Research indicates men often receive greater merit rewards than women for the same performance. It is unclear, however, whether gender differences in merit rewards narrow with increasing firm tenure or whether gender differences in merit-rewards stay constant across employees' firm-internal career. Using longitudinal personnel records of a private U.S. employer (2005–2014), the author finds no evidence for declining gender effects on pay when employees stay longer, not even among nonprofessionals where performance is easier to assess. Results contradict information-based theories and speak to status characteristics theory. Moreover, gender disparities are significant only when supervisors have discretion over merit increases.
AbendrothA.-K.MelzerS.KalevA.Tomaskovic-DeveyD. (2016).
Women at work: Women’s access to power and the gender earnings gap. ILR Review,
70(1), 190–222.
2.
AbrahamM. (2017).
Pay formalization revisited: Considering the effects of manager gender and discretion on closing the wage gap. Academy of Management Journal,
60(1), 29–54.
3.
AckerJ. (2006).
Inequality regimes: Gender, race, and class in organizations. Gender & Society,
20, 441–464.
4.
AignerD. J.CainG. G. (1977).
Statistical theories of discrimination in labor markets. Industrial and Labor Relations Review,
30(2), 175–187.
5.
AkerlofG. A. (1970).
The market for ‘lemons’. Uncertainty and the market mechanism. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,
84, 488–500.
6.
AlkadryM. G.TowerL. E. (2006).
Unequal pay: The role of gender. Public Administration Review,
66(6), 888–898.
7.
AltonjiJ. G.PierretC. R. (2001).
Employer learning and statistical discrimination. Quarterly Journal of Economics,
116(1), 313–350.
8.
AlvessonM. (2001).
Knowledge work: Ambiguity, image and identity. Human Relations,
54(7), 863–886.
9.
ArrowK. J. (1973). The theory of discrimination. In AshenfelterO.ReesA. (Eds.), Discrimination in labor markets (pp. 1--31).
Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press.
10.
AuspurgK.HinzT.SauerC. (2017).
Why should women get less? Evidence on the gender pay gap from multifactorial survey experiments. American Sociological Review,
82(1), 179–210.
11.
BabcockL.LascheverS. (2003). Women don’t ask: Negotiation and the gender divide.
Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press.
12.
BaronJ. N. (1984).
Organizational perspectives on stratification. Annual Review of Sociology,
10(1), 37–69.
13.
BaronJ. N.HannanM. T.HsuG.KoçakÖ. (2007).
In the company of women: Gender inequality and the logic of bureaucracy in start-up firms. Work and Occupations,
34, 35–66.
14.
BaronJ. N.PfefferJ. (1994).
The social-psychology of organizations and inequality. Social Psychology Quarterly,
57, 190–209.
15.
BelliveauM. A. (2012).
Engendering inequity? How social accounts create vs. merely explain unfavorable pay outcomes for women. Organization Science,
23(4), 1154–1174.
16.
BergerJ.CohenB. P.ZelditchM. (1972).
Status characteristics and social interaction. American Sociological Review,
37(3), 241–255.
17.
BergerJ.FisekM. H.NormanR. Z.WagnerD. G. (1985). The formation of reward expectation in status situations. In BergerJ.ZelditchM. (Eds.), Status, rewards, and influence (pp. 121--154).
San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass.
18.
BergerJ.NormanR. Z.BalkwellJ. W.SmithR. F. (1992).
Status-inconsistency in task situations – A test of 4 status processing principles. American Sociological Review,
57, 843–855.
19.
BianchiS. M.RobinsonJ. P.MilkieM. A. (2006). Changing rhythms of American family life.
New York, NY:
Russell Sage Foundation.
20.
BidwellM. (2011).
Paying more to get less: The effects of external hiring versus internal mobility. Administrative Science Quarterly,
56, 369–407.
21.
Bidwell, M., Briscoe, F., Fernandez-Mateo, I., & Sterling, A. (2013). The Employment Relationship and Inequality: How and Why Changes in Employment Practices Are Reshaping Rewards in Organizations. The Academy of Management Annals, 7, 61--121.
22.
BidwellM.MollickE. (2015).
Shifts and ladders: Comparing the role of internal and external mobility in executive careers. Organization Science,
26(6), 1629–1645.
23.
BielbyW. T. (2000).
Minimizing workplace gender and racial bias. Contemporary Sociology – A Journal of Reviews,
29, 120–129.
24.
BlauF. D.KahnL. M. (2017).
The gender wage gap: Extent, trends, and explanations. Journal of Economic Literature,
55(3), 789–865.
25.
BrettJ. M.StrohL. K. (1997).
Jumping ship. Who benefits from an external labor market strategy?Journal of Applied Psychology,
82, 331–341.
26.
BrewerM. B. (1988). A dual process model of impression formation. In ScrullT.WyerR. S.HaslamS. A. (Eds.), Advances in social cognition (
Vol. 1) (pp. 1--36).
Hillsdale, NJ:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
27.
BrewerM. B.LuiL. N. (1989).
The primacy of age and sex in the structure of person categories. Social Cognition,
7(3), 262–274.
28.
BrowneI.MisraJ. (2003).
The intersection of gender and race in the labor market. Annual Review of Sociology,
29, 487–513.
29.
CastillaE. J. (2008).
Gender, race, and meritocracy in organizational careers. American Journal of Sociology,
113, 1479–1526.
30.
CastillaE. J. (2015).
Accounting for the gap: A firm study manipulating organizational accountability and transparency in pay decisions. Organization Science,
26(2), 311–333.
31.
CastillaE. J.BenardS. (2010).
The paradox of meritocracy in organizations. Administrative Science Quarterly,
55, 543–576.
32.
ChanC. K.AntebyM. (2015).
Task segregation as a mechanism for within-job inequality: Women and men of the transportation security administration. Administrative Science Quarterly,
61(2), 184–216.
33.
CollinsP. H. (2015).
Intersectionality’s definitional dilemmas. Annual Review of Sociology,
41, 1–20.
34.
CookeT. J. (2003).
Family migration and the relative earnings of husbands and wives. Annals of the Association of American Geographers,
93(3), 338–349.
35.
CorrellS. J.BenardS. (2006). Biased estimators? Comparing status and statistical theories of gender discrimination. In ThyeS. R. (Ed.), Social psychology of the workplace (
Vol. 23, pp. 89–116).
Stamford, CT:
Jai Press Inc.
36.
DiPreteT. A.EirichG. M. (2006).
Cumulative advantage as a mechanism for inequality: A review of theoretical and empirical developments. Annual Review of Sociology,
32(1), 271–297.
37.
DobbinF.SchrageD.KalevA. (2015).
Rage against the iron cage. American Sociological Review,
80(5), 1014–1044.
38.
DokkoG.WilkS. L.RothbardN. P. (2009).
Unpacking prior experience: How career history affects job performance. Organization Science,
20(1), 51–68.
39.
DreherG. F.CoxT. (2000).
Labor market mobility and cash compensation: The moderating effects of race and gender. The Academy of Management Journal,
43, 890–900.
40.
DreherG. F.LeeJ.-Y.ClerkinT. A. (2011).
Mobility and cash compensation: The moderating effects of gender, race, and executive search firms. Journal of Management,
37, 651–681.
41.
DwyerR. E. (2004).
Downward earnings mobility after voluntary employer exits. Work and Occupations,
31, 111–138.
42.
ElviraM. M.GrahamM. E. (2002).
Not just a formality: Pay system formalization and sex-related earnings effects. Organization Science,
13(6), 601–617.
43.
FergusonK. (1984). The feminist case against bureaucracy.
Philadelphia, PA:
Temple University Press.
44.
FoschiM. (1989). Status characteristics, standards, and attributions. In BergerJ.ZelditchM.AndersonB. (Eds.), Sociological theories in progress: New formulations (pp. 58–72).
Newbury Park, CA:
Sage Publications.
45.
FoschiM. (1996).
Double standards in the evaluation of men and women. Social Psychology Quarterly,
59, 237–254.
46.
FoschiM. (2000).
Double standards for competence: Theory and research. Annual Review of Sociology,
26, 21–42.
47.
FreidsonE. (1988). Professional powers: A study of the institutionalization of formal knowledge.
Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press.
48.
FullerS. (2008).
Job mobility and wage trajectories for men and women in the United States. American Sociological Review,
73, 158–183.
49.
GlassJ. (2004).
Blessing or curse? Work-family policies and mother’s wage growth over time. Work and Occupations,
31, 367–394.
50.
GoldinC. (2014).
A grand gender convergence: Its last chapter. American Economic Review,
104(4), 109–119.
51.
GreenmanE.XieY. (2008).
Double jeopardy? The interaction of gender and race on earnings in the United States. Social Forces,
86(3), 1217–1244.
52.
HachenD. S. (1990).
Three models of job mobility in labor markets. Work and Occupations,
17, 320–354.
53.
HalabyC. N. (1988).
Action and information in the job mobility process – The search decision. American Sociological Review,
53, 9–25.
54.
HodsonR.SullivanT. (2012). The social organization of work (
Vol. 2012, 5th ed.).
Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth Cengage Learning.
55.
IacusS. M.KingG.PorroG. (2011).
Multivariate matching methods that are monotonic imbalance bounding. Journal of the American Statistical Association,
106(493), 345–361.
56.
IacusS. M.KingG.PorroG. (2012).
Causal inference without balance checking: Coarsened exact matching. Political Analysis,
20(1), 1–24.
57.
IbarraH. (1992).
Homophily and differential returns – Sex-differences in network structure and access in an advertising firm. Administrative Science Quarterly,
37, 422–447.
58.
JoshiA.SonJ.RohH. (2015).
When can women close the gap? A meta-analytic test of sex differences in performance and rewards. Academy of Management Journal,
58(5), 1516–1545.
59.
JovanovicB. (1979).
Job matching and the theory of turnover. Journal of Political Economy,
87, 972–990.
60.
KalevA.DobbinF.KellyE. (2006).
Practices or best guesses? Assessing the efficacy of corporate affirmative action and diversity policies. American Sociological Review,
71, 589–617.
61.
KnokeD.IshioY. (1998).
The gender gap in company job training. Work and Occupations,
25, 141–167.
62.
KronbergA.-K. (2013).
Stay or leave? Externalization of job mobility and the effect on the US gender earnings gap, 1979-2009. Social Forces,
91, 1117–1146.
63.
LamS.DreherG. (2004).
Gender, extra-firm mobility, and compensation attainment in the United States and Hong Kong. Journal of Organizational Behavior,
25, 791–805.
64.
LynessK. S.HeilmanM. E. (2006).
When fit is fundamental: Performance evaluations and promotions of upper-level female and male managers. Journal of Applied Psychology,
91(4), 777–785.
65.
MandelH.SemyonovM. (2016).
Going back in time? Gender differences in trends and sources of the racial pay gap, 1970 to 2010. American Sociological Review,
81(5), 1039–1068.
66.
McDonaldS.LinN.AoD. (2009).
Networks of opportunity: Gender, race, and job leads. Social Problems,
56, 385–402.
67.
MilgromE. M. M.PetersenT.SnartlandV. (2001).
Equal pay for equal work? Evidence from Sweden and a comparison with Norway and the U.S. The Scandinavian Journal of Economics,
103(4), 559–583.
68.
OettingerG. S. (1996).
Statistical discrimination and the early career evolution of the black-white wage gap. Journal of Labor Economics,
14, 52–78.
69.
PearlmanJ. (2018).
Gender differences in the impact of job mobility on earnings: The role of occupational segregation. Social Science Research,
74, 30–44.
70.
PetersenT.MorganL. A. (1995).
Separate and unequal: Occupation-establishment sex segregation and the gender wage gap. American Journal of Sociology,
101, 329–365.
71.
PetersenT.SaportaI. (2004).
The opportunity structure for discrimination. American Journal of Sociology,
109, 852–901.
72.
PetersenT.SnartlandV.BeckenL.-E.OlsenK. M. (1997).
Within-job wage discrimination and the gender wage gap: The case of Norway. European Sociological Review,
13(2), 199–213.
73.
PhelpsE. S. (1972).
The statistical theory of racism and sexism. American Economic Review,
62, 659–661.
74.
PughM. D.WahrmanR. (1983).
Neutralizing sexism in mixed-sex groups – Do women have to be better than men?American Journal of Sociology,
88, 746–762.
75.
Quintana-GarcíaC.ElviraM. M. (2016).
The effect of the external labor market on the gender pay gap among executives. ILR Review,
70(1), 132–159.
76.
RashotteL. S.WebsterM.Jr. (2005).
Gender status beliefs. Social Science Research,
34(3), 618–633.
77.
RaudenbushS. W.BrykA. S. (2002). Hierarchical linear models. Applications and data analysis models (2nd ed.).
Thousand Oaks, CA:
Sage Publications.
78.
ReskinB. F. (2000).
The proximate causes of employment discrimination. Contemporary Sociology- A Journal of Reviews,
29, 319–328.
79.
ReskinB. F.McBrierD. B. (2000).
Why not ascription? Organizations’ employment of male and female managers. American Sociological Review,
65, 210–233.
80.
RiderC. I.NegroG. (2015).
Organizational failure and intraprofessional status loss. Organization Science,
26(3), 633–649.
81.
RidgewayC.CorrellS. (2004).
Unpacking the gender system – A theoretical perspective on gender beliefs and social relations. Gender & Society,
18, 510–531.
82.
RidgewayC. L. (1997).
Interaction and the conservation of gender inequality: Considering employment. American Sociological Review,
62, 218–235.
83.
RidgewayC. L. (2011). Framed by gender: How gender inequality persists in the modern world.
New York, NY:
Oxford University Press.
84.
SalancikG. R.PfefferJ. (1978).
Uncertainty, secrecy, and choice of similar others. Social Psychology,
41, 246–255.
85.
SingerJ. D.WilletJ. B. (2003). Applied longitudinal data. Modeling change and event occurrence.
Toronto, Canada:
Oxford University Press.
86.
StainbackK.Tomaskovic-DeveyD.SkaggsS. (2010).
Organizational approaches to inequality: Inertia, relative power, and environments.Annual Review of Sociology,
36, 225–247.
87.
SteinpreisR. E.AndersK. A.RitzkeD. (1999).
The impact of gender on the review of the curricula vitae of job applicants and tenure candidates: A national empirical study. Sex Roles,
41, 509–528.
88.
SterlingA. D.FernandezR. M. (2018).
Once in the door: Gender, tryouts, and the initial salaries of managers. Management Science,
64(6), 5444--5460.
89.
TetlockP. E.MitchellG. (2009). Implicit bias and accountability systems: What must organizations do to prevent discrimination? Research in Organizational Behavior, 29, 3--38.
90.
Tomaskovic-DeveyD.Avent-HoltD. (2019). Relational inequalities: An organizational approach.
New York, NY:
Oxford University Press.
91.
TopelR. H.WardM. P. (1992).
Job mobility and careers of young men. Quarterly Journal of Economics,
107, 439–480.
92.
WaldmanM. (1984).
Job assignments, signaling, and efficiency. The RAND Journal of Economics,
15(2), 255–267.
93.
WilliamsC. L.KilanskiK.MullerC. (2014).
Corporate diversity programs and gender inequality in the oil and gas industry. Work and Occupations,
41(4), 440–476.
94.
WoodhamsC.LuptonB.PerkinsG.CowlingM. (2015).
Multiple disadvantage and wage growth: The effect of merit pay on pay gaps. Human Resource Management,
54(2), 283–301.
