility Finances and Economic Concerns across U.S. Cities.” Brookings Institute. https://www.wwdmag.com/research/research-ranks-us-cities%E2%80%99-water-infrastructure-investment.

35.

Kurth

Joel

. 2018. “In Detroit, Surviving without Running Water Has Become a Way of Life.” Bridge Michigan, October 24. https://www.bridgemi.com/detroit-journalism-cooperative/detroit-surviving-without-running-water-has-become-way-life.

36.

Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program Clearinghouse. 2019. “Seasonal Termination Protection Regulations.” https://liheapch.acf.hhs.gov/Disconnect/SeasonalDisconnect.htm.

37.

Low-Income Water Customer Assistance Programs Act (2017-2018). S.3564, 115^th Cong.

38.

Mack

Elizabeth A.

Wrase

Sarah

. 2017. “A Burgeoning Crisis? A Nationwide Assessment of the Geography of Water Affordability in the United States.” PLoS ONE 12 (1): 1–19.

39.

McLeod

Ethan

. 2018a. “DPW Plans Another Water Rate Hike; Council President to Introduce Income-Based Billing Legislation.” Baltimore Fishbowl, November 29. https://baltimorefishbowl.com/stories/dpw-plans-30-percent-water-rate-hike-council-president-to-introduce-income-based-billing-legislation/.

40.

McLeod

Ethan

. 2018b. “How Council President Young’s Income-based Water Billing Legislation Would Work.” Baltimore Fishbowl, December 3. https://baltimorefishbowl.com/stories/how-council-president-youngs-income-based-water-billing-legislation-would-work/.

41.

Mirosa

Oriol

. 2015. “Water Affordability in the United States: An Initial Exploration and an Agenda for Research.” Sociological Imagination 51 (2): 35–67.

42.

Montag

Coty

. 2019. “Water/color: A Study of Race & the Water Affordability Crisis in America’s Cities.” https://www.naacpldf.org/wp-content/uploads/Water_Report_Executive-Summary_5_21_19_FINAL-V2.pdf.

43.

Murthy

Sharmila L.

2016. “A New Constitutive Commitment to Water.” Boston College Journal of Law & Social Justice 36 (2): 159–233.

44.

Pennsylvania. 1978. Utility Service Tenants Rights Act.

45.

Philadelphia Department of Revenue. 2019. “Annual Report to the Mayor on the Tiered Assistance Program (TAP).” https://www.phila.gov/media/20191218130822/Tiered-Assistance-Program-TAP-annual-report-2017-v2.pdf.

46.

Popowsky

Sonny

Olanepikun-Lewis

Folasade A.

Ewing

Tony

Johnson

Rasheia R

. 2018. “2018 Rate Determination.” https://www.phila.gov/media/20180713144736/2018-RATE-DETERMINATION-TIMESTAMPED.pdf.

47.

Qureshi

Haleemah N.

2018. “Binding Civil and Civic Infrastructure: The Need for Transparency and Accountability in Baltimore’s Water Crisis.” Cambridge: Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

48.

Rubens

Kimberly

. 2019. “18-0307, Bill Background and Fiscal Note Policy Objectives.” https://baltimorefishbowl.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/5.16.19-WAEA-Background-and-Fiscal-Note-1.pdf.

49.

Ryan

Brent D.

2012. Design after Decline: How America Rebuilds Shrinking Cities. The City in the Twenty-First Century. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

50.

Shen

Fern

. 2019. “Chow Chewed Out as Water Affordability Bill Passes.” Baltimore Brew, September 27. https://www.baltimorebrew.com/2019/09/27/chow-chewed-out-as-water-affordability-bill-passes/.

51.

Sullivan

Emily

. 2019. “Mayor Young Says He Won’t Sign Gag Order Bill, Will Water Accountability and Equity Act.” WYPR, November 6. https://www.wypr.org/post/mayor-young-says-he-won-t-sign-gag-order-ban-will-sign-water-accountability-and-equity-act.

52.

Teodoro

Manuel P.

2019. “Water and Sewer Affordability in the United States.” AWWA Water Science 1 (2): e1129.

53.

United Nations. 2014. “Joint Press Statement by Special Rapporteur on Adequate Housing as a Component of the Right to an Adequate Standard of Living and to Right to Non-discrimination.” https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=15188&LangID=E.

54.

U.S. Census Bureau. 2017. “American Community Survey 1-Year Estimates.” https://www.countyplanning.us/resources/census-data/american-community-survey/american-community-survey-1-year-estimates/.

55.

Walton

Brett

. 2016a. “Water Affordability Is a New Civil Rights Movement in the United States.” Circle of Blue, March 25. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/water-affordability-new-civil-rights-movement-united-states-ganter.

56.

Walton

Brett

. 2016b. “Water Systems Need Investment and Affordability.” https://www.circleofblue.org/2016/united-states/water-systems-need-investment-affordability/.

57.

Walton

Brett

. 2018. “When the Water Is Shut Off.” https://www.circleofblue.org/2018/world/water-shut-off/.

58.

Water Tax Payer Protection Act. 2019. H.B. 161. 2019 Maryland General Assembly. Reg. Sess. 2019.

59.

Water Accountability and Equity Act. 2019. Baltimore City Council. C.B. 18-0307.

60.

Wayne Metro. 2019. “Community Action Alliance WRAP.” https://wrap.waynemetro.org/program-resources/wrap-faq.

61.

Whitaker

David

. 2015. “Legality of Water Affordability Plan: Statement of Legislative Policy Division of Detroit.” https://detroitmi.gov/sites/detroitmi.localhost/files/migrated_docs/legislative-policy-reports/2015%20Report%20to%20Council/Legality%20of%20Water%20Affordability%20Plan%2010-21-2015.pdf.

62.

Young

Jack

. 2018. Water Accountability and Equity Act. Bill 18-0307. https://baltimore.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=3769175&GUID=4A3F24AF-7CC7-442B-86C5-B01AF0A148F7&FullText=1.

63.

Zamudio

Maria Ines

. 2019. “After Price Hikes, Thousands in Chicago Are without Water.” WBEZ Chicago, February 14. https://www.wbez.org/shows/wbez-news/chicagos-water-prices-are-skyrocketing-faster-than-other-great-lakes-cities/69951240-ea15-40c7-a649-5b6787e35b6b.