Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2025-9
Reexamination of Multi-level Representation and Critical Mass: The Roles of Black Leadership and Its Relationship With Street-Level Officers in Police Killings
The study’s goal is to examine the multi-level representation in the context of cooperation and support between black police chiefs and street-level officers. Another goal here is to re-examine and propose different critical mass models in policing. The study uses police killing data from 2014 to 2017 in the United States. Using multi-level modeling techniques, the existing critical mass model, which assumes a single threshold, is not supported. Instead, the study finds that the mutual support model is supported, showing that street-level black officers need support from the black chief, while the black chief also needs further support from street-level officers. Simultaneously, it finds that the presence of a black chief shifts the threshold of street-level representation to a lower level, showing a close relationship between mutual support and critical mass due to a similar mechanism. The findings suggest the importance of police leadership.
AndrewsR.MillerK. J. (2013). Representative bureaucracy, gender, and policing: The case of domestic violence arrests in England. Public Administration, 91(4), 998–1014. https://doi.org/10.1111/padm.12002
2.
AtkinsD. N.WilkinsV. M. (2013). Going beyond reading, writing, and arithmetic: The effects of teacher representation on teen pregnancy rates. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 23(4), 771–790. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/mut001
3.
BentonM. (2020). Representation is not enough: Symbolic representation and perceptions of the police. Administration & Society, 52(5), 794–822.
4.
BishuS. G.KennedyA. R. (2020). Trends and gaps: A meta-review of representative bureaucracy. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 40(4), 559–588.
5.
BoltonK.FeaginJ. R. (2004). Black in blue: African-American police officers and racism. Routledge.
6.
BroughtonS.PalmieriS. (1999). Gendered contributions to parliamentary debates: The case of euthanasia. Australian Journal of Political Science, 34(1), 29–45.
7.
BrownB.LiY. (2023). Police executive leadership: An empirical and theoretical exploration of police chief performance. International Journal of Police Science & Management, 25(1), 53–66. https://doi.org/10.1177/14613557221132488
8.
CardarelliA. P.McDevittJ.BaumK. (1998). The rhetoric and reality of community policing in small and medium-sized cities and towns. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 21(3), 397–415. https://doi.org/10.1108/13639519810228723
9.
CarmichaelJ. T.KentS. L. (2015). The use of lethal force by Canadian police officers: Assessing the influence of female police officers and minority threat explanations on police shootings across large cities. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 40(4), 703–721.
10.
CesarioJ.JohnsonD. J.TerrillW. (2019). Is there evidence of racial disparity in police use of deadly force? Analyses of officer-involved fatal shootings in 2015–2016. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 10(5), 586–595.
CorrellJ.BernadetteP.JuddC. M.WittenbrinkB. (2002). The police officer’s dilemma: Using ethnicity to disambiguate potentially threatening individuals. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 83(6), 1314–1329. https://doi.org/10.1037//0022-3514.83.6.1314
13.
CorrellJ.ParkB.JuddC. M.WittenbrinkB. (2007). The influence of stereotypes on decisions to shoot. European Journal of Social Psychology, 37(6), 1102–1117. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.450
14.
CorrellJ.WittenbrinkB.ParkB.JuddC. M.GoyleA. (2011). Dangerous enough: Moderating racial bias with contextual threat cues. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 47, 184–189.
15.
CrowlJ. N. (2017). The effect of community policing on fear and crime reduction, police legitimacy and job satisfaction: An empirical review of the evidence. Police Practice & Research, 18(5), 449–462.
16.
DavisB. C.LivermoreM.LimY. (2011). The extended reach of minority political power: The interaction of descriptive representation, managerial networking, and race. The Journal of Politics, 73(2), 494–507. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022381611000077
17.
DingF.LuJ.RiccucciN. M. (2021). How bureaucratic representation affects public organizational performance: A meta-analysis. Public Administration Review, 81(6), 1003–1018.
18.
EternoJ. A.BarrowC. S.SilvermanE. B. (2017). Forcible stops: Police and citizens speak out. Public Administration Review, 77(2), 181–192.
19.
FridellL.LimH. (2016). Assessing the racial aspects of police force using the implicit- and counter-bias perspectives. Journal of Criminal Justice, 44, 36–48.
GastonS.BrunsonR. K.AyeniD. O. (2023). Suspicious places make people suspicious: Officers’ perceptions of place-based conditions in racialized drug enforcement. Criminology & Public Policy, 22(1), 63–82. https://doi.org/10.1111/1745-9133.12606
22.
GelmanA.HillJ. (2006). Data analysis using regression and multilevel/hierarchical models (1st ed.). Cambridge University Press.
23.
GeorgeB.PandeyS. K. (2017). We know the Yin—but where is the Yang? Toward a balanced approach on common source bias in public administration scholarship. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 37(2), 245–270. https://doi.org/10.1177/0734371X17698189
24.
GrissomJ. A.Nicholson-CrottyJ.KeiserL. (2012). Does my boss’s gender matter? Explaining job satisfaction and employee turnover in the public sector. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 22(4), 649–673. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/mus004
25.
GrissomJ. A.RodriguezL. A.KernE. C. (2017). Teacher and principal diversity and the representation of students of color in gifted programs: Evidence from National Data. The Elementary School Journal, 117(3), 396–422.
26.
GroggerJ.RidgewayG. (2006). Testing for racial profiling in traffic stops from behind a veil of darkness. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 101(475), 878–887.
27.
HeadleyA. M.WrightJ. E. (2020). Is representation enough? Racial disparities in levels of force and arrests by police. Public Administration Review, 80(6), 1051–1062.
28.
HoekstraM.SloanC. W. (2022). Does race matter for police use of force? Evidence from 911 calls. American Economic Review, 112(3), 827–860. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20201292
29.
HongS. (2017). Black in blue: Racial profiling and representative bureaucracy in policing revisited. Journal of Public Administration Research And Theory, 27(4), 547–561. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/mux012
30.
HongS. (2021). Representative bureaucracy and hierarchy: Interactions among leadership, middle-level, and street-level bureaucracy. Public Management Review, 23(9), 1317–1338. https://doi.org/10.1080/14719037.2020.1743346
31.
HuberL.GundersonA. (2022). Putting a fresh face forward: Does the gender of a police chief affect public perceptions?Political Research Quarterly, 76, 1418–1432. https://doi.org/10.1177/10659129221142598
32.
JohnstonK.HoustonJ. (2018). Representative bureaucracy: Does female police leadership affect gender-based violence arrests?International Review of Administrative Sciences, 84(1), 3–20. https://doi.org/10.1177/0020852315619222
33.
KahnK. B.DaviesP. G. (2017). What influences shooter bias? The effects of suspect race, neighborhood, and clothing on decisions to shoot. Journal of Social Issues, 73, 723–743.
34.
KelloggK. C. (2019). Subordinate activation tactics: Semi-professionals and micro-level institutional change in professional organizations. Administrative Science Quarterly, 64(4), 928–975. https://doi.org/10.1177/0001839218804527
35.
KoslickiW. M.LytleD. J.WillitsD. W.BrooksR. (2021). ‘Rhetoric without reality’ or effective policing strategy? An analysis of the relationship between community policing and police fatal force. Journal of Criminal Justice, 72, 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2020.101730
36.
KrookM. L. (2015). Empowerment versus backlash: Gender quotas and critical mass theory. Politics, Groups, and Identities, 3(1), 184–188.
37.
LimH. H. (2006). Representative bureaucracy: Rethinking substantive effects and active representation. Public Administration Review, 66, 193–204.
38.
LongJ. S. (1997). Regression models for categorical and limited dependent variables. Sage.
39.
McColdP.WachtelB. (1996). Police officer orientation and resistance to implementation of community policing [Paper presentation]. Annual Meeting of the American Society of Criminology, Chicago, IL, 20–23 November 1996.
40.
MeierK. J. (1993). Latinos and representative bureaucracy testing the Thompson and Henderson hypotheses. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 3(4), 393–414.
41.
MeierK. J.Nicholson-CrottyJ. (2006). Gender, representative bureaucracy, and law enforcement: The case of sexual assault. Public Administration Review, 66(6), 850–860.
42.
MeierK. J.StewartJ. (1992). The impact of representative bureaucracies: Educational systems and public policies. American Review of Public Administration, 22(3), 157–171.
43.
MeierK. J.XuX. (2022). Critical thoughts about critical mass in representative bureaucracy: A theoretical exploration and empirical illustration. Governance, 36, 887–907. https://doi.org/10.1111/gove.12711
44.
MenifieldC. E.ShinG.StrotherL. (2019). Do white law enforcement officers target minority suspects?Public Administration Review, 79(1), 56–68. https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.12956
45.
MolinaA. L. (2016). A manager is a manager is a manager? Race and managerial impact on organizational performance. Public Organization Review, 16(1), 39–53. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11115-014-0292-9
Nicholson-CrottyS.Nicholson-CrottyJ.FernandezS. (2017). Will more black cops matter? Officer race and police-involved homicides of black citizens. Public Administration Review, 77(2), 206–216.
48.
OuseyG. C.UnneverJ. D. (2012). Racial-ethnic threat, out-group intolerance, and support for punishing criminals: A cross-national study. Criminology, 50(3), 565–603. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-9125.2012.00275.x
49.
OzkanT.WorrallJ. L.PiqueroA. R. (2016). Does minority representation in police agencies reduce assaults on the police?American Journal of Criminal Justice, 41(3), 402–423. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12103-016-9338-6
PérezR.WardG. (2019). From insult to estrangement and injury: The violence of racist police jokes. American Behavioral Scientist, 63(13), 1810–1829. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764219842617
53.
PicciottoH. (2008). A new path to the quadratic formula. The Mathematics Teacher, 101(6), 473–478.
54.
PittsD. W. (2007). Representative bureaucracy, ethnicity, and public schools: Examining the link between representation and performance. Administration & Society, 39(4), 497–526. https://doi.org/10.1177/0095399707303129
55.
Preito-HodgeK. (2023). Behind the badge and the veil: Black police officers in the era of Black Lives Matter. Psychology of Violence, 13(3), 171–182. https://doi.org/10.1037/vio0000462
56.
Preito-HodgeK.Tomaskovic-DeveyD. (2021). A tale of force: Examining policy proposals to address police violence. Social Currents, 8, 403–423.
57.
PyoS.LeeH. (2024). Gender representation in police organizations: Do upper-level and street-level female bureaucrats differ in their roles?Governance, 37, 241–259. https://doi.org/10.1111/gove.12758
58.
RaineyH. G. (2014). Understanding and managing public organizations (5 ed.). Jossey-Bass.
59.
RiccucciN. M.SaldivarK. (2014). The status of employment discrimination suits in police and fire departments across the United States. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 34(3), 263–288. https://doi.org/10.1177/0734371X12449839
60.
RiccucciN. M.Van RyzinG. G.JacksonK. (2018). Representative bureaucracy, race, and policing: A survey experiment. Journal of Public Administration Research And Theory, 28, 506–518.
61.
RidgewayG. (2007). Analysis of racial disparities in the New York Police Department’s stop, question, and frisk practices. RAND.
62.
RobertsS. O.RizzoM. T. (2021). The psychology of American racism. American Psychologist, 76(3), 475–487. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000642
63.
RogersL. O.RosarioR. J.PadillaD.FooC. (2021). “[I]t’s hard because it’s the cops that are killing us for stupid stuff”: Racial identity in the sociopolitical context of Black Lives Matter. Developmental Psychology, 57(1), 87–101. https://doi.org/10.1037/DEV0001130
64.
SaidelJ. R.LoscoccoK. (2005). Agency leaders, gendered institutions, and representative bureaucracy. Public Administration Review, 65(2), 158–170. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6210.2005.00441.x
65.
SassT. R.TroyerJ. L. (1999). Affirmative action, political representation, unions, and female police employment. Journal of Labor Research, 20, 571–587. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12122-999-0022-1
66.
SchaferJ. A.VaranoS. P.GalliP. M.FordT. (2021). Police supervisor attitudes toward organizational change. Journal of Crime and Justice, 44(3), 258–274. https://doi.org/10.1080/0735648X.2020.1803952
67.
SeldenS. C. (1997). Representative bureaucracy: Examining the linkage between passive and active representation in the Farmers Home Administration. American Review of Public Administration, 27, 22–42.
68.
SeldenS. C.BrudneyJ. L.KelloughJ. E. (1998). Bureaucracy as a representative institution: Toward a reconciliation of bureaucratic government and democratic theory. American Journal of Political Science, 42(3), 717–744.
69.
SelznickP. (2011). Leadership in administration: A sociological interpretation. Quid Pro Books.
70.
ShoubK.ChristianiL. (2023). Context matters: The conditional effect of black police chiefs on policing outcomes. Urban Affairs Review, 59(6), 2043–2056. https://doi.org/10.1177/10780874221113216
71.
SievertM. (2021). A replication of “representative bureaucracy and the willingness to coproduce”. Public Administration, 99, 616–632. https://doi.org/10.1111/padm.12743
72.
SievertM. (2023). The limited impact of reference groups’ symbolic gender representation on willingness to coproduce. Public Administration Review. https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.13619
73.
SimJ. J.CorrellJ.SadlerM. S. (2013). Understanding police and expert performance: When training attenuates (vs. exacerbates) stereotypic bias in the decision to shoot. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 39(3), 291–304. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167212473157
74.
SmithB. W.HolmesM. D. (2014). Police use of excessive force in minority communities: A test of the minority threat, place, and community accountability hypotheses. Social Problems, 61(1), 83–104.
75.
SongM. (2018). Gender representation and student performance: Representative bureaucracy goes to Korea. American Review of Public Administration, 48(4), 346–358. https://doi.org/10.1177/0275074016676888
76.
SpohnC. (2015). Race, crime, and punishment in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. Crime & Justice, 44(1), 49–97. https://doi.org/10.1086/681550
77.
TheobaldN. A.Haider-MarkelD. P. (2009). Race, bureaucracy, and symbolic representation: Interactions between citizens and police. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 19(2), 409–426. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/mun006
78.
ThompsonF. J. (1976). Minority groups in public bureaucracies: Are passive and active representation linked?Administration & Society, 8(2), 201–226.
79.
WebeckS.LeeH. (2022). The behavioral foundations of representative bureaucracy. Perspectives on Public Management and Governance, 5, 209–221. https://doi.org/10.1093/ppmgov/gvac013
WilkinsV. M.KeiserL. R. (2006). Linking passive and active representation by gender: The case of child support agencies. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 16(1), 87–102. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/mui023
82.
WilkinsV. M.WilliamsB. N. (2008). Black or blue: Racial profiling and representative bureaucracy. Public Administration Review, 68(4), 654–664. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6210.2008.00905.x
83.
WilkinsV. M.WilliamsB. N. (2009). Representing blue: Representative bureaucracy and racial profiling in the Latino community. Administration & Society, 40(8), 775–798. https://doi.org/10.1177/0095399708326332
84.
WilsonJ. Q. (2009). Varieties of police behavior: The management of law and order in eight communities. Harvard University Press.
85.
WuS. (2021). Leadership matters: Police chief race and fatal shootings by police officers. Social Science Quarterly, 102(1), 407–419.
86.
XuX.MeierK. J. (2022). Separating symbolic and active representation: A mixed methods study of gender and education in China. Public Management Review, 24, 1429–1451. https://doi.org/10.1080/14719037.2021.1900352
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
