This paper critically examines Robin Hahnel’s 2017 book Radical Political Economy: Sraffa versus Marx and especially compares the relative explanatory power of Marx’s theory and Sraffa’s theory. Hahnel’s book argues that Sraffa’s theory is superior to Marx’s theory with respect to the following six subjects: prices, profit, technological change, crises, the environment, and moral critique (each one considered in a separate chapter). This paper challenges Hahnel’s arguments on all six subjects and argues that Marx’s theory has greater explanatory power than Sraffa’s theory and continues to be the best critical theory of capitalism.
GaregnaniPierangelo. 1992. Some notes for an analysis of accumulation. In Beyond the Steady State, eds. HaleviJosephLaibmanDavidNellEdward J., 47–71. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
6.
HahnelRobin. 2017. Radical Political Economy: Sraffa versus Marx. New York: Routledge
7.
LavoieMarc. 2006. Introduction to post-Keynesian Economics. London: Palgrave.
8.
MandelErnst. 1978. Late Capitalism. London: Verso.
MarxKarl. [1867] 1977. Capital, volume 1. New York: Random House.
11.
MarxKarl. [1894] 1981. Capital, volume3. New York: Random House.
12.
MarxKarlEngels.Friedrich [1861–63] 1988. Economic Manuscript of 1861–63. In Marx-Engels Collected Works, volume 30. New York: International.
13.
MoseleyFred. 1992. The Falling Rate of Profit in the Postwar US Economy. London: Macmillan.
14.
MoseleyFred2011. The Determination of the ‘Monetary Expression of Labor Time’ (“MELT”) in the Case of Non-Commodity Money, Review of Radical Political Economics43 (1): 95–105.
15.
MoseleyFred. 2015. The marginal productivity theory of capital in intermediate microeconomics textbooks: A critique. Review of Radical Political Economics47 (2): 292–308.
16.
MoseleyFred. 2016. Money and Totality: Marx’s Logical Method in Capital and the End of the “Transformation Problem.”Leiden: Brill.
17.
MoseleyFred. 2018. The development of Marx’s theory of the falling rate of profit in the four drafts ofCapital. In Marx’sCapital: An Unfinishable Project?, eds. van der LindenMarcelHubmannGerard, 95–143. Leiden: Brill.
RoemerJohn. 1979. Continuing controversy of the falling rate of profit: Fixed capital and other issues. Cambridge Journal of Economics3 (4): 379–98.
20.
RosdolskyRoman. 1977. The Making of Marx’s Capital. London: Pluto Press.
21.
SchumpeterJoseph. 1954. History of Economic Analysis. New York: Oxford University Press.
22.
ShaikhAnwar. 1978. Political economy and capitalism: Notes on Dobb’s theory of crisis. Cambridge Journal of Economics2 (2): 233–51.
23.
ShaikhAnwar. 1980. Marxian competition versus perfect competition: Further comments on the so-called choice of technique. Cambridge Journal of Economics4 (1): 75–83.
24.
SraffaPiero. 1960. Production of Commodities by Means of Commodities: Prelude to a Critique of Economic Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
