This study uses Tobit to assess contextual punishment determinants for a large sample of felony drug cases that reached final disposition in 1990. After statistically holding constant ascribed and legal variables, the authors find that punishments for African American defendants in drug-related cases varied by social and political context. African American defendants adjudicated in jurisdictions characterized by a large Black population received reduced punishments; but in jurisdictions that were characterized by strong law-and-order political support, Black defendants received longer sentences. After introducing these interactions, Blacks faced on average reduced penalties for drug crimes. Blacks were the recipients of adjusted sentencing but not in the uniformly harsh direction proposed by much of the sentencing research. In sum, the results of this research add to the growing literature documenting the political foundations of punishment patterns in the U.S. criminal courts.
Albonetti, C.A. ( 1991). An integration of theories to explain judicial discretion . Social Problems, 38, 247-266.
2.
American Judicature Society. (2008). Judicial selection in the states. Retrieved from http://www.ajs.org/js/
3.
Barclay, S., & Birkland, T. ( 1998). Law, policymaking, and the policy process: Closing the gaps. Policy Studies Journal, 26, 227-243.
4.
Blakely v. Washington, 542 U.S. 296 (2004).
5.
Blalock, H.M., Jr. ( 1967). Toward a theory of minority-group relations. New York, NY: Capricorn Books.
6.
Blumer, H. ( 1958). Race prejudice as a sense of group position. Pacific Sociological Review, 1, 3-7.
7.
Brace, P., & Hall, M.G. ( 1993). Integrated models of judicial dissent. Journal of Politics, 55, 914-935.
8.
Brace, P., & Hall, M.G. ( 1995). Studying courts comparatively: The view from theAmerican states. Political Research Quarterly, 48, 5-29.
9.
Carp, R.A., & Stidham, R. ( 1996). Judicial process in America (3rd ed.). Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly Inc.
10.
Chambliss, W. ( 1994). Policing the Ghetto underclass: The politics of law- and law enforcement. Social Problems, 41, 177-194.
11.
Chappell, A.T., & Maggard, S.R. ( 2007). Applying Black’s theory of law to crack and cocaine dispositions. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 51, 264-278.
12.
Chiricos, T., Welch, K., & Gertz, M. ( 2004). Racial typification of crime and support for punitive measures. Criminology, 4, 359-389.
13.
Chiricos, T.G., & Crawford, C. ( 1995). Race and imprisonment: A contextual assessment of the evidence. D. F. Hawkins (Ed.), Ethnicity, race, and crime: Perspectives across time and place. Albany: State University of New York Press.
14.
Cook, B.B. ( 1977). Public opinion and federal judicial policy. American Journal of Political Science, 21, 567-600.
15.
Crawford, C., Chiricos, T., & Kleck, G. ( 1998). Race, racial threat, and sentencing of habitual offenders . Criminology, 36, 481-511.
16.
Crow, M.S. ( 2008). The complexities of prior record, race, ethnicity, and policy: Interactive effects in sentencing. Criminal Justice Review, 38, 502-523.
17.
Crow, M.S., & Bales, W. ( 2006). Focal concerns: The effect of sentencing policy as a practical constraint on sentencing decisions. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 30, 15-57.
18.
Curry, T.R., & Corral-Camacho, G. (2007). Sentencing young minority males for drug offenses: Testing for conditional effects between race/ethnicity, gender and age during the US war on drugs. Punishment and Society, 10, 253-276.
19.
Demuth, S., & Steffensmeier, D. (2004). Ethnicity effects on sentence outcomes in large urban courts: Comparisons among White, Black, and Hispanic defendants. Social Science Quarterly, 85, 994-1011.
20.
Edsall, T.B., & Edsall, M.D. ( 1991). Chain reaction: The impact of race, rights, and taxes on American politics. New York, NY: Norton.
21.
Fossett, M.A., & Kiecolt, K.J. ( 1989). The relative size of minority populations and White racial attitudes. Social Science Quarterly, 70, 820-835.
22.
Gabel, P., & Harris, P. ( 1983). Building power and breaking images: Critical legal theory and the practice of law. New York University: Review of Law and Social Change, 11, 369-412.
23.
Garland, D. ( 1991a). Punishment and culture: The symbolic dimension of criminal justice. Studies in Law, Politics, and Society, 11, 191-222.
24.
Garland, D. ( 1991b). Sociological perspectives on punishment. Crime and Justice: A Review of Research, 14, 115-166.
25.
Garland, D. ( 2001). The culture of control: Crime and social order in contemporary society. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
26.
Greene, W.H. ( 1993). Econometric analysis (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Macmillan Publishing Company.
27.
Griset, P. ( 1994). Determinate sentencing and the high cost of overblown rhetoric: The New York experience. Crime and Delinquency, 40, 532-548.
28.
Griset, P. ( 1996). Determinate sentencing and administrative discretion over time served in prison: A case study of Florida. Crime and Delinquency, 42, 127-143.
29.
Hagan, J. ( 1974). Extra-legal attributes and criminal sentencing: An assessment of a sociological viewpoint. Law & Society Review, 8, 357-383.
30.
Hall, M.G. ( 1987). Constituent influence in state supreme courts: Conceptual notes and a case study. Journal of Politics, 49, 1117-1124.
31.
Hall, M.G. ( 1992). Electoral politics and strategic voting in state supreme courts. The Journal of Politics, 54, 427-446.
32.
Hall, M.G., & Brace, P. ( 1992). Toward an integrated model of judicial voting behavior . American Politics Quarterly, 20, 147-168.
33.
Hall, M.G., & Brace, P. ( 1994). The vicissitudes of death by decree: Forces influencing capital punishment decision making in state supreme courts. Social Science Quarterly, 75, 136-151.
34.
Hall, M.G., & Brace, P. ( 1996). Justices’ responses to case facts: An interactive model. American Politics Quarterly, 24, 237-261.
35.
Hardy, K.A. ( 1983). Equity in court dispositions. In G. P. Witaker & C. D. Phillips (Eds.), Evaluating performance of criminal justice agencies (pp. 183-207). Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE.
36.
Harrington, M.P. & Spohn, C. ( 2007). Defining Sentence Type: Further Evidence against Use of the Total Incarceration Variable. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency. 44 (1): 36-63.
37.
Hawkins, H.C. ( 2005). Race and sentencing outcomes in Michigan. Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, 3, 91-109.
38.
Helms, R. ( 2009). Modeling the politics of punishment: A conceptual and empirical analysis of ‘law in action’ in criminal sentencing. Journal of Criminal Justice, 37, 10-20.
39.
Helms, R., & Costanza, S.E. (2009). Race, politics, and drug law enforcement: An analysis of civil asset forfeiture patterns across US counties. Policing and Society, 19, 1-19.
40.
Helms, R., & Jacobs, D. ( 2002). The political context of sentencing: An analysis of community and individual determinants. Social Forces, 81, 577-604.
41.
Holleran, D. & Spohn, C. ( 2004). On the use of the total incarceration variable in sentencing research. Criminology42:211-240.
42.
Howell, R. ( 2004). Sentencing reform lessons: From the sentencing reform act of 1984 to the Feeny amendment. The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 94, 1069-1106.
43.
Huang, W., Wilson, S., Finn, M.A., Ruback, B.R., & Friedmann, R.R. (1996). Individual and contextual influences on sentence lengths: Examining political conservatism. The Prison Journal, 76, 398-419.
44.
Hudson, B.A. ( 1987). Justice through punishment: A critique of the ‘justice’ model of corrections. London, England: MacMillan Education.
45.
Jacob, H. ( 1991). Decision making in trial courts. J. B. Gates & C. A. Johnson (Eds.), The American courts: A critical assessment. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly Inc.
46.
Jacob, H. ( 1995). Law and politics in the United States (2nd ed.). Boston, MA: Little, Brown & Company.
47.
Jacobs, D., & Helms, R. ( 1996). Towards a political model of incarceration: A time-series examination of multiple explanations for prison admission rates. American Journal of Sociology, 102, 323-357.
48.
Jacobs, D., & Helms, R. ( 1997). Testing coercive explanations for order: The determinants of law enforcement strength over time. Social Forces, 75, 1361-1392.
49.
Jacobs, D., & Helms, R. ( 1999). Collective outbursts, politics, and punitive resources: Toward a political sociology of spending on social control. Social Forces, 77, 1497-1524.
50.
Jacobs, D. and Helms, R. ( 2001). Toward a Political Sociology of Punishment: Politics and Changes in the Incarcerated Population. Social Science Research, 30 (2001): 171-194.
51.
Kleck, G. ( 1981). Racial discrimination in criminal sentencing: A critical evaluation of the evidence with additional evidence on the death penalty. American Sociological Review, 46, 783-805.
52.
Kleck, G. ( 1985). Life support for ailing hypotheses: Modes of summarizing the evidence for racial discrimination in sentencing. Law and Human Behavior, 9, 271-285.
53.
Kritzer, H.M. ( 1979). Political cultures, trial courts, and criminal cases . In P. F. Nardulli (Ed.), The study of criminal courts: Political perspectives (pp. 131-169). Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.
54.
Kuklinski, J.H., & Stanga, J.E. ( 1979). Political participation and government responsiveness: The behavior of California superior courts. The American Political Science Review, 73, 1090-1099.
55.
Long, J.S. ( 1997). Regression models for categorical and limited dependent variables. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE .
56.
McIntosh, W.V. ( 1991). Courts and socioeconomic change. In J. B. Gates & C. A. Johnson (Eds.), The American courts: A critical assessment . Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly Inc.
57.
Myers, M.A. ( 1989). Symbolic policy and the sentencing of drug offenders . Law & Society Review, 23, 293-315.
58.
Myers, M.A., & Talarico, S.M. (1987). The social contexts of criminal sentencing. New York, NY: Springer-Verlag.
59.
Osgood, D.W., & Rowe, D.C. ( 1994). Bridging criminal careers, theory, and policy through latent variable models of individual offending. Criminology , 32, 517-554.
60.
Pasko, L. ( 2002). Villain or victim: Regional variation and ethnic disparity in federal drug offense sentencing. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 13, 307-328.
61.
Peterson, R.D., & Hagan, J. ( 1984). Changing conceptions of race: Towards an account of anomalous findings of sentencing research. American Sociological Review , 49, 56-70.
62.
Pratt, T. ( 1998). Race and sentencing: A meta-analysis of conflicting empirical research results. Journal of Criminal Justice, 26, 513-523.
63.
Rosenbaum, D.P., Lurigio, A.J., & Davis, R.C. ( 1998). The prevention of crime: Social and situational strategies . Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
64.
Sampson, R.J., & Laub, J.H. ( 1993). Structural variations in juvenile court processing: Inequality, the underclass, and social control. Law & Society Review , 27, 285-311.
65.
Savelsberg, J. ( 1994). Knowledge, domination, and criminal punishment. American Journal of Sociology, 99, 11-43.
66.
Scheingold, S.A. ( 1984). The politics of law and order. New York, NY: Longman.
67.
Scheingold, S.A. ( 1990). The politicization of street crime: The cedar city experience . Studies in Law, Politics, and Society, 10, 175-215.
68.
Scheingold, S.A. ( 1991). The politics of street crime. Philadelphia , PA: Temple University Press.
69.
StataCorp. (2008). Stata statistical software, Release 10.0. College Station, TX: StataCorp.
70.
Steen, S., & Bandy, R. ( 2007). When the punishment becomes the problem: Criminal justice in the new millennium. Punishment and Society, 9, 5-26.
71.
Steffensmeier, D., & Britt, C. ( 2001). Judges’ race and judicial decision making: Do black judges sentence differently? Social Science Quarterly, 82, 749-764.
72.
Steffensmeier, D., & Demuth, S. ( 2000). Ethnicity and sentencing outcomes in U.S. federal courts who is punished more harshly? American Sociological Review , 65, 705-729.
73.
Steffensmeier, D., Jeffery, T.U., & John, K. ( 1998). The interaction of race, gender, and age in criminal sentencing: The punishment cost of being young, black, and male. Criminology, 36, 763-798.
74.
Steffensmeier, D. and Demuth, S. ( 2006). Does Gender Modify the Effects of Race-Ethnicity on Criminal Sanctioning? Sentences for Male and Female White, Black, and Hispanic Defendants . Journal of Quantitative Criminology22:241-261.
75.
Stucky, T.D., Heimer, K., & Lang, J.B. ( 2007). A bigger piece of the pie? State corrections spending and the politics of social order. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 44, 91-123.
76.
Taylor, M.C. ( 1998). How White attitudes vary with the racial composition of local populations: Numbers count. American Sociological Review, 63, 512-535.
77.
Tonry, M.H. ( 1994). Racial politics, racial disparities, and the war on crime . Crime and Delinquency, 40, 475-494.
78.
Tonry, M.H. ( 1995). Malign Neglect-Race, Crime, and Punishment in America . Oxford University Press.
79.
Traut, C.A., & Emmert, C.F. ( 1998). Expanding the integrated model of judicial decision making: The California justices and capital punishment. The Journal of Politics, 60, 1166-1180.
80.
Ulmer, J.T., Kurlychek, M.C., & Kramer, J.H. ( 2007). Prosecutorial discretion and the imposition of mandatory minimum sentences. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency , 44, 427-458.
81.
United States v. Booker (04-104) 543 U.S. 220 (2005) No. 04-104, 375 F.3d 508.
82.
U.S. Census of Population and Housing. (1992 ). Summary tape file 3 on CD-ROM (Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Vermont, and Virginia) [Machine-Readable Data Files]. Prepared by the Bureau of the Census. Washington, DC: The Bureau.
83.
U.S. Sentencing Commission. (2008). The U.S. sentencing commission annual report. [Technical Report].
84.
von Hirsch, A. ( 1976). Doing justice: The choice of punishments. New York, NY: Hill & Wang.
85.
von Hirsch, A. ( 1985). Past or future crimes: Deservedness and dangerousness in the sentencing of criminals. Piscataway, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
86.
Wahlbeck, P.J. ( 1997). The life of the law: Judicial politics and legal change . The Journal of Politics, 59, 778-802.
87.
Waltman, J.L., & Bowers, D.A. ( 1993). Do more conservative states impose harsher felony sentences? An exploratory analysis of 32 states. Criminal Justice Review , 18, 61-70.
88.
Weidner, R.R., Frase, R.S., & Schultz, J.S. ( 2005). The impact of contextual factors on the decision to imprison in large urban jurisdictions: A multilevel analysis. Crime and Delinquency, 51, 400-424.
89.
Wright, G.C., Erickson, R.S., & McIver, J.P. (1987). Public opinion and policy liberalism in theAmerican states. American Journal of Political Science, 31, 980-1001.
90.
Zatz, M.S. ( 1987). The changing forms of racial/ethnic biases in sentencing . Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 24, 69-92.
