This paper analyzes the formation of a general rate of profit and the subsequent prices of production in the context of Marx’s two-sector scheme of expanded reproduction. We show that a consistent solution of the transformation problem can be derived by incorporating the original transformation procedure into the inter-temporal equilibrium framework provided by the scheme of accumulation. Previous solutions for the special case of simple reproduction are also examined, and it is shown that all these solutions rest on the restrictive assumption of constant wage rates.
BaumolW.1983. Marx and the iron law of wage. The American Economic Review73 (2): 303-308.
2.
von Böhm-BawerkE.1984. Karl Marx and the close of his system, ed. P. Sweezy. New York: Monthly Review Press.
3.
von BortkiewiczL.1952. Value and price in the Marxian system. International Economic Papers2.
4.
von BortkiewiczL.1984. On the correction of Marx’s fundamental theoretical construction in volume II of Capital. In Karl Marx and the close of his system, ed. von Böhm-BawerkE.SweezyP.New York: Monthly Review Press.
5.
BródyA.1974. Proportions, prices and planning. A mathematical restatement of the labour theory of value. New York: Elsevier.
6.
DimitrievK. V.1974. The theory of value of David Ricardo. In Economic essays on value, competition and utility, ed. NutiM.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
7.
DuménilG.1983-84. Beyond the transformation riddle: A labor theory of value. Science and Society47 (4): 427-450.
8.
FoleyD.1982. The value of money, the value of labor-power and the Marxian transformation problem. Review of Radical Political Economics14 (2): 37-47.
9.
FreemanA.1984. The logit of the transformation problem. In Marx, Ricardo, Sraffa, ed. MandelE.FreemanA.London: Verso.
10.
GrossmannH.1992. The law of accumulation and breakdown of the capitalist system. London: Pluto Press.
11.
HarrisD.1972. On Marx’s scheme of reproduction and accumulation. The Journal of Political Economy803(1): 505-522.
12.
KlimanA.McGloneT.1988. The transformation non-problem and the non-transformation problem. Capital and Class35: 56-83.
13.
KuhnR.2007. Henryk Grossman and the recovery of Marxism. Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
14.
LaibmanD.1973. Values and prices of production: The political economy of the transformation problem. Science & Society37 (4): 404-436.
15.
LaibmanD.2000. Rhetoric and substance in value theory: An appraisal of the new orthodox Marxism. Science & Society64 (3): 310-332.
16.
LapidesK.1992. Henryk Grossman and the debate on the theoretical status of Marx’sCapital. Science & Society56 (2): 133-162.
17.
LipietzA.1982. The so-called transformation problem revisited. Journal of Economic Theory26: 59-88.
18.
MandelE.1992. Introduction toCapitalvolume II. London: Penguin.
19.
MarxK.1976. Capital, volume I. London: Penguin.
20.
MarxK.1992. Capital, volume II. London: Penguin.
21.
MarxK.1991. Capital, volume III. London: Penguin.
22.
MarxK.2000. Value, price and profits (abridged): An introduction to the theory of capitalism, ed. MarxE.Zarembkaabridged P. Research in Political Economy 18. JAI/Elsevier Press.
23.
MayK.1948. Value and price of production: A note on Winternitz’ solution. The Economic Journal58 (323): 596-599.
24.
MeekR.1956. Some notes on the “transformation problem.”The Economic Journal66 (261): 94-107.
25.
MorishimaM.1977. Marx’s economics: A dual theory of value and growth. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
26.
MorishimaM.SetonF.1961. Aggregation in Leontief matrices and the labour theory of value. Econometrica29 (2): 203-220.
27.
MoseleyF.1997. Marx’s reproduction scheme and Smith’s dogma. In The circulation of capital. Essays on volume two of Marx’s Capital, ed. ArthurC. J.ReutenG.New York: St. Martin’s Press.
28.
RobinsonJ.1986. The accumulation of capital. London: Basingstoke Macmillan.
29.
RosdolskyR.1977. The making of Marx’sCapital. London: Pluto Press.
30.
SamuelsonP.1970. The “transformation” from Marxian “values” to competitive “prices”: A process of rejection and replacement. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science67 (1): 423-425.
31.
MarxK.1971. Understanding the Marxian notion of exploitation: A summary of the so-called transformation problem between Marxian values and competitive prices. Journal of Economic Literature9 (2): 399-431.
32.
SetonF.1957. The “transformation problem.”The Review of Economic Studies24 (3): 149-160.
33.
ShaikhA.1977. Marx’s theory of value and the “transformation problem.” In The subtle anatomy of capitalism, ed. SchwartzJ.Santa Monica, CA: Goodyear.
34.
ShouldB.1957. Marx and Say’s law. The Quarterly Journal of Economics71 (4): 611-629.
35.
SraffaP.1963. Production of commodities by means of commodities. Bombay: K. K. Vora, Vora and Co. Publishers.
36.
SweezyP.1970. The theory of capitalism development. New York: Oxford University Press.
37.
Winternitz. 1948. Values and prices: A solution of the so-called transformation problem. The Journal of Economics58 (230): 276-280.
