In this paper, I underline the challenges for group-analytic research by
demonstrating the immense difference in the amount of research done in group
psychotherapy in general as compared to group analysis. After presenting an overview
of findings from empirical, quantitative outcome studies in group psychotherapy at
large, I will discuss some trends in contemporary group psychotherapy research, and
finally, I will give a rough sketch of group-analytic research. I will focus on
quantitative research and I will see group analysis as a clinical enterprise - a
theory, model, art and craft that has been developed and can be used to treat
psychiatric disorders, and toameliorate psychological problems.
Anthony, E. J.
(1971) ‘The History of Group
Psychotherapy’, in
H. I. Kaplan
and
B. J. Sadock
(eds) Comprehensive Group Psychotherapy.
Baltimore, MD: William and Wilkins
.
2.
Bateman, A.
and
Fonagy, P.
(1999)
‘Effectiveness of Partial Hospitalization in the Treatment of
Borderline Personality Disorder: A Randomized Controlled Trial’
, American Journal of Psychiatry156:
1563-1569
.
3.
Bateman, A.
and
Fonagy, P.
(2001)
‘Treatment of Borderline Personality Disorder with
Psychoanalytically Oriented Partial Hospitalization: An 18-Month Follow-up’
, American Journal of Psychiatry158:
36-42
.
4.
Beck, A. P.
and
Lewis, C. M.
(eds) (2000) The Process of Group Psychotherapy. Systems for
Analyzing Change.
Washington, DC: American Psychological Association
.
5.
Bednar, R. L.
and
Kaul, T. J.
(1978) ‘Experimental Group Research: Current
Perspectives’, in
S. L. Garfield
and
A. E. Bergin
(eds) Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior Change: An Empirical
Analysis, pp. 769-815.
New York: Wiley
.
6.
Bretz, H. J.
,
Heekerens, H. P.
and
Schmitz, B.
(1994)
‘A Meta-Analysis of the Effectiveness of Gestalt Therapy’
, Zeitschrift für Klinische Psychologie, Psychiatrie und Psychotherapie42(3):
241-260
.
7.
Brunori, L.
,
Gibin, A. M.
,
Miglioli, A.
and
Bussandri, M.
(2004)
‘Analysis of the Therapeutic Course of an Eating Disorders Group’
, Group Analysis37(3):
387-399
.
8.
Burlingame, G. M.
,
MacKenzie, K. R.
and
Strauss, B.
(2004) ‘Small Group Treatment: Evidence for
Effectiveness and Mechanisms of Change, in
M J. Lambert
(ed.) Bergin and Garfield’s Handbook of Psychotherapy and
Behavior Change, pp. 647-696.
New York: Wiley
.
9.
Catina, A.
and
Tschuschke, V.
(1993)
‘A Summary of Empirical Data from the Investigation of Two
Psychoanalytic Groups by Means of Repertory Grid Technique’
, Group Analysis26(4):
433-447
.
10.
Conway, S.
,
Audin, K.
,
Barkham, M.
,
Mellor-Clark, J.
, and
Russell, S.
(2003)
‘Practice-based Evidence for a Brief Time-intensive Multi-modal
Therapy Guided by Group-analytic Principles and Method’
, Group Analysis36(4):
411-435
.
11.
Dick, B.
(1975)
‘A Ten Year Study of Out-patient Analytic Group Therapy’
, British Journal of Psychiatry127:
350-375
.
12.
Dush, D. M.
,
Hirt, M. L.
and
Schroeder, H.
(1983)
‘Self-statement Modification with Adults: A Meta-analysis’
, Psychological Bulletin94:
408-422
.
13.
Emrick, C.
(1975)
‘A Review of Psychologically Oriented Treatment of Alcoholism’
, Journal for the Study of Alcoholism36:
88-108
.
14.
Foulkes, S. H.
and
Anthony, E. J.
(1984) Group Psychotherapy. The Psychoanalytical
Approach.
London: Maresfield reprints
.
15.
Fuhriman, A.
and
Burlingame, G. M.
(1994) Handbook of Group Psychotherapy: An Empirical and
Clinical Synthesis.
New York: John Wiley and Sons
.
16.
Gonzáles de Chávez, M.
,
Gutierrez, M.
,
Ducaju, M.
and
Fraile, J. C.
(2000)
‘Comparative Study of Therapeutic Factors of Group Therapy in
Schizophrenic Inpatients and Outpatients’
, Group Analysis33(2):
251-264
.
17.
Hall, Z.
and
King, E.
(1997)
‘Group Therapy within the NHS V: Patients’ Views on the
Benefit of Group Therapy for Women Survivors of Child Sexual Abuse’
, Group Analysis30(3):
409-427
.
18.
Heinzel, R.
,
Breyer, F.
and
Klein, T.
(2000)
‘Outpatient Psychoanalytic Individual and Group Psychotherapy in
a Nationwide Catamnestic Study in Germany’
, Group Analysis33(3):
353-372
.
19.
Kapur, R.
(1993)
‘Measuring the Effects of Group Interpretations with the Severely
Mentally Ill’
, Group Analysis26(4):
411-432
.
20.
Karterud, S.
(1992)
‘Reflections on Group-Analytic Research’
, Group Analysis25:
353-364
.
21.
Lambert, M. J.
(2004) (ed.) Bergin and Garfield’s Handbook of
Psychotherapy and Behavior Change.
New York: Wiley
.
22.
Lieberman, M.
(1976)
‘Change Induction in Small Groups
, Annual Review of Psychology27:
217-250
.
23.
Linehan, M. M.
,
Cochran, B. N.
and
Kehrer, C. A.
(2001) ‘Dialectical Behavior Therapy for
Borderline Personality Disorder’, in
D. H. Barlow
(ed.) Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders: A Step-by-Step
Treatment Manual, pp. 470-522.
New York: Guilford Press
.
24.
Lorentzen, S. (2003) Long-term Analytic Group Psychotherapy with
Outpatients. Evaluation of Process and Change. Academic dissertation.
University of Oslo.
25.
Lorentzen, S.
and
Høglend, P.
(2002)
‘The Change Process of a Patient in Long-Term Group Psychotherapy’
, Group Analysis35(4):
500-524
.
26.
Lorentzen, S.
and
Høglend, P.
(2004)
‘Predictors of Change during Long-Term Analytic Group Psychotherapy’
, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics73:
25-35
.
27.
Lorentzen, S.
,
Bøgwald, K-P.
and
Høglend, P.
(2002)
‘Change During and After Long-term Analytic Group Psychotherapy’
, International Journal of Group Psychotherapy52(3):
419-429
.
28.
Lorentzen, S.
,
Sexton, H.
and
Høglend, P.
(2004)
‘Therapeutic Alliance, Cohesion and Outcome in a Long-Term
Analytic Group. A Preliminary Study’
, Nordic Journal of Psychiatry58(1),
33-40
.
29.
Luborsky, L.
,
Singer, B.
and
Luborsky L.
(1975)
‘Comparative Studies of Psychotherapy’
, Archives of General Psychiatry32:
995-1008
.
30.
McRoberts, C.
,
Burlingame, G. M.
and
Matthew, J. H.
(1998)
‘Comparative Efficacy of Individual and Group Psychotherapy: A
Meta-Analytic Perspective’
, Group Dynamics. Theory, Research, and Practice2:
101-117
.
31.
Meltzoff, J.
and
Kornreich, M.
(1970) Research in Psychotherapy.
New York: Atherton Press
.
32.
Miller, R.
and
Berman, J.
(1983)
‘The Efficacy of Cognitive Behavior Therapies: A Quantitative
Review of Research Evidence’
, Psychological Bulletin94:
39-53
.
33.
Nietzel, M. T.
,
Russel, R. L.
,
Hemmings, K. A.
and
Gretter M. L.
(1987)
‘Clinical Significance of Psychotherapy for Unipolar Depression:
A Meta-Analytic Approach to Social Comparison’
, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology55:
156-161
.
34.
Pattison, E.
(1965)
‘Evaluation Studies of Group Psychotherapy’
. International Journal of Group Psychotherapy, 15:
382-397
.
35.
Piper, W. E.
,
McCallum, M.
,
Joyce, A. S.
,
Rosie, J. S.
and
Ogrodniczuk, J. S.
(2001)
‘Patient Personality and Time-limited Group Psychotherapy for
Complicated Grief’
, International Journal of Group Psychotherapy51(4):
525-552
.
36.
Rickard, H.
(1962)
‘Selected Group Psychotherapy Evaluation Studies’
, Journal of General Psychology67:
35-50
.
37.
Robinson, L
,
Berman, J.
, and
Neimeyer, R.
(1990)
‘Psychotherapy for the Treatment of Depression: A Comprehensive
Review of Controlled Outcome Research’
, Psychological Bulletin108:
30-49
.
38.
Sandahl, C.
,
Herlitz, K.
,
Ahlin, G.
, and
Rönnberg, S.
(1998)
‘Time-Limited Group Psychotherapy for Moderately Alcohol
Dependent Patients: A Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial’
, Psychotherapy Research8(4):
361-378
.
39.
Sandahl, C.
,
Lindgren, A.
and
Herlitz, K.
(2000)
‘Does the Group Conductor Make a Difference? Communication
Patterns in Group-Analytically and Cognitive Behaviourally Oriented Therapy Groups’
, Group Analysis33(3):
333-351
.
40.
Seidler, G.
(2000)
‘The Self-Relatedness Construct: Empirical Verification via
Observation in the Context of Inpatient Group Therapy’
, Group Analysis33(3):
413-432
.
41.
Shapiro, D. A.
and
Shapiro, D.
(1982)
‘Comparative Therapy Outcome Research: Methodological
Implications of Meta-Analysis,’Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology51:
42-53
.
42.
Sharpe, J.
,
Selley, C.
,
Low, L.
and
Hall, Z.
(2001)
‘Group-Analytic Therapy for Male Survivors of Childhood Sexual Abuse’
, Group Analysis34(2):
195-209
.
43.
Sheehan, J. D.
and
Fitzgerald, M.
(1994)
‘Measuring Progress in Psychoanalytical Psychotherapy: A Pilot Study’
, Group Analysis27(2):
211-220
.
44.
Sigrell, B.
(1995).
‘The Long-Term Effects of Group Psychotherapy: A Thirteen-Year
Follow-Up Study’
, Group Analysis25(3):
333-352
.
45.
Smith M. L.
and
Glass G. V.
(1977)
‘Meta-Analysis of Psychotherapy Outcome Studies’
, American Psychologist32:
752-760
.
46.
Smith, M.
,
Glass, G.
, and
Miller, T.
(1980) The Benefits of Psychotherapy.
Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins University Press
.
47.
Stotsky, B.
and
Zolik, E.
(1965)
‘Group Psychotherapy with Psychotics’
, International Journal of Group Psychotherapy15:
321-344
.
48.
Strauss, B.
and
Burgmeier-Lohse, M.
(1994)
‘Prozess-Ergebnis-Zusammenhãnge in der analytisch
orientierten Gruppenpsychotherapie: Eine Erkundungsstudie im stationaren Rahmen’
, Psychotherapeut39:
239-250
.
49.
Terlidou, C.
,
Moschonas, D.
,
Kakitsis, P.
,
Manthouli, M.
,
Moschona, T.
, and
Tsegos, I.
(2004)
‘Personality Changes after Completion of Long-term Group-Analytic Psychotherapy’
, Group Analysis37(3):
401-418
.
50.
Tillitski, C. J.
(1990)
‘A Meta-Analysis of Estimated Effect Sizes for Group versus
Individual versus Control Treatments’
, International Journal of Group Psychotherapy40:
215-224
.
51.
Tschuschke, V.
(1999)
‘Gruppentherapie versus Einzelntherapie-gleich wirksam?’Gruppenpsychotherapie und Gruppendynamik35:
257-274
.
52.
Tschuschke, V.
and
Anbeh, T.
(2000)
‘Early Effects of Long-term Outpatient Group Therapies - First
Preliminary Results’
, Group Analysis33(3):
397-411
.
53.
Tschuschke, V.
,
Catina, A.
,
Beckh, T.
and
Salvini, D.
(1992)
‘Therapeutic Factors of Inpatient Analytic Group Psychotherapy’
, Psychotherapie, Psychosomatik, Medizinische Psychologie442:
91-101
.
54.
Valbak, K.
(2001)
‘Good Outcome for Bulimic Patients in Long-term Group Analysis: A
Single Group Study’
, European Eating Disorders Review9(1):
19-32
.
55.
Vostanis, P.
and
O’Sullivan, D.
(1992)
‘Evaluation of Therapeutic Factors in Group Psychotherapy by
Therapists in Training’
, Group Analysis25(3):
325-332
.
56.
Wennberg, P.
,
Weinryb, R. M.
,
Saxon L.
,
Göransson, S.
,
Bush, M.
and
Skaarbrandt, E.
(2004)
‘Personality, Levels of Psychological Distress and Premature
Termination of Psychodynamic Group Therapy: Results from a Prospective
Longitudinal Study’
, Group Analysis37:
179-185
.
57.
Wilberg, T.
,
Friis, S.
,
Karterud, S.
,
Mehlum, L.
,
Urnes, Ø.
and
Vaglum, P.
(1998)
‘Outpatient Group Psychotherapy: A Valuable Continuation
Treatment for Patients with Borderline Personality Disorder Treated in a Day
Hospital?: A 3- year Follow-up Study’
, Nordic Journal of Psychiatry52:
213-221
.
58.
Wilberg, T.
,
Karterud, S.
,
Pedersen, G.
,
Urnes, Ø.
,
Irion, T.
,
Brabrand, J.
,
Haavaldsen, G.
,
Leirvåg, H.
,
Johnsen, H.
,
Andreasen, H.
and
Stubhaug, B.
(2003)
‘Outpatient Group Psychotherapy Following Day Treatment of
Patients with Personality Disorders’
, Journal of Personality Disorders17:
510-521
.
