U.S. schools suspend 2.5 million children each school year. Although states mandate suspensions for serious offenses, most students are suspended for minor transgressions, such as “willful defiance” of authority. Moreover, districts suspend students of color for minor issues at higher rates than White children. In response, California banned suspension for “willful defiance” in elementary schools statewide in 2015 and larger districts eliminated the practice for all grades throughout the 2010s. In this article, we use California Department of Education (CDE) data from 2011 to 2018 to determine: (1) whether banning suspension for willful defiance changes school district suspension rates; (2) whether these bans are associated with changes in special education enrollment; and (3) how these relationships differ by the race/ethnicity of the student.
AB-420, Amendment to Section 48900 of the California Education Code (2014).
2.
American Institutes of Research. 2022. Compendium of School Discipline Laws and Regulations. Washington, DC: National Center on Safe and Supportive Learning Environments. Retrieved August 5, 2022 (https://safesupportivelearning.ed.gov/school-discipline-compendium).
3.
ArciaE.2006. “Achievement and Enrollment Status of Suspended Students: Outcomes in a Large, Multicultural School District.” Education and Urban Society38(3):359–69.
4.
BearG. G.2012. “Both Suspension and Alternatives Work, Depending on One’s Aim.” Journal of School Violence11:174–86.
5.
BernalJ. L.CumminsS.GasparriniA.. 2017. “Interrupted Time Series Regression for the Evaluation of Public Health Interventions: A Tutorial.” International Journal of Epidemiology46(1):348–55.
6.
BradshawC. P.MitchellM. M.LeafP. J.. 2010. “Examining the Effects of Schoolwide Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports on Student Outcomes: Results from a Randomized Controlled Effectiveness Trial in Elementary Schools.” Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions12(3):133–48.
7.
BradshawC. P.SawyerA. L.O’BrennanL. M.. 2009. “A Social Disorganization Perspective on Bullying-related Attitudes and Behaviors: The Influence of School Context.” American Journal of Community Psychology43(3):204–20.
8.
BradshawC. P.WaasdorpT. E.LeafP. J.. 2012. “Effects of School-wide Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports on Child Behavior Problems.” Pediatrics130(5):e1136–45.
9.
BrockS. E.JimersonS. R.HansenR. L.. 2009. Identifying, Assessing, and Treating ADHD at School. Boston, MA: Springer.
CarrellS. E.HoekstraM. L.. 2010. “Externalities in the Classroom: How Children Exposed to Domestic Violence Affect Everyone’s Kids.” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics2(1):211–28.
13.
ConradP.1992. “Medicalization and Social Control.” Annual Review of Sociology18(1):209–32.
14.
ConradP.2007. The Medicalization of Society: On the Transformation of Human Conditions into Treatable Disorders. Baltimore, MD: JHU Press.
15.
CurranF. C.2016. “Estimating the Effect of State Zero Tolerance Laws on Exclusionary Discipline, Racial Discipline Gaps, and Student Behavior.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis38(4):647–68.
EdwardsL.2016. “Homogeneity and Inequality: School Discipline Inequality and the Role of Racial Composition.” Social Forces95(1):55–76.
18.
FarkasG.MorganP. L.HillemeierM. M.MitchellC.WoodsA. D.. 2020. “District-level Achievement Gaps Explain Black and Hispanic Overrepresentation in Special Education.” Exceptional Children86(4):374–92.
19.
FergusonA. A.2000. Bad Boys: Public Schools in the Making of Black Masculinity. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
20.
FiglioD. N.2007. “Boys Named Sue: Disruptive Children and Their Peers.” Education Finance and Policy2(4):376–94.
21.
FisherA. E.FisherS.ArsenaultC.JacobR.Barnes-NajorJ.. 2020. “The Moderating Role of Ethnic Identity on the Relationship between School Climate and Self-esteem for African American Adolescents.” School Psychology Review49(3):291–305.
GelmanA.HillJ.. 2007. Data Analysis Using Regression and Multilevel/Hierarchical Models. New York: Cambridge University Press.
25.
GerberM. M.SemmelM. I.. 1984. “Teacher as Imperfect Test: Reconceptualizing the Referral Process.” Educational Psychologist19(3):137–48.
26.
GregoryA.ClawsonK.DavisA.GerewitzJ.. 2016. “The Promise of Restorative Practices to Transform Teacher-student Relationships and Achieve Equity in School Discipline.” Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation26(4):325–53.
27.
GregoryA.SkibaR. J.NogueraP. A.. 2010. “The Achievement Gap and the Discipline Gap: Two Sides of the Same Coin?”Educational Researcher39(1):59–68.
28.
GregoryA.WeinsteinR. S.. 2008. “The Discipline Gap and African Americans: Defiance or Cooperation in the High School Classroom.” Journal of School Psychology46(4):455–75.
29.
HallbergK.WilliamsR.SwanlundA.EnoJ.. 2018. “Short Comparative Interrupted Time Series Using Aggregate School-level Data in Education Research.” Educational Researcher47(5):295–306.
HelmstetterE.CurryC. A.BrennanM.Sampson-SaulM.. 1998. “Comparison of General and Special Education Classrooms of Students with Severe Disabilities.” Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities33(3):216–27.
32.
HinshawS. P.SchefflerR. M.. 2014. The ADHD Explosion: Myths, Medication, Money, and Today's Push for Performance. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
33.
HirschfieldP. J.2008. “Preparing for Prison? The Criminalization of School Discipline in the USA.” Theoretical Criminology12(1):79–101.
34.
HollerR. A.ZirkelP. A.. 2008. “Section 504 and Public Schools: A National Survey Concerning ‘Section 504-only’ Students.” NASSP Bulletin92(1):19–43.
35.
HuangF. L.CornellD. G.. 2017. “Student Attitudes and Behaviors as Explanations for the Black-White Suspension Gap.” Children and Youth Services Review73:298–308.
36.
JacobsenW. C.PaceG. T.RamirezN. G.. 2019. “Punishment and Inequality at an Early Age: Exclusionary Discipline in Elementary School.” Social Forces97(3):973–98.
KimC. Y.LosenD. J.HewittD. T.. 2010. The School-to-prison Pipeline: Structuring Legal Reform. New York, NY: NYU Press.
39.
KupchikA.2016. The Real School Safety Problem: The Long-term Consequences of Harsh School Punishment. University of California Press.
40.
LavinM. F.2016. They call us problem child: Delinquency, medicalization, and social class in primary education. Deviant Behavior37(11):1276–1287.
41.
LosenD. J.HodsonC.EeJ.MartinezT.. 2014. “Disturbing Inequities: Exploring the Relationship between Racial Disparities in Special Education Identification and Discipline.” Journal of Applied Research on Children5(2):15.
MandellD. S.DavisJ. K.BevansK.GuevaraJ. P.. 2008. “Ethnic Disparities in Special Education Labeling Among Children with Attention-deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder.” Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders16(1):42–51.
45.
MittlemanJ.2018. “A Downward Spiral? Childhood Suspension and the Path to Juvenile Arrest.” Sociology of Education91(3):183–204.
46.
MoodyM.2016. “From Under-diagnoses to Over-representation: Black Children, ADHD, and the School-to-prison Pipeline.” Journal of African American Studies20(2):152–63.
47.
MorganP. L.FarkasG.. 2016. “Are We Helping All the Children that We Are Supposed to Be Helping?.” Educational Researcher45:226–28.
48.
MorganP. L.FarkasG.CookM.StrassfeldN. M.HillemeierM. M.PunW. H.SchusslerD. L.. 2017. “Are Black Children Disproportionately Overrepresented in Special Education? A Best-evidence Synthesis.” Exceptional Children83(2):181–98.
49.
MorganP. L.FarkasG.CookM.StrassfeldN. M.HillemeierM. M.PunW. H.WangY.SchusslerD. L.. 2018. “Are Hispanic, Asian, Native American, or Language-minority Children Overrepresented in Special Education?”Exceptional Children84(3):261–79.
50.
MorganP. L.HillemeierM. M.FarkasG.MaczugaS.. 2014. “Racial/Ethnic Disparities in ADHD Diagnosis by Kindergarten Entry.” Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry55(8):905–13.
51.
MorganP. L.StaffJ.HillemeierM. M.FarkasG.MaczugaS.. 2013. “Racial and Ethnic Disparities in ADHD Diagnosis from Kindergarten to Eighth Grade.” Pediatrics132(1):85–93.
52.
MorrisE. W.PerryB. L.. 2016. “The Punishment Gap: School Suspension and Racial Disparities in Achievement.” Social Problems63(1):68–86.
53.
MorrisE. W.PerryB. L.. 2017. “Girls Behaving Badly? Race, Gender, and Subjective Evaluation in the Discipline of African American Girls.” Sociology of Education90(2):127–48.
54.
MowenT.BrentJ.. 2016. “School Discipline as a Turning Point: The Cumulative Effect of Suspension on Arrest.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency53(5):628–53.
55.
MummoloJ.PetersonE.. 2018. “Improving the Interpretation of Fixed Effects Regression Results.” Political Science Research and Methods6(4):829–35.
56.
National Association of State Boards of Education. 2022. “School Health Policies: State Policy Database.” Retrieved August 5, 2022 (https://www.nasbe.org/).
57.
OkonofuaJ. A.EberhardtJ. L.. 2015. “Two Strikes: Race and the Disciplining of Young Students.” Psychological Science26(5):617–24.
58.
OwensJ.McLanahanS. S.. 2020. “Unpacking the Drivers of Racial Disparities in School Suspension and Expulsion.” Social Forces98(4):1548–77.
59.
PayneA. A.WelchK.. 2010. “Modeling the Effects of Racial Threat on Punitive and Restorative School Discipline Practices.” Criminology48(4):1019–62.
60.
PearmanF. A.CurranF. C.FisherB.GardellaJ.. 2019. “Are Achievement Gaps Related to Discipline Gaps? Evidence from National Data.” AERA Open5(4):1–18.
61.
PérezB.SkibaR. J.ChungC.-G.. 2008. Latino Students and Disproportionality in Special Education: Education Policy Brief. Volume 6, Number 2. Bloomington, IN: Center for Evaluation and Education Policy, Indiana University.
62.
PerryB. L.MorrisE. W.. 2014. “Suspending Progress: Collateral Consequences of Exclusionary Punishment in Public Schools.” American Journal of Sociology79(6):1067–87.
63.
RameyD. M.2015. “The Social Structure of Criminalized and Medicalized School Discipline.” Sociology of Education88(3): 181–201.
64.
RameyD. M.2016. “The Influence of Early School Punishment and Therapy/Medication on Social Control Experiences during Young Adulthood.” Criminology54(1): 113–41.
65.
RameyD. M. (2020). “Recent Developments in School Social Control.” Sociology Compass14(2): e12743.
66.
Raffaele-MendezL. M.KnoffH. M.FerronJ. M.. 2002. “School Demographic Variables and Out-of-school Suspension Rates: A Quantitative and Qualitative Analysis of a Large, Ethnically Diverse School District.” Psychology in the Schools39(3):259–77.
67.
RobbJ. A.SibleyM. H.PelhamW. E.FosterE. M.MolinaB. S. G.GnagyE. M.KuriyanA. B.. 2011. “The Estimated Annual Cost of ADHD to the US Education System.” School Mental Health3(3):169–77.
68.
RockE. E.FesslerM. A.ChurchR. P.. 1997. “The Concomitance of Learning Disabilities and Emotional/Behavioral Disorders: A Conceptual Model.” Journal of Learning Disabilities30(3):245–63.
69.
SkibaR. J.ArtilesA. J.KozleskiE. B.LosenD. J.HarryE. G.. 2016. “Risks and Consequences of Oversimplifying Educational Inequities: A Response to Morgan et al. 2015.” Educational Researcher45:221–25.
70.
SkibaR. J.MichaelR. S.NardoA. C.PetersonR. L.. 2002. “The Color of Discipline: Sources of Racial and Gender Disproportionality in School Punishment.” The Urban Review34(4):317–42.
71.
SkibaR. J.ShureL.WilliamsN.. 2012. “Racial and Ethnic Disproportionality in Suspension and Expulsion.” Pp.89–118 in Disproportionality in Education and Special Education: A Guide to Creating More Equitable Learning Environments, edited by NoltemeyerA. L.McLoughlin.C. S.Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas Publisher.
72.
SnyderT. D.de BreyC.DillowS. A.. 2019. Digest of Education Statistics 54th edition (NCES 2020-009). Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
73.
SteffensmeierD.UlmerJ. T.FeldmeyerB.HarrisC. T.. 2010. “Scope and Conceptual Issues in Testing the Race–Crime Invariance Thesis: Black, White, and Hispanic Comparisons.” Criminology48:1133–69.
74.
SullivanA. L.ProctorS. L.. 2016. “The Shield or the Sword? Revisiting the Debate on Racial Disproportionality in Special Education and Implications for School Psychologists.” School Psychology Forum10(3):278–88.
