Smoke,CO,and CO 2 Measurements and Evaluation using Different Fire Testing Techniques for Flame Retardant Unsaturated Polyester Resin Formulations

Abstract

Smoke is considered to be the main fire hazard but its production depends on major variables, principally the chemical character and the burning rate of the polymer plus the availability of oxygen and hence ventilation. The main aim of this work is to study the effect of smoke suppressants on flammability and smoke production of flame retarded unsaturated polyester resin-nanocomposites using four different testing regimes representing different fire scenarios. Samples containing zinc borate, zinc stannates, ammonium polyphosphate with and without nanoclay are analyzed for smoke generation using cone calorimetry (well-ventilated fire), a tube furnace (fully developed fire), and a smoke density chamber (under-ventilated fire). Carbon monoxide (CO) and carbon dioxide (CO₂) measurements using thermogravimetry-evolved gas analysis (TG-EGA), cone calorimetry, and tube furnace have also been analyzed and compared. Results have confirmed that the production of smoke, CO, and CO₂ depend upon smoke suppressants and fire conditions used during testing samples.

From this study it is evident that tin additives have very little influence on flammability of unsaturated polyester resin but they reduce smoke formation. The slight flame retardant action of the Res/APP/ZB sample is due to enhanced cross-linking of APP in the presence of zinc borate, whereas zinc stannates do not promote cross-linking of APP and hence show no improvement in flame retardancy. Finally, the presence of nanoclay in flame retarded resin shows significant reduction in smoke formations in both well-ventilated and under-ventilated fire condition. However, in the presence of smoke suppressants used in this study, the nanoclay is not instrumental in further suppressing smoke formation.

Keywords

unsaturated polyester nanocomposites flame retardants smoke suppressants toxicity fire conditions.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Walczak, E.K. (1998). New Polyester Resin with Reduced Flammability and Smoke Evolution Capacity, Fire and Materials, 22: 253-255.

Cusack, P.A. , Heer, M.S. and Monk, A.W. (1997). Zinc Hydroxyl Stannate as an Alternative Synergist to Antimony Trioxide in Polyester Resins Containing Halogenated Flame Retardants, Polymer Degradation and Stability , 58(1-2): 229-237.

Atkinson, P.A. , Haines, P.J. and Skinner, G.A. (2000). Inorganic Tin Compounds as Flame Retardants and Smoke Suppressants for Polyester Thermosets, Thermochimica Acta, 360(2): 29-40.

Atkinson, P.A. , Haines, P.J. and Skinner, G.A. (2001). The Mechanism of Action of Tin Compounds as Flame Retardants and Smoke Suppressants for Polyester Thermosets, Polymer Degradation and Stability, 71(3): 351-360.

Cusack, P.A. , Monk, A.W. , Pearce, J.A. and Reynolds, S.J. (1989). An Investigation of Inorganic Tin Flame Retardants which Suppress Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Emissions from Burning Brominated Polyester Resins, Fire and Materials , 14: 23-29.

Cusack, P.A. and Pritchard, G. (1998). Plastics Additives: An A-Z Reference, Chapman and Hall, London.

Cusack, P.A. (1986). An Investigation of the Flame-Retardant and Smoke-Suppressant Properties of Tin (IV) Oxide in Unsaturated Polyester Thermosets, Fire and Materials, 10: 41-46.

Hornsby, P.R. and Watson, P.L. (1989). Mechanism of Smoke Suppression and Fire Retardancy in Polymers Containing Magnesium Hydroxide Filler, Plastic and Rubber Processing and Applications, 11: 45-51.

Hornsby, P.R. (1994). The Application and Smoke-Suppressing Additive for Polymers, Fire and Materials, 18: 269-276.

10.

Hanafi, W.Z.A.W. and Hornsby, P.R. (1993). Smoke Suppression and Fire Retardancy in Unsaturated Polyesters Containing Hydrated Fillers, Plastic and Rubber Processing and Applications, 19: 175-184.

11.

Cross, M.S. , Cusack, P.A. and Hornsby, P.R. (2003). Effects of Tin Additives on the Flammability and Smoke Emission Characteristics of Halogen-Free Ethylene-Vinyl Acetate Copolymer, Polymer Degradation and Stability, 79(2): 309-318.

12.

Edelson, D. , Lum, R.M. , Reents Jr, W.D. , Starnes Jr, W.H. and Wescott Jr, L.D. (1982). New Insights into Flame-retardance Chemistry of Poly(vinyl chloride), Symposium (International) on Combustion , 19(1): 807-814.

13.

Nazaré, S. , Kandola, B. , Myler, P. and Horrocks, A.R. Role of Polymer-Layered Silicates in Enhancing Thermal and Mechanical Properties of Flame Retardant Glass Reinforced Polyester Composites, In Preparation.

14.

Nazaré, S. , Kandola, B. and Horrocks, A.R. (2006). Flame-retardant Unsaturated Polyester Resin Incorporating Nanoclays, Polymer Advanced Technology, 17: 294-303.

15.

Toxicity of Fire Effluent-Estimation of Toxic Potency: Apparatus and Test Method (2002). IEC 60695-7-50:2002.

16.

Purser, D.A. , Fardell, P.J. , Rowley, J. , Vollam, S. and Bridgeman, B. (1994). An improved Tube Furnace method for the generation and measurement of toxic combustion products under a wide range of fire conditions , In: Proceedings of the 6th International Conference Flame Retardants, London, UK, Interscience Communications, 26-27 January 1994.

17.

Hull, T.R. , Quinn, R.E. , Areri, I.G. and Purser, D.A. (2002). Combustion Toxicity of Fire Retarded EVA, Polymer Degradation and Stability, 77(2): 235-242.

18.

Lebek, K. , Hull, T.R. and Price, D. (2005). Products of Rigid PVC Burning Under Various Fire Conditions, in ACS Symposium Series 922, C.A. Wilkie and G.L. Nelson (eds), Fire and Polymers IV Materials and Concepts of Hazard Prevention, American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, pp. 334-347.

19.

Zhang, S. , Horrocks, A.R. , Hull, R. and Kandola, B. (2006). Flammability, Degradation and Structural Characterization of Fibre-Forming Polypropylene Containing Nanoclay-flame Retardant Combinations , Polymer Degradation and Stability, 91(4): 719-725.

20.

Le Bras, M. , Camino, G. , Bourbigot, S. and De Lobel, R. (eds), (1998). Flame Retardancy of Polymeric Materials, The Use of Intumescence, pp. 1-32. The Royal Soc. of Chem., London.

21.

Scudamore, M.J. , Briggs, P.J. and Prager, F.H. (1991). Cone Calorimetry - A Review of Tests Carried out on Plastics for the Association of Plastic Manufacturers in Europe, Fire and Materials, 15(2): 65-84.

22.

Hirschler, M.M. (1993). An Attachment for Use with the NBS Smoke Density Chamber for Measurement of Smoke Obscuration at Different Orientations, Fire and Materials, 17: 173-183.

23.

Foley, M. and Drysdale, D. (1994). Note: Smoke Measurements and the Cone Calorimeter , Fire and Materials, 18: 385-387.

24.

Wang, D. and Wilkie, C.A. (2003). In-situ Reactive Blending to Prepare Polystyrene-Clay and Polypropylene-Clay Nanocomposites, Polymer Degradation and Stability, 80(1): 171-182.

25.

Mouritz, A.P. , Mathys, Z. and Gibson, A.G. (2006). Heat Release of Polymer Composites in Fire, Composites: Part A Applied Science and Manufacturing, 37(7): 1040-1054.

26.

Babrauskas, V. (1992). The Generation of CO in Bench-Scale Fire Test and the Prediction for Real-Scale Fires, Proc. Int. Conf. Fire Mater., 155-177.

27.

Gilman, J.W. (1999). Flammability and Thermal Stability Studies of Polymer Layered-Silicate (Clay) Nanocomposites, Applied Clay Sci., 15(1-2): 31-49.

28.

Price, D. , Cunliffe, L.K. , Bullet, K.J. , Hull, T.R. , Milnes, G.J. , Hunt, B.J. and Joseph, P. (2004). Mechanisms of the Flame Retardant Behaviour of Covalently Bonded Phosphorus in Poly(Methyl Methacrylates), 228th ACS National Meeting, Philadelphia, Pennsylvannia, pp. 22-26.

29.

Kandare, E. , Nazaré, S. , Kandola, B.K. , Horrocks, A.R. and Price, D. Study of the Thermal Decomposition of Flame-retardant Unsaturated Polyester Resins by Thermogravimetric Analysis and Py-GC/MS, In preparation.

30.

Chiu, H.-T. , Chiu, S.-H. , Jeng, R.-E. and Chung, J.-S. (2000). A Study of the Combustion and Fire-Retardance Behaviour of Unsaturated Polyester/Phenolic Resin Blends , Polymer Degradation and Stability, 70(3): 505-514.