This paper analyzes the redevelopment of a residential compound in Jerusalem from a justice perspective. It focuses on the role of the Neighborhood Council (NC) in negotiating representation and recognition of local residents in the planning process. Based on analysis of interviews, planning documents, focus group meetings, and court appeals, we argue that as a hybrid governance structure, which mediates between the residents and the municipality, the NC is uniquely positioned to promote more just and inclusive planning process and outcomes at the neighborhood scale. However, the NC still faces substantial challenges due to its intermediary position.
AlfasiNuritGananErela. 2015. “Jerusalem of (Foreign) Gold: Entrepreneurship and Pattern-Driven Policy in a Historic City.” Urban Geography36 (2): 157–80.
2.
AndersonGaryBlairRobertShirkJosh. 2018. “Neighborhood Associations and Community Development: Differences in Needs and Strategies.” Community Development49 (5): 504–21.
3.
ArnsteinSherry R.1969. “A Ladder of Citizen Participation.” Journal of the American Institute of Planners35 (4): 216–24.
4.
AugustMartine. 2016. “‘It’s All About Power and You Have None’: The Marginalization of Tenant Resistance to Mixed-Income Social Housing Redevelopment in Toronto, Canada.” Cities57:25–32.
5.
AugustMartineWalksAllan. 2017. “Urban Redevelopment.” In International Encyclopedia of Geography: People, the Earth, Environment and Technology, edited by RichardsonDouglasCastreeNoelGoodchildMichaelKobayashiAudrey, 1–11. Hoboken: John Wiley.
6.
AvniNufar. 2017. “‘So Long, and Thanks for All the Fish?’ Examining the Built and Cultural Heritage of the Jaffa Port Redevelopment.” International Journal of Heritage Studies23:679–94.
7.
AvniNufar. 2019. “Bridging Equity? Washington DC’s New Elevated Park as a Test Case for Just Planning.” Urban Geography40 (4): 488–505.
8.
AvniNufarFischlerRaphaël. 2019. “Social and Environmental Justice in Waterfront Redevelopment: The Anacostia River, Washington, D.C.” Urban Affairs Review. Published electronically March 22. doi:10.1177/1078087419835968.
9.
BaileyNick. 2012. “The Role, Organisation and Contribution of Community Enterprise to Urban Regeneration Policy in the UK.” Progress in Planning77 (1): 1–35.
10.
BarRoni.2019. “Shifting Borders, Shifting Center: Hedging-out Uncertainty in West Jerusalem’s Urban Core.” Urban Geography2019:1–21. doi:10.1080/02723638.2019.1613137.
BlanderAkivaMoserSarahAvniNufar. 2018. “Religio-Nationalism and ‘Soft Boundaries’: Urban Gating in West Jerusalem and Tel Aviv.” Geoforum96:227–35.
13.
BuckmanStephen T.2011. “Upper Middle Class NIMBY in Phoenix: The Community Dynamics of the Development Process in the Arcadia Neighborhood.” Journal of Community Practice19 (3): 308–25. doi:10.1080/10705422.2011.595306.
14.
CarmonNaomi. 1999. “Three Generations of Urban Renewal Policies: Analysis and Policy Implications.” Geoforum30 (2): 145–58.
15.
CharneyIgal. 2017. “A ‘Supertanker’ Against Bureaucracy in the Wake of a Housing Crisis: Neoliberalizing Planning in Netanyahu’s Israel.” Antipode49 (5): 1223–43.
CoaffeeJonHealeyPatsy. 2003. “‘My Voice: My Place’: Tracking Transformations in Urban Governance.” Urban Studies40 (10): 1979–99.
18.
DavidsonMarkLeesLoretta. 2010. “New-Build Gentrification: Its Histories, Trajectories, and Critical Geographies.” Population, Space and Place16 (5): 395–411.
19.
DuroseCatherineLowndesVivien. 2010. “Neighborhood Governance: Contested Rationales within a Multi-Level Setting—A Study of Manchester.” Local Government Studies36 (3): 341–59.
20.
EshelSharonHananelRavit. 2019. “Centralization, Neoliberalism, and Housing Policy Central–Local Government Relations and Residential Development in Israel.” Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space37 (2): 237–55.
21.
FainsteinSusan S.2010. The Just City. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
22.
FeitelsonEran. 2018. “Shifting Sands of Planning in Israel.” Land Use Policy79:695–706.
23.
FincherRuthIvesonKurt. 2012. “Justice and Injustice in the City.” Geographical Research50 (3): 231–41.
24.
FontanJean-MarcHamelPierreMorinRichardShraggeEric. 2009. “Community Organizations and Local Governance in a Metropolitan Region.” Urban Affairs Review44 (6): 832–57.
25.
FraserNancy. 1995. “Recognition or Redistribution? A Critical Reading of Iris Young’s Justice and the Politics of Difference.” Journal of Political Philosophy3 (2): 166–80.
26.
FraserNancy. 1998. “Social Justice in the Age of Identity Politics: Redistribution, Recognition, and Participation.” Working Paper No. 98–108. SSG Sozialwissenschaften, USB Köln, Berlin.
27.
FraserNancyHonnethAxel. 2003. Redistribution or Recognition?: A Political-philosophical Exchange. London: Verso.
28.
FriedmanRachelRosenGillad. 2019. “The Challenge of Conceptualizing Affordable Housing: Definitions and Their Underlying Agendas in Israel.” Housing Studies34 (4): 565–87.
29.
GevaYinnonRosenGillad. 2016. Community Work in Urban Regeneration: A New Model for Promoting Urban Justice?Jerusalem: Floersheimer Studies. (Hebrew)
30.
GevaYinnonRosenGillad. 2018. “The Regeneration Deal: Developers, Homeowners and New Competencies in the Development Process.” Geoforum96:10–20.
31.
GoetzEdward G.2013. New Deal Ruins: Race, Economic Justice, and Public Housing Policy. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
32.
HackworthJasonSmithNeil. 2001. “The Changing State of Gentrification.” Tijdschrift Voor Economische en Sociale Geografie92 (4): 464–77.
33.
HananelRavit. 2017. “From Central to Marginal: The Trajectory of Israel’s Public-Housing Policy.” Urban Studies54 (11): 2432–47.
34.
HassonShlomoLeyDavid. 1994. Neighborhood Organisations and the Welfare Stat. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
35.
HassonShlomoLeyDavid. 1997. “Neighborhood Organizations, the Welfare State, and Citizenship Rights.” Urban Affairs Review33 (1): 28–58.
36.
HyraDerek. 2015. “The Back-to-the-City Movement: Neighborhood Redevelopment and Processes of Political and Cultural Displacement.” Urban Studies52 (10): 1753–73.
37.
JakarGidon S.RazinEranRosentraubMark S.RosenGillad. 2018. “Sport Facility Development: Municipal Capital and Shutting out the Private Sector.” European Planning Studies26 (6): 1222–41.
38.
Jerusalem Municipality. 2016. Minutes of Planning Sub-committee 2016/11. Jerusalem: Office of Planning. (Hebrew)
39.
JunKyu NahmMussoJuliet. 2013. “Participatory Governance and the Spatial Representation of Neighborhood Issues.” Urban Affairs Review49 (1): 71–110.
40.
KathiPradeep ChandraCooperTerry L. 2005. “Democratizing the Administrative State: Connecting Neighborhood Councils and City Agencies.” Public Administration Review65 (5): 559–67.
41.
KingKaren N. 2004. “Neighborhood Associations and Urban Decision Making in Albuquerque.” Nonprofit Management and Leadership14 (4): 391–409.
42.
KingLester O.LoweJeffrey S. 2018. “‘We Want to Do It Differently’: Resisting Gentrification in Houston’s Northern Third Ward.” Journal of Urban Affairs40 (8): 1161–76.
43.
KuyucuTunaÜnsalÖzlem. 2010. “Urban Transformation as State-Led Property Transfer: An Analysis of Two Cases of Urban Renewal in Istanbul.” Urban Studies47 (7): 1479–99.
44.
LakeRobert. 2017. “Justice as Subject and Object of Planning.” International Journal of Urban and Regional Research40 (6): 1205–20.
45.
LaurianLucie. 2009. “Trust in Planning: Theoretical and Practical Considerations for Participatory and Deliberative Planning.” Planning Theory & Practice10 (3): 369–91.
46.
LaveeEinatCohenNissimNoumanHani. 2018. “Reinforcing Public Responsibility? Influences and Practices in Street-Level Bureaucrats’ Engagement in Policy Design.” Public Administration96 (2): 333–48.
47.
LelieveldtHermanDekkerKarienVölkerBeateTorenvliedRené. 2009. “Civic Organizations as Political Actors.” Urban Affairs Review45 (1): 3–24.
48.
MarcusePeterConnollyJamesNovyJohannesOlivoIngridPotterCuzSteilJustin. 2009. Searching for the Just City: Debates in Urban Theory and Practice. New York: Routledge.
49.
MargalitTalia. 2014. “Multi-Spot Zoning: A Chain of Public–Private Development Ventures in Tel Aviv.” Cities37:73–81.
50.
MargalitTaliaKempAdriana. 2019. “The Uneven Geographies of Post-Political Planning: Objections to Urban Regeneration Projects in Peripheral and Central Israeli Citie.” Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space51 (4): 931–49.
51.
Moriah Jerusalem Development Corporation. 2016. “The Nurit Street Memorandum. 24.07.2016.” Unpublished manuscript. (Hebrew)
52.
MualamNir. 2018. “Playing with Supertankers: Centralization in Land Use Planning in Israel—A National Experiment Underway.” Land Use Policy75:269–83.
NC Ganim vs Jerusalem District Planning Committee and Others. 2016. “The Jerusalem District Court Sitting as the Administrative Court 36250-10-16.” Unpublished manuscript. (Hebrew)
55.
Nitzan-ShiftanAlona. 2017. Seizing Jerusalem: The Architectures of Unilateral Unification. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
56.
ParkSunggeunMosleyJennifer E.GroganColleen M. 2018. “Do Residents of Low-Income Communities Trust Organizations to Speak on Their Behalf? Differences by Organizational Type.” Urban Affairs Review54 (1): 137–64.
57.
PorterLibbyShawKate. 2013. Whose Urban Renaissance?: An International Comparison of Urban Regeneration Strategies. London: Routledge.
58.
PurcellMark. 2006. “Urban Democracy and the Local Trap.” Urban Studies43 (11): 1921–41.
59.
ReeceJason W.2018. “In Pursuit of a Twenty-First Century Just City.” Journal of Planning Literature33 (3): 299–309.
60.
RosenGilladCharneyIgal. 2018. “Reaching New Heights: Post-Politicizing High-Rise Planning in Jerusalem.” Built Environment43 (4): 539–54.
61.
RosenGilladWalksAlan. 2015. “Castles in Toronto’s Sky: Condo-Ism as Urban Transformation.” Journal of Urban Affairs37 (3): 289–310.
62.
SchivelyCarissa. 2007. “Understanding the NIMBY and LULU Phenomena: Reassessing Our Knowledge Base and Informing Future Research.” Journal of Planning Literature21 (3): 255–66.
63.
ShternMarikYacobiHaim. 2019. “The Urban Geopolitics of Neighboring: Conflict, Encounter and Class in Jerusalem’s Settlement/Neighborhood.” Urban Geography40 (4): 467–87.
64.
SingerMatan E.RosenGillad. 2019. “Rethinking Responses towards Group-Homes: Inclusionary Legislation, Supportive Municipal Attitudes, and Place-Based Opposition.” Social & Cultural Geography20 (3): 344–66.
StoeckerRandy. 1997. “The CDC Model of Urban Redevelopment: A Critique and an Alternative.” Journal of Urban Affairs19 (1): 1–22.
67.
UitermarkJustusBoskerTjerk. 2014. “Wither the ‘Undivided City’? An Assessment of State-Sponsored Gentrification in Amsterdam.” Tijdschrift Voor Economische en Sociale Geografie105 (2): 221–30.
68.
Viapland and Ganim NC. n.d. Implementing Social Considerations in an Urban Redevelopment Project: The Nurit Stret Cimound. Unpublished report. (Hebrew)
Yinon-AmoyalEinatKallusRachel. 2005. “The Neighborhood Council: Where ‘Top-down’ Engages with ‘Bottom-Up.’” Geojournal64 (2): 91–104.
71.
ZabanHila. 2016. “In the Name of Pluralism: Fighting the (Perceived) Ultraorthodox Penetration in the Baka Neighborhood of Jerusalem.” Israel Studies21 (3): 153-178.
72.
ZabanHila. 2019. “Whose Neighborhood is It? On Belonging and Neighborhood Citizenship in the Baka Neighborhood of Jerusalem.” In Diversity and Turbulence in Contemporary Global Migration, edited by WalthrustNatalie Jones, 131–40. Leiden: Brill Publishers.
73.
ZapataMarisa A.BatesLisa K. 2015. “Equity Planning Revisited.” Journal of Planning Education and Research35 (3): 245–48.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
