The Harrodian “knife edge” instability is a salient feature characterizing the inner nature of capitalism, usually explained by the Keynesian notion of “animal spirits.” In this article, we argue that the movement of the rate of surplus value is the variable that conditions the turbulence around the economy’s hypothetical steady growth path. We further show that the notion of the rate of surplus is not restricted to income distribution, but it is much more general and lurks behind the Harrodian knife-edge growth problem, relating to the fundamental contradictions of capitalist production that become apparent in the transition to an economic downturn.
BasuDeepankarManolakosPanagiotis T.2013. Is there a tendency for the rate of profit to fall? Econometric evidence for the US economy, 1948–2007. Review of Radical Political Economics45 (1): 76–95.
2.
ChatzarakisNikolaosTsalikiPersefoni. 2021. The dynamics of capital accumulation in Marx and Solow. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics57: 148–58.
3.
ChatzarakisNikolaosTsalikiPersefoniTsoulfidisLefteris. 2022. A model of economic growth and long cycles. Review of Radical Political Economics54 (3): 351–82.
4.
CockshottPaulCottrellAllinMichaelsonGreg. 1995. Testing Marx: Some new results from UK data. Capital & Class19 (1): 103–30.
5.
DomarEvsey D.1946. Capital expansion, rate of growth, and employment. Econometrica14 (2): 137–47.
6.
FlaschelPeterSkottPeter. 2006. Steindlian models of growth and stagnation. Metroeconomica57 (3): 303–38.
7.
HagemannHarald. 2009. Solow’s 1956 contribution in the context of the Harrod-Domar model. History of Political Economy41 (Annual Suppl. 1): 67–87.
8.
HarrodRoy F.1939. An essay in dynamic theory. The Economic Journal49 (193): 14–33.
9.
HarrodRoy F.1948. Towards a Dynamic Economics: Some Recent Development in Economic Theory and Their Applications to Policy. London: Macmillan.
10.
HarrodRoy F.1960. Second essay in dynamic theory. The Economic Journal70 (278): 277–93.
11.
IvanovaMaria N.2020. Marx’s theory of money: A reappraisal in the light of unconventional monetary policy. Review of Radical Political Economics52 (1): 137–51.
12.
KaldorNicholas. 1955. Alternative theories of distribution. The Review of Economic Studies23 (2): 83–100.
13.
KaldorNicholas. 1957. A model of economic growth. The Economic Journal67 (268): 591–624.
14.
KaldorNicholas. 1988. The role of effective demand in the short run and the long run. In The Foundations of Keynesian Analysis, ed. AlainBarrère. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
15.
KaleckiMichal. 1954. Theory of Economic Dynamics. London: George Allen and Unwin Ltd.
16.
KenwayPeter. 1980. Marx, Keynes, and the possibility of crisis. Cambridge Journal of Economics4 (1): 23–36.
17.
KeynesJohn Maynard. (2007) 1936. The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money. London: Macmillan.
18.
LiMinqi. 2020. Profit, Accumulation, and Crisis in Capitalism: Long-term Trends in the UK, US, Japan, and China, 1855–2018. London: Routledge.
19.
LianosTheodore P.1992. The rate of surplus value, the organic composition of capital, and the rate of profit in Greek manufacturing. Review of Radical Political Economics24 (1): 136–45.
20.
LuxemburgRosa. (1913) 1951. The Accumulation of Capital, trans. SchwarzschildAgnes. London: Routledge and Regan Paul Ltd.
21.
ManiatisThanasis. 2005. Marxian macroeconomic categories in the Greek economy. Review of Radical Political Economics37 (4): 494–516.
22.
MarxKarl. (1859) 1977. Contribution to a Critique of Political Economy. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
23.
MarxKarl. (1867) 2004. Capital. A Critique of Political Economy, volume 1. London: Penguin.
24.
MarxKarl. (1885) 2006. Capital. A Critique of Political Economy, volume 2. London: Penguin.
25.
MarxKarl. (1894) 1992. Capital. A Critique of Political Economy, volume 3. London: Penguin.
26.
MejoradoAscensionRomanManuel. 2023. Declining Profitability and the Evolution of the US Economy: A Classical Perspective. New York: Routledge.
27.
NikaidoHukukane. 1975. Factor substitution and Harrod’s knife-edge. Zeitschrift für Nationalökonomie/Journal of Economics35 (1/2): 149–54.
28.
NikaidoHukukane. 1980. Harrodian pathology of neoclassical growth: The irrelevance of smooth factor substitution. Zeitschrift für Nationalökonomie/Journal of Economics40 (1/2): 111–34.
PasinettiLuigi L.1962. Rate of profit and income distribution in relation to the rate of economic growth. The Review of Economic Studies29 (4): 267–79.
31.
RawthornBobHarrisDonald J.1985. The organic composition of capital and capitalist development. In Rethinking Marxism: Essays for Harry Magdoff and Paul Sweezy, eds. ResnickStephenWolffRichard. New York: Automedia.
32.
RobinsonJoan. 1956. The Accumulation of Capital. London: Macmillan and Co. Ltd.
33.
SandilandsRoger J.2000. Perspectives on Allyn Young in theories of endogenous growth. Journal of the History of Economic Thought22 (3): 309–28.
34.
SandilandsRoger J.2009. Solovian and new growth theory from the perspective of Allyn Young on macroeconomic increasing returns. History of Political Economy41 (Annual Suppl. 1): 285–303.
35.
SerranoFranklinFreitasFabio. 2017. The Sraffian supermultiplier as an alternative closure for heterodox growth theory. European Journal of Economics and Economic Policies14 (1): 70–91.
36.
ShaikhAnwar. 1992. The falling rate of profit as the cause of long waves: Theory and empirical evidence. In New Findings in Long Wave Research, eds. KleinknechtAlfredMandelErnestWallersteinImmanuel. London: Macmillan Press.
37.
ShaikhAnwar. 2011. The first great depression of the 21st century. Socialist Register47: 44–63.
38.
ShaikhAnwar. 2016. Capitalism: Competition, Conflict, Crises. New York: Oxford University Press.
39.
ShaikhAnwar M.TonakE. Ahmed. 1994. Measuring the Wealth of Nations: The Political Economy of the National Accounts. New York: Cambridge University Press.
40.
SkottPeter. 2019. Autonomous demand, Harrodian instability and the supply side. Metroeconomica70 (2): 233–46.
41.
SolowRobert M.1956. A contribution to the theory of economic growth. The Quarterly Journal of Economics70 (1): 65–94.
42.
StockhammerEngelbert. 2011. Wage norms, capital accumulation, and unemployment: A post-Keynesian view. Oxford Review of Economic Policy27 (2): 295–311.
43.
SwanTrevor W.1956. Economic growth and capital accumulation. Economic Record32 (2): 334–61.
44.
TrofimovIvan. 2017. Profit rates in the developed capitalist economies: A time series investigation. PSL Quarterly Review70 (281): 85–128.
45.
TrofimovIvan. 2022. Determinants of the profit rates in the OECD economies: A panel data analysis of the Kalecki’s profit equation. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics61: 380–97.
46.
TsalikiPersefoni V.2006. Marx on entrepreneurship: A note. International Review of Economics53 (4): 592–602.
47.
TsalikiPersefoni V.2008. Economic development, human capital, and technical change: The question of machinery revisited. International Review of Economics55 (4): 363–71.
48.
TsoulfidisLefteris. 2006. Falling rate of profit and overaccumulation in Marx and Keynes. Political Economy Quarterly43 (3): 65–75.
49.
TsoulfidisLefterisPaitaridisDimitris. 2019. Capital intensity, unproductive activities, and the Great Recession in the US economy. Cambridge Journal of Economics43 (3): 623–47.
50.
TsoulfidisLefterisTsalikiPersefoni. 2014. Unproductive labour, capital accumulation and profitability crisis in the Greek economy. International Review of Applied Economics28 (5): 562–85.
51.
TsoulfidisLefterisTsalikiPersefoni. 2019. Classical Political Economics and Modern Capitalism. Berlin: Springer Books.
52.
Tugan-BaranovskiiMikhail I.1901. Studien zur Theorie und Geschichte der Handelskrisen in England. Jena: G. Fischer.
