Why do militant groups decide to escalate or deescalate their use of violence in conflict? Examining the case of the “Troubles” in Northern Ireland, we analyze groups that adopt violence as a political strategy and evaluate factors that influence its application. To do so, we adopt a novel empirical approach to the study of militant groups. Drawn from information science, this approach enables estimation of variable influence and uncertainty within structured case studies, and is thus ideal for topics such as militant decision-making where systematic data collection is difficult.
ArjonaA (2016) Institutions, civilian resistance, and wartime social order: A process-driven natural experiment in the Colombian civil war. Latin American Politics and Society58(3): 99–122.
2.
AsalVRethemeyerRK (2008) The nature of the beast: Organizational structures and the lethality of terrorist attacks. The Journal of Politics70(2): 437–449.
3.
BaeleSJBoydKACoanTG (2019) ISIS Propaganda: A Full-spectrum Extremist Message. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
4.
BejanVParkinWS (2015) Examining the effect of repressive and conciliatory government actions on terrorism activity in Israel. Economics Letters133: 55–58.
5.
BellSRMurdieA (2018) The apparatus for violence: Repression, violent protest, and civil war in a cross-national framework. Conflict Management and Peace Science35(4): 336–354.
6.
BennettH (2010) From direct rule to motorman: Adjusting British military strategy for Northern Ireland in 1972. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism33(6): 511–532.
7.
BermanELaitinDD (2008) Religion, terrorism and public goods: Testing the club model. Journal of Public Economics92(10–11): 1942–1967.
8.
BermanEShapiroJNFelterJH (2011) Can hearts and minds be bought? The economics of counterinsurgency in Iraq. Journal of Political Economy119(4): 766–819.
9.
BloomM (2004) Palestinian suicide bombing: Public support, market share, and outbidding. Political Science Quarterly119(1): 61–88.
10.
BosiL (2012) Explaining pathways to armed activism in the provisional Irish Republican Army, 1969–1972. Social Science History36(3): 347–390.
11.
BruceS (1992) The Red Hand: Protestant Paramilitaries in Northern Ireland. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
12.
Bueno De MesquitaEDicksonES (2007) The propaganda of the deed: Terrorism, counterterrorism, and mobilization. American Journal of Political Science51(2): 364–381.
13.
BymanD (2006) Do targeted killings work. Foreign Affairs85(2): 95–111.
14.
ChartersDA (1977) Intelligence and psychological warfare operations in Northern Ireland. The RUSI Journal122(3): 22–27.
15.
ChatagnierJTMintzASambanY (2012) The decision calculus of terrorist leaders. Perspectives on Terrorism6(4/5): 125–144.
16.
DrozdovaKGaubatzKT (2014) Reducing uncertainty: Information analysis for comparative case studies. International Studies Quarterly58(3): 633–645.
17.
DuganLChenowethE (2012) Moving beyond deterrence: The effectiveness of raising the expected utility of abstaining from terrorism in Israel. American Sociological Review77(4): 597–624.
18.
EastinJGadeEK (2018) Beheading the hydra: Counterinsurgent violence and insurgent attacks in Iraq. Terrorism and Political Violence30(3): 384–407.
19.
EnglishR (2003) Armed Struggle. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
20.
FarrallL (2011) How al Qaeda works: What the organization’s subsidiaries say about its strength. Foreign Affairs90(2): 128–138.
21.
FeinsteinJSKaplanEH (2010) Analysis of a strategic terror organization. Journal of Conflict Resolution54(2): 281–302.
22.
FeldmanA (1991) Formations of Violence: The Narrative of the Body and Political Terror in Northern Ireland. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
23.
FindleyMGYoungJK (2007) Fighting fire with fire? How (not) to neutralize an insurgency. Civil Wars9(4): 378–401.
24.
FreemanM (2014) A theory of terrorist leadership (and its consequences for leadership targeting). Terrorism and Political Violence26(4): 666–687.
25.
GillPLeeJRethemeyerKR, et al. (2014) Lethal connections: The determinants of network connections in the provisional Irish republican army, 1970– 1998. International Interactions40(1): 52–78.
26.
HafezMMHatfieldJM (2006) Do targeted assassinations work? A multivariate analysis of Israel’s controversial tactic during al-aqsa uprising. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism29(4): 359–382.
27.
HorganJTaylorM (1997) The provisional Irish Republican army: Command and functional structure. Terrorism and Political Violence9(3): 1–32.
28.
HorowitzSYeM (2013) Targeting civilians in ethno-territorial wars: Power-and preference-based sources of ethnic cleansing and mass killing strategies. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism36(5): 372–393.
29.
HovilLWerkerE (2005) Portrait of a failed rebellion: An account of rational, sub-optimal violence in western Uganda. Rationality and Society17(1): 5–34.
30.
HsuHYMcDowallD (2020) Examining the state repression–terrorism nexus: Dynamic relationships among repressive counterterrorism actions, terrorist targets, and deadly terrorist violence in Israel. Criminology & Public Policy19(2): 483–514.
31.
IdeTMelloPA (2022) QCA in international relations: A review of strengths, pitfalls, and empirical applications. International Studies Review24(1): 1–20.
32.
JohnstonPB (2012) Does decapitation work? Assessing the effectiveness of leadership targeting in counterinsurgency campaigns. International Security36(4): 47–79.
33.
JordanJ (2009) When heads roll: Assessing the effectiveness of leadership decapitation. Security Studies18(4): 719–755.
34.
KalyvasS (2006) The Logic of Violence in Civil War. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
35.
KeohaneNOZeckhauserRJ (2003) The ecology of terror defense. In: ViscusiWK (ed) The Risks of Terrorism. New York: Springer, 103–131.
36.
KingGKeohaneROVerbaS (1994) Designing social inquiry: Scientific inference in qualitative research. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
37.
Kirk-SmithMDingleJ (2009) Countering terrorism in Northern Ireland: The role of intelligence. Small Wars & Insurgencies20(3–4): 551–573.
38.
KyddAHWalterBF (2006) The strategies of terrorism. International Security31(1): 49–80.
39.
LaFreeGDuganLKorteR (2009) The impact of British counter terrorist strategies on political violence in Northern Ireland: Comparing deterrence and backlash models. Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal47(1): 17–45.
40.
LichbachMI (1987) Deterrence or escalation? The puzzle of aggregate studies of repression and dissent. Journal of Conflict Resolution31(2): 266–297.
41.
LowryDR (1976) Internment: Detention without trial in Northern Ireland. Human Rights (Chicago, Ill)5(3): 261–331.
42.
LoyleCESullivanCDavenportC (2014) The Northern Ireland research initiative: Data on the troubles from 1968 to 1998. Conflict Management and Peace Science31(1): 94–106.
43.
MarchmentZGillP (2019) Modelling the spatial decision-making of terrorists: The discrete choice approach. Applied Geography104: 21–31.
44.
MathiesonN (2021) A dangerous balance: Indiscriminate counterterrorism measures and mobilization against the state. Journal of Global Security Studies6(4): p.ogab014.
45.
McCleeryMJ (2012) Debunking the myths of Operation Demetrius: The introduction of internment in Northern Ireland in 1971. Irish Political Studies27(3): 411–430.
46.
McCormickGH (2003) Terrorist decision-making. Annual Review of Political Science6(1): 473–507.
MelaughM (N.d.) Northern Ireland conflict, politics, and society. Information on ‘The Troubles’. Available at: https://cain.ulster.ac.uk/.
50.
MesevVShirlowPDownsJ (2009) The geography of conflict and death in Belfast, Northern Ireland. Annals of the Association of American Geographers99(5): 893–903.
51.
MoloneyE (2007) A Secret History of the IRA. London, UK: Penguin Press.
52.
MorehouseM (2014) It’s easier to decapitate a snake than it is a hydra: An analysis of Colombia’s targeted killing program. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism37(7): 541–566.
53.
NeumannPEvansRPantucciR (2011) Locating Al Qaeda’s center of gravity: The role of middle managers. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism34(11): 825–842.
54.
NewberyS (2009) Intelligence and controversial British interrogation techniques: The Northern Ireland case, 1971–2. Irish Studies in International Affairs20: 103–119.
55.
Ó DochartaighN (1995) “Sure, it’s hard to keep up with the splits here”: Irish-American responses to the outbreak of conflict in Northern Ireland 1968–1974. Irish Political Studies10(1): 138–160.
56.
Ó DochartaighN (2005) From Civil Rights to Armalites: Derry and the Birth of the Irish Troubles. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
57.
Ó DochartaighN (2015) The longest negotiation: British policy, IRA strategy and the making of the Northern Ireland peace settlement. Political Studies63(1): 202–220.
58.
Ó FaoleánG (2014) Ireland's Ho Chi Minh Trail? The Republic of Ireland's role in the provisional IRA’s bombing campaign, 1970–1976. Small Wars & Insurgencies25(5–6): 976–991.
59.
Ó FaoleánG (2015) The Ulster Defence Regiment and the question of Catholic recruitment, 1970–1972. Terrorism and Political Violence27(5): 838–856.
60.
PREM 15 1010 (1972, 3–23 July) Situation in Northern Ireland; part 24. Kew: National Archives.
61.
ReinischD (2020) Prisoners as leaders of political change: Cage 11 and the peace process in Northern Ireland. In: Gutmann M (ed) Historians on Leadership and Strategy: Case Studies from Antiquity to Modernity. New York: Springer, pp. 55–75.
62.
RekawekK (2011) Irish Republican Terrorism and Politics: A Comparative Study of the Official and the Provisional IRA. London, UK: Routledge.
63.
RossFS (2011) Smashing H-Block: The Rise and Fall of the Popular Campaign against Criminalization, 1976–1982. Liverpool, UK: Liverpool University Press.
64.
SagemanM (2004) Understanding Terror Networks. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.
65.
SalehyanI (2007) Transnational rebels: Neighboring states as sanctuary for rebel groups. World Politics59(2): 217–242.
66.
SandersA (2013) Operation Motorman (1972) and the search for a coherent British counterinsurgency strategy in Northern Ireland. Small Wars & Insurgencies24(3): 465–492.
67.
SandersA (2018) Principles of minimum force and the parachute regiment in Northern Ireland, 1969–1972. Journal of Strategic Studies41(5): 659–683.
68.
ShapiroJN (2012) Terrorist decision-making: Insights from economics and political science. Perspectives on Terrorism6(4/5): 5–20.
69.
SilkeA (1999) Ragged justice: Loyalist vigilantism in Northern Ireland. Terrorism and Political Violence11(3): 1–31.
70.
SilkeATaylorM (2000) War without end: Comparing IRA and loyalist vigilantism in Northern Ireland. The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice39(3): 249–266.
71.
SmithMLR (2003) Fighting for Ireland? The Military Strategy of the Irish Republican Movement. London, UK: Taylor & Francis.
72.
SullivanCMLoyleCEDavenportC (2012) The coercive weight of the past: Temporal dependence and the conflict-repression nexus in the Northern Ireland “Troubles.”International Interactions38(4): 426–442.
73.
SullivanS (1998) From theory to practice: The patterns of violence in Northern Ireland 1969–1994. Irish Political Studies13(1): 76–99.
74.
TaylorP (2014) The Provos: The IRA and Sinn Fein. London: A&C Black.
75.
ThompsonJLP (1989) Deprivation and political violence in Northern Ireland, 1922–1985: A time-series analysis. Journal of Conflict Resolution33(4): 676–699.
76.
Van EveraS (1997) Guide to Methods for Students of Political Science. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
77.
WeinsteinJM (2006) Inside Rebellion: The Politics of Insurgent Violence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
78.
WhiteRWDemirel-PeggTLullaV (2021) Terrorism, counterterrorism and “the rule of law”: State repression and “shoot-to-kill” in Northern Ireland. Irish Political Studies36(2): 263–290.
79.
WhiteRWWhiteTF (1995) Repression and the liberal state: The case of Northern Ireland, 1969–1972. Journal of Conflict Resolution39(2): 330–352.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
