Democratic values and the microfoundations of Arab support for peace with Israel

Abstract

The Arab Spring and the short-lived political ascendancy of Islamist movements reignited the debate about what greater popular participation in foreign policy decision-making would entail for the prospects of peace between Israel and its Arab neighbors. Building on the developing body of individual-level investigations into the Democratic Peace thesis and contributing to the wider debate about the relationship between peace and democracy in the Middle East, this paper utilizes 2010–2011 Arab Barometer data to establish the determinants of public support for a two-state solution to the Israeli–Palestinian conflict across the Arab world. The results reveal that emancipative political values such as support for gender equality and secularism help predict greater support for peace with Israel. These findings demonstrate that contrary to the claims of skeptics, democratization and peace can reinforce each other in the Arab world.

Keywords

Arab Spring democracy gender equality Islamism Israeli–Palestinian conflict public opinion secularism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abadi

(2002) Algeria’s policy toward Israel: Pragmatism and rhetoric. Middle East Journal 56(4): 616–641.

Abu-Bader

Abu-Qarn

(2003) Government expenditures, military spending and economic growth: Causality evidence from Egypt, Israel, and Syria. Journal of Policy Modeling 25: 567–583.

Alterman

(2005) Dynamics without drama: New options and old compromises in Egypt’s foreign policy. Cambridge Review of International Affairs 18(3): 357–369.

Amnesty International (2016) Annual Report 2015/16. Available from: https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/research/2016/02/annual-report-201516/ (accessed 7 April 2016).

Astorino-Courtois

(1996) Transforming international agreements into national realities: Marketing Arab–Israeli peace in Jordan. The Journal of Politics 58(4): 1035–1054.

Astorino-Courtois

(2000) Can peace be marketed? A preliminary analysis of Israelis and Palestinians. Conflict Management and Peace Science 18(1): 97–122.

Barak

(2010) Ambiguity and conflict in Israeli–Palestinian relations. Israel Studies 15(3): 163–188.

Barnett

Levy

(1991) Domestic sources of alliances and alignments: The case of Egypt, 1962–1973. International Organization 45(3): 369–396.

Barzegar

(2008) Iran and the Shiite crescent: Myths and realities. Brown Journal of World Affairs 15(1): 87–99.

10.

Bengio

(2014) Surprising ties between Israel and the Kurds. Middle East Quarterly 21: 3.

11.

Berger

(2012) Guns, butter, and human rights—The congressional politics of U.S. aid to Egypt. American Politics Research 40(4): 603–635.

12.

Berger

(2014) Foreign policies or culture: What shapes Muslim public opinion on political violence against the United States? Journal of Peace Research 51(6): 782–796.

13.

Brand

(1999) The effects of the peace process on political liberalization in Jordan. Journal of Palestine Studies 28(2): 52–67.

14.

Brands

(2011) Saddam and Israel: What do the new Iraqi records reveal? Diplomacy and Statecraft 22(3): 500–520.

15.

Caprioli

(2000) Gendered conflict. Journal of Peace Research 37(1): 51–68.

16.

Chiozza

(2002) Is there a clash of civilizations? Evidence from pattern of international conflict involvement, 1946–1997. Journal of Peace Research 39(6): 711–734.

17.

Ciftci

(2010) Modernization, Islam, or social capital: What explains attitudes toward democracy in the Muslim world? Comparative Political Studies 43(11): 1442–1470.

18.

Ciftci

(2013) Secular-Islamist cleavage, values, and support for democracy and Shari’a in the Arab world. Political Research Quarterly 66(4): 781–793.

19.

Conover

Sapiro

(1993) Gender, feminist consciousness, and war. American Journal of Political Science 37(4): 1079–1099.

20.

David

(1991) Explaining Third World alignment. World Politics 43(2): 233–256.

21.

Doyle

(1986) Liberalism and world politics. The American Political Science Review 80(4): 1151–1169.

22.

Freedom House (2016) Freedom in the World. Available from: https://www.freedomhouse.org/sites/default/files/FH_FITW_Report_2016.pdf (accessed 17 October 2016).

23.

Freilich

(2006) National security decision-making in Israel: Processes, pathologies, and strengths. Middle East Journal 60(4): 635–663.

24.

Friedman

(2005) Commercial pacifism and protracted conflict. Journal of Conflict Resolution 49(3): 360–382.

25.

Furia

Lucas

(2006) Determinants of Arab Public opinion on foreign relations. International Studies Quarterly 50(3): 585–605.

26.

Gause

III Lustick

(2012) America and the regional powers in a transforming Middle East. Middle East Policy 19(2): 1–9.

27.

Guirguis

(2012) The Copts and the Egyptian Revolution: Various attitudes and dreams. Social Research 79(2): 511–530.

28.

Guzansky

(2015) Israel and the Arab Gulf States: From tacit cooperation to reconciliation? Israel Affairs 21(1): 131–147.

29.

Haddad

(2002) Lebanese Christians’ attitudes toward Israel and the peace process. Studies in Conflict and Terrorism 25(6): 402–419.

30.

Hasenclever

Rittberger

(2000) Does religion make a difference? Theoretical approaches to the impact of faith on political conflict. Millennium 29(3): 641–674.

31.

Hegre

Oneal

Russett

(2010) Trade does promote peace: New simultaneous estimates of the reciprocal effects of trade and conflict. Journal of Peace Research 47(6): 763–774.

32.

Henderson

(1998) The democratic peace through the lens of culture, 1820–1989. International Studies Quarterly 42(3): 461–484.

33.

Henry

Springborg

(2011) A Tunisian solution for Egypt’s military. Foreign Affairs, 21 February. Available from: http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/67475/clement-m-henry-and-robert-springborg/a-tunisian-solution-for-egypts-military (accessed 28 June 2016).

34.

Huntington

(1996) The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order. New York: Simon & Schuster.

35.

Inglehart

(2003) How solid is mass support for democracy—And how do we measure it? PS: Political Science and Politics 36: 51–57.

36.

Inglehart

Norris

(2003) The true clash of civilizations. Foreign Policy 135: 62–71.

37.

Inglehart

Puranen

Welzel

(2015) Declining willingness to fight for one’s country: The individual-level basis of the long peace. Journal of Peace Research 52(4): 418–434.

38.

Jamal

(2007) When is social trust a desirable outcome? Comparative Political Studies 40(11): 1328–1349.

39.

Johns

Davies

GAM

(2012) Democratic peace or clash of civilizations? Target states and support for war in Britain and the United States. The Journal of Politics 74(4): 1038–1052.

40.

Jones

Milton-Edwards

(2013) Missing the “devils” we knew? Israel and Political Islam amid the Arab Awakening. International Affairs 89(2): 399–415.

41.

Kaartveit

(2013) The Christians of Palestine: Strength, vulnerability, and self-restraint within a multi-sectarian community. Middle Eastern Studies 49(5): 732–749.

42.

Karawan

(1994) Sadat and the Egyptian–Israeli peace revisited. International Journal of Middle East Studies 26(2): 249–266.

43.

Khashan

(2000) Arab Attitudes toward Israel and Peace. The Washington Institute for Near East Policy, Policy Focus No. 40, August. Available from: http://www.washingtoninstitute.org/policy-analysis/view/arab-attitudes-toward-israel-and-peace (accessed 28 June 2016).

44.

Khashan

(2009) The evolution of Israeli–Lebanese relations: From implicit peace to explicit conflict. Israel Affairs 15(4): 319–334.

45.

Lacina

Lee

(2013) Culture clash or democratic peace? Results of a survey experiment on the effect of religious culture and regime type on foreign policy opinion formation. Foreign Policy Analysis 9(2): 143–170.

46.

Lebovic

Thompson

(2006) An illusionary or elusive relationship? The Arab–Israel conflict and repression in the Middle East. The Journal of Politics 68(3): 502–551.

47.

Lucas

(2003) Deliberalization in Jordan. Journal of Democracy 14(1): 137–144.

48.

Maddy-Weitzman

(2010) Arabs versus the Abdullah Plan. Middle East Quarterly 17(3): 3–12.

49.

Magen

(2015) Comparative assessment of Israel’s foreign policy response to the “Arab Spring”. Journal of European Integration 37(1): 113–133.

50.

Maoz

(2007) Evaluating Israel’s strategy of low-intensity warfare, 1949–2006. Security Studies 16(3): 319–349.

51.

Maoz

Russett

(1993) Normative and structural causes of democratic peace, 1946–1986. American Political Science Review 87(3): 624–638.

52.

Marshall

(2014) Polity IV Project: Political Regime Characteristics and Transitions, 1800–2013. Available from: http://systemicpeace.org/polity/isr2.htm (accessed 28 June 2016).

53.

Mi’ari

(1999) Attitudes of Palestinians toward normalization with Israel. Journal of Peace Research 36(3): 339–348.

54.

Miller

(2000) Explaining variations in regional peace: Three strategies for peace-making. Cooperation and Conflict 35(2): 155–192.

55.

Nachtwey

Tessler

(2002) The political economy of attitudes toward peace among Palestinians and Israelis. Journal of Conflict Resolution 46(2): 260–285.

56.

Norris

Inglehart

(2002) Islamic culture and democracy: Testing the “Clash of Civilizations”. Comparative Sociology 1(3–4): 235–263.

57.

Petrucci

Fois

(2016) Attitudes towards Israel in Tunisian political debate: From Bourguiba to the new constitution. The Journal of North African Studies 21(3): 392–410.

58.

Podeh

(2014) Israel and the Arab Peace Initiative, 2002–2014: A plausible missed opportunity. Middle East Journal 68(4): 584–603.

59.

Press-Barnathan

(2006) The neglected dimension of commercial liberalism: Economic cooperation and transition to peace. Journal of Peace Research 43(3): 261–278.

60.

Regan

Leng

(2003) Culture and negotiation in militarized interstate disputes. Conflict Management and Peace Science 20(1): 111–132.

61.

Regan

Paskeviciute

(2003) Women’s access to politics and peaceful states. Journal of Peace Research 40(3): 287–302.

62.

Ripsman

(2005) Two stages of transition from a region of war to a region of peace: Realist transition and liberal endurance. International Studies Quarterly 49(4): 669–693.

63.

Ripsman

(2011–2012) Promoting regional peacemaking. International Journal 67(2): 431–436.

64.

Russett

Oneal

Cox

(2000) Clash of civilizations, or realism and liberalism déjà vu? Some evidence. Journal of Peace Research 37(5): 583–608.

65.

Sahliyeh

Deng

(2003) The determinants of Palestinians’ attitudes toward peace with Israel. International Studies Quarterly 47(4): 693–708.

66.

Scham

Lucas

(2003) “Normalization” and “anti-normalization” in Jordan: The public debate. Israel Affairs 9(3): 141–164.

67.

Sela

(2005) Politics, identity, and peacemaking: The Arab discourse on peace with Israel in the 1990s. Israel Studies 10(2): 15–71.

68.

Shamir

Shikaki

(2002) Determinants of reconciliation and compromise among Israelis and Palestinians. Journal of Peace Research 39(2): 185–202.

69.

Shamir

Shikaki

(2005) Public opinion in the Israeli–Palestinian two-level game. Journal of Peace Research 42(3): 311–328.

70.

Smooha

(1997) Ethnic democracy: Israel as an archetype. Israel Studies 2(2): 198–241.

71.

Telhami

Kull

(2013) Israeli and Palestinian Public Opinion on Negotiating a Final Status Peace Agreement. The Anwar Sadat Chair for Peace and Development/The Program for Public Consultation, 6 December. Available from: http://www.usip.org/publications/usip-announces-release-of-new-study-of-israeli-and-palestinian-public-opinion-final (accessed 28 June 2016).

72.

Tessler

Gao

(2005) Gauging Arab support for democracy. Journal of Democracy 16(3): 83–97.

73.

Tessler

Nachtwey

(1998) Islam and attitudes toward international conflict. Evidence from survey research in the Arab world. The Journal of Conflict Resolution 42(5): 619–636.

74.

Tessler

Nachtwey

(1999) Palestinian political attitudes: An analysis of survey data from the West Bank and Gaza. Israel Studies 4(1): 22–43.

75.

Tessler

Warriner

(1997) Gender, feminism, and attitudes toward international conflict: Exploring relationships with survey data from the Middle East. World Politics 49(2): 250–281.

76.

Tessler

Nachtwey

Grant

(1999) Further tests of the women and peace hypothesis: Evidence from cross-national survey research in the Middle East. International Studies Quarterly 43(3): 519–531.

77.

Tessler

Jamal

Robbins

(2012) New findings on Arabs and democracy. Journal of Democracy 23(4): 89–103.

78.

Tickner

(2004) Feminist responses to international security studies. Peace Review 16(1): 43–48.

79.

Tomz

Weeks

JLP

(2013) Public opinion and the democratic peace. American Political Science Review 107(4): 849–865.

80.

Verveer

(2012) Why women are a foreign policy issue. Seriously, guys. Foreign Policy 193: 90–92.

81.

Welzel

(2007) Are levels of democracy influenced by mass attitudes? International Political Science Review 28(4): 397–424.

82.

Yom

(2009) Jordan: Ten more years of autocracy. Journal of Democracy 20(4): 151–166.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

3.44 MB

0.00 MB