Abstract
Where do profits come from? Are they morally justified? Sraffians provide a clear answer to the first question but have declined to give a direct answer to the second question. This article argues that the “fundamental Sraffian theorem” implies a compelling moral critique of profits, but that this critique can be strengthened by replacing the “contribution-based” approach common among economists with a “sacrifice-based” theory consistent with work by modern egalitarian philosophers.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alperovitz
G.
Daly
L.
2008 . Unjust Deserts: How the Rich Are Taking Our Common Inheritance . New York : The New Press .
2.
Bellamy
E.
[1888 ] 2000 . Looking Backward . New York : Signet Classic .
3.
Dworkin
R.
1981 a. What is equality? Part 1: Equality of welfare . Philosophy & Public Affairs 10 (3 ): 185 –246 .
4.
Dworkin
R.
1981 b. What is equality? Part 2: Equality of resources . Philosophy & Public Affairs 10 (4 ): 283 –345 .
5.
Greenwood
D.
Wolff
E.
1992 . Changes in wealth in the United States 1962–1983 . Journal of Population Economics 5 (4 ): 261–88.
6.
Hahnel
R.
2006 . Exploitation: A modern approach . Review of Radical Political Economics 38 (2 ): 175–92.
7.
Hahnel
R.
2012 . Of the People, by the People: The Case for a Participatory Economy . Portland : Soapbox Press .
8.
Hahnel
R.
2017 a. Income Distribution and Environmental Sustainability: A Sraffian Approach . New York : Routledge .
9.
Hahnel
R.
2017 b. Radical Political Economy: Sraffa versus Marx . New York : Routledge .
10.
Hahnel
R.
Wright
E. O.
2016 . Alternatives to Capitalism: Proposals for a Democratic Economy . London : Verso .
11.
Kotlikoff
L.
Summers
L.
1981 . The role of intergenerational transfers in aggregate capital accumulation . Journal of Political Economy 89 (4 ): 706–32.
12.
Kurz
H.
Salvadori
N.
1995 . Theory of Production: A Long-Period Analysis . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
13.
Mokyr
J.
1990 . Lever of Riches: Technological Creativity and Economic Progress . Oxford : Oxford University Press .
14.
Morishima
M.
1974 . Marx in light of modern economic theory . Econometrica 42 (4 ): 611–32.
15.
Nozick
R.
1974 . Anarchy, State, and Utopia . New York : Basic Books .
16.
Piketty
T.
2014 . Capital in the Twenty-First Century . Cambridge : Harvard University Press .
17.
Roemer
J.
1996 . Theories of Distributive Justice . Cambridge : Harvard University Press .
18.
Roemer
J.
1998 . Equality of Opportunity . Cambridge : Harvard University Press .
19.
Romer
P.
1990 . Endogenous technological change . Journal of Political Economy 98 (5 ): 83 –84 .
20.
Thurow
L.
1996 . The Future of Capitalism: How Today’s Economic Forces Will Shape the Future . New York : William Morrow .