More Money or More Problems? Assessing the Fiscal Impact of Consolidation in Macon-Bibb County,Georgia

Abstract

Attempts to create consolidated city-county governments have persisted in recent decades, with many local government reformers touting this type of organizational change as a solution to a number of challenges in metropolitan areas. Overall, research in this area has generally shown no conclusive outcomes related to achieving greater efficiencies as measured by a reduction in expenditures. However, the 2014 consolidation of Macon-Bibb County, Georgia presents an opportunity to explore a substantively important case due to a mandated 20% reduction in expenditures over a 5-year period. This analysis finds that while officials generally met their goal of reducing budgeted expenditures, an analysis of actual expenditures and questions pertaining to longer-term outcomes, including reductions in staffing, performance, and credit ratings may be a cautionary tale for similar efforts in the future.

Keywords

local government consolidation amalgamation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Access Economics. (2006). Local government finances in western Australia: Research report for the western Australian local government association. WALGA.

Acuff

(2022a). Beyond the city–county divide: Examining consolidation referenda since 2000. State and Local Government Review, 54(4), 287–309.

Acuff

(2022b). An empirical examination of representational equity in consolidated governments, 1965–2002. Urban Affairs Review, 58(6), 1523–1553.

Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations. (1965). Factors affecting voter reactions to governmental reorganization in metropolitan areas (Technical Report M-15). U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.

Altamimi

Liu

Jimenez

(2023). Not too much, not too little: Centralization, de-centralization, and organizational change. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 33(1), 170–185.

Altshuler

Morrill

Wolman

Mitchell

(1999). Governance and opportunity in metropolitan America. National Academy Press.

Amos

McDonald

M. P.

Watkins

(2017). When boundaries collide: Constructing a national database of demographic and voting statistics. Public Opinion Quarterly, 81(S1), 385–400.

Arapis

Reitano

(2018). A glimmer of optimism in government savings accumulation? An empirical examination of municipal unassigned fund balance in Florida. Public Finance Review, 46(3), 389–420.

Benton

J. E.

Gamble

(1984). City/county consolidation and economies of scale: Evidence from a time-series analysis in Jacksonville, Florida. Social Science Quarterly, 65(1), 190.

10.

Blom-Hansen

Houlberg

Serritzlew

Treisman

(2016). Jurisdiction size and local government policy expenditure: Assessing the effect of municipal amalgamation. American Political Science Review, 110(4), 812–831.

11.

Bollens

S. A.

(2003). In through the back door: Social equity and regional governance. Housing Policy Debate, 13(4), 631–657.

12.

Boyne

G. A.

(1992). Local government structure and performance: Lessons from America? Public Administration, 70(3), 333–357.

13.

Cabell

Dunlap

(2018, June 6). Are you paying more in property taxes since consolidation? It depends on where you live. The Macon Telegraph. https://www.macon.com/news/local/article212566859.html

14.

Carr

J. B.

Feiock

R. C.

(2004). City-county consolidation and its alternatives: Reshaping the local government landscape. M.E. Sharpe.

15.

City of Macon, Georgia (2013). Financial report, for the six months ended 2013, December 31. http://www.maconbibb.us/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/City-of-Macon-Georgia-12-31-13-FS2.pdf

16.

Clarke

(2006). Voting rights & city-county consolidations. Houston Law Review, 43, 621–699.

17.

Condrey

S. E.

(1994). Organizational and personnel impacts on local government consolidation: Athens-Clarke County, Georgia. Journal of Urban Affairs, 16(4), 371–383.

18.

Drew

(2020). Reforming Local Government: Consolidation, Cooperation, or Re-Creation? Springer.

19.

Drew

(2022). Saving Local Government: Financial Sustainability in a Challenging World. Springer.

20.

Drew

Dollery

Kortt

M. A.

(2016). Peas in a pod: Are efficient municipalities also financially sustainable? Australian Accounting Review, 26(2), 122–131.

21.

Dunlap

(2016, May 10). Proposed Macon-Bibb budget reaches consolidation milestone. The Telegraph. http://www.macon.com/news/local/article76762382.html

22.

Dunlap

(2017, April 24). County manager for Macon-Bibb resigns. The Telegraph. https://www.macon.com/news/politics-government/article146457619.html

23.

Dunlap

(2018). Here’s why Macon-Bibb hasn’t violated its charter by overspending, officials say. The Macon Telegraph. https://www.macon.com/news/local/article216586910.html

24.

Dunlap

(2019, March 16). Former Bibb County manager charged in alleged pension fraud. The Telegraph. https://www.macon.com/news/local/article228026049.html

25.

Durning

Nobbie

P. D.

(2000). Post-transition employee perspectives of city-county unification: The case of Athens-Clarke County. Public Administration Quarterly, 24(2), 140–168.

26.

Faulk

Grassmueck

(2012). City-county consolidation and local government expenditures. State & Local Government Review, 44(3), 196–205.

27.

Faulk

Schaal

Taylor

C. D.

(2013). How does local government amalgamation affect spending? Evidence from Louisville, Kentucky. Public Finance & Management, 13(2), 80.

28.

Feiock

R. C.

(2007). Rational choice and regional governance. Journal of Urban Affairs, 29(1), 47–63.

29.

Feiock

R. C.

Carr

J. B.

Johnson

L. S.

(2006). Structuring the debate on consolidation: A response to Leland and Thurmaier. Public Administration Review, 66(2), 274–278.

30.

Floore

(2017). FY 2018 budget proposed by Mayor Reichert. https://www.maconbibb.us/proposedfy18budget/

31.

Foster

K. A.

(1997). The political economy of special-purpose government. Georgetown University Press.

32.

Gaffney

Marlowe

(2014). Fiscal implications of city-city consolidations. State and Local Government Review, 46(3), 197–204.

33.

Gaines

(2013, May 31). Board postpones Macon-Bibb County’s July elections. The Macon Telegraph. https://www.macon.com/news/politics-government/election/article30119973.html

34.

Gaines

(2015, January 4). Macon-bibb merger: First year in review. The Macon Telegraph. http://www.macon.com/news/politics-government/article30163788.html

35.

Gaines

Stucka

(2011, March 29). Officials weigh in on Macon-Bibb consolidation. The Macon Telegraph. http://www.macon.com/news/article28604887.html

36.

Galizzi

Rota

Sicilia

(2023). Local government amalgamations: State of the art and new ways forward. Public Management Review, 25(12), 2428–2450.

37.

Gend’zwiłł

Kurniewicz

Swianiewicz

(2021). The impact of municipal territorial reforms on the economic performance of local governments: A systematic review of quasi-experimental studies. Space and Polity, 25(1), 37–56.

38.

Georgia General Assembly. (1999). Local and special acts and resolutions of the General Assembly of the state of Georgia 1999 volume two. https://dlg.usg.edu/record/dlg_zlgl_599832121

39.

Georgia General Assembly (2015). HB 575, An Act to repeal an Act creating a new charter for Payne City. 2015–2016 Regular Session. https://www.legis.ga.gov/legislation/44518

40.

Gerring

(2012). Mere description. British Journal of Political Science, 42(4), 721–746.

41.

Goertz

Mahoney

(2012). A Tale of Two Cultures: Qualitative and Quantitative Research in the Social Sciences. Princeton University Press.

42.

Halter

(1993). City-city consolidations in the United States. National Civic Review, 82(3):282–290.

43.

Harrigan

Vogel

(2003). Political change in the metropolis. Longman.

44.

Jimenez

B. S.

Hendrick

(2010). Is government consolidation the answer? State & Local Government Review, 42(3), 258–270.

45.

Johnson

Carr

(2004). Making the case for (and against) city-county consolidation. In Carr

J. B.

Feiock

R. C.

(Eds.), City-County Consolidation and its alternatives: Reshaping the local government landscape (pp. 246–290). M.E. Sharpe.

46.

Lee

(2013, May 29). It’s hurry up and wait on Macon-Bibb election format. The Macon Telegraph. http://www.macon.com/news/politics-government/election/article30119928.html

47.

Lee

(2015, April 1). Payne city officially dissolved. The Macon Telegraph. https://www.macon.com/news/politics-government/article30224283.html

48.

Leland

S. M.

Johnson

G. A.

(2004). Consolidation as a local government reform: Why city-county consolidation is an enduring issue. In Carr

J. B.

Feiock

R. C.

(Eds.), City-county consolidation and its alternatives: Reshaping the local government landscape (pp. 25–38). M.E. Sharpe.

49.

Leland

S. M.

Thurmaier

(2010). City-county consolidation: Promises made, promises kept? Georgetown University Press.

50.

Leland

S. M.

Thurmaier

K. M.

(2004). Case studies of city-county consolidation: Reshaping the local government landscape. M.E. Sharpe.

51.

Lijphart

(1971). Comparative politics and the comparative method. American Political Science Review, 65(3), 682–693.

52.

Macon-Bibb County (2014). 2015 annual budget. http://www.maconbibb.us/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Macon-Bibb-County-FY-2015-Budget.pdf

53.

Macon-Bibb County (2015). 2016 annual budget. http://www.maconbibb.us/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/Macon-Bibb-GA-FY-2016-Budget-Back-Up-Copy.pdf

54.

Macon-Bibb County (2016). 2017 annual budget. http://www.maconbibb.us/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/17-Budget-Book-Final-2.pdf

55.

Macon-Bibb County, Georgia. (2018). Comprehensive annual financial report, fiscal year ended 2018, June 30. http://www.maconbibb.us/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Macon-Bibb_County_FY2018_CAFR.pdf

56.

Macon-Bibb County, Georgia. (2020). Annual comprehensive financial report, fiscal year ended 2020, June 30. https://www.maconbibb.us/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Macon-Bibb-County-CAFR-2020.pdf

57.

Macon-Bibb County, Georgia. (2021). Annual comprehensive financial report, fiscal year ended 2021, June 30. https://www.maconbibb.us/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Macon-Bibb-Co-ACFR-2021-Final.pdf

58.

Mahoney

Goertz

(2006). A tale of two cultures: Contrasting quantitative and qualitative research. Political Analysis, 14(3), 227–249.

59.

Manis

S. B.

(1995). Unofficial opinion 95-5. Office of Attorney General of Georgia. https://law.georgia.gov/opinions/95-5-0

60.

Marando

V. L.

(1979). City-county consolidation: Reform, regionalism, referenda and requiem. The Western Political Quarterly, 32(4), 409–421.

61.

Martin

L. L.

Schiff

J. H.

(2011). City–county consolidations: Promise versus performance. State and Local Government Review, 43(2), 167–177.

62.

McQuestin

Drew

Dollery

(2018). Do municipal mergers improve technical efficiency? An empirical analysis of the 2008 Queensland municipal merger program. Australian Journal of Public Administration, 77(3), 442–455.

63.

McQuestin

Drew

Iiboshi

(2022). The temporal dependence of public policy evaluation: The case of local government amalgamation. Local Government Studies, 49(5), 953–974.

64.

McQuestin

Drew

Miyazaki

(2021). Do amalgamations make a difference? What we can learn from evaluating the policy success of a large scale forced amalgamation of local government. Public Administration Quarterly, 45(3), 278.

65.

Mintz

Portnov

B. A.

(2023). Social and environmental factors affecting the amount of property taxes collected by local authorities in Israel. Land Use Policy, 133, 106811.

66.

Miyazaki

(2018). Examining the relationship between municipal consolidation and cost reduction: An instrumental variable approach. Applied Economics, 50(10), 1108–1121.

67.

Moody’s Investors Service. (2017). Moody’s assigns Aa2 to Macon-Bibb, GA’s $18.8m rev. bonds, ser. 2017A&B; outlook negative. https://www.moodys.com/research/Moodys-Assigns-Aa2-to-Macon-Bibb-GAs-188M-Rev-Bonds-Ser-Rating-Action–PR_904044315

68.

Moody’s Investors Service. (2018). Moody’s downgrades Macon-Bibb consolidated gov’t, GA’s go debt to a1. https://www.moodys.com/research/Moodys-downgrades-Macon-Bibb-Consolidated-Govt-GAs-GO-debt-to–PR_904515873

69.

Moody’s Investors Service. (2023). Moody’s affirms Macon-Bibb County consolidated gov’t, GA’s Aa3 issuer and go ratings; outlook stable. https://www.moodys.com/research/Moodys-affirms-Macon-Bibb-County-Consolidated-Govt-GAs-Aa3-issuer-and-Rating-Action–PR_908062461

70.

National Association of Counties. (2011). City County Consolidation Proposals. http://www.naco.org/sites/default/files/documents/CityCountyConsolidations.01.01.2011.pdf

71.

Odom

(2018, August 23). Macon-Bibb leaders fail citizens and continue to violate the consolidation charter. The Macon Telegraph. https://www.macon.com/opinion/opn-columns-blogs/article217171700.html

72.

Ostrom

(1971). Public choice: A different approach to the study of public administration. Public Administration Review, 31(2), 203–216.

73.

Ostrom

Tiebout

C. M.

Warren

(1961). The organization of government in metropolitan areas: A theoretical inquiry. American Political Science Review, 55(04), 831–842.

74.

Parks

R. B.

Oakerson

R. J.

(1989). Metropolitan organization and governance: A local public economy approach. Urban Affairs Quarterly, 25(1), 18–29.

75.

Ramati

(2011, November 18). Pro-consolidation voices heard at forum. The Macon Telegraph. http://www.macon.com/latest-news/article28626505.html

76.

Ramati

(2013, June 29). Bibb elections board sets Sept. 17 election. The Macon Telegraph. http://www.macon.com/news/politics-government/election/article30120507.html

77.

Reichert

(2017). 2018 budget message: “Investing in our future”. https://www.maconbibb.us/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Proposed-FY18-Budget-Mayors-Comments.pdf

78.

Reingewertz

(2012). Do municipal amalgamations work? Evidence from municipalities in Israel. Journal of Urban Economics, 72(2–3), 240–251.

79.

Rosenbaum

W. A.

Henderson

T. A.

(1973). Explaining the attitude of community influentials toward government consolidation a reappraisal of four hypotheses. Urban Affairs Review, 9(2), 251–275.

80.

Rosenbaum

W. A.

Kammerer

G. M.

(1974). Against long odds: The theory and practice of successful governmental consolidation. Sage Publications.

81.

Sanford

Hudson

O’Looney

Gordon

(2012). Responding to the new realities: Case studies in county governance. (Technical report). National Center for the Study of Counties.

82.

Savitch

Vogel

R. K.

(2009). Regionalism and urban politics. In Davies

J. S.

Imbroscio

D. L.

(Eds.), Theories of urban politics (2nd ed., pp. 106–124). SAGE Publications.

83.

Savitch

H. V.

Vogel

R. K.

(2004). Suburbs without a city: Power and city-county consolidation. Urban Affairs Review, 39(6), 758–790.

84.

Savitch

H. V.

Vogel

R. K.

(2010). Beyond the rhetoric: Lessons from Louisville’s consolidation. The American Review of Public Administration, 40(1), 3–28.

85.

Selden

S. C.

Campbell

R. W.

(2000). The expenditure impacts of unification in a small Georgia county: A contingency perspective of city-county consolidation. Public Administration Quarterly, 24(2), 169–201.

86.

Stucka

(2009, December 9). Macon-bibb leaders can’t get together on consolidation. The Macon Telegraph. http://www.macon.com/news/article28576156.html

87.

Stucka

(2012a, April 26). Macon-bibb consolidation plan gets governor’s signature. The Macon Telegraph. https://www.macon.com/news/article30104952.html

88.

Stucka

(2012b, July 24). Pro Macon-Bibb consolidation group draws $169,000 in donations. The Macon Telegraph. http://www.macon.com/news/politics-government/election/article30109197.html

89.

Swanson

B. E.

(2000). Quandaries of pragmatic reform: A reassessment of the Jacksonville experience. State & Local Government Review, 32(3), 227–238.

90.

Taylor

C. D.

Faulk

Schaal

(2017). Where are the cost savings in city–county consolidation? Journal of Urban Affairs, 39(2), 185–204.

91.

Tiebout

C. M.

(1956). A pure theory of local expenditures. The Journal of Political Economy, 64(5), 416–424.

92.

United States Census Bureau (2012). American community survey 1-year estimate data (2012). http://data.census.gov

93.

United States Census Bureau (2014). American community survey 5-year estimate data (2010-2014). http://data.census.gov

94.

United States Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics (2023). Handbook of methods Consumer price index calculation. https://www.bls.gov/opub/hom/cpi/calculation.htm

95.

Visser

J. A.

(2002). Understanding local government cooperation in urban regions: Toward a cultural model of interlocal relations. The American Review of Public Administration, 32(1), 40–65.

96.

Walker

R. M.

Boyne

G. A.

(2006). Public management reform and organizational performance: An empirical assessment of the UK Labour government’s public service improvement strategy. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management: The Journal of the Association for Public Policy Analysis and Management, 25(2), 371–393.

97.

WMGT. (2015). Payne city becomes part of Macon-Bibb County. 41NBC/WMGT Web Producer. https://www.41nbc.com/payne-city-becomes-part-of-macon-bibb-county