Marx’s account of technical progress has been criticized by philosophers as being a metanarrative, by ecological economists as being unduly strong, by economists as being unduly weak, and by post-Sraffian authors as being ill-founded. This article discusses Marx’s account of technical progress in light of these criticisms on a conceptual, theoretical, and empirical level, relying on the apparatus of wage curves. It argues that some of the critiques cannot be sustained, since the criticized positions cannot be attributed to Marx. The remaining critiques, in turn, amount to alternative predictions on the evolution of wage curves which are, however, and in contrast to those of Marx, not in line with empirical evidence, as the estimation of wage curves for thirteen countries from 2000 to 2013 shows.
Aristotle. 1984. Metaphysics. In The Complete Works of Aristotle: The Revised Oxford Translation, volume 2, ed. BarnesJonathan, 1–217. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
2.
BasuSusanto. 1996. Procyclical productivity: Increasing returns or cyclical utilization?The Quarterly Journal of Economics111 (3): 719–51.
3.
BidardChristian. 2004. Prices, Reproduction, Scarcity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
4.
CampbellTravisTavaniDaniele. 2019. Marx-biased technical change and income distribution: A panel data analysis. Metroeconomica70 (4): 655–87.
5.
CarterAnne P.1970. Structural Change in the American Economy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
6.
CekotaJaromir. 1988a. Technological change in Canada (1961–80): An application of the surrogate wage function. Canadian Journal of Economics21 (2): 348–58.
7.
CekotaJaromir. 1988b. The contemporary relevance of Marx’s economics: Theory and evidence. Eastern Economic Journal24 (1): 73–80.
8.
ChakrabartyDipesh. 2000. Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical Difference. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
9.
Da SilvaEdnaldo. 1987. Wage-profit trade-offs in Brazil: An input/output analysis, 1970–1975. Science & Society51 (3): 347–54.
10.
Da SilvaEdnaldo. 1991. The wage-profit curve in Brazil: An input-output model with fixed capital, 1975. Review of Radical Political Economics23 (1–2): 104–10.
11.
DavidPaul A.1975. Labor scarcity and the problem of technological practice and progress in nineteenth-century America. In Technical Choice, Innovation and Economic Growth: Essays on American and British Experience in the Nineteenth Century, ed. DavidPaul19–91. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
12.
De JuanOscarFebreroEladio. 2000. Measuring productivity from vertically integrated sectors. Economic Systems Research12 (1): 65–82.
13.
DegasperiMatteoFredholmThomas. 2010. Productivity accounting based on production prices. Metroeconomica61 (2): 267–81.
14.
ElsterJon. 1983. Explaining Technical Change: A Case Study in the Philosophy of Science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
15.
FeenbergAndrew. 2010. Marxism and the critique of social rationality: From surplus value to the politics of technology. Cambridge Journal of Economics34 (1): 37–49.
16.
FelipeJesusLaviñaEdithaFanEmma. 2008. The diverging patterns of profitability, investment, and growth of China and India during 1980–2003. World Development36 (5): 741–74.
17.
FerrettiFabrizio. 2008. Patterns of technical change: A geometrical analysis using the wage-profit rate schedule. International Review of Applied Economics22 (5): 565–83.
18.
Fischer-KowalskiMarinaHaberlHelmut. 2015. Social metabolism: A metrics for biophysical growth and degrowth. In Handbook of Ecological Economics, eds. Martinez-AlierJoanMuradianRoldan, 100–38. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.
19.
Fischer-KowalskiMarinaKrausmannFridolinMayerAndreasSchaffartzikAnke. 2014. Boserup’s theory on technological change as a point of departure for the theory of sociometabolic regime transitions. In Ester Boserup’s Legacy on Sustainability: Orientations for Contemporary Research, eds. Fischer-KowalskiMarinaReenbergAnetteSchaffartzikAnkeMayerAndreas, 23–42. New York: Springer.
20.
FlaschelPeterFrankeReinerVenezianiRoberto. 2013. Labor productivity and the law of decreasing labor content. Cambridge Journal of Economics37 (2): 379–402.
21.
FoleyDuncan K.2006. Adam’s Fallacy: A Guide to Economic Theology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
22.
FoleyDuncan K.MarquettiAdalmir. 1999a. Productivity, employment, and growth in European integration. Metroeconomica50 (3): 277–300.
23.
FoleyDuncan K.MarquettiAdalmir. 1999b. Economic Growth from a Classical Perspective. New York: The New School University for Social Research.
24.
GrollShalomOrzechZe’ev B.1990. Marx’s social dynamics and neutral technical progress: A contradiction?Australian Economic Papers29 (54): 85–100.
25.
GuptaS.SteedmanIan. 1971. An input-output study of labor productivity in the British economy. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics33 (1): 21–34.
26.
HahnelRobin. 2017a. Radical Political Economy: Sraffa versus Marx. London: Routledge.
27.
HahnelRobin. 2017b. Environmental sustainability in a Sraffian framework. Review of Radical Political Economics49 (3): 477–88.
28.
HahnelRobin. 2017c. Income Distribution and Environmental Sustainability: A Sraffian Approach. London: Routledge.
29.
HegelGeorg W. F.2010. The Science of Logic. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
30.
HölzlWerner. 2010. Was there a Marxian bias in Austrian manufacturing? Evidence on the direction of technical change, 1978–1994. International Review of Applied Economics24 (1): 35–56.
31.
JeongSangjun. 2017. Biased technical change and economic growth: The case of Korea, 1970–2013. Research in Political Economy32: 81–103.
32.
KennedyCharlesThirlwallAnthony P.1972. Surveys in applied economics: Technical progress. The Economic Journal82 (325): 11–72.
33.
KerstingGötzSchefoldBertram. 2021. Best techniques leave little room for substitution. A new critique of the production function. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics59: 509–33.
34.
KittsteinerHeinz D.1980. Naturabsicht und unsichtbare Hand: Zur Kritik des geschichtsphilosophischen Denkens. Frankfurt a.M.: Ullstein.
35.
KittsteinerHeinz D.1998. Geschichtsphilosophie und politische Ökonomie. Zur Konstruktion der historischen Zeit bei Marx. In Listen der Vernunft. Motive geschichtsphilosophischen Denkens, ed. KittsteinerHeinz D., 110–31. Frankfurt a.M.: Fischer.
36.
KrausmannFridolinWeiszHelgaEisenmengerNina. 2016. Transitions in sociometabolic regimes throughout human history. In Social Ecology: Society-Nature Relations across Time and Space, eds. HaberlHelmutFischer-KowalskiMarinaKrausmannFridolinWiniwarterVerena, 63–92. New York: Springer.
37.
KurzHeinz D.1979. Wahl der Technik und Arbeitswertlehre in einem einfachen Modell mit zwei originären “Faktoren.”Jahrbuch für Sozialwissenschaft30 (1): 27–51.
38.
KurzHeinz D.2010. Technical progress, capital accumulation and income distribution in classical economics: Adam Smith, David Ricardo, and Karl Marx. European Journal of the History of Economic Thought17 (5): 1183–222.
39.
KurzHeinz D.2020. The theory of value and distribution and the problem of capital. European Journal of Economics and Economic Policies: Intervention17 (2): 241–64.
40.
KurzHeinz D.SalvadoriNeri. 1995. Theory of Production: A Long-period Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
41.
LeontiefWassily. 1986. Technological change, prices, wages, and rate of return on capital in the U.S. economy. In Input-Output Economics, ed. LeontiefWassily392–417. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
42.
LohmannGeorg. 2018. Normative und rechtsstaatliche Kapitalismuskritiken und ihre Verdrängung bei Marx. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie66 (4): 429–65.
43.
LoweAdolph. 1976. The Path of Economic Growth. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
44.
MacKenzieDonald. 1984. Marx and the machine. Technology and Culture25 (3): 473–502.
45.
MarquettiAdalmirPorsseMelody Soares. 2014. Patterns of technical progress in the Brazilian economy, 1952–2008. CEPAL Review113: 57–73.
46.
MarxKarl. 1975–2004. Marx & Engels Collected Works (MECW), 50 volumes. London: Lawrence & Wishart.
MarxKarl. [1863–67] 1992. Ökonomische Manuskripte. 1863–1867. In Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels: Gesamtausgabe, volume 2.4.2, ed. Internationale Marx-Engels-Stiftung, 3–902. Berlin: Dietz Verlag.
49.
MarxKarlEngels.Friedrich [1848] 1977. Manifest der Kommunistischen Partei. In Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels: Werke, volume 4, ed. Institut für Marxismus-Leninismus beim ZK der SED, 459–93. Berlin: Dietz Verlag.
50.
MarziGraziella. 1994. Vertically integrated sectors and the empirics of structural change. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics5 (1): 155–75.
51.
MarziGraziellaVarri.Paolo1977. Variazioni di produttività nell’economia italiana, 1959–1967: Un’applicazione dello schema di Sraffa. Bologna: Il mulino.
52.
MengJie. 2013. Product innovation and capital accumulation: An attempt to introduce neo-Schumpeterian insights into Marxian economics. Research in Political Economy28: 261–85.
53.
MichlThomas R.1991. Wage-profit curves in US manufacturing. Cambridge Journal of Economics15 (3): 271–86.
54.
MishraRamesh. 1979. Technology and social structure in Marx’s theory: An exploratory analysis. Science & Society43 (2): 132–57.
55.
OchoaEduardo M.1986. An input-output study of labor productivity in the US economy, 1947–72. Journal of Post Keynesian Economics9 (1): 111–37.
56.
OchoaEduardo M.1989. Values, prices, and wage-profit curves in the US economy. Cambridge Journal of Economics13 (3): 413–29.
57.
OzakiIwao. 1970. Economies of scale and input-output coefficients. In Applications of Input-Output Analysis, eds. CarterAnne P.BródyAndrás, 280–302. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
58.
ÖzolCengiz. 1984. Parable and realism in production theory: The surrogate wage function. Canadian Journal of Economics17 (2): 353–68.
59.
ÖzolCengiz. 1991. The surrogate wage function and capital: Theory with measurement. Canadian Journal of Economics24 (1): 175–91.
60.
PanethimitakisAlex. 1993. Direct versus total labor productivity in Greek manufacturing: 1958–1980. Economic Systems Research5 (1): 79–94.
61.
ParysWilfried. 2018. Labor value and energy values: Some developments on the common substance of value since 1867. European Journal of the History of Economic Thought25 (5): 1052–80.
62.
PasinettiLuigi L.1973. The notion of vertical integration in economic analysis. Metroeconomica25 (1): 1–29.
63.
PasinettiLuigi L.1977. Lectures on the Theory of Production. New York: Columbia University Press.
64.
PasinettiLuigi L.1981. Structural Change and Economic Growth: A Theoretical Essay on the Dynamics of the Wealth of Nations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
65.
PetrovićPavle. 1991. Shape of a wage-profit curve, some methodology and empirical evidence. Metroeconomica42 (2): 93–112.
66.
PostoneMoishe. 1993. Time, Labor, and Social Domination: A Reinterpretation of Marx’s Critical Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
67.
PrestonBeth. 2013. A Philosophy of Material Culture: Action, Function, and Mind. London: Routledge.
68.
RicoyCarlos. 2003. Marx on division of labor, mechanization, and technical progress. European Journal of the History of Economic Thought10 (1): 47–79.
69.
RiedelDieter. 1993. Wie Hegel das richtig gesagt hat. In Beiträge zur Marx-Engels-Forschung. Neue Folge. 1993. Marx-Engels-Forschung im historischen Spannungsfeld, eds. HeckerRolfSperlRichardVollgrafCarl-Erich, 122–148. Hamburg: Argument Verlag.
70.
RobinsonJoan. 1979. Notes on the economics of technical progress. In The Generalization of the General Theory and Other Essays, ed. RobinsonJoan79–111. London: Macmillan.
71.
RobinsonJoan. 1980. What Are the Questions? and Other Essays: Further Contributions to Modern Economics. New York: Sharpe.
72.
RoemerJohn E.1981. Analytical Foundations of Marxian Economic Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
73.
RosenbergNathan. 1982a. Marx as a student of technology. In Inside the Black Box: Technology and Economics, ed. RosenbergNathan34–51. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
74.
RosenbergNathan. 1982b. The historiography of technical progress. In Inside the Black Box: Technology and Economics, ed. RosenbergNathan3–33. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
75.
SalantiAndrea. 1985. Prices of production, market prices, and the analysis of the choice of techniques. Metroeconomica37 (1): 97–117.
76.
SchefoldBertram. 1976. Different forms of technical progress. The Economic Journal86 (344): 806–19.
77.
SchefoldBertram. 1979. Capital, growth, and definitions of technical progress. Kyklos32 (1): 236–50.
78.
SchefoldBertram. 1980. Fixed capital as a joint product and the analysis of accumulation with different forms of technical progress. In Essays on the Theory of Joint Production, ed. PasinettiLuigi L. 138–217. London: Macmillan.
79.
SchefoldBertram. 2013. Only a few techniques matter! On the number of curves on the wage frontier. In Sraffa and the Reconstruction of Economic Theory; Volume One: Theories of Value and Distribution, eds. LevreroEnrico S.PalumboAntonellaStiratiAntonella, 46–69. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
80.
SchefoldBertram. 2016. Profits equal surplus value on average and the significance of this result for the Marxian theory of accumulation. Being a new contribution to Engels’ prize essay competition, based on random matrices and on manuscripts recently published in the MEGA for the first time. Cambridge Journal of Economics40 (1): 165–99.
81.
SchefoldBertram. 2019. The transformation of values into prices on the basis of random systems revisited. Evolutionary and Institutional Economics Review16 (2): 261–302.
82.
ShaikhAnwar. 2016. Capitalism: Competition, Conflict, Crises. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
83.
SraffaPiero. 1960. Production of Commodities by Means of Commodities: Prelude to a Critique of Economic Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
84.
TsoulfidisLefterisManiatisThanasis. 2002. Values, prices of production, and market prices: Some more evidence from the Greek economy. Cambridge Journal of Economics26 (3): 359–69.
85.
TsoulfidisLefterisRieuDong-Min. 2006. Labor values, prices of production, and wage-profit rate frontiers of the Korean economy. Seoul Journal of Economics19 (3): 275–95.
86.
VaccaraBeatrice. 1970. Changes over time in input-output coefficients for the United States. In Applications of Input-Output Analysis, eds. CarterAnne P.BródyAndrás, 238–60. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
87.
VaonaAndrea. 2011. Profit rate dynamics, income distribution, structural and technical change in Denmark, Finland, and Italy. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics22 (3): 247–68.
88.
WoodEllen M.1995. Democracy against Capitalism: Renewing Historical Materialism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
