Time-limited and problem-focused trends in mental health services from contemporary
economic forces in both managed care and institutional settings have had a direct
effect on the clinical decision-making of group psychotherapists. This article
outlines five dilemmas that are examined in the light of the current milieu. These
include the varying degrees of homogeneity versus heterogeneity in patient
selection, the integration of psychoeducational methods with interpersonal processes
in group therapy, the effects of time limitations on the collective therapeutic
focus of the group, the balance between support and confrontation in time-limited
group treatment and the dilemmas surrounding the therapist’s relative
degree of transparency versus opaqueness in the group.
Authier, J.
,
Gustafson, K.
,
Guerney, B.
and
Kasdorf, J.A.
(1975)
‘The Psychological Practitioner as Teacher: A
Theoretical–historical and Practical Review’
, The Counseling Psychologist5(2):
31–50
.
2.
Berrien, F.K.
(1968) General and Social Systems.
New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press
.
3.
Budman, S.H.
and
Gurman, A.S.
(1988) Theory and Practice of Brief Therapy.
New York: Guilford Press
.
4.
Budman, S.H.
and
Steenbarger, B.
(1997) The Essential Guide to Group Practice in Mental Health.
New York: Guilford Press
.
5.
Burlingame, G.M.
and
Fuhriman, A.
(1990)
‘Time-limited Group Therapy’
, The Counseling Psychologist18:
93–118
.
6.
Carey, K.
and
Burgess, J.F.
(2000)
‘Hospital Costing: Experience from the VHA’
, Financial Accountability and Management16(4):
289–308
.
7.
Chambliss, C.H.
(1999) Psychotherapy and Managed Care: Reconciling Research
and Reality.
New York: Allyn and Bacon, Inc.
8.
Dies, R.R.
(1973)
‘Group Therapist Self-disclosure: An Evaluation by Clients’
, Journal of Counseling Psychology20(4):
344–348
.
9.
Dryden, W.
(1997) Therapist’s Dilemmas (Revised edition).
London: Sage
.
10.
Fay, A.
and
Lazarus, A.A.
(1993) ‘Cognitive–behavioral Group
Therapy’, in
A. Alonzo
and
H. I. Swiller
(eds) Group Therapy in Clinical Practice, pp.
449–469.
Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press
.
11.
Feachem, R.G.A.
,
Sekhri, N.K.
and
White, K.L.
(2002)
‘Getting More for Their Dollar: A Comparison of the NHS with
California’s Kaiser Permanente’
, British Medical Journal324:
135–143
.
12.
Fiese, B.H.
and
Scaturo, D.J.
(1995)
‘The Use of Self-help Terminology in Focusgroup Discussions with
Adult Children of Alcoholics: Implications for Research and Clinical Practice’
, Family Therapy22(1):
1–8
.
13.
Fox, R.
(2002)
‘Efficiency in the NHS’
, Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine95(12):
579–579
.
14.
Freud, S.
(1910/1958) ‘Wild’ Psycho-analysisStandard Edition, Vol. 11, pp. 219–230.
London: Hogarth Press
, 1958.
15.
Fuhriman, A.
and
Burlingame, G.M.
(2001)
‘Group Psychotherapy Training and Effectiveness’
, International Journal of Group Psychotherapy51(3):
399–416
.
16.
Gill, M.M.
(1982) The Analysis of Transference.
New York: International Universities Press
.
17.
Goldstein, A.P.
(1973) Structured Learning Therapy: Toward a Psychotherapy
for the Poor.
New York: Academic Press
.
18.
Goldstein, A.P.
(1981) Psychological Skill Training: The Structured Learning Technique.
New York: Elsevier Science
.
19.
Goodman, G.
and
Jacobs, M.K.
(1994) ‘The Self-help, Mutual-support
Group’, in
A. Fuhriman
and
G.M. Burlingame
(eds), Handbook of Group Psychotherapy: An Empirical and Clinical
Synthesis, pp. 489–526.
New York: Wiley
.
20.
Gustafson, J.P.
(1995) The Dilemmas of Brief Psychotherapy.
New York: Plenum Press
.
21.
Haley, S.A.
(1974)
‘When the Patient Reports Atrocities: Specific Treatment
Considerations of the Vietnam Veteran’
, Archives of General Psychiatry30:
191–196
.
22.
Hoyt, M.F.
(1995) Brief Therapy and Managed Care: Readings for
Contemporary Practice.
New York: Jossey-Bass
.
23.
Kahn, M.
(1997) Between Therapist and Client: The New
Relationship.
New York: W.H. Freeman and Company
.
24.
Kohut, H.
(1971) The Analysis of the Self.
New York: International Universities Press
.
25.
LaPuma, J.
(1998) Managed Care Ethics: Essays on the Impact of Managed
Care on Traditional Medical Ethics.
New York: Hatherleigh Press
.
26.
Lazarus, A.A.
(1966)
‘Behavior Rehearsal vs. Non-directive Therapy vs. Advice in
Effecting Behavior Change’
, Behavior Research and Therapy4:
209–212
.
27.
MacKenzie, K.R.
(1993) ‘Time-limited Group Theory and
Technique’, in
A. Alonzo
and
H.I. Swiller
(eds) Group Therapy in Clinical Practice, pp.
423–447.
Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press
.
28.
McKay, M.
and
Paleg, K.
(eds) (1992) Focal Group Psychotherapy.
Oakland, CA: New Harbinger
.
29.
Moreno, J.L.
(1946) Psychodrama.
New York: Beacon House
.
30.
Orne, M.T.
(1962)
‘On the Social Psychology of the Psychological Experiment: With
Particular Reference to Demand Characteristics and their Implications’
, American Psychologist17:
776–783
.
31.
Rangell, L.
(1969)
‘The Psychoanalytic Process’
, International Journal of Psychoanalysis49:
19–26
.
32.
Rogers, C.R.
(1962) ‘The Interpersonal Relationship: The Core
of Guidance’, in
C.R. Rogers
and
B. Stevens
(eds) Person to Person, pp. 91–92.
Lafayette, CA: Real People Press
.
33.
Rose, S.D.
(1999) ‘Group Therapy: A
Cognitive–behavioral Approach’, in
J.R. Price
,
D.R. Hescheles
and
A.R. Price
(eds) A Guide to Starting Psychotherapy Groups, pp.
99–114.
San Diego, CA: Academic Press
.
34.
Ryle, A.
(1979)
‘The Focus on Brief Interpretive Psychotherapy: Dilemmas, Traps
and Snags’
, British Journal of Psychiatry134:
46–54
.
35.
Scaturo, D.J.
(2002a)
‘Fundamental Dilemmas in Contemporary Psychotherapy: A
Transtheoretical Concept’
, American Journal of Psychotherapy56(1):
115–133
.
36.
Scaturo, D.J.
(2002b)
‘Technical Skill and the Therapeutic Relationship: A Fundamental
Dilemma in Cognitive–behavioral and Insight–oriented Therapy’
, Family Therapy29(1):
1–21
.
37.
Scaturo, D.J.
and
Hardoby, W.J.
(1988)
‘Psychotherapy with Traumatized Vietnam Combatants: An Overview
of Individual, Group, and Family Treatment Modalities’
, Military Medicine153(5):
262–269
.
38.
Scaturo, D.J.
and
McPeak, W.R.
(1998)
‘Clinical Dilemmas in Contemporary Psychotherapy: The Search for
Clinical Wisdom’
, Psychotherapy35(1):
1–12
.
39.
Schacht, T.E.
,
Binder, J.L.
and
Strupp, H.H.
(1984) ‘The Dynamic Focus’,
in
H.H. Strupp
and
J.L. Binder
, Psychotherapy in a New Key: A Guide to Time-limited Dynamic
Psychotherapy, pp. 65–109.
New York: Basic Books
.
40.
Schutz, W.C.
(1980) ‘Encounter Therapy’,
in
R.J. Corsini
(ed.) Current Psychotherapies.
Itasca, IL: F.E. Peacock
.
41.
Sekhri, N.K.
(2000)
‘Managed Care: The US Experience’
, Bulletin of the World Health Organization78(6):
830–844
.
42.
Shaw, M.E.
(1964) ‘Communication
Networks’, in
L. Berkowitz
(ed.) Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, Vol. 1, pp.
111–147.
New York: Academic Press
.
43.
Spitz, H.I.
(1995) Group Psychotherapy and Managed Mental Health Care: A
Clinical Guide for Providers, Vol. 2.
New York: Brunner/Mazel
.
44.
Sprafkin, R.P.
,
Gershaw, N.J.
and
Goldstein, A.P.
(1978)
‘Teaching Interpersonal Skills to Psychiatric Outpatients: Using
Structured Learning Therapy in a Community-based Setting’
, Journal of Rehabilitation, April/May/June:
26–36
.
45.
Sprafkin, R.P.
,
Goldstein, A.P.
and
Gershaw, N.J.
(1993) Social Skills for Mental Health: A Structured Learning Approach.
New York: Allyn and Bacon, Inc.
46.
Stanton, M.D.
(1980) ‘Family Therapy: Systems
Approaches’, in
G.P. Sholevar
,
R.M. Benson
and
B.J. Blinder
(eds) Emotional Disorders in Children and Adolescents: Medical and
Psychological Approaches to Treatment, pp.
159–179.
New York: SP Medical and Scientific Books
.
47.
Wachtel, E.F.
(1979)
‘Learning Family Therapy: The Dilemmas of an Individual Psychotherapist’
, Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy10:
122–135
.
48.
White, J.R.
and
Freeman, A.S.
(eds) (2000) Cognitive–behavioral Group Therapy for
Specific Problems and Populations.
Washington, DC: American Psychological Association
.
49.
Yalom, I.D.
(1983) Inpatient Group Psychotherapy.
New York: Basic Books
.
50.
Yalom, I.D.
(1995) The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy (4th
edn).
New York: Basic Books
.
51.
Yerkes, R.M.
, and
Dodson, J.D.
(1908)
‘The Relation of Strength of Stimulus to Rapidity of Habit-formation’
, Journal of Comparative Neurology and Psychology18:
459–482
.
