This research examines the mismatch between the reality of a city’s population loss and the planning strategies they have adopted. Thirty-five depopulating U.S. cities’ comprehensive plans are analyzed to determine whether they are acknowledging past depopulation trends, how they are projecting future population changes, and what planning strategies they are pursuing in light of their depopulation trends. Findings illustrate a majority of cities acknowledge depopulation; however, they rely on optimistic population projections for the future. Despite this, a mix of planning strategies, ranging from smart decline to pro-growth, are used regardless of a city’s acknowledgment/acceptance of population loss.
AalbersManuel B.BerntMatthias. 2019. “The Political Economy of Managing Decline and Rightsizing.” Urban Geography40:165–73. doi:10.1080/02723638.2018.1524654
BeauregardRobert A.2009. “Urban Population Loss in Historical Perspective: United States, 1820–2000.” Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space41 (3): 514–28.
4.
BeckmanBen. 2010. “The Wholesale Decommissioning of Vacant Urban Neighborhoods: Smart Decline, Public-Purpose Takings, and the Legality of Shrinking Cities.” Cleveland State Law Review58 (387): 387–461.
5.
BerkePhilipGodschalkDavid. 2009. “Searching for the Good Plan: A Meta-Analysis of Plan Quality Studies.” Journal of Planning Literature23 (3): 227–40.
6.
BerkePhilip R.ConroyMaria Manta. 2000. “Are We Planning for Sustainable Development? An Evaluation of 30 Comprehensive Plans.” Journal of the American Planning Association66 (1): 21–33.
7.
BerkePhilip R.GodschalkDavidKaiserEdward J.RodriguezDaniel A.2006. Urban Land Use Planning. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
8.
BerntMatthias. 2009. “Partnerships for Demolition: The Governance of Urban Renewal in East Germany’s Shrinking Cities.” International Journal of Urban and Regional Research33 (3): 754–69.
9.
BerntMatthiasHaaseAnnegretGroßmannKatrinCocksMatthewCouchChrisCorteseCaterinaKrzysztofikRobert. 2014. “How Does(n’t) Urban Shrinkage get onto the Agenda? Experiences from Leipzig, Liverpool, Genoa and Bytom.” International Journal of Urban and Regional Research38 (5): 1749–66.
CoppolaAlessandro. 2019. “Projects of Becoming in a Right-Sizing Shrinking City.” Urban Geography40:237–56. doi:10.1080/02723638.2017.1421391
12.
Cunningham-SabotEmmanuèleRothHélène. 2013. “Growth Paradigm against Urban Shrinkage: A Standardized Fight? The Cases of Glasgow (UK) and Saint-Etienne (France).” In Shrinking Cities: International Perspectives and Policy Implications, edited by PallagstKarinaWiechmannThorstenMartinez-FernandezCristina, 99–124. New York: Routledge.
13.
Cunningham-SabotEmmanuèleAudiracIvonneFolSylvieMartinez-FernandezCristina. 2013. “Theoretical Approaches of Shrinking Cities.” In Shrinking Cities: International Perspectives and Policy Implications, edited by PallagstKarinaWiechmannThorstenMartinez-FernandezCristina, 14–50. New York: Routledge.
FolSylvie. 2012. “Urban Shrinkage and Socio-Spatial Disparities: Are the Remedies Worse than the Disease?” Built Environment38 (2): 259–75.
19.
FrazierAmy E.Bagchi-SenSharmisthaKnightJason. 2013. “The Spatio-Temporal Impacts of Demolition Land Use Policy and Crime in a Shrinking City.” Applied Geography41:55–64.
GroßmannKatrinBontjeMarcoHaaseAnnegretMykhnenkoVlad. 2013. “Shrinking Cities: Notes for the Further Research Agenda.” Cities35:221–25.
22.
HaaseAnnegretRinkDieterGrossmannKatrinBerntMatthiasMykhnenkoVlad. 2014. “Conceptualizing Urban Shrinkage.” Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space4:1519–34.
23.
HaaseDagmarHaaseAnnegretRinkDieter. 2014. “Conceptualizing the Nexus between Urban Shrinkage and Ecosystem Services.” Landscape and Urban Planning132:159–69.
24.
HackworthJason. 2014. “The Limits to Market-Based Strategies for Addressing Land Abandonment in Shrinking American Cities.” Progress in Planning90:1–37.
25.
HallHeather M.2009. “Slow Growth and Decline in Greater Sudbury: Challenges, Opportunities, and Foundations for a New Planning Agenda.” Canadian Journal of Urban Research18 (1): 1–26.
26.
HarttMaxwellHackworth.Jason2018. “Shrinking Cities, Shrinking Households, or Both?” International Journal of Urban and Regional Research. Published electronically November10. doi:10.1111/1468-2427.12713.
27.
HarttMaxwellWarkentinJoshua. 2017. “The Development and Revitalisation of Shrinking Cities: A Twin City Comparison.” Town Planning Review88 (1): 29–41.
28.
HarveyDavid. 1989. “From Managerialism to Entrepreneurialism: The Transformation in Urban Governance in Late Capitalism.” Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography71 (1): 3–17.
29.
HoekstraMyrte S.HochstenbachCodyBontjeMarco A.MusterdSako. 2018. “Shrinkage and Housing Inequality: Policy Responses to Population Decline and Class Change.” Journal of Urban Affairs. Published electronically May9, 1–18. doi:10.1080/07352166.2018.1457407.
30.
HollanderJustin B.2010. “Moving toward a Shrinking Cities Metric: Analyzing Land Use Changes Associated with Depopulation in Flint, Michigan.” Cityscape: A Journal of Policy Development and Research12 (1): 133–52.
31.
HollanderJustin B.2011. “Can a City Successfully Shrink? Evidence from Survey Data on Neighborhood Quality.” Urban Affairs Review, Research Note47 (1): 129–41.
32.
HollanderJustin B.2013. “Contemporary Perceptions of Nine Decades of Depopulation in New Bedford, Massachusetts.” Urban Design International18 (1): 6–23.
33.
HollanderJustin B.CahillBernard. 2011. “Confronting Population Decline in the Buffalo, New York, Region: A Close Reading of the Erie-Niagara Framework for Regional Growth.” Journal of Architectural and Planning Research28(3): 252–67.
LoganJohn R.MolotchHarvey L.1987. “The City as a Growth Machine.” In The Gentrification Debates: A Reader, edited by FainsteinSusanCampbellScott, 82–102. New York: Routledge.
40.
NémethJeremyHollanderJustin B.2016. “Right-Sizing Shrinking Cities: A Landscape and Design Strategy for Abandoned Properties.” Journal of Landscape Architecture11 (2): 90–100.
OswaltPhilippRienietsTim. 2006. Atlas of Shrinking Cities. Ostfildern, Germany: Hatje Cantz.
46.
PallagstKarina. 2009. “Shrinking Cities in the United States of America.” In The Future of Shrinking Cities: Problems, Patterns and Strategies of Urban Transformation in a Global Context, edited by PallagstKarinaet al., 81–88. Los Angeles: University of California.
47.
PallagstKarinaFleschurzRenéSaidSiba. 2017a. “What Drives Planning in a Shrinking City? Tales from Two German and Two American Cases.” Town Planning Review88:15–28.
48.
PallagstKarinaMulliganHelenCunningham-SabotEmmanuèleFolSylvie. 2017b. “The Shrinking City Awakens: Perceptions and Strategies on the way to Revitalisation?” Town Planning Review88 (1): 9–13.
49.
PedroniThomas C.2011. “Urban Shrinkage as a Performance of Whiteness: Neoliberal Urban Restructuring, Education, and Racial Containment in the Post-Industrial, Global Niche City.” Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education3 (2): 203–15.
ReckienDianaMartinez-FernandezCristina. 2011. “Why do Cities Shrink?” European Planning Studies19 (8): 1375–97.
53.
RhodesJames. 2019. “Revitalizing the Neighborhood: The Practices and Politics of Rightsizing in Idora, Youngstown.” Urban Geography40:215–36. doi:10.1080/02723638.2016.1258179.
54.
RhodesJamesRussoJohn. 2013. “Shrinking ‘Smart’? Urban Redevelopment and Shrinkage in Youngstown, Ohio.” Urban Geography34 (3): 305–26.
55.
RyanBrent D.2008. “The Restructuring of Detroit: City Block Form Change in a Shrinking City, 1900–2000.” Urban Design International13 (3): 156–68.
56.
RybczynskiWitoldLinnemanPeter D.1999. “How to Save Our Shrinking Cities.” Public Interest135:30–44.
57.
SchatzLaura. 2017. “Going for Growth and Managing Decline: the Complex Mix of Planning Strategies in Broken Hill, NSW, Australia.” Town Planning Review88 (1): 43–57.
58.
SchetkeSophieHaaseDagmar. 2008. “Multi-Criteria Assessment of Socio-Environmental Aspects in Shrinking Cities. Experiences from Eastern Germany.” Environmental Impact Assessment Review28 (7): 483–503.
59.
SchillingJosephLoganJonathan. 2008. “Greening the Rust Belt: A Green Infrastructure Model for Right Sizing America’s Shrinking Cities.” Journal of the American Planning Association74 (4): 451–66.
ShettySujataReidNeil. 2013. “Global Challenges and Local Responses: Creating a new Urban World in the Shrinking Cities of the US Industrial Midwest.” Regional Science Policy & Practice5 (2): 201–17.
62.
SilvermanRobert MarkYinLiPattersonKelly L.2015. “Municipal Property Acquisition Patterns in a Shrinking City: Evidence for the Persistence of an Urban Growth Paradigm in Buffalo, NY.” Cogent Social Sciences1 (1): 1–22.
63.
SousaSílviaPinhoPaulo. 2015. “Planning for Shrinkage: Paradox or Paradigm.” European Planning Studies23 (1): 12–32.
TigheJ. RosieGanningJoanna P.2016. “Do Shrinking Cities Allow Redevelopment Without Displacement? An Analysis of Affordability Based on Housing and Transportation Costs for Redeveloping, Declining, and Stable Neighborhoods.” Housing Policy Debate26 (4–5): 785–800.
WachsM.2016. “The Past, Present, and Future of Professional Ethics in Planning.” In Readings in Planning Theory, edited by FainsteinSusan S.DefilippisJames, 4th ed., 464–79. Malden: MA: Wiley-Blackwell.
68.
WeaverRussellHoltkampChris. 2015. “Geographical Approaches to Understanding Urban Decline: From Evolutionary Theory to Political Economy… and Back?” Geography Compass9 (5): 286–302.
69.
WeaverRussellBagchi-SenSharmisthaKnightJasonFrazierAmy E.2017. Shrinking Cities: Understanding Urban Decline in the United States. New York, NY: Routledge.
70.
WiechmannThorstenPallagstKarina M.2012. “Urban Shrinkage in Germany and the USA: A Comparison of Transformation Patterns and Local Strategies.” International Journal of Urban and Regional Research36 (2): 261–80.
WilsonTomUeffingPhilippBellMartin. 2015. “Spatially Consistent Local Area Population Estimates for Australia, 1986–2011.” Journal of Population Research32 (3–4): 285–96.
