Take politics off the table: A study of Italian youth’s self-managed dairy restriction and healthy consumerism

Abstract

French

The last 20 years have been characterized by very different dynamics: massive reduction of milk and, to a lesser extent, dairy consumption; fewer positive attitudes towards milk; no reclaims for affordable, public dairy production; the development of a large conversation about the presumed risks associated with the intake of lactose; and semantic battles on non-dairy ‘milk’ alternatives. These new attitudes haven’t been systematically studied. We explore here the links between milk/dairy consumption, health concerns, and trust in medical expertise. Through an online survey of highly educated youth in Italy (N=378) we have investigated: milk and dairy consumption; attitudes towards items carried out by vegan movements; attitudes towards medical expertise and trust in counseling by general practitioners. Results show that anti-speciesist and vegan movements are very little known among consumers. Data display very limited impact of the ideas and concepts of anti-milk movements within our sample. The results highlight that milk consumption shrinking is due to health concern and an unfavorable perception of dangerous consequences in lactose intake, and additionally to a general distrust towards medical expertise and evidence-based arguments. Indeed, we observe a tendency to self-diagnose intolerance/allergies, questioning the role of physicians and medical knowledge in advising for dietary choices among highly educated youth. The analysis of the patterns of consumption and motives clearly shows that health considerations, not politics, are behind the Italian youth’s dairy restrictions. Healthy consumerism emerges as a concept fitting better than political consumerism for interpreting our results.

Keywords

cultural sociology ethical consumerism Italy milk youth culture

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alfieri

Sironi

Marta

, et al. (2015) Young Italian NEETs (Not in Employment, Education, or Training) and the influence of their family background. Europe’s Journal of Psychology 11(2): 311–322.

Allès

Baudry

Méjean

, et al. (2017) Comparison of sociodemographic and nutritional characteristics between self-reported vegetarians, vegans, and meat-eaters from the NutriNet-Santé study. Nutrients 9(9): 1023–1041.

Alteri

Leccardi

Raffini

(2016) Youth and the reinvention of politics. New forms of participation in the age of individualization and presentification. Partecipazione e conflitto 9(3): 717–747.

Amenta

Polletta

(2019) The cultural impacts of social movements. Annual Review of Sociology 45:279–299.

Andersen

Holm

(2018) Naturalness as a safe haven: Parental consumption practices and the management of risk. Young Consumers 19(3): 296–309.

Armstrong

(2000) All things bold and beautiful: Researching adult learning through soaps. 41st Annual Adult Education Research Conference, Vancouver, Canada.

Atkins

(2010) Liquid Materialities. A History of Milk, Science and the Law. London: Routledge.

Bardhan

Huria

(1987) Cost of milk production: Its relevance to pricing. In: Shah

(ed.) Milk Pricing and Marketing Practices of Cooperative Dairy Industry in Gujarat. Surat: Maricheemalee Prakashan, 88–100.

Bassoli

Monticelli

(2018) What about the welfare state? Exploring precarious youth political participation in the age of grievances. Acta Politica 53: 204–230.

10.

Bennett

(1995) The value of farm animal welfare. Journal of Agricultural Economics 46: 46–59.

11.

Bertuzzi

(2018) The animal advocacy archipelago and the four animalisms. Partecipazione e Conflitto 11(3): 865–890.

12.

Bertuzzi

(2019) The contemporary Italian animal advocacy. Modern Italy 24(1): 1–20.

13.

Bertuzzi

(2020) The individualization of political activism: A reflection on social movements and modernization, starting from the case of Italian animal advocacy. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 40(3/4): 282–303.

14.

Bettin Lattes

(2007) Prefazione. In: Bontempi

Pocaterra

(eds) I figli del disincanto. Giovani e partecipazione politica in Europa. Milan: Bruno Mondadori, 9–16.

15.

Biorcio

Vitale

(2020) Learning democratic attitudes and skills: Politics and volunteer engagement. In Guidi

Fonovic

Cappadozzi

(eds) Accounting for the Varieties of Volunteering. New International Statistical Standards Tested in Italy. Berlin: Springer, 167–191.

16.

Bir

Widmar

Wolf

Delgado

(2019) Traditional attributes moo-ve over for some consumer segments: Relative ranking of fluid milk attributes. Appetite 134: 162–171.

17.

Boltanski

(1968) La Découverte de la maladie: la diffusion du savoir médical. Paris: Centre de sociologie européenne.

18.

Boltanski

(2011) On Critique. A Sociology of Emancipation. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.

19.

Borgerson

(2005) Materiality, agency, and the constitution of consuming subjects: Insights for consumer research. Advances in Consumer Research 32: 439–443.

20.

Bowler

(2010) Netnography: A method specifically designed to study cultures and communities online. The Qualitative Report 15(5): 1270–1275.

21.

Caranci

De Felici

Giuliano

, et al. (2016) Utilizzo degli indici di deprivazione per orientare le politiche pubbliche di contrasto alla povertà. Nona Conferenza Espanet, Macerata, Italy, 22–24 September 2016. Available at: http://isfoloa.isfol.it/xmlui/handle/123456789/1329

22.

Cicourel

(1999) The interaction of cognitive and cultural models in health care delivery. In: Sarangi

Roberts

(eds) Talk, Work and Institutional Order: Discourse in Medical, Mediation and Management Settings. Berlin: Mouton De Gruyter, 183–226.

23.

Cohen

(2017) Regulating milk: Women and cows in France and the United States. The American Journal of Comparative Law 65(3): 469–526.

24.

Cohen

Otomo

(eds) (2017) Making Milk: The Past, Present, and Future of our Primary Food. London: Bloomsbury.

25.

Daftary

(2019) Market-driven dairying and the politics of value, labor and affect in Gujarat, India. The Journal of Peasant Studies 46(1): 80–95.

26.

Delgado

(2003) Rising consumption of meat and milk in developing countries has created a new food revolution. The Journal of Nutrition 133(11): 3907S–3910S.

27.

Doxa-Aidepi (2015) Quando nasce la colazione italiana? Un salto negli anni ‘50. Available at: http://iocominciobene.it/quando-nasce-la-colazione-italiana-un-salto-negli-anni-50/ (accessed 9 February 2019).

28.

DuPuis

(2002) Nature’s Perfect Food: How Milk Became America’s Drink. New York: NYU Press.

29.

EFSA (2010) Scientific opinion on lactose thresholds in lactose intolerance and galactosaemia. Efsa Journal 8(9): 1777–1806.

30.

Enticott

(2003) Risking the rural: Nature, morality and the consumption of unpasteurised milk. Journal of Rural Studies 19(4): 411–424.

31.

Eurispes (2017) Rapporto Italia 2017. Bologna: Minerva Edizioni.

32.

Eurispes (2018) Vegani e vegetariani sono il 7% della popolazione dai 18 anni in su. Available at: https://eurispes.eu/news/eurispes-rapporto-italia-2018-vegani-e-vegetariani-sono-il-7-della-popolazione-dai-18-anni-in-su/ (accessed 26 February 2019).

33.

Faria

Paez

(2019) It’s Splitsville: Why animal ethics and environmental ethics are incompatible. American Behavioral Scientist 63(8): 1047–1060.

34.

Forno

(2018) Protest, social movements, and spaces for politically-oriented consumerist actions – Nationally, transnationally, and locally. In: Boström

Micheletti

Oosterveer

(eds) The Oxford Handbook of Political Consumerism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 69–88.

35.

Gerrior

Putnam

Bente

(1998) Milk and milk products: Their importance in the American diet. Food Review/National Food Review 21: 29–37.

36.

Harman

(2018) The Italian breakfast: Mulino Bianco and the advent of a family practice (1971–1995). European Journal of Marketing 52(12): 2478–2498.

37.

Harmon

(2018) Why white supremacists are chugging milk (and why geneticists are alarmed). New York Times, 17 October.

38.

Idan

Xing

Ivory

, et al. (2020) Sociodemographic correlates of medical mistrust among African American men living in the East Bay. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved 31(1): 115–127.

39.

Inaudi

(2018) Milk is life: Nutritional interventions and child welfare: The Italian case and post-war international aid. In: Gentilcore

Smith

(eds) Proteins, Pathologies and Politics Dietary Innovation and Disease from the Nineteenth Century. London: Bloomsbury, 149–160.

40.

Ismea (2017) XIV Rapporto 2016 sulle produzioni agroalimentari e vitivinicole italiane DOP IGP STG.

41.

Istat (2018) Available at: https://www.istat.it/it/archivio/demografia

42.

Jones

(2017) Patients, consumers, and the enduring challenge to medical authority. Reviews in American History 45(1): 128–135.

43.

Kamana

Ceuppens

Jacxsens

, et al. (2014) Microbiological quality and safety assessment of the Rwandan milk and dairy chain. Journal of Food Protection 77(2): 299–307.

44.

Kozinets

(2010) Netnography. Doing Ethnographic Research Online. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

45.

Kristensen

Boye

Askegaard

(2011) Leaving the milky way! The formation of a consumer counter mythology. Journal of Consumer Culture 11(2): 195–214.

46.

Lamont

Small

(2008) How culture matters for the understanding of poverty: Enriching our understanding. In: Lin

Harris

(eds) The Colors of Poverty: Why Racial and Ethnic Disparities Persist. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 76–102.

47.

Leccardi

(2014) Young people and the new semantic of the future. SocietàMutamentoPolitica 5(1): 41–54.

48.

Le Pape

Plessz

(2017) C’est l’heure du petit-déjeuner? Rythme des repas, incorporation et classe sociale. L’Année sociologique 67(1): 73–105.

49.

Mattozzi

Piccioni

(2012) A depasteurization of Italy? Mediations of consumption and the enrollment of consumers within the raw-milk network. Sociologica 3.

50.

Mayer

(2018) The political impact of social insecurity in France. Partecipazione e Conflitto 11(3): 646–691.

51.

Mayfield

Bennett

Tranter

, et al. (2007) Consumption of welfare-friendly food products in Great Britain, Italy and Sweden, and how it may be influenced by consumer attitudes to, and behaviour towards, animal welfare attributes. International Journal of Sociology of Food and Agriculture 15(3): 59–73.

52.

Mendelson

(2008) Milk. The Surprising Story of Milk Through the Ages. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.

53.

Micheletti

(2003) Political Virtue and Shopping. Individuals, Consumerism, and Collective Action. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

54.

Micheletti

McFarland

(2010) Creative Participation: Responsibility-Taking in the Political World. Boulder: Paradigm Publisher.

55.

Mills

(1940) Situated actions and vocabularies of motive. American Sociological Review 5(6): 904–913.

56.

Montini

(1957) Introduzione. In: Istituto Nazionale della Nutrizione, Amministrazione per le Attività Assistenziali Italiane ed Internazionali (eds) Il latte alimento per tutti nel pensiero di fisiologi, igienisti e clinici italiani. Roma: Garzanti, 16.

57.

Moon

(2018) Why is milk being called a white supremacist symbol? Pacific Standard 24(10).

58.

Morel

Palier

Palme

(2012) Towards a Social Investment Welfare State? Ideas, Policies and Challenges. Bristol: Policy Press.

59.

Morris

Mylan

Beech

(2019) Substitution and food system de-animalisation. The International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food 25(1): 42–58.

60.

Mouat

Prince

(2018) Cultured meat and cowless milk: On making markets for animal-free food. Journal of Cultural Economy 11(4): 315–329.

61.

NDDB (1977) Operation Flood II: A Proposal. Anand, Gujarat: National Dairy Development Board.

62.

Nichols

(2017) The Death of Expertise. The Campaign Against Established Knowledge and Why it Matters. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

63.

Nielsen

Popkin

(2004) Changes in beverage intake between 1977 and 2001. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 27(3): 205–210.

64.

O’Neill

(2002) A Question of Trust: The BBC Reith Lectures 2002. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

65.

Pagliai

(2010) Giorgio La Pira e il ‘piano latte’. La funzione sociale della Centrale. Florence: Edizioni Polistampa.

66.

Papacharissi

(ed.) (2011) A Networked Self. Identity, Community, and Culture in Social Network Site. London: Routledge.

67.

Pirni

Raffini

(2017) The ri-elaboration of the collective sphere. New paths of sociality and groups-formation among the new generations. Partecipazione e Conflitto 9(3): 799–823.

68.

Polizzi

Tajani

Vitale

(2013) Programmare i territori del welfare. Attori, meccanismi ed effetti. Roma: Carocci Editore.

69.

Righetti

(2018) Il veganismo tra mainstream e controcultura. Micro & Macro Marketing 27(1): 109–130.

70.

Sabban

(2014) The taste for milk in modern China (1865–1937). In: Klein

Murcott

(eds) Food Consumption in Global Perspective. Consumption and Public Life. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 182–208.

71.

Sandlin

(2007) Netnography as a consumer education research tool. International Journal of Consumer Studies 31: 288–294.

72.

Schluchter

(1986) Modes of authority and democratic control. In: Meja

Stehr

Thisgeld

(eds) Modern German Sociology. New York: Columbia University Press, 291–323.

73.

Terhal

(1987) The optimal management of milk grid system. In: Shah

(ed.) Milk Pricing and Marketing Practices of Cooperative Dairy Industry in Gujarat. Surat: Maricheemalee Prakashan, 166–179.

74.

Tosi

Vitale

(2008) Responsabilité directe. Hybridations croisées entre catholiques et laïcs dans les mouvements pour la paix en Italie. In: Sommier

Fillieule

Agrikolianky

(eds) La Généalogie des mouvements antiglobalisation en Europe. Paris: Karthala, 187–206.

75.

Tosi

Vitale

(2009) Explaining how political culture changes: Catholic activism and the secular left in Italian peace movements. Social Movements Studies 8(2): 131–147.

76.

Turina

(2018) Pride and burden: The quest for consistency in the anti-speciesist movement. Society & Animals 26(3): 239–258.

77.

Turina

(2019) An interpretive account of individual, nonviolent radicalization. Humanity & Society 43(3): 250–269.

78.

Veron

(2016) (Extra)ordinary activism: Veganism and the shaping of hemeratopias. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 36(11/12): 756–773.

79.

Vitale

(2003) Abbassare la soglia: confini ed apprendimento. In: Bifulco

(ed.) Il genius loci del welfare. Strutture e processi della qualità sociale. Rome: Officina, 136–49.

80.

Weber

(2019) Economy and Society. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

81.

Williamson

Bigman

(2018) A systematic review of medical mistrust measures. Patient Education and Counseling 101(10): 1786–1794.

82.

Wright

(2019) Milking the Zeitgeist. HUMaNIMALIA 10(2): 250–255.

83.

Zaitlin

Dwyer

Gleason

(2013) Mistaken beliefs and the facts about milk and dairy foods. Nutrition Today 48(3): 135–143.

84.

Zamagni

(1998) L’evoluzione dei consumi tra tradizione e innovazione. In: S toria d’Italia: Annali 13. L’Alimentazione. Turin: Einaudi, 171–204.