Accessory dwelling units (ADUs) are a strategy for providing affordable rental housing. We suggest a typology of regulatory approaches in Long Island, New York, differentiating between jurisdictions that allow nonfamily/nondomestic employee renters in ADUs (Type 1), allow only family members and domestic employees in ADUs (Type 2), and do not allow any ADUs (Type 3). Content analysis, descriptive statistics, and t tests reveal that there is variation among occupancy and design regulations, suggesting that jurisdictional fragmentation and exclusionary zoning present obstacles to using ADUs as an affordable housing strategy.
AltusDeborah E.XaveriusPamela K.MathewsR. MarkKosloskiKarl D.2002. “Evaluating the Impact of Elder Cottage Housing on Residents and their Hosts.” Journal of Clinical Geropsychology8 (2): 117–37. doi:10.1023/A:1014672625735.
2.
American Public Transportation Association. 2017. Public Transportation Ridership Report: Fourth Quarter 2016. Washington, DC: American Public Transportation Association.
3.
AnackerKatrin B.LiYanmei. 2016. “Rental Housing Affordability of U.S. Renters during the Great Recession, 2007 to 2009.” Housing and Society43 (1): 1–17. doi:10.1080/08882746.2016.1160556.
4.
AntoninettiMaurizio. 2008. “The Difficult History of Ancillary Units: The Obstacles and Potential Opportunities to Increase the Heterogeneity of Neighborhoods and the Flexibility of Households in the United States.” Journal of Housing for the Elderly22 (4): 348–75. doi:10.1080/02763890802458320.
5.
AschChris MyersMusgroveGeorge Derek. 2017. Chocolate City: A History of Race and Democracy in the Nation’s Capital. Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press.
6.
BaxandallRosalynEwenElizabeth. 2000. Picture Windows: How the Suburbs Happened. New York: Basic Books.
7.
BeenVickiGrossBenjaminInfrancaJon. 2014. Responding to Changing Households: Regulatorym Challenges for Micro-Units and Accessory Dwelling Units. New York: NYU Furman Center.
8.
BorchertJames. 1980. Alley Life in Washington: Family, Community, Religion, and Folklife in the City. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
9.
BrinigMargaret F.GarnettNicole Stelle. 2013. “A Room of One’s Own? Accessory Dwelling Unit Reforms and Local Parochialism.” Journal Articles, Paper 286. Notre Dame Law School, Notre Dame.
10.
BrownAnneMukhijaVinitShoupDonald. Forthcoming . “Converting Garages into Housing.” Journal of Planning Education and Research.
11.
BrownBarbara B.CropperVivian L.2001. “New Urban and Standard Suburban Subdivisions: Evaluating Psychological and Social Goals.” Journal of the American Planning Association67 (4): 402–19. doi:10.1080/01944360108976249.
12.
BrownMartin JohnPalmeriJordan. 2014. Accessory Dwelling Units in Portland, Oregon: Evaluation and Interpretation of a Survey of ADU Owners. Portland: State of Oregon Department of Environmental Quality.
13.
BrownMartin JohnWatkinsTaylor. 2012. “Understanding and Appraising Properties with Accessory Dwelling Units.” The Appraisal Journal80 (4): 297–308.
14.
BuhrJenni. 1990. “Levittown as a Utopian Community.” In Long Island: The Suburban Experience, edited by KellyBarbara M., 67–78. Interlaken, NY: Heart of the Lakes Publishing.
15.
BukerGerald E.2015. “A Study of Backyard Cottage Policy in Seattle, Washington: Existing Conditions Study, Capacity Analysis, and Survey in Conjunction with Seattle’s Department of Planning and Development.” Master’s thesis. University of Washington, Seattle.
16.
CampoliJulieMacLeanAlex S.2007. Visualizing Density. Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.
17.
Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation. 2015. Literature Review and Case Studies of Local Jurisdictions That Permit Secondary Suites. Ottawa: Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation.
18.
ChappleKaren. 2015. Planning Sustainable Cities and Regions: Towards More Equitable Development. New York: Routledge.
19.
ChappleKarenWegmannJakeMashhoodFarzadColemanRebecca. 2017. Jumpstarting the Market for Accessory Dwelling Units: Lessons Learned from Portland, Seattle, and Vancouver. San Francisco: Urban Land Institute San Francisco, Terner Center for Housing Innovation, and Center for Community Innovation.
20.
ChappleKarenWegmannJakeNemirowAlisonDentel-PostColin. 2012. Yes in My Backyard: Mobilizing the Market for Secondary Units. Berkeley: Center for Community Innovation.
21.
CobbRodney L.DvorakScott. 2000. Accessory Dwelling Units: Model State Act and Local Ordinance. Washington, DC: AARP.
Community Advocates. 2006. “Accessory Housing: Report and Guide to Successful Programs.” Community Advocates, Roslyn Heights, NY.
24.
CuffDanaHigginsT.DahlPer-Johan, eds. 2010. Backyard Homes LA. Los Angeles: cityLAB, UCLA Department of Architecture and Urban Design.
25.
DeRiggiMildred Murphy. 2000. “Preserving Nassau County’s Heritage in Museums and Parks.” In Nassau County: From Rural Hinterland to Suburban Metropolis, edited by KriegJoann P.NaylorNatalie A., 126–36. Interlaken, NY: Empire State Books.
26.
DiCarloAntonio S.ProsperVera. 2012. “Match-Up Home Sharing Program.” In Livable New York for All Ages: A Community Resource Manual for Future-Based, Inclusive Planning, Livable Communities, Aging-in-Place, Sustainable Neighborhoods, Section III.1g, 1–10. Albany: New York State Office for the Aging. https://aging.ny.gov/LivableNY/ResourceManual/TableOfContents.pdf
27.
DolgonCorey. 2005. The End of the Hamptons: Scenes from the Class Struggle in America’s Paradise. New York: New York University Press.
28.
DonovanShaun. 2013. Secretary Donovan Highlights Convening on State of America’s Rental Housing. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
29.
DorinsonJoseph. 1990. “The Suburbanization of Brooklyn: Persistence without Plan.” In Long Island: The Suburban Experience, edited by KellyBarbara M., 14–23. Interlaken, NY: Heart of the Lakes Publishing.
30.
DuffShelly. 2012. “The Possibilities in Neighborhoods: Utilizing Accessory Apartments in Existing Homes to Address Social, Environmental, and Economic Issues.” Urban Design International17 (1): 33–44. doi:10.1057/udi.2011.19.
31.
Dunham-JonesEllenWilliamsonJune. 2011. Retrofitting Suburbia: Urban Design Solutions for Redesigning Suburbs. New York: Wiley.
32.
FarberNicholasShinkleDouglasLynottJanaFox-GrageWendyHarrellRodney. 2011. Aging in Place: A State Survey of Livability Policies and Practices. Washington, DC: AARP.
33.
FearonPeter. 1998. Hamptons Babylon: Life among the Super-Rich on America’s Rivera. Secaucus, NJ: Birch Lane Press.
34.
FischelWilliam A.2001. The Homevoter Hypothesis: How Home Values Influence Local Government Taxation, School Finance, and Land-Use Policies. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
35.
GainesSteven. 1998. Philistines at the Hedgerow: Passion and Property in the Hamptons. Boston: Little, Brown.
36.
GalsterGeorge C.TatianPeter A.SantiagoAnna M.PettitKathryn L. S.SmithRobin E.2003. Why Not in My Backyard? Neighborhood Impacts of Deconcentrating Assisted Housing. New Brunswick, NJ: Center for Urban Policy Research.
37.
GellenMartin. 1985. Accessory Apartments in Single-Family Housing. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
38.
GordonDiana R.2015. Village of Immigrants: Latinos in an Emerging America. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
39.
HarePeter H.1982. “Why Granny Flats are a Good Idea.” Planning48 (2): 15–16.
40.
HarePeter H.1989a. Accessory Units: The State of the Art. Washington, DC: Patrick H. Hare Planning and Design.
41.
HarePeter H.1989b. Accessory Units: The State of the Art: Report IV: Survey of Installations of Accessory Units in Communities Where They Are Legal. Washington, DC: Patrick H. Hare Planning and Design.
42.
HarePeter H.1991a. Accessory Units: The State of the Art: Report III: Model Zoning: Provisions, Processes, and Examples from Successful Communities. Washington, DC: Patrick H. Hare Planning and Design.
43.
HarePeter H.1991b. “The Echo Housing/Granny Flat Experience in the U.S.” In Granny Flats as Housing for the Elderly: International Perspectives, edited by LazarowichMicheal, 57–70. New York: The Haworth Press.
44.
HarePeter H.1992. Accessory Units: The State of the Art: A Continually Updated Manual: Report II: Selected Resource Guide to Accessory Units. Washington, DC: Patrick H. Hare Planning and Design.
45.
HarrisonMarjorie Freeman. 2000. “Italian-American Inwood and the Making of the Modern Nassau Republican Party.” In Nassau County: From Rural Hinterland to Suburban Metropolis, edited by KriegJoann P.NaylorNatalie A., 95–108. Interlaken, NY: Empire State Books.
46.
HoweDeborah A.1990. “The Flexible House: Designing for Changing Needs.” Journal of the American Planning Association56 (1): 69–77. doi:10.1080/01944369008975746.
47.
JacksonKenneth T.1985. Crabgrass Frontier: The Suburbanization of the United States. New York: Oxford University Press.
48.
JakabovicsAndrewRossLynn M.SpottsMichaelSimpsonMolly. 2014. Bending the Cost Curve: Solutions to Expand the Supply of Affordable Rentals. Washington, DC: Urban Land Institute.
49.
Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University. 2013. America’s Rental Housing: Evolving Markets and Needs. Cambridge: Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University.
50.
Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University. 2014. Housing America’s Older Adults: Meeting the Needs of an Aging Population. Cambridge: Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University.
KellyBarbara M.1990. “Long Island: A Suburban Place.” In Long Island: The Suburban Experience, edited by KellyBarbara M., 7–11. Interlaken, NY: Heart of the Lakes Publishing.
53.
KiernanJohn B.2000. “The Creation of the Nassau County Legislature.” In Nassau County: From Rural Hinterland to Suburban Metropolis, edited by KriegJoann P.NaylorNatalie A., 137–42. Interlaken, NY: Empire State Books.
54.
KroesslerJeffrey A.1990. “Suburban Growth, Urban Style Patterns of Growth in the Borough of Queens.” In Long Island: The Suburban Experience, edited by KellyBarbara M., 24–35. Interlaken, NY: Heart of the Lakes Publishing.
55.
LiebigPhoebe S.KoenigTeresaPynoosJon. 2006. “Zoning, Accessory Dwelling Units, and Family Caregiving.” Journal of Aging and Social Policy18 (3–4): 155–72. doi:10.1300/J031v18n3_11.
56.
LipmanBarbaraLubellJeffreySalomonEmily. 2012. Housing an Aging Population: Are We Prepared?Washington, DC: Center for Housing Policy.
57.
Long Island Index. 2007. A Tale of Two Suburbs: A Case Study Comparing Governance, Taxes and Local Services on Long Island and in Northern Virginia: Executive Summary. Garden City, NY: Long Island Index.
58.
Long Island Index. 2015. Housing Choice and Affordability on Long Island and beyond: A Survey of Suburban New York Metro Area Residents. Garden City, NY: Long Island Index.
59.
MahlerSarah J.1995. Salvadorans in Suburbia: Symbiosis and Conflict. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
60.
McGeeDorothy Horton. 2000. “The Naming of Nassau County.” In Nassau County: From Rural Hinterland to Suburban Metropolis, edited by KriegJoann P.NaylorNatalie A., 158–65. Interlaken, NY: Empire State Books.
61.
MitchellRyan. 2014. Tiny House Living: Ideas for Building and Living Well in Less than 400 Square Feet. New York: F+W Media.
62.
MooreElizabeth. 2017. Home Remedies: Accessory Apartments on Long Island: Lessons Learned. Garden City, NY: Long Island Index.
63.
MooreSteven A.PalleroniSergio, eds. 2008. The Alley Flat Initiative: Topics in Sustainable Development 2008 Report. Austin: Center for Sustainable Development.
MorrisTom. 1989. “Planners Say LI Needs its Illegal Apartments and Must Declare . . . Amnesty.” Newsday, December8.
66.
MukhijaVinit. 2014. “Outlaw In-Laws: Informal Second Units and the Stealth Reinvention of Single-family Housing.” In The Informal American City: Beyond Taco Trucks and Day Labor, edited by MukhijaVinitLoukaitou-SiderisAnna, 39–57. Cambridge: MIT Press.
67.
MukhijaVinitCuffDanaSerranoKimberly. 2014. Backyard Homes and Local Concerns: How Can Local Concerns Be Better Addressed?Los Angeles: UCLA Luskin School of Public Affairs and cityLAB.
68.
MullonSharon. 2013. Long Island’s Rental Housing Crisis. New York: Regional Plan Association.
National Low Income Housing Coalition. 2015. Out of Reach: Low Wages and High Rents Lock Renters Out. Washington, DC: National Low Income Housing Coalition.
72.
Newsday. 1978. Long Island at a Crossroads. (series)
73.
New York State. 2006. Strategies for a New Age: New York State’s Transportation Master Plan for 2030. Albany: Department of Transportation.
74.
NicholsJane LouiseAdamsErin. 2013. “The Flex-Nest: The Accessory Dwelling Unit as Adaptable Housing for the Life Span.” Interiors4 (1): 31–52. doi:10.2752/204191213X13601683874136.
75.
NiedtChristopherAnackerKatrin B.2016. Accessory Dwellings on Long Island: An Overview. Hempstead, NY: National Center for Suburban Studies at Hofstra University.
76.
PalmieriThomas Joseph. 2000. “History of Hospitals in Nassau County.” In Nassau County: From Rural Hinterland to Suburban Metropolis, edited by KriegJoann P.NaylorNatalie A., 207–11. Interlaken, NY: Empire State Books.
77.
PetersonKol. 2018. Backdoor Revolution: The Definitive Guide to ADU Development. Portland: Building an ADU.
78.
PfeifferDeirdre. 2015. “Retrofitting Suburbia through Second Units: Lessons from the Phoenix Region.” Journal of Urbanism: International Research on Placemaking and Urban Sustainability8 (3): 279–301.
PollakP. Baron. 1994. “Rethinking Zoning to Accommodate the Elderly in Single Family Housing.” Journal of the American Planning Association60 (4): 521–31. doi:10.1080/01944369408975608.
81.
PollakP. Baron. 1996. “Zoning as a Tool for Shared Housing.” In Under One Roof: Issues and Innovations in Shared Housing, edited by HemmensGeorge C.HochCharles J.CarpJana, 107–113. Albany: State University of New York Press.
82.
RattinerDan. 2008. In the Hamptons: My Fifty Years with Farmers, Fishermen, Artists, Billionaires, and Celebrities. New York: Three Rivers Press.
83.
RattinerDan. 2010. In the Hamptons Too: Further Encounters with Farmers, Fishermen, Artists, Billionaires, and Celebrities. Albany: Excelsior Editions.
84.
RattinerDan. 2012. Still in the Hamptons: More Tales of the Rich, the Famous, and the Rest of Us. Albany: Excelsior Editions.
85.
RattinerDan. 2015. In the Hamptons Forever: Mostly True Tales from the East End. Albany: Excelsior Editions.
86.
RattrayEverett T.1979. The South Fork: The Land and the People of Eastern Long Island. Wainscott, NY: Pushcart Press.
87.
Regional Real Estate Consultants. 1990. Accessory Apartments: Characteristics, Issues, Opportunities. Ottawa: Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation.
88.
RetsinasJoanRetsinasNicolas P.1991. “Accessory Apartment Conversion Programs.” Journal of Aging and Social Policy3 (1/2): 73–89. doi:10.1300/J031v03n017_07.
89.
RosenbaumHerbert D.2000. “Reflections on Nassau County’s Suburban Politics.” In Nassau County: From Rural Hinterland to Suburban Metropolis, edited by KriegJoann P.NaylorNatalie A., 118–25. Interlaken, NY: Empire State Books.
90.
RoyNelson B.2016. Bending the Cost Curve for Economical Housing by Design. Sarasota, FL: Nelson B. Roy.
91.
RudelThomas K.1984. “Household Change, Accessory Apartments, and Low Income Housing in Suburbs.” Professional Geographer36 (2): 174–81. doi:10.1111/j.0033-0124.1984.00174.x.
92.
SchwartzAlex F.2015. Housing Policy in the United States. New York: Routledge.
93.
ShellandJames. 2000. “Executive Power: A Comparison of Styles.” In Nassau County: From Rural Hinterland to Suburban Metropolis, edited by KriegJoann P.NaylorNatalie A., 109–17. Interlaken, NY: Empire State Books.
94.
SmitsEdward J.2000. “An Ecodeterminist View of Nassau’s Growth.” In Nassau County: From Rural Hinterland to Suburban Metropolis, edited by KriegJoann P.NaylorNatalie A., 167–75. Interlaken, NY: Empire State Books.
95.
SpeckJeff. 2012. Walkable City: How Downtown Can Save America, One Step at a Time. New York: North Point Press.
96.
SteffenBarry L.FudgeKeithMartinMargeSouzaMaria TeresaVandenbrouckeDavid A.YaoYung-Gann David. 2011. Worst Case Housing Needs 2009: Report to Congress. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
SusankaSarahObolenskyKira. 2009. The Not So Big House: A Blueprint for the Way We Really Live. Newtown, CT: Taunton Press.
100.
TachievaGalina. 2010. Sprawl Repair Manual. Washington, DC: Island Press.
101.
TeafordJon C.2000. “Nassau County: A Pioneer of the Crabgrass Frontier.” In Nassau County: From Rural Hinterland to Suburban Metropolis, edited by KriegJoann P.NaylorNatalie A., 26–37. Interlaken, NY: Empire State Books.
102.
Tri-State Regional Planning Commission. 1981. Legalizing Single Family Conversions. New York: Tri-State Regional Planning Commission.
103.
U.S. Bureau of the Census. 2010. Decennial 2010 Census. Washington, DC: U.S. Bureau of the Census.
104.
U.S. Bureau of the Census. n.d.-a. American Community Survey 2009-2013. Washington, DC: U.S. Bureau of the Census.
105.
U.S. Bureau of the Census. n.d.-b. American Community Survey 2015. Washington, DC: U.S. Bureau of the Census.
106.
U.S. Bureau of the Census. n.d.-c. Annual Estimates of the Resident Population: April 1, 2010 to July 1, 2017: 2017 Population Estimates. Washington, DC: U.S. Bureau of the Census.
107.
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. n.d. Affordable Housing. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
108.
VaradyDavid P.1988. “Factors Affecting Middle-Income Elderly Interest in Accessory Apartment Conversion.” The Journal of Architectural and Planning Research5 (1): 81–88.
109.
VaradyDavid P.1990. “Which Elderly Home Owners are Interested in Accessory Apartment Conversion and Home-Sharing.” Journal of Housing for the Elderly6 (1): 87–100. doi:10.1300/J081V06N01_06.
110.
Village of Euclid, Ohio v. Ambler Realty Co. 1926. 272 U.S. 365, 389-9.
111.
WatsonNicole ElsasserSteffenBarry L.MartinMargeVandenbrouckeDavid A.2017. Worst Case Housing Needs: 2017 Report to Congress. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
112.
WegmannJake. 2015. “Research Notes: The Hidden Cityscapes of Informal Housing in suburban Los Angeles and the Paradox of Horizontal Density.” Buildings and Landscapes: Journal of the Vernacular Architecture Forum22 (2): 89–110.
113.
WegmannJakeMawhorterSarah. 2017. “Measuring Informal Housing Production in California Cities.” Journal of the American Planning Association83 (2): 119–30. doi:10.1080/01944363.2017.1288162.
114.
WegmannJakeNemirowAlison. 2011. Secondary Units and Urban Infill: A Literature Review. Berkeley: University of California.
115.
WhiteThomas W.WilkinsCharles S.PintoEdward J.2016. Economical Rental Housing by Design for Communities That Work. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute.
116.
WilliamsonJune. 2013. Designing Suburban Futures: New Models from Build a Better Burb. Washington, DC: Island Press.
117.
WinscheRichard A.HammondGary R.1990. “The Evolution of the Gould/Guggenheim Estate at Sands Point.” In Long Island: The Suburban Experience, edited by KellyBarbara M., 39–49. Interlaken, NY: Heart of the Lakes Publishing.
118.
WithersDawn. 2012–2013. “Looking for a Home: How Micro-Housing Can Help California.” Golden Gate University Environmental Law Journal6:125–52.
119.
WoetzelJonathanMischkeJanPeloquinShannonWeisfieldDaniel. 2016. A Tool Kit to Close California’s Housing Gap: 3.5 Million Homes by 2025. Los Angeles: McKinsey.
120.
ZontaMichela. 2016. Housing the Extended Family. Washington, DC: Center for American Progress.
